r/NFA • • Oct 09 '26

HOLY SHIT MEGATHREAD. Just read it. ATF Guidance just released for the 5th Circuit injunction

711 Upvotes

r/NFA • • Jul 19 '26

Megathread: Form Approval ⏳ 2026 3rd quarter stamp approval megathread.

38 Upvotes

Form 1 or 4 Instructions

Form 4 - Desired Post Format: link to entry form

  • Form Type: Form 1 or Form 4
  • Paid or not: $200 or $0
  • Entity: Trust or Individual
  • Fingerprint Type: Mailed Paper or EFT Upload
  • Pending: mm/dd/yy
  • Approved: mm/dd/yy
  • Wait: (Approved - Pending)
  • State: Standard 2 Character Abbreviation
  • Control Number: example 2022535123 - this is the number contained in the initial email from the ATF - if you don't want to write the full number, just put 00 for the last two digits - example 2022535100

Notes:

  • Certified Form 4s will not appear in your personal ATF login - your dealer submitted it through their login, it will only appear your FFLs login.
  • No approval screenshots please - follow the format detailed above.
  • ⚠️⛔️ Comments posted in this thread should be approvals only. If you make a new comment that is not an Approval, you’ll be aggressively downvoted… as is tradition ⛔️⚠️
  • If you have a question - please ask! But please ask your question by replying to the stickied comment.

r/NFA • • 7h ago

Legal Question ⚖️ If 200,000 Stun Guns Can Be Considered Common Use, Why Not 234,000 Transferable Machine Guns? A Form 1 Challenge to the Hughes Amendment

204 Upvotes

I’ve been digging into the constitutionality of the Hughes Amendment, 18 U.S.C. §922(o), particularly the argument that machine guns fall outside Second Amendment protection because they’re considered “dangerous and unusual.”

The more I research it, the more questions I have about how courts determine what constitutes common use, especially when the government itself has restricted the supply of a particular firearm for 40 years.

According to ATF’s published statistics, as of June 2025 there were approximately 234,718 transferable machine guns in the National Firearms Registration and Transfer Record.

That doesn’t mean 234,718 individual civilians own machine guns. Some are held by dealers, government entities, or others. But these are firearms that qualify for transfer under the pre-May 19, 1986 grandfather provision.

Now compare that with Caetano v. Massachusetts (2016).
In that case, the Supreme Court rejected Massachusetts’ reasoning for excluding stun guns from Second Amendment protection.

Justice Alito, joined by Justice Thomas, specifically discussed the fact that hundreds of thousands of Tasers and stun guns had been sold to private citizens. He considered those numbers relevant to determining whether they were in common use for lawful purposes.
To be clear, the Court did not establish 200,000 as some magical constitutional threshold. And Alito’s discussion was a concurrence, not the Court’s holding.
But the comparison raises an interesting question.

If hundreds of thousands of stun guns are relevant evidence of common use, why are hundreds of thousands of legally registered transferable machine guns treated so differently?

I recognize that machine guns and stun guns have different capabilities, risks, and legal histories. I’m not arguing that their ownership numbers alone make them constitutionally equivalent.

What interests me is the government’s role in creating the very scarcity that courts subsequently rely upon.
Consider the timeline:

Before May 19, 1986, eligible civilians could lawfully manufacture and register machine guns using ATF Form 1, subject to the NFA.

After the Hughes Amendment, that pathway was generally closed to ordinary civilians.

For the last 40 years, the civilian transferable supply has effectively been frozen, with no general pathway for newly manufactured machine guns to enter that market.

Then courts evaluate whether machine guns are in common use by examining the relatively limited number available to civilians.

Isn’t that circular reasoning?

The government restricts the supply, then points to the restricted supply as evidence that the firearm is unusual, and therefore outside constitutional protection.

How could any prohibited category of arms ever become common under that standard?

Here’s where the Form 1 question comes in.

Suppose a law-abiding citizen submits an ATF Form 1 seeking authorization to manufacture and register a new machine gun.

The applicant is willing to comply with the NFA, undergo the background check, register the firearm, and pay any applicable tax.

ATF denies the application under §922(o).

The applicant then challenges that denial in federal court rather than manufacturing anything unlawfully.

This isn’t entirely hypothetical as a legal strategy.

