r/musictheory • • Jul 21 '26

Announcement New Policies on “I made an App/Diagram type Posts

213 Upvotes

The community has overwhelmingly expressed dissatisfaction with people posting Self-Made apps/diagrams etc., especially those that use AI.

Not only do these posts ignore our AI disclosure rules (breaking rule 9), they are often better-suited for other forums (breaking rule 4), are self-promotion (breaking rule 2), are posted with no engagement in the forum (breaking rule 8), and are also made by people with little knowledge of theory or are otherwise poorly designed which opens up issues that cause rules 7 and 1 to be violated.

As such:

  • “I made an App/Diagram etc.” posts, as well as posts that provide non-Self-Made resources are disallowed unless they meet the following criteria, to be determined by the mod team:
  1. The poster must be a regular contributor. Regular contributors should contact the Mod Team prior to posting.
  2. The resource is wholly on-topic for the forum and does not break any other rules.

Any posts not meeting these criteria or otherwise breaking the rules will be removed and the user may be banned at the mod team’s discretion.

  • Posters that even appear to be "trying to get around” this policy by linking to their apps in responses to other posters will have the posts removed and may be banned at the mod team’s discretion.

We are NOT trying to prohibit relevant and helpful resources, and traditional websites, books, videos, and “corporate” apps, or traditionally published diagrams are exempted from these policies (so long as they do not break other rules).

In the future, we may be able to provide a “Verified App” type of post. For now, this policy is intended to limit the amount of off-topic, controversial, and unnecessary apps/resources getting posted.


r/musictheory • • May 06 '26

Announcement New Rule about AI

246 Upvotes

A new rule (#9) has been added here at r/musictheory

Going forward:

  • Any post that is wholly or partially generated by AI must be disclosed as such. A simple statement like “This post was generated using AI” or “This post was created using AI assistance” will suffice.

  • Posts that are or are even suspected of being AI generated that do not disclose that fact will be removed at the Mod Team’s discretion.

  • We discourage AI creation of music and other creative endeavors. Therefore:

  1. Healthy discussions about AI tools used in Analysis of music and in similar Music Theory areas are allowed and welcome, so long as they do not violate other rules.

  2. Healthy discussions about the impacts of AI in music creation, performance, notation, and so on are allowed and welcome, so long as they do not violate other rules.

  3. Linking to or including AI generated content for the purposes of discussion as in #1 and #2 above is allowed, however it needs to be disclosed that those items are AI generated. Lack of this disclosure may result in removal at the Mod Team’s discretion.

  • Posts that link to or include AI generated or suspected AI generated content without any other kind of meaningful discussion will be removed at the Mod Team’s discretion.

Please report suspected AI content that lacks the disclosure policies above.


r/musictheory • • 7h ago

Discussion Why are Big Ben's Bells so Dissonant?

29 Upvotes

Why exactly does big ben's bells not match a pleasant tuning?
Like the Actual Hour bell itself is an E but has a very strong A5 character and very permeating G2 resonance? and the minor third isn't audible at all, does it even exist here? (the tierce). The quarter bells have the exact same problem! and the Westminster chimes "melody" is in F-major while the "big ben" is an e.
For example the nottingham bells, and the peace tower in canada actually sounds tuned correctly.
And even 1870s articles were complaining too.
Big Ben's Bells
Nottingham's Bells
Peace Tower Bells


r/musictheory • • 12h ago

General Question I vi IV V vs I V vi IV

Post image
10 Upvotes

I have been practicing those 2 chord progressions in an app. I made a bunch of mistakes when disnguishing those and started to think about them. Is it just me or the one ending on V sounds more resolved than the one ending on IV? Why could that be?


r/musictheory • • 2h ago

Answered What does this dotted line from C to E mean?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Learning to play the prelude 5 from Debussy's second book but I'm unsure what is the meaning of the dotted line going from C to E here


r/musictheory • • 6h ago

General Question Hark the Herald Chord Question

2 Upvotes

What is the brilliant, magical (augmented?) chord near the end of this carol?

My ear is decent, but this is a tricky one for me due to the brass/orchestra.

https://song.link/i/6832949205


r/musictheory • • 20h ago

General Question Fm9 vs Fm#9 on guitar

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Hey, I Hope it’s Not a dumb question but when I Play a fm9 on Guitar and I sharpen the 9 why does it turn to a fm7 instead to a #9 but when I raise it again in then becomes a f7#9. its really confusing.


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Notation Question D# vs Eb on sheet music

Post image
57 Upvotes

I am teaching myself to read sheet music and found this a little confusing. Is that last note of the second bar on the third line, an E natural or an Eb? My brain sees that we've shifted position on the staff line and wants to play an E natural, however I think I am supposed to repeat the same note, an Eb/D#.

Why is it written like this?


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

General Question Piano: moving in thirds ✅, but fourths and fifths is much harder to navigate/conceptualize for me

7 Upvotes

Coming from guitar where moving in 4ths/fifths is very easy, and on piano I can conceptualize/visualize thirds well enough as it’s adding a major or minor third below of above the last chord, skip a note in the scale, whatever

But for fifths I can’t seem to find out how to see them, one way is going down a maj3 and min3, or a maj3 and a half step, is this just how to look at the movement?

