r/piano • • 3d ago

Weekly Thread 'There are no stupid questions' thread - Monday, November 16, 2026

6 Upvotes

Please use this thread to ask ANY piano-related questions you may have!

Also check out our FAQ for answers to common questions.

*Note: This is an automated post. See previous discussions here.


r/piano • • 15h ago

🧑‍🏫Question/Help (Intermed./Advanced) what do these lines mean at the end of this bar?

Post image
167 Upvotes

i’ve never really seen it in any of my music until now. does it have a meaning? i figured it would because it’s not a common sight for me 😢

my second time posting this because reddit took it down for low effort content…


r/piano • • 8h ago

🙋Question/Help (Beginner) Wondering about theory and how to get “fluent” enough to freestyle as if it was an extension of myself

41 Upvotes

Saw this video and many others. And I’m genuinely shaking in frustration, how do I get this fluent to the point where I can just close my eyes and just play from my heart as if the piano was a part of me speaking.

Please anything helps. I don’t want to just play the piano. I want it to be a part of me, I want to be able to control it fully. If you’ve managed to get to this point then please, just tell me what to do and I will follow.


r/piano • • 56m ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Were abusive piano teachers a thing of the past?

7 Upvotes

I know this sounds like a weird discussion topic but I was thinking about my ex-piano teacher from my childhood, who was pretty much the reason for me quitting piano because she would hit my hands with a cane if I played the notes wrong and/or verbally berated me for it. Mind you, I was 10! And she didn't do it to me, she's also like this with her other students. And the wild part is the other parents of her students would encourage this sort of behaviour and even buy her new canes.

Now I'm 23, and I was just thinking if physical discipline was just normalised back in the day, or was I just unlucky with my teacher.


r/piano • • 2h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Piano Concert 22 November

4 Upvotes

All the details in comments :)


r/piano • • 6h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Schubert: Piano Sonata D. 959 – IV. Rondo. Allegretto

8 Upvotes

Schubert’s death anniversary has arrived, and continuing from yesterday’s post (https://www.reddit.com/r/piano/s/ZkUHi8p673), this is my 4th movement (from 2020) of his penultimate Piano Sonata No. 20 in A Major D. 959 💐

There have been debates if Schubert has neglected the distinction between 4/4 and alla breve in his late works by writing C for both, and because of the held bass notes in the beginning of the left hand, I chose on the latter for this Rondo to be played as a more fluent Allegretto dance and “one long phrase” for its rational-emotional build-up to the final Presto coda.

Here is a link to the entire sonata:
https://youtu.be/qvg3uh5Eros

Thank you! 🕯️ (19th November 2026)


r/piano • • 6h ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This How to the great pianists maintain works fresh in their minds and fingers for decades?

8 Upvotes

And I'd like to restrict this discussion strictly to classical pianists, because they almost strictly play works written by other people. Jazz and pop pianists have a prodigious memory too, of course, but they incorporate a lot of improvisation in their playing and so have greater leeway from remembering huge amounts of pre-written notes.

I am always astonished when some great pianist is being interviewed in front of a piano and when discussing some pieces they give the interviewer a little snippet of the piece in question. There are interviews in which Horowitz plays for the interviewer things that he hasn't touched in years and sometimes decades. There's a video where he and his wife Wanda are chatting about random pieces and he plays little bits and pieces of many of them.

In his book about Richter, Bruno Monsaingeon discusses a day in which Richter was in such a good mood that he discussed a lot of literature and music, and says in passing that Richter treated him to a performance of the Carmen overture (not a piano work that Richter would've kept in his active repertoire).

There's an interview in which Ashkenazy is describing the work of Rachmaninoff and mentions similar threads across the composer's work and shows examples by playing through bits of the Rach concerti and the 2nd symphony. Now, the concerti are a staple of a pianist's active repertoire, but a piano reduction of a symphony?

There's an interview in which Katsaris is describing his love for the piano and shows his excitement by quickly doodling through a bunch of random snippets of pieces that are not part of the core pianistic canon.

In my early 20s I knew a large chunk of so many of the great works of the piano repertoire but now that I am in my late 30s I'd need the music in front of me to play them.

Just how do they do it? Remembering melodies and being able to hum them is one thing, but to physically play extremely convoluted virtuosic piano pieces that one hasn't touched in years and decades at any given moment? Just how?

