r/MelbourneTrains • u/HansSlinger • 5h ago
Discussion Summary of the Big Build Royal Commission so far
Victoria's Big Build Royal Commission – key revelations so far (20 November 2026)
*MODS, please don't delete this post like you did my last. These are of interest to all Gunzels is what is being uncovered here undermines our collective passion - great Melbourne public transport and trains. This is also distinct from other articles postwd
For anyone not following the Royal Commission into corruption and misconduct on Victoria's Big Build projects, here's a summary of what's emerged so far. Keen to hear thoughts.
Background
- The Royal Commission was established in August 2026, following allegations of organised crime infiltration, corruption and intimidation on taxpayer-funded construction projects.
- An earlier investigation by Geoffrey Watson SC estimated that as much as $15 billion may have been lost through corruption and misconduct. This is an estimate, not a finding of the Royal Commission.
- Former premier Jacinta Allan resisted calls for a Royal Commission. Following her replacement by Ben Carroll, the inquiry was established.
- The inquiry is investigating not just the CFMEU, but also construction companies, subcontractors, government agencies and failures of oversight.
Key evidence and allegations presented
- Union influence over government: Internal John Holland documents from 2021 described the CFMEU's influence within the Andrews government as unprecedented. The company considered its relationship with the union important to securing its position with government.
- Political connections: A 2017 John Holland document acknowledged the union movement's organisational and financial role in electing the Labor government.
- Forced union membership: A worker on the $110 million Gap Road rail project in Sunbury testified that he was effectively forced to join the CFMEU, paying approximately $590 in membership fees.
- Forced labour hire changes: The same worker testified that he had to transfer from his existing labour hire employer to BK Labour, despite doing essentially the same job for similar pay.
- Industrial intimidation: The inquiry heard evidence of work stoppages, alleged threats against labour hire companies and union officials using safety-related powers to disrupt construction.
- Safety concerns potentially weaponised: Evidence raised questions about whether health and safety notices were being used to pressure contractors into accepting union demands rather than addressing genuine workplace hazards.
- Government oversight: The inquiry is examining what Victorian government officials knew about the Gap Road disruptions, the arrangements subsequently negotiated and who ultimately paid for them.
- Bikie involvement: Evidence showed CFMEU officials repeatedly pressuring contractor Laing O'Rourke to employ Bandidos bikie Joel Leavitt on the Cranbourne rail project.
- Potential timesheet fraud: Leavitt conceded it was possible he claimed taxpayer-funded wages for shifts he hadn't worked. Phone records suggested he was sometimes at home or at the gym when timesheets recorded him working.
- Contractor pressure: The inquiry is examining allegations that construction companies were pressured to accommodate CFMEU demands to avoid industrial disruption or jeopardising future government work.
What hasn't been established yet
- The Royal Commission has not concluded that $15 billion was stolen or wasted.
- It has not established the full financial impact of alleged corruption on rail project costs.
- It has not made final findings about the personal responsibility of former premiers, ministers or senior public servants.
- Much of the material presented remains witness testimony, documentary evidence and allegations under examination.
What happens next?
- Further public hearings are scheduled from 30 November 2026.
- The Commission is investigating whether taxpayer money can be recovered and how government procurement and project oversight should be reformed.
- Its final report is due by 20 August 2027.
The big question: How did contractors, unions and government agencies collectively allow these practices to develop on projects funded by Victorian taxpayers, and who will ultimately be held accountable?
Additional revelations from 18–19 November worth including in the post:
* $165,000 paid for no work: BK Labour director Bernard Kearney admitted paying bikie Joel Leavitt $165,000 despite Leavitt having performed no work for the company. Kearney could not explain why he paid. ABC News
* $20,000 souvlaki invoice: The inquiry examined an allegedly inflated catering invoice on the Hurstbridge rail project. A roughly $9,000 catering bill became $20,000, with messages suggesting two safety representatives intended to pocket $5,000 each. ABC News
* Fake invoices admitted: BK Labour's director admitted arranging fabricated invoices in response to a regulator investigating approximately $78,000 in cash withdrawals and payments to a former CFMEU official. The Australian Financial Review
* More than $250,000 paid to former CFMEU official: The inquiry examined payments by BK Labour to former senior union organiser Joe Myles for purported consulting work. ABC News
* $6 million estimated cost blowout: The Gap Road project reportedly incurred an estimated $6 million in additional costs following the industrial dispute. ABC News
* Ministerial pressure alleged: A government infrastructure official testified that a message originating from then-minister Jacinta Allan's office warned contractors they could lose future Victorian government work if they failed to resolve the CFMEU dispute. This remains testimony, not a final finding. The Guardian
* Two witnesses referred to police: On 19 November, the Commission referred two witnesses to Victoria Police for consideration of potential prosecution over their conduct when answering questions. The ABC identified them as Joel Leavitt and Bernard Kearney. ABC News
Primary sources: Royal Commission hearings, transcripts and exhibits and ABC's 19 November reporting.