Thanks!


r/musictheory • • 5h ago

Notation Question Can someone help me understand slash chord/compound chord notation?

0 Upvotes

Hi, ADHD and Autism here, with an utter hatred for how disoriented these things make me.

If I see a progression like:

C F/A C D

My first instinct when I see the F/A is:

What the fuck do you want me to play

My first thought is to play F as the root note and then make a major chord, but oops, that means the A isn't the top note, so I ACTUALLY need to make C (THE ONLY NOTE NOT MENTIONED IN THE NOTATION) the root note of the chord and play F as the middle and A as the top

W H Y

Who thought this was good notation and/or why can't I seem to overcome this?

My family is a very musical family and whenever I complain about this and ask why it is they just say "That's how it's always been" and don't actually help me learn how to understand it better


r/musictheory • • 18h ago

General Question How do i study for my grade 8 music theory?

0 Upvotes

Hi. I am a student who will be taking the ABRSM grade 8 theory exam in next year August. So far,i am studying with my new teacher for a year who teaches theory quite well(we are now going through past year questions)

However, i still have many knowledge gaps that ive forgotten (especially ones my old teacher taught me) as i was busy with my IGs.

Now,these exams had ended and i can focus on my theory and practical again. I am currently rereading from the "Guidelines on harmony" book in the rhythm MP series and relearning the rules. I also have the books "in preparation for the theory examinations grade 6-8" and "guidelines on the instruments of the orchestra" as well as my new teacher's notes.

In addition,i would also hope to remember the theory concepts well and possibly study theory broader than what abrsm grade 8 syllabus offers so I can benefit from it for my practical too.

Ant advice on how can i study more efficiently to aim for at least a merit in the following exam? Any resources you would recommend for me?(Past years,answers etc). I am aware that ABRSM isnt as open source as IGCSE so I would appreciate model answers/human written mark schemes too. Thanks in advance.


r/musictheory • • 21h ago

Notation Question Traditional Harmony Hindemith exercise.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, historically I have learnt about 4 part harmony but wasn’t very good at it and I’m not very confident doing it. I have recently purchased Paul Hindemiths “Traditional Harmony: Book 1” and will complete the exercises in it to practice but I was hoping for feedback. The first exercise asks me to harmonise the bass line and use the chords written under the bass line. Before I move on, I wanted to check (and yes I know there are a lot more creative things I could do to harmonise) is it technically correct? I’ve checked for parallel fifths and octaves and cannot identify any.


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

General Question How do I improve my sense of scales and harmony, strictly while humming?

3 Upvotes

While I’m out, I have a lot of time to hum to myself, for a couple of hours a day. I have been moving around the major scale as primary practice, trying to internalize every degree. I want to scale out and do more than the major and major scale specifically, like modes. But when I try to do something other than major and minor, I cannot keep track of what scale degree I am on anymore. And cannot outline chords other than basic triads too.

With this, I don’t really know where else to start. Maybe I need to spend more time breaking the major/minor scale down? Humming chord outlines in the process? The thing is I produce music and what I hum is a huge influence for what I make, so I wanted to try different scales/modes as practice, I just don’t know which one to focus on next since there’s so many.

While I’m humming I don’t have too much time to check my accuracy except occasionally, so while trying to hum something not minor nor major, I often get lost.

I guess I’m asking, now that I have internalized the major and minor in their basic, root positions, where else do I go next? What can improve my sense of melody and harmony without an instrument ready to supplement my humming?

If you have any other advice as to how to make more of the major scale by humming that could help me, please say.


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

General Question Really crazy hard music theory questions

Thumbnail
gallery
363 Upvotes

I have been trying to puzzle out the answers to these questions. The first one is the minor (-) symbol — because I know when you lower the third in a triad functioning as the dominant chord, it really changes the sound (or did I understand that question right? I’m even not sure about that….)

The other ones, I looked up about transposing instruments and you’ll see how I tried to write things out. My answers were so incorrect, they weren’t even in the multiple choice options!

So you can see what a fix I’m in.

Can anybody help?

Thank you! I’m a hobbiest composer but trying to strengthen my skills!! This is a test a friend of mine took.


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Notation Question What does this symbol mean?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi, I've never seen this symbol before and can't find anything about it on the Internet. Does anyone know what it means?


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

Songwriting Question Seriously; how do write a good chord progression

52 Upvotes

I’ve been wanting to write songs for as long as I can remember, and as of late i’ve been dipping my toes into the production side of it. I’ve spent months doing nothing but practice, watching videos, learning instruments, I know the fundamentals pretty good. But, no matter what I do, no chord progression I come up with sounds pleasing, they’re all dull. I know that you technically can’t ‘math’ your way through music, and I’ve been told to just copy my favorite artists; but how exactly do i do that? Copy the song exactly and study it? Try and learn it by ear? I need a guide on how to dissect songs. I can hear everything, i understand how it can go together, but I can’t put a name onto any of it, nor can I apply anything to my actual songwriting abilities. I know about intervals, harmonies im starting to crack, I know about I III IV and all that stuff. I just can’t apply it anything, everything I write never matches the mark that I want it to. It’s like the answer is lying right behind a thin black sheet that I just can’t seem to pull back, is there a certain method to dissecting songs or building chord voicings that I’m missing?