Is it because when one is at that level the piano is such an intrinsic part of them that one no longer needs to "remember" how to do it? Is it that pianism is so deep in their flesh and bones that being able to dash off anything is as second nature to them as tying our shoelaces is to us? Are they playing by ear? Is it just simply a matter of being a genius, how an extremely competent physicist would be able to just sit down and solve on the spot any calculus problem without having to "remember" how to manipulate functions?


r/piano • • 2h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) November 22 Piano Concert "ALCHEMY OF SOUND"

3 Upvotes

Hi! I’m Anastasiya, a concert pianist and Assistant Professor of Music at Christ University.
If you’re looking for something peaceful and different to do this Sunday evening, I’m performing a solo piano concert on Nov 22 at 6:00 PM at Moo Cha Kura, Koramangala.

Program: Bach, Brahms, Chopin, Rachmaninov, Granados, Borodin, and more.

Happy to answer any questions in the comments—hope to see some of you there! 🌸


r/piano • • 4h ago

🎶Other Participate in "Play Schumann's 'Kinderszenen' Your Way", the friendly quasi-monthly challenge for everybody!

4 Upvotes

Remember me? I used to help run the r/piano Piano Jams, before they were halted. A group of us started something similar at Pianotell--a quasi-monthly event where pianists of all levels tackle a piece together. We just started working on Schumann's "Kinderszenen" (Scenes from Childhood). Grade levels for the movements vary from 5-7, but some beginners are using simplified versions. Come join us, the more the merrier!

https://forum.pianotell.com/d/2789-play-kinderszenen-your-way-piyw-13-january-2027


r/piano • • 5h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Chopin Prelude in A Major

4 Upvotes

r/piano • • 1h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) English Suite No. 2 in A Minor BWV 807 Allemande

2 Upvotes

r/piano • • 10h ago

🤔Misc. Inquiry/Request LEGO IDEAS: Beethoven 200th Anniversary

9 Upvotes

Calling all Beethoven fans! Please make a Lego account and support this amazing Lego "Idea" (basically a fan-created lego) for a Beethoven 200th Anniversary set! I am a Lego collector/lover and this would be an instant purchase. This set needs a lot more supporters, so please share with your Beethoven loving friends and family members too! https://ideas.lego.com/product-ideas/650b8536-13cc-49f5-9b05-871ee4f43c08?tab=official-updates


r/piano • • 13m ago

🎼Useful Resource (learning aid, score, etc.) GitHub - fancellu/piano-scales-js: A simple, interactive single-page web application designed to help users explore musical scales on a piano keyboard.

Thumbnail
github.com
0 Upvotes

https://fancellu.github.io/piano-scales-js/ 805 Scales. Either select notes with mouse or MIDI input

People might find it useful.


r/piano • • 20m ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This As an adult where can I take my piano journey?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been getting back into the piano. I learned it as a kid for 4 years. As an adult I’m content with just playing for myself and learning songs I like. But I’m curious if I can go beyond that? Maybe joining a band, recitals, etc? What are my options?


r/piano • • 28m ago

🙋Question/Help (Beginner) How do you teach your self

0 Upvotes

I’ve learnt how to do a few chords and switching them, but I honestly just don’t know where to start and what to do can someone help?
Are they’re any good books to learn?


r/piano • • 29m ago

🙋Question/Help (Beginner) Self-taught beginner using Piano Marvel + Roland: Alfred’s Basic Adult All-in-One vs. Faber Adult Piano Adventures — and how/where did you learn?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

​I’m a self-taught beginner learning without a teacher. My current setup is a Roland digital piano and Piano Marvel, plus I have a classic Romanian beginner method book (Maria Cernovodeanu – Mica metodă de pian), which feels a bit too much like being thrown straight into playing pieces without enough structured explanation when you don’t have a teacher guiding you.

​I’m trying to pick a solid adult method book to pair with Piano Marvel and decide between:

​Alfred’s Basic Adult All-in-One Course (Level 1)

​Faber Adult Piano Adventures All-in-One (Book 1)

​From what I’ve gathered so far (and from AI/research), there seem to be some real trade-offs for someone learning solo:

​Alfred is integrated into Piano Marvel’s library, which sounds super convenient for real-time feedback and rhythm, but I’ve read concerns that it can keep you in fixed hand positions (like C position) too long, risking finger-number habits instead of real note/interval reading, or leaning heavily on basic block/oom-pah accompaniment early on.

​Faber is often praised for clearer explanations for self-learners, landmark notes/intervals, and more balanced hands early on, but it isn’t in Piano Marvel, so I’d be splitting my routine between the book and the app.

​My main worry is not learning properly or picking up bad habits from either choice—whether that’s weak sight-reading, stiff technique/rhythm, or gaps in theory that a digital app doesn’t catch.

​For those who learned or are learning on your own:

​How and where did you actually learn? (Which books, apps, YouTube channels, websites, or routines worked best for you, and what did you skip?)