In Hollis v. Lynch (5th Cir. 2016), a plaintiff pursued essentially that approach. The Fifth Circuit recognized standing but ultimately rejected the Second Amendment challenge.

What’s particularly interesting is that Hollis discussed the Caetano concurrence and the comparison between stun gun ownership and machine gun ownership.

That makes me wonder whether the historical-tradition framework subsequently established in Bruen, and clarified in Rahimi, provides any meaningful basis for revisiting that analysis.

I also haven’t been able to locate a reliable ATF breakdown showing how many machine guns were originally manufactured and registered by civilians on Form 1 before May 19, 1986.
That seems like relevant historical data worth obtaining.

The questions I’m interested in discussing are:
Can government-created scarcity legitimately establish that a category of firearms is constitutionally unusual?

How should courts evaluate common use when civilian acquisition has been substantially restricted for decades?

What significance should Caetano have when comparing ownership numbers across different categories of arms?

Does Bruen change the constitutional analysis applied in Hollis, or does Heller’s discussion of M16s effectively foreclose the argument?

What historical analogue supports a categorical prohibition on newly manufactured civilian machine guns, rather than registration and regulation under the NFA?

Could a properly structured civil challenge following a Form 1 denial present these questions for judicial review without anyone violating federal law?

I’m aware that there is substantial unfavorable precedent here. I’m not pretending Heller didn’t discuss M16s or that courts haven’t repeatedly upheld §922(o).

I’m also not advocating that anyone manufacture or possess anything prohibited under current law.

What I’m questioning is whether the government should be able to use the consequences of its own restrictions as the constitutional justification for maintaining those restrictions.

I’m interested in understanding whether there’s a legitimate constitutional argument here, not just another discussion about whether machine guns should be legal. I am sure anyone who paid a pile of cash for a transferable would oppose this as it would make those guns worth significantly less.


r/NFA • • 2h ago

NFA Photo The Nightman Cometh

Post image
65 Upvotes

Night vision range session this weekend.

HK MR556 with the new Echocore Sector CF.
Staccato C2 with Rugged Obsidian 9.


r/NFA • • 6h ago

New Sound Signature Review - Canik VOID-9 on 9mm Pistol and Human Perception Analysis

Post image
97 Upvotes

Good morning, folks! Three (four?) deliverables for you today. First, two tests of the Canik VOID-9 (solid and vented end caps) on the 9mm HK P30L including free Human Perception Analysis (Suppression Rating Loudness and Tone). Also, a Hazard Map Brief for a spatial look at the risk field while using both configurations of the silencer. Then, a podcast episode with an intro to the silencer, the new Perception Plots, and the technical talk for the PRO-KOR 6 Mini Ti from last week.

Lab Data Stuff

Report 6.244 - Today we examine the high fidelity test results for the Canik VOID-9 silencer, in two configurations (solid and vented end caps) in the subsonic ammunition combustion regime with Speer Lawman 147gr 9mm ammunition fired from the HK P30L combat handgun.

Tools to help you in addition to the report:

Well this is an interesting silencer...

CliffsNotes

  • The VOID series is Canik's first entry into the silencer space. The VOID-9 is designed by Otter Creek Labs and uses Infinity hybrid tech. 3D printed titanium and changeable end caps (solid or vented).
  • Interesting size class. Typical 1.38-in diameter, but only 6.75-in long, piston included. With piston, 9.4 ounces as tested. Sort of fitting in the "mid size" 9mm pistol silencer category here.
  • Speaking of pistons - Canik doesn't have a metric 13.5mm LH piston (for shame). So, we used a Rugged Obsidian 9 piston. Not sure if it matters, but it might, because the Canik 1/2-28 piston it came with doesn't have vents and the Rugged piston (and other pistons) do, so... guess we'll see what happens later. HK test host has metric barrel from the father land.
  • We have done a ton of Infinity tech testing and it's on our website. Infinity 762, 556k, Rampart Range Carson series, Universe-36: all Infinity tech. The VOID-9 adds 9mm pistol to the mix. Very interesting adaptation.
  • When you vent an Infinity core, you don't just add holes. You actually choose (designer of end cap choice) whether you vent more from the bore or some from the annulus, or both. The VOID-9 adds bore venting AND annular venting. What's the result? Really strong performance, actually, all things considered.
  • Two big performance factors here: high early time flow rate gives great operator protection no matter which end cap you choose. Choose the vented and it ramps it up big time. Matching CAT SC at the shooter's ear here. Will it sound the same to the shooter as the CAT SC? No. Will it protect the shooter in the free field the same way? Yes. Pretty strong muzzle suppression performance, all things considered. The fact that the Vented end cap doesn't tank the muzzle Suppression Rating is pretty cool. Elevating the shooter's ear Suppression Rating by half a category is fairly significant.
  • What makes the shooter's ear Suppression Rating jump up with the vented end cap? Glad you asked:

