We all waitng to MTGO go back on-line so maybe you find some time to read my article!
Modern has a bit of a slow season, nothing big has happened regarding big tournaments in our favorite format, which isn't surprising since it's now a standard season. That doesn't mean players have abandoned Modern and it's boring. Now it's time to test new lists; Star Trek expansion has been released, and cards from it are already appearing in modern designs, so yes, people are testing, challenges are ongoing, so there's plenty to follow.
As usual, for everyone interested, here is an article with charts on Substack, and on the channel you can find a video with my analysis. On X, I try to post various interesting things several times a week, so if anyone feels like it, feel free to follow.
TL;DR
- Combo 37 Top 8 lists, most of any archetype, 1 trophy
- Aggro 5 of 13 trophies, after 1 in week 45
- Moonshadow 3 trophies from 14 lists in Top 8, all Rakdos version
- Prison 14 lists in Top 8 in 10 of 13 events, 1 trophy
- Genesis Device (new Star Trek card) is tested by 8 Amulet Titan players
- Midrange 9% of Chally meta, lowest of 12 weeks, 3 trophies
- No deck or archetype change beyond normal variation
This week in numbers
- 13 Modern Challenges, 403 Top 32 lists
- participant coverage 65% (403 lists of 620 players)
- 12 tracked decks, 0 changes beyond normal variation
- 7 archetypes, 0 changes beyond normal variation
- Rogue & unclassified 3%, −0.6 pp vs week 45
- 10 different decks with a trophy, none above 3
Aggro
Aggro (archetype) | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 34% | Change vs last week: +4.2 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 32 | Trophies: 5 | Pilots: 81
And Aggro returns to the top of Modern and is again the most popular archetype of the format. Its share is almost 35% of the entire format. Quite a lot must be admitted; the archetype is quite granular, and its best deck is not the most popular deck in Modern.
Moonshadow
Moonshadow | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 10% | Change vs last week: +0.0 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 14 | Trophies: 3 | Pilots: 29
Moonshadow rebuilt its position somewhat after last week, where it didn't win any trophies; now it has three trophys. Moreover, the deck has the highest pilot dispersion in the entire format, with the best player accounting for only 7% of the lists. What does this tell us? Namely, despite its popularity and very scattered player base, the deck performs excellently. It's similar to Broodscale, where many different players played the deck, yet it still won. This contradicts the rule I observed earlier that a popular deck performs worse because many undertrained players play it. Moonshadow is easier to master than other decks in the format and is an exceptionally explosive deck, capable of closing games very quickly. Of course, it has weak points, but sometimes even a RiP played too late (and that might be the second OTD turn) doesn't guarantee a win. Moreover, the case with trophies shows something else: it's not worth worrying that the deck doesn't earn trophies in one week; it's just variance, not a weakness of the design. As you can see, a lot of a given deck in T8 challenges is a sign that the deck is strong. And all trophies were won by the most popular variant, Rakdos.
Card changes: none reported
Energy
Energy | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 8% | Change vs last week: +1.4 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 12/13 | Top 8 lists: 5 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 14
Energy jumped to second place in Aggro I currently has 8% of the finish; here we have two main variants, the dominant Boros and the more midrange Jeskai. This week Boros was better because all 5 lists in T8 belonged to this color combination.
Card changes: none reported
Affinity
Affinity | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 6% | Change vs last week: +1.7 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 12/13 | Top 8 lists: 10 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 14
This week, Robots are in third place, losing the popularity contest to Energy by 2 percentage points. However, Affinity won one trophy. The deck itself is also not uniform because we have several variants, but the variant with Emry dominates and put 10 lists to T8. Moreover, the deck is trying to adopt new cards from Star Trek. Will this bring the desired effect? We will find out in the coming weeks.
Card changes:
- new this week: Blackcleave Cliffs, 2 pilots, 3 lists
- new this week: Collation Trimatrix, 2 pilots, 3 lists
Prowess
Prowess | Aggro | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 6% | Change vs last week: +1.2 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 12/13 | Top 8 lists: 3 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 19
Prowess lost in recent weeks on metagme, managed to introduce three lists to T8, and won one trophy. The reason for this is that the deck is more demanding and less aggressive than Moonshadow and loses direct duels to it. It's hard for me to predict how the deck will continue to develop, but one thing is certain: this build can still win Challenge and enter T8, though not as often as before.