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

General Question To jazz/gigging keyboard players, in practice, how do you actually remember chords?

27 Upvotes

I am aware that there is the technically correct way to spell chords using stacked 3rds with the appropriate chromatic sign. However, I’m curious if this is how everyone actually remembers chords in their heads while improvising or reading a chart.

For example, take a D-flat 7. Do you remember the 7th as a B or a C flat in your head. Like, in your mind, are you reaching for a C flat or B on the keyboard? And then if you modulate to D-flat minor are you going to convert in your head to C# minor or continue to think in terms of a D flat root.

My real question I guess is, should I try to drill in my head the correct way of spelling chords. Is that the best practice? When trying to be able to play chords instantly without any thinking, should I make an effort to remember chords in terms of their correct theoretical spelling.

Any advice is appreciated thanks!!!


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

Notation Question What does the slash chord refer to in this context?

Post image
25 Upvotes

I understand that slash chords can be used to represent chord inversions, e.g. C/E refers to the inversion of C major with E as the root note. I also understand they can be used to indicate a bass note played below a chord, e.g. C/D would refer to a c major chord with a D note played by the bass

And I understand the usage of Roman numeral analysis, representing chords within a key using Roman numerals. But I don't know what this means. Are they secondary chords? I would appreciate some help ☺️


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Songwriting Question How to write a song like Kitchenware and Candybars?

0 Upvotes

To me, every time I play and listen to that song it feels genuinely ethereal. I literally rue the fact that I couldn't come up with something like that myself; everything about it is just so right. Dark, strong, hopeful, symphonic, acoustic, electric, subtle, weak, loud. It puts me in the feels beyond the feels. So, whilst obviously a bit of a dumb question, how do I write something like that on my own as someone whose average with the guitar and knows nothing about songwriting. Thanks!


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

General Question Theory program/app I can use from bed

4 Upvotes

I’m having knee surgery later this week and am looking for a good music theory program, app, site, or program I can use from bed. I won’t be able to stand/walk for awhile; so while I play guitar, bass, and keys I won’t be able to use them for a while.

I’m focused on guitar/bass more and my end goal is to be able to play with my friends who are classically/jazz trained. mostly improve, so I’m not too worried about reading notation beyond basic learning purposes.

I’m currently using pickup music for bass and Fretgenius to memorize note layout on guitar/bass.


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

Songwriting Question For those who write jazz/jazz adjacent music, do you write chords or melody first?

7 Upvotes

I write mostly indie and pop music, where each section (verse, chorus, etc.) typically consists of a 2 to 4 chord loop. I typically write the chords on piano or guitar, flesh out the instrumentation, and then write a vocal melody on top of that.

I've been listening to a lot of jazz and show-tunes lately, and I wonder about the process of composers in those styles. I understand most of the theory behind jazz, but I've never had success trying to write complex chord progressions that can actually be made into a full song, so I wonder if I would have more success writing the melody first and then harmonizing it. The issue is, I typically struggle to hear a good melody until I have the chords.

I know there are many ways to write, so I'm sure jazz composers have used many different approaches. But just curious if there any composers on this forum, and what approaches they've had success with.


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

General Question Why is the first inversion of a major chord also considered a major chord?

3 Upvotes

Hi,

Why is the first inversion of a C major chord (E G C) also a C major? I get that when I play the notes at the same time , the higher octave C has overtones of lower C ,so there is some feeling of the C major, but when I play them in a sequence, they really are not the same intervals right? Major chord is a major 3rd plus minor 3rd.

I had this thought when I was trying to learn triads on my guitar on the higher 3 strings.


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

General Question Band pieces with microtones/quarter tones?

9 Upvotes

What wind band pieces include microtones or quarter tones?


r/musictheory • • 3d ago

Directed to FAQs/Search How do you use melodic and harmonic minor scales?

15 Upvotes

Beyond this question, how can these scales be applied and, above all, what could they be used for?


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

General Question Help identifying rhythms in Addams Family tango scene (1991)

4 Upvotes

Help! I'm writing an essay on the gender roles portrayed in the Addams Family 1991 (**edit, sorry I think it might be 1993 sequal!!) tango scene between Morticia and Gomez for my Latin American music class. I'm very new to Latin American rhythms, and I'm having trouble identifying them in the video. I need to spend some portion of the essay analyzing the music itself, but the central focus is on the gender roles.

Would anyone be able to help me identify which rhythms they are using and where (clave, habenera, tresillo, etc.)? Or if you could point me to a resource where I can hear all the rhythms and compare them so I can more easily identify them.

**Specifically, there is a part where Morticia takes shells off of a seafood platter and holds them up like a Spanish instrument and performs a rhythm. It's bugging me sooo much that I can't figure out the rhythm!!

Any help would be appreciated!!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIDabDkcS8o