New PEW-SOFT HD Silencer Perception Plots (Suppression Rating Loudness and Tone Analysis)

With the VOID-9 Vented end cap, ejection port blast plummets and so does mechanical shock. The Suppression Rating reflects this, the raw data reflects this, the Hazard Maps reflect this, etc. But people always want more and everyone learns differently. So... we're giving you more and hoping it will help further explain how this all works. Buckle up for actual tone. Tone is not subjective. But the words you use to describe this objective phenomenon can be. So these plots should help you.

  • These new Perception Plots are free for everyone. Members get them for FRP too. The free ones are still very useful. You might also have hearing damage in a certain frequency range. These plots can help you with that too, and explain why you are hearing what you are hearing.
  • PEW Science Suppression Rating calculations always consider tone mathematically, by default, as it is an inherent signature characteristic. To provide further objective engineering breakdown of how a suppressed signature is perceived across the human hearing spectrum, we offer this new deliverable for your consumption. Members have seen something similar from us before. This is kicked up a notch. And it's so good, I wanted to make sure it is publicly available and free for everyone just like the Suppression Rating and Hazard Maps.
  • These plots should be self-explanatory (just read the plot titles, plot legend, and plot axes). For the full description, see Section 6.244.1 in the Report. Unlike conventional microphone frequency plots that merely display raw free field pressure amplitudes, these curves are derived directly from the Suppression Rating analysis to map the true physical loudness and tonal response experienced by the human ear across four distinct regimes of perception (300 Hz to 15,000 Hz). These are not simple FFTs of pressure signals.

If you like these, we'll keep doing them. Let me know!

Commentary:

Not everyone likes suppressing pistols. Most of us carry a pistol a lot and frankly, we don't carry a silencer for it often, if at all. But boy, when you need it.... you need it. I really enjoy having a silencer with me for critter control around the ranch, for fun suppressed practice after my main unsuppressed pistol shooting practice, stuff like that. And for those folks that use them professionally, obviously they have a need too. Centerfire pistol silencers have always been my favorite type of silencer and I hope folks enjoy this data and analysis. Whether it's 9mm or .45, or maybe other stuff, the mechanical aspect of pistol silencers has always been really cool to me. They are harder to make "good" than rifle silencers. They are neat.

I hope you folks find the data and analysis useful! Really hope the tone and perception analysis helps all of you.

Check out pewscience.com for the Suppression Rating.

Here is a direct link to the reviews.

Here are the updated PEW Science Rankings.

Our silhouette man is super cool (high speed, low drag) with a suppressed HK!

TLDR: Green good, red bad.

Podcast Stuff

Episode 331 of The Jay Situation Podcast is out now on pewscience.com and all major providers.

Direct-download from the website, or use your favorite provider below:

Amazon Music | YouTube | YouTube Music | iTunes | Spotify | Pandora | TuneIn | Direct RSS Link

Today's topics:⠀

  1. Sound Signature Review 6.244 – Canik VOID-9 with Solid and Vented End Caps on 9mm semiautomatic pistol. This silencer is designed for Canik by Otter Creek Labs. 3D printed titanium, Infinity hybrid design technology, interchangeable end caps, and… it’s not that big. How does Canik’s entry into the silencer space stack up with the high levels of competition? You may be pleasantly surprised. Introduction to today’s very in-depth report. (00:08:03)
  2. PEW Science PEW-SOFT HD Silencer Perception Plots – these are new deliverables, and they are free for the public! PEW Science Suppression Rating calculations always consider tone mathematically, by default, as it is an inherent signature characteristic. To provide further objective engineering breakdown of how a suppressed signature is perceived across the human hearing spectrum, PEW Science has developed this new value-added deliverable for you. Members also get FRP tone profiles. (00:23:06)
  3. Sound Signature Review 6.243 – JK Armament PRO-KOR 6 Mini Ti on the 10.3-in barrel MK18 and 14.5-in barrel M4. Two 5.56 tests! JK is back and you saw the PRO-KOR 556K testing and analysis back in April. The 6 Mini Ti is shorter, and you really don’t lose that much performance, apparently. Technical discussion of last week’s report. (00:42:57)

