r/MuslimNikah
•
u/Moist_Mycologist7852
•
9h ago
Title: Called off my nikkah because my fiancé became harsh and controlling right after we agreed to proceed. Now I’m second-guessing myself..did I make a mistake?
​
I received a marriage proposal from a family living about two hours away from my city. We did a very thorough background check on both the family and the guy, and everyone had great things to say about them.
We decided to proceed, and I met him for the first time. He was so sweet and bubbly, I was instantly attracted to him, and I became really happy and excited about the nikkah preparations.
A few days later, his family reached out saying he wanted to give me a gift and speak with me. We were all thrilled, and I was so excited to meet him again and actually have a proper chat.
However, when the day came, he was completely different. His tone was harsh and controlling. He told me that I had to be very obedient and respectful toward him, and that I had to inform him wherever I go. Honestly, by nature, I am already a soft-spoken, submissive, and respectful girl..so these expectations aren't even things I’d need to change about myself for. It was the harsh, condescending way he delivered it, especially on what was basically our first real conversation..that made me feel deeply uneasy.
After that meeting, I told my mom that I needed to talk to him more before taking things forward so I could properly understand him, his *akhlaq* and how he treats people.
Here is what happened during that talking phase:
**Day 1 & 2:** On the very first call, he started lecturing me again in a condescending manner about needing to be respectful and obedient, which triggered my anxiety since I'm naturally a nervous person. On top of that, he made me call him first both times (when, as a girl, I expected him to take the initiative). On the second call, he repeated the "respect and obedience" speech and started saying me on how frequently I must call his mother, how to speak to his father, and how to behave with his sisters. It didn't feel like mutual bonding; it felt like he was trying to control me to satisfy his ego.
**The "Demand" comment:** The next day, he didn't text me at all. When I finally messaged him first, he admitted he had been free the entire day and was deliberately waiting for me to reach out. He literally told me, *"I can show my 'demand' to you, but I won't do that."* That really hurt. Usually, men in the talking stage are warm and affectionate with their future wives, yet he was playing power games and making me feel unvalued.
**My Hijab:** During another meeting, I mentioned that I wanted to wear my hijab for my nikkah. He brushed me off and said, *"I don't know, ask my sisters about that."* That stung so much.
**The Final Straw (Finances & Parents):** Out of nowhere during a conversation—keep in mind I had *never* once brought up his money or work—he randomly told me, *"I don't like you putting your hand in my business. Don't ever do that, stay out of the money dealings."* When I asked what he meant because I was confused, he said, *"No, some women try to interfere in financial transactions."* He also warned me that whatever he does for his parents, I must stay away and not interfere. That felt so insulting because it’s basic common sense—in fact, I’m the type of person who would actively encourage my husband to do more for his parents, not stop him.
I realized I wasn't happy talking to him at all, and I was constantly hurt, so I made the decision to call off the nikkah. Btw all signs showed up after isthikarah prayers.
When I did, his mother cried, which made me feel awful. His sisters also told me that I’m the unlucky one for missing out on a guy like their brother, completely ignoring everything he said and did.
Now I feel like *Shaitan* is messing with my head, making me wonder if I made the wrong decision. Should I have spoken to him more to give him a chance? I know you shouldn't marry someone expecting them to change, and I’ve always just wanted a kind, friendly spouse.
Did I make a mistake here?