Card changes: none reported
Combo
Combo (archetype) | Combo | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 31% | Change vs last week: −1.3 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 37 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 78
The combo drops to second place in terms of metagame positions; it's not a significant loss but still. What's more interesting is that this week the combo managed to win only one trophy. Similarly to Aggro, such a single event doesn't tell us much; it's more of a variance than a serious signal. If we observe this trend over the coming weeks, then yes, it might mean something, but for now, in my opinion, it's just a curiosity. And I would focus more on participation in T8 rather than trophies. If it doesn't change, the archetype or deck is doing very similarly.
Broodscale Combo
Broodscale Combo | Combo | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 12% | Change vs last week: −1.9 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 17 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 27
Combo is the second archetype of Modern, and Broodscale is his first deck. That hasn't changed for a long time, and I'm not surprised at all because the deck is very strong. Everyone is waiting for BnR, but does Broodscale really deserve a ban? Opinions are strongly divided; I try not to focus on that myself. Within the archetype, Broodscale won the only trophy. What's even more interesting is that in 7 weeks (since W39), Broodscale lost 10% of the meta share. This is not something you expect under an OP deck. During Boros Energy dominance, he maintained a much higher share and his sniffles were smaller than Broodscale.
Card changes: none reported
Amulet Titan
Amulet Titan | Combo | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 6% | Change vs last week: −1.1 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 11/13 | Top 8 lists: 6 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 14
The Titan Amulet is the second most popular Combo deck; it seems the Roiling Canopy buff had an effect, and the deck returns to the metagame after a brief absence caused by a lotus field ban. Moreover, in the latest set, something appeared that seems to strengthen the Amulet even more: the Genesis Device, which searches for land for three man, and also works like a Scapeshift but is uncontrollable? No wonder that more than half of the lists and half of the Amulet pilots are testing this card. The coming weeks will show whether it will be permanently included in the list or if it might just be an interesting experiment.
Card changes:
- new this week: Genesis Device, 8 pilots, 13 lists
Ruby Storm
Ruby Storm | Combo | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 4% | Change vs last week: +0.4 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 11/13 | Top 8 lists: 4 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 10
This week, the favorite deck of the hero of our last interview, Hugo Freitas, did not win any trophy, but introduced four lists to the T8. Very typical for this build, the pilots of this deck are very focused; one-third of the letters belong to one pilot. I am very pleased that there are players and decks who have their loyal fans, and the format is not just a race for a trendier design.
Card changes: none reported
Control
Control (archetype) | Control | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 9% | Change vs last week: +2.0 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 15 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 21
Control does really well; it's the third archetype of modern and accounts for almost 10% of all decks included in the t32 challenge. However, remember that this archetype, unlike what we saw in the previous two, is actually one deck, or maybe one game strategy, meaning Prison.
Prison
Prison | Control | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 8% | Change vs last week: +0.9 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 14 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 16
Prison is currently the only significant strategy within controls; the deck is not pleasant to play against because no one likes not being able to attack or cast their spells. Unfortunately, in a combo-dominated format, it seems to be the best strategy. The deck is very focused; one-third of the decks are piloted by a single player. It's no surprise, control decks have always been specialist builds. Additionally, the deck started playing Fracturing Gust in sideboard, a very interesting strategy for Affinity. But it's hard for me to say if it's effective? Maybe someone here can say more in the comments?
Card changes:
- new this week: Fracturing Gust (SB), 4 pilots, 5 lists
Midrange
Midrange (archetype) | Midrange | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 9% | Change vs last week: −2.1 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 6 | Trophies: 3 | Pilots: 21
My favorite archetype has been losing ground in recent weeks. It seems that Midrange is currently an archetype played by a few but successful finalists players; a drop from 20% (W36) to 9% (W46) is quite a lot.
Blink
Blink | Midrange | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 2% | Change vs last week: +0.4 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 7/13 | Top 8 lists: 2 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 7
Here's a surprise, because Blink hasn't appeared in rankings for some time due to a very low share in the meta, and now he's the biggest midrange deck, still 2% metagame, so it's not a lot. Interestingly, Blink introduced two decks into T8 and won one trophy. And here's another surprise: it's not the most popular variant Esper that wins the challenge, but his long-unseen brother Jeskai!