    a. General overview (recap) of the PRO-KOR 6 Mini Ti. (00:45:10)

    b. PRO-KOR 6 Mini Ti silencer design and functional physics. (00:51:51)

    c. MK18 and M4 Hazard Maps in Silencer Hazard Map Brief 8.1.40. (00:57:30)

    d. Technical performance discussion – suppressing 5.56 on two barrel lengths. (01:00:57)

    e. Performance comparisons and overall thoughts. (01:08:38)

As always, thank you so much for listening, and for your support!

Happy Wednesday!My dudes


r/NFA • • 19h ago

Drama 🎭 Gotta add SOLGW to the list of companies I'll never spend a dime with

Thumbnail
gallery
757 Upvotes

r/NFA • • 3h ago

Suppressed CZ527 NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

I was in my living room minding my own business when I saw this guy chasing a doe in my yard. I couldn’t pass up the opportunity, so I grabbed my rifle out of the closet and took the shot off my back porch. Living in the middle of nowhere can be fun sometimes.

Rifle is chambered in 7.62x39 with a Dead Air Nomad


r/NFA • • 1h ago

Hobby machinist skills test

Post image
21 Upvotes

As a home machinist with tools far more capable than myself, I managed to not create an immediate failure.

Went way overboard with tolerances for a .22lr, no FAFO here...


r/NFA • • 2h ago

Black Friday wait?

13 Upvotes

Silly question but I have suppressor cash burning a whole in my pocket. Wait for Black Friday potential or pull the trigger now? I know the market is so hot there’s no incentive for anyone to offer a deal.


r/NFA • • 3h ago

SureFire SOCOM556-RC4 - Flash Suppression Series Episode 21

Thumbnail
youtu.be
16 Upvotes

The SureFire RC4 Flash test is now live on the channel! It's important to check out our disclosure before you watch this video!

We will be featuring the RC4 Mini next!

Let us know how you think this can performed!


r/NFA • • 18h ago

Flask funnel baffle bois

Post image
115 Upvotes

Obviously whiskey inspired. Somebody's getting a good coating of epoxy and fiberglass and a soda can shield


r/NFA • • 11m ago

POI shift?

3 Upvotes

I’m looking for a 30 cal can with the least amount of POI shift. I plan to have this as a dedicated suppressor. I just would like the smallest amount of change possible between taking it off and reinstalling it for travel purposes.

Also any suggestions on the best 308 can?


r/NFA • • 23h ago

NFA Photo My 357/38 guns

Post image
166 Upvotes

Love shooting 38 Specials suppressed.🤗😁


r/NFA • • 1d ago

300BLK ASVAL/VSS

Thumbnail
gallery
350 Upvotes

Local gunsmith collaborated with B&T to make a 300BLK ASVAL. I know, I know it’s not an AR15 but technically it’s using an AR15 BCG AFAIK. (And it’s fucking cool as shit)

I wanna help him out by spreading the word.

More info:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSc1meW6mb9fxqh2kb_evS8TwUhjhM27JTc4PKqy2vNFOZwcbA/viewform?pli=1&authuser=0

Website:

https://bsdfabworkx.com/


r/NFA • • 1d ago

Original Content 60mm demo shot

251 Upvotes

Want to see stuff like this in person? Check out the Big Bore Blast in April. Bigboreblast.com chevtec.com


r/NFA • • 5h ago

Suppressor for 7.62 bolt gun SBR, difficulty inside post.

4 Upvotes

7.5" barrel 7.62x39, bolt action. My normal go-to for suppressors don't suggest anything shorter than 10.5".

