TL;DR: (you're welcome 😂) Started late in life (first real job at 36) and stressed about retirement. About $195k equity stuck in a house I love, in an area about to boom, but 45 minutes from everything I do, and 1hr 30mins from the office where I could advance more. Stretched thin overall and the house needs about $20k of work to just be healthy, not upgrades. HELOC (scared of debt), rent it out (doesn’t work yet, I think?), or sell, invest, and simplify my life (but absolutely miss the boom)?
Ok so almost 5 years ago I started over with literally nothing but this house. Got my GED, landed my job 3 years ago at 36, and haven’t stopped since. Paid off $20k in credit card debt, was able to buy my teen a car (probably more for me than for her lol), and over the years I’ve put a new roof, new fence, new deep well pump and new AC on this place. I do absolutely love it here. It’s quiet, I have my privacy, and my area is one of the fastest growing in FL. 1/2 acre fenced and my private park. Big hospital coming, tons of development. I KNOW the boom is coming, we’re one of the last areas “available” to develop in this part of FL.
But I’m spread so thin, I’m so tired lol. Between hustling at work, dealing with the co-parenting mind games, and raising 2 daughters and being there for them through everything they’re going through (which is a lot)... the house is starting to feel like a burden. It’s been 5 years of just non-stop going. It needs about $20k of work (bathroom redo + probably mold) and I just can’t pay for that out of my paycheck right now.
And as much as I love it here, being this far out is exhausting. Anytime I want to go out and actually enjoy myself, it’s a 45 minute drive to the city. My mom’s place? 45 minutes at least. The office is an hour and a half each way, and being closer would honestly help me grow there even more. I’m in the car constantly and it’s a LOT of freaking gas lol.
And the thing that keeps me up at night: I got started SO late. I didn’t have a real job until 36, so I’ve only been investing for a few years, really only got serious this past year. I want to retire comfortably, and that’s a stress I carry every single day. I hate that most of my money is sitting in this house doing nothing when it could be growing.
Numbers: house is worth around $290k, I owe about $95k at 2.875%, and my payment is $842/mo with taxes and insurance. So about $195k in equity just sitting there. I got a 20% raise in July of this year ($27 to $32.50/hr, about $67.6k), and now they want me to take over my team AND the department I created and have been building, so I’m going in for around 30% more. My job security is locked in, I work from home and have a company truck (that mostly sits lol) and come and go to the office as I please which is usually once a week right now. It is a bit chaotic, but great lol. My take-home right now is about $4,125/mo and my fixed bills are about $2,935 (then add gas, groceries, etc.), so there’s not much wiggle room until that raise happens. I have 2 car loans ($27.5k total at 5.25% and 5.75%), I pay my cards off every month, 820 credit score, about $11.5k in cash/bitcoin, and only about $25k in my 401k/Roth/HSA.
What I keep going back and forth on:
HELOC. fix what I need to fix and love my home a little bit more. $20k interest-only would be about $121/mo. Totally doable on paper, but I worked SO hard to get out of debt that even that scares me. I don’t want to go backwards. I’d want to take more to have more of a cushion.....but yeah, no.
Rent it out long term. I’d manage it myself (I used to run Airbnbs so I’ve got that part handled). But it would net me maybe $900/mo after maintenance and vacancy, and renting closer to the city is around $2k depending on where.. so I’d be paying $465 to $1,115 MORE a month than I do now. Doesn’t work until the raise is locked in. Plus FL just passed Amendment 3, so the homestead exemption goes to $150k in 2027 and $250k in 2028. I bought 12 years ago almost, so my taxes are low. Renting it out means losing that right when it’s about to save me real money. Go figure.
Sell. I’d walk away with $150k+, pay off both cars, and finally get somewhere around $120k actually invested and growing for my retirement instead of sitting in drywall. And honestly it’s not just the money. No more house projects, no more well, no more yard, no more “what’s breaking next,” and no more living in my car. Just a simple freaking life with way less on my to-do list so I can actually be present for my girls and myself. But giving up 2.875% AND selling right before this area blows up?? Ultimate face palm. Seriously I already hate myself for even thinking of it lol.
So what would you do? Is a small HELOC actually “good debt” here or is my gut right? Should I just wait until my raise is locked in? Does selling to invest make sense when I’m this behind on retirement? Am I missing an option? I just need some solid advice!