r/musictheory • u/AviBledsoe • 7h ago
Discussion Why are Big Ben's Bells so Dissonant?
Why exactly does big ben's bells not match a pleasant tuning?
Like the Actual Hour bell itself is an E but has a very strong A5 character and very permeating G2 resonance? and the minor third isn't audible at all, does it even exist here? (the tierce). The quarter bells have the exact same problem! and the Westminster chimes "melody" is in F-major while the "big ben" is an e.
For example the nottingham bells, and the peace tower in canada actually sounds tuned correctly.
And even 1870s articles were complaining too.
Big Ben's Bells
Nottingham's Bells
Peace Tower Bells