Among the 36 starting QBs to win a Super Bowl in NFL history, I think we all tend to agree that most of them were good QBs, and of the good ones, several were great. This tends to be assessed almost 180 degrees in reverse by fans - that a QB who won the Super Bowl is by nature good if not great, and in extremely rare cases may we refer to them as mediocre or even something as blasphemous as "bad", or worse.
Joe Flacco, among these QBs, sits at a weird spot. He started the entire season that he won the Super Bowl, and he played utterly amazing football throughout the playoffs. The 2012 Ravens, though loaded to the brim with legends and guys whose careers deserved the ultimate cherry on top as much as anyone in the league, now seem to be regarded as one of the worst Super Bowl winning teams of the past couple decades. They had a bumpy ride in the regular season, and in an era with 4 first round bye teams, they had to play 4 playoff games and a still unprecedented 18 quarters of football including their legendary double OT duel with Peyton Manning's Broncos. Flacco was the best QB in the world for over a month in early 2013, and to this day few if any QBs this century can claim to have performed better in that stretch of a season than he has.
That all being said, for most of Flacco's career, he has been a decidedly decent but not great or extraordinary QB. He was more Eli than Peyton, so to speak. He's good for a fun step-in for a starter every now and then, but Colts, Jets, Broncos, and Browns fans would probably have something to say if you were to claim he was or is elite due to his status as one of these few Super Bowl winning QBs. Though in reality his numbers in the regular season were never anything special even during that magical 2012 Super Bowl winning season, he declined in the subsequent seasons to a level that I think is not properly appreciated by the many. I believe that the idea that Flacco was something other than a mediocre QB, simply because he was a Super Bowl winning QB, perpetuated itself without sound basis for far too long, and has stuck in the collective imagination. Because that's all anyone ever says about Flacco, he had a strong arm and won a Super Bowl. Remember when he threw a 70 yard TD to kick Peyton Manning out of the dance? When you actually look at his numbers, he was an average or, at times, substantially below average QB for the remainder of his time in Baltimore. He was there for 6 more seasons after the Super Bowl victory. I can understand fealty of a certain kind and to a certain extent, but 6 seasons' worth??? Okay, Lamar took over after 5.5, but that's over half a decade's worth of love. For a QB who not only was not great, but that you could argue was not even good, for much of that span.
However, in order to actually harangue the Ravens for doing this, I probably have to provide a better alternative. It's easy to clown Bears fans for taking Trubisky over Mahomes and Watson, but the Ravens were picking at 16 in that draft and didn't have the opportunity to take either of them. A year or two prior Dak Prescott went in the 4th round, but that's like criticizing 80% of the league for not passing on Purdy like 5 times each, if even the team he eventually went to didn't quite realize what they had in those guys to snipe them earlier, then how can you fault the other teams? When you look through the QB drafts from 2013 through 2017, as Baltimore did finally hit on their guy in 2018, it becomes really hard to claim they should've drafted Flacco's successor. Nobody really came out of the draft at spots that they had the opportunity to grab them during those years. Jared Goff and Carson Wentz, Mariota and Winston were, respectively, top 2 picks. I guess you could say they should've went for Derek Carr or Teddy Bridgewater, but also, seriously???
The Ravens had an impossible dilemma in front of them, because Flacco was a guy who proved he could turn it on at the right moments and win them a Super Bowl with incredible play, but also a guy who 90% of the time did not perform great. And though he played pretty poorly in the playoffs both of his first two seasons, he had his absolute best stretches of games in his career, on multiple separate occasions, in the playoffs. What's more, Baltimore never went one and done in the playoffs with Flacco, and made two AFC Championship games with him at the helm. So to move on from him and meaningfully improve at the position would both have required a leap of faith that the next guy could get it done (and though they found as great a "next guy" as they possibly could have been expected to have, a multi-MVP winner who can do and has done things we've never seen another QB do and probably will never see again, it's been nearly 20 years since Flacco was drafted and this extraordinary "next guy" still has not gotten it done) and to have probably taken some damage as it'd have required moving up in the draft or trading for/signing an established QB.
TLDR: My main question is, should the Ravens have moved on from Joe Flacco earlier due to his perennial regular season mediocrity, even in spite of his postseason aptitude, and in the absence of obvious or easy/attainable replacements? Or wait, as they did, for nearly 6 full seasons before just so happening to land the next guy way later in a draft than he should've gone?