​If you used Alfred or Faber alongside an app like Piano Marvel, how did you combine them without getting stuck in bad habits?

​Did you feel one of them left noticeable gaps in your fundamentals (reading, rhythm, hand independence, theory)?

​Anything you wish you had watched out for earlier as a self-taught beginner?

​Thanks in advance for any honest advice!


r/piano • • 4h ago

🎵My Original Composition I composed a waltz!

2 Upvotes

I made it as simple as possible, and I hope you'll listen until the end. Please share your thoughts too!

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wemi5wTdPcbpCabQE9HMvWHse6tPOc0y/view?usp=drivesdk


r/piano • • 4h ago

🔌Digital Piano Question Upgrading from FP-10 after couple years (Yes, I've read the FAQ)

2 Upvotes

After three years of learning I feel like it's time to upgrade my FP-10 to something with better action. I'm not looking for entry level but mid range. At this point I know it's more about the technique and not the piano, but with my small hands and being left handed. Playing tremolando with black keys with my right hand is just uncomfortable (i.e. Gm - Bm Dm F) the keys are too stiff at the end of the board.I don't have that much problem at my teachers piano but that's Casio GP-310. 

The used market in my country is non existent. I have to buy new. I'm struggling to pick anything because I can't put an upright anywhere in my apartment, the current location is in front of my closet, so I have to move the piano from time to time, and moving 45-50kg isn't feesable on hard wood floor and with my upper body strength. If I could I would just buy Casio AP 650, but it's not a slab. So I'm looking for a slab alternative. There is a very limited assortment available in physical stores so I can't even try out couple different ones, they only stock either cheap ones or very expensive ones. I've read about Kawai ES 920 but it seemed that it has mixed reception, and without ability to try it myself, kinda hard to pull the trigger.

I realize that at that price point (around Casio AP 650) I should just get an digital upright which would actually be a clear improvement, but I'm really coping it won't come down to this. So any recommendations for slab digital piano around the price point of Casio AP 650? Or more like ~$100


r/piano • • 5h ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Pieces you hate/recordings that change your hatred

2 Upvotes

I really hate the Mozart Fantasia in D minor (k397). It sounds arbitrary, empty, almost like a sketch of a piece. It seems harmonically and melodically monotonous and the dynamic markings are random, almost opposite of musicality. I would like to find a recording that makes me not hate it.

  1. Do you have any suggestions for recordings? I listened to the ones by the famous mozart people
  2. Do you have a similar famous piece that you hate? Did you find a recording that gave you a new appreciation for it? Better yet, did you find a way to play it in a way that changed the piece for you?

r/piano • • 1h ago

🔌Digital Piano Question Any good pianos with hammer weight under 400$? (Digital piano)

1 Upvotes

If this is not allowed to ask, then its ok to throw rocks at me

But i just want to know any good picks for a piano at 400$. I can also get second hand but i dont what nitpicks or red flags to look out for since ive never owned a piano.

I dont particularly care about midi keyboards, but id want something where you can change the sounds of the keyboard while playing


r/piano • • 10h ago

🔌Digital Piano Question Hi Please give me a guide 🙏🏻

5 Upvotes

I am 20 years old now and I've never played piano in my life before but I am really interested in it since I was at the age of 16. My father was asking me which keyboard Piano to buy for a beginner? It's never too late right? 😟 Any tips on which Digital Piano to buy?


r/piano • • 2h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) November 22 Piano Concert

1 Upvotes

Hi! I’m Anastasiya, a concert pianist and Assistant Professor of Music at Christ University.
If you’re looking for something peaceful and different to do this Sunday evening, I’m performing a solo piano concert on Nov 22 at 6:00 PM at Moo Cha Kura, Koramangala.

Program: Bach, Brahms, Chopin, Rachmaninov, Granados, Borodin, and more.

Happy to answer any questions in the comments—hope to see some of you there! 🌸


r/piano • • 22h ago

🧑‍🏫Question/Help (Intermed./Advanced) Did I miss out by not learning any half pedaling or pedal manipulation techniques in conservatory? When did this get in vogue?

37 Upvotes

Prior to reading threads here, I'd never even considered half pedaling or gradual pedal release, I've always treated it as effectively an on/off switch.

I studied seriously for 10+ years, including in conservatory, a couple decades ago and never learned this or heard any of my fellow pianists talk about it. Is it a technique that has seen a resurgence of late or did I just miss out on picking up on it when learning?

(FWIW, some of the people I studied with have gone on to serious professional solo careers, so they were no slouch!)