Card changes: none reported
Zoo
Zoo | Midrange | Weekly change: not tested | Share of Challenge Top 32: 2% | Change vs last week: +0.2 pp, not tested | Event presence: 6/13 | Top 8 lists: 2 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 3
My pet deck hasn't had a very good week, just two lists in the T8 challenge and only three pilots playing Zoo. This shows that Zoo is more of a deck played by a few regular players than something very popular. Overall, it is true for a long time now, it's only been interrupted by sprinkles of greater popularity when Zoo wins several times in a row in challenges or paper tournaments. Interestingly, this week the Zoo Frog version dominates, and one player experimented with cards like these: Assassin's Trophy, Consult the Star Charts, Prismari Charm, Questing Druid
Card changes: none reported
Graveyard
Graveyard (archetype) | Graveyard | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 9% | Change vs last week: +0.4 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 13/13 | Top 8 lists: 8 | Trophies: 1 | Pilots: 24
There are no major changes in grave-based decks, and as for many weeks, they are rather in the minority, although there is one surprise you will read about below.
Reanimator
Reanimator | Graveyard | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 4% | Change vs last week: +1.0 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 11/13 | Top 8 lists: 3 | Trophies: 0 | Pilots: 11
It's a promised surprise; I haven't seen a classic reanimator with Persist in a long time, and here you go, it jumps to the top spots in the GY archetype and introduces 3 lists into T8. Interestingly, this is not the result of a single player but rather several different pilots, and the deck is spread among different players. As of today, it's too much to talk about any significant growth, but the trend is going up, and if it continues, the situation will stop being a curiosity and become something to remember when preparing for the challenge.
Card changes: none reported
Ramp
Ramp (archetype) | Ramp | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 5% | Change vs last week: −2.5 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 9/13 | Top 8 lists: 4 | Trophies: 2 | Pilots: 12
Ramp is currently one deck, Tron. It has several builds, but a detailed description is below. Nevertheless, last week Ramp won two trophies, which is a very good result, especially considering that for T8 she introduced only four lists.
Tron
Tron | Ramp | Weekly change: stable | Share of Challenge Top 32: 5% | Change vs last week: −0.7 pp, within normal variation | Event presence: 9/13 | Top 8 lists: 4 | Trophies: 2 | Pilots: 12
Tron is winning trophies very convincingly; in the last three weeks, he had 1 (W44), 2 (W45), and again two. The deck is not very popular in the metagame, but as you can see, it manages well in the hands of an experienced pilot. It also has several variants; the most popular is, of course, Eldrazi Tron, which accounts for almost 85% of all Tron lists in challenges, and this version wins trophies. The others are Mono Green and Mono Blue, but none qualified as T8.
Card changes: none reported
Card changes in decks outside the breakdown
- Neobrand, new this week: Test of Courage (SB), 2 pilots, 2 lists
- Vengevine and Birthing Ritual: new decks in the rules this week, older lists reassigned
On the Radar
- Neobrand 14 lists vs 9 in week 45, not tested
- Neobrand 4 Top 8 lists in 3 events, 11 pilots
- Neobrand level: 2% in week 44, 3% in week 46
- Belcher 8 lists, top pilot 38% of lists
- Vengevine 4 lists, Birthing Ritual 3, both new in the rules
Trophy distribution, all 13
- 3: Moonshadow
- 2: Tron
- 1: Broodscale Combo, Prison, Living End, Prowess, Affinity, Blink, Dimir Midrange, Mono-Black Midrange
- archetypes: Aggro 5, Midrange 3, Ramp 2, Combo 1, Control 1, Graveyard 1
- 10 different decks, none above 3
What changed in the data
- DeckDB rules 37380967f3fb8a22 to c4310b586bc1a4d2
- two new decks: Vengevine (Aggro), Birthing Ritual (Combo)
- 317 of 24965 common lists with a changed deck
- Rogue & unclassified to Birthing Ritual 294, Blink to Birthing Ritual 16
- Rogue & unclassified to Vengevine 7; this week 4 Vengevine, 3 Birthing Ritual
- Scryfall card data updated, cards of the newest set now recognised
- week 45 recomputed on the new rules, all changes vs week 45
So all this week, as you can see, despite the slow season, something is happening, the metagame is changing, although I would call it more slight fluctuations than significant changes. New cards are appearing, people are testing them, checking new builds, so the situation looks as it should after the season ends: regeneration, new toys, and gathering strength before the next season. At this time, the most anticipated event is actually the announcement of BnR, which is less than two weeks away. What are your picks? How I'm still hoping for an un-ban Deathrite Shaman!
And as usual, if you reached the end of the text and liked it, you can buy me a coffe to support me. However, don't feel obligated to do that; my content will always be free, and I care that it only receives support if you truly appreciate it! If you prefer, you can also support me by liking my profile on YouTube or X! I would be equally grateful!
See you next week
Karol Małota
aka WarLord1986pl / TribalFlamesInYourFace