I'm not looking for Hollywood quiet, just something to tamp down the noise a bit. Currently running an SMD on it, which pushes the fireball forward, but does little for the noise for those around me (I only shoot it outdoors and generally when no one is around, but sometimes the range gets crowded)

I'd prefer direct thread if at all possible, but I understand that might not be possible.


r/NFA • • 20h ago

Preventing suppressor walk off on a pistol

Post image
52 Upvotes

Running a VP9 with a SAW shiv. Ive swapped the springs and it’s running 100% reliable with all types of ammo, but I can’t get through 10 rounds without the can starting to loosen up. I’ve hand cranked it as tight as humanly possible (no access to a vice) and tried plumbers tape with even less success. Is there anything else that can be done without figuring out a vice setup in my apartment? Trying to avoid rocksett as I won’t always be running the can, but I’m out of ideas.


r/NFA • • 23h ago

NFA Photo Can't imagine hunting without suppressors

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

Georgia legalized it back in 2014 and I wouldn't feel comfortable getting in the field without one, especially something like this .300 win mag. AA Suppressor Raptor 8 with reflex mount on Howa 1500.


r/NFA • • 19h ago

Discussion Working on a Mossberg master key mount

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/NFA • • 1h ago

Mount Questions 🔩 Looking for a hub adapter

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I'm really just wanting to do direct thread. I know there are Plan B mounts, but are there any 1.4375x20 mounts that are extended and not flush? I don't need much it's maybe half the length of a crush washer not sure if shims are okay for direct thread either.


r/NFA • • 1h ago

AR lower/pistol questions

0 Upvotes

I've done research but I'm still wondering about a few things. I'm new so go easy on me. For this post I'd like to ignore the GOA lawsuit rules for now.

I know I can buy a stripped AR lower on a 4473 just like any rifle/handgun.

If I then Form 1 that stripped lower, and put it into a NFA trust, it can be legally built out into an SBR.

Question 1: With that unbuilt lower being Form 1'd and engraved, how does that affect storage? Since it isn't built out, if someone like my wife is not on the trust, is it ok to let them have access to it while its unbuilt, or should they not have access to it?

Once I decide to build that lower, I put everything on it except a stock, I put an 11.5 upper on, and attach a pistol brace (or buffer tube bare). This means that lower started its life as an AR pistol and can go back and forth between that and an SBR. Leading to:

Question 2: If that fully made gun that has been form 1'd is in SBR condition (Rifle stock, 11.5 upper, vertical foregrip) and my wife is not on the NFA trust then its obvious they can't have access to the gun. But if I take that gun, and put it in pistol condition (pistol brace, no foregrip, 11.5 barrel) is it ok for them to have access to it? Same question for if that lower is used for a 16 inch upper.

Question 3: with these questions in mind, I'm under the impression that if I have that same lower that has been form 1'd and was built first as a pistol, I can bring it across state lines in pistol condition without informing ATF, but if its in rifle condition I can't. But it's still an engraved lower. Right?

Question 4: now if I want to sell this lower fully stripped in the future with my info engraved on it...can I do that or because it has been registered as an NFA item does it need to go through NFA transfer rules?

Appreciate any help for this newbie.


r/NFA • • 18h ago

Mount Questions 🔩 Enough barrel to thread?

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Looking to get a suppressor for my .338 winmag rifle and was wondering if this is enough barrel to thread? It is roughly 1” from end of barrel to the beginning of the grooves. Would it be bad to thread onto the grooves?

Any suggestions are appreciated


r/NFA • • 16h ago

Original Content Tight Fit

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Finally got my first suppressor a Silencerco Hybrid 46. Have the intention of building an 8.6 bolt gun and to run it on my 45-70 guide gun but figured I'd pick up an ASR mount for the first rifle I ever put together and it couldn't have been a closer fit. 18in barrel with a 17.5 Parallax Tactical FFSSR.


r/NFA • • 20h ago

Love the Temperance, had to try the Verdict7.62

Post image
20 Upvotes

Been a lot of talk on the Polite Society for a new company in the market! Price is right! I’m going to run from 300blk to 6.5prc through her Friday morning.


r/NFA • • 23h ago

Romanian Micro Draco

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

Draco Build
SLR Rifleworks:
Stock
4.7” Ion Handguard
AK Ion Handstop
Synergy Linear Compensator (Raw)

Tangodown Grip (Mahogany)

TWS Hob Knob (Black)
Stormwerkz Folding mechanism

Surefire X300U- B (Flat Dark Earth)

Bulgarian Ak Mag Steel Reinforced

Krebs Custom Safety Lever with bolt hold

M*Carbo Ak Extra Power Spring

Sig Sauer Romeo 5 with low profile mount