I mod a small retro-tech sub. Recently someone posted a triumphant 'FINALLY!!! N64 WORKS ON OLD NOKIA PHONES!!!' announcement. The post was clearly LLM-written and the project appeared to be an AI-generated port of an existing emulator, demonstrated running in another emulator.
A discussion about AI slop followed. I gently clarified that I’m fine with AI-assisted projects, but prefer transparency about what’s actually been achieved rather than grandiose claims. Got some pushback.
For context, I use AI myself. I’ve spent 5+ years building a retro adventure game with 100 scenes, using AI towards the end for some generic assets and image conversions. I’ve also vibe-coded entire little apps for my own personal usage (e.g. a driver for a 90's scanner which required decompiling the old driver). Both are legitimate, but IMO they’re very different achievements.
My gripe isn’t AI. It’s the formulaic 'I FINALLY DID IT!!!' posts with little technical substance, vague disclosure and defensiveness when questioned.
Not proposing bans or mandatory AI labels. Our sub is tiny and a gentle steer is probably enough.
Curious what other mods are doing. Specific AI rules? Disclosure requirements? Treating it as low-effort content? Or just letting the community decide? Figured it was a good time to reflect...