TL;DR: My (M20) cousin (F20) discovered my lack of affective empathy for her, and our relationship is over, plus it seems my relationship with my sister (F18) has a low chance of continuing as well.
Hey, so this is my first time ever posting anything on the internet ever, and so I’m kinda nervous as fuck, but Im also nervous because Im embarrassed and dont wanna be judged for how much of a fucking narcissist I am. Ik I will be, but I still needed to write this post, since I have no therapist and no true support system, and I feel like im gonna implode/have a panic attack. Honestly, I think I’m writing this to vent, or maybe to just seek clarity, but honestly idrk. This is gonna be pretty long, so yeah be wary of that. Anyway, so here goes:
a couple months ago, around July my cousin contacted me. She was upset about how I only sporadically called her, and wanted to know if I wanted to still continue our relationship, or just call it quits. Ngl, I kinda didn’t wanna be abandoned, but also would be sort of relieved if it ended, like the burden (not logically, but that’s how I emotionally see it) of keeping up a relationship would be over (idk how else to explain it, it’s something even I don’t rlly understand). Any way, I decided to try to continue our relationship, and was honest with her about a couple things. Like, I became vulnerable with her (didn’t want to ofc because I don’t like being too vulnerable, but I thought that me doing that showed my willingness to continue so to speak) and even explained some medical stuff I was/am suffering from that’s rlly fucking embarrassing, like encopresis/IBS stuff and how it impacted me in school (I ruminate daily about those dark years btw).
Now, funny enough the first thing she asked me the moment I answered her call was if I loved her. I tried to deflect, but she wouldn’t have it. So I reluctantly answered with something along the lines of “I care about you, but not as much as you care about me. Like I care about my dad and my sister, and then you next. Also, I don’t really love anyone. I’m not capable of it.” But tbh, I don’t/didn’t care about her that much at all, so I guess I was being somewhat deceitful. Anyway, she told me that that wasn’t the response she wanted to hear, but [insert other stuff I forgot about].
Anyway, she was content enough with all the info I gave her, and so we established regular times of calling: at least once a week, we would call, usually to talk and play Roblox. It could be just a gaming session, or she could vent about her work. Sometimes she would call why driving home just to talk (so no gaming). Now, I felt almost no actually empathy for her, and had to practice cognitive empathy for most of it. Example: we would vent to each other about our abusive narcissistic dna donors (gonna be stuck with the sperm donor for at least 4-5 years UGHHHHHHH).
Now, about a month ago, we were playing roblox and talking about our past. See, we’ve known each other for about 14 years now, and we were even classmates for a while in Elementary school. Anyway, she brings up her stuffed animal from childhood. I told her I don’t remember that stuffy, and my cous attributes that to trauma amnesia (something we’ve talked about before, when venting before). I was a lil nervous, but went clean: I do have trauma amnesia for most of my childhood, but the reason I don’t remember her stuffed animal, and for that matter other things about her (like her favorite color, which is complete bonkers I cant deny that), is because I spent most of my life being self-centered (due to the way I was being treated), and so didn’t spent too much time around others (like my sis for example), and when I DID spent time around them, I didn’t bother to learn stuff about them (and thus remember) because I didn’t care to learn. Anyway, she then asked (or maybe she asked this before that explanation; the order in which these things happened slips my mind) “who have you cared about all these years then?” I responded with something along the lines of “no one rlly. Just myself.” Anyway, I then brought up how I was willing to be honest, but that I didn’t enjoy having this conversation (even tho I was the one to start it), and that I had told her this months ago that I didn’t care about her as much as she did me. She then states that “yeah, you did tell me that. I overlooked that, because I thought you were confused, but ig you know yourself more.” I was like “yeah…” and then our conversation ended. Looking back, Ig this is kinda my fault, because I wanted to be honest, but I also kinda didn’t (and I was aware of this by choosing to say “I don’t care about you as much as you care about me” instead of saying idrc about you at all), and so I strung out our relationship when I shoulda just ended it. More on that later…
Yesterday, my sister left me a text that our cousin wanted to have a group call to talk. I was asleep at the time so I didn’t see it, but it also mentioned that we could call at 7 pm EST today, so I did. The call starts, and my cousin thanks us both for answering. I don’t remember everything, but so it seems she told my sister of our estrangement, and why it happened (that I didn’t love her). She also mentioned that she didn’t understand why I didn’t feel that way, but that she accepted it. And also that my sister didn’t understand either. Anyway, so it turns out she did the group call because she wanted me to “clarify everything”, meaning she wanted me to admit my feelings for her in front of my sister… Anyway, I tell her in a normal, nonchalant respectful tone “what is there to clarify? I told you everything and how I feel about you.” That sounds cruel, but I was trying to not shy away from the truth even with my sister present, so I mentioned that. Anyway, so she asks some questions, like if I love her. I say something like “no, I don’t feel that way about you.” I felt shame saying that, especially with my sis on the goddamn call, but the first step to authenticity is honesty right? If I’m honest, then it’s not as big a deal (educate me on the proper way of thinking pls if I’m just being delusional)? Anyway, she asked other stuff but it was around that general theme of how I felt about her. I was definitely upset, that she was involving my sister especially since my cousin previously mentioned to me that her relationship with the both of us is separate even if we are siblings, but I still chose to go along with this anyway. When done asking, she basically says “blah blah blah. Just wanted to clarify [I don’t think she brought up “clarify” as much times as my big paragraph may imply, but still]. Got all that [sister’s name]?” My sis responds with “yeah.”
Anyway, my cous then mentions if I still want to have a relationship with her. I say “idk.” She mentions that now that she knows how I feel, she wont/cant pretend to keep things going as they are, but that she still has feelings for me, and so we could every few months or so catch up on stuff in general. I say “ok that sounds fine.” Anyway, she then asks if there’s anything I wanna ask her. Honestly, I had nothing important to ask her. Everything was clarified. So I thought “why not just ask her a very non-important question?” After thinking, I respond with “ I know this is the least important thing here, but should I unfriend you on roblox?” Yeah, the emotional intelligence of a pineapple ik gang. There’s a pause. I ask in a normal tone “did I offend you?” (trying to acknowledge my emotional insensitivity, tho I couldve just NOT ask that). She responds “is that your only question?” A lil annoyed I try to walk it off, saying “yeah, there’s nothing else to rlly clarify tbh. You talked about how we could talk every few months, and it makes sense to me. Also you called for me to clarify and so I did. I ask about the game thing because I game most of the time to cope with my super controlling crappy sperm donor and my medical conditions, and so idk if I wanna be reminded of this/you if I see you online.” I then ask “how should I have responded?” She irritably responds “don’t ask me how you should’ve responded. You’re not a robot. Etc, etc.” More calmly, she states,” it’s ok. You have no empathy.” Yeah, I’ll be ruminating about that comment for a LONG time. [Heck, I immediately stopped writing this post the moment I finished writing that sentence and have spent the last 2 hours ruminating on this, a rumination that’s bad enough that my hand is on currently my heart cuz im not feeling it (I’m not getting a panic attack surprisingly)]. Anyway, going back to the story, I shrugged it off, said something casually like “in any case, I have nothing else to ask. So i guess thats it then?” referencing the end of the call? After a response, I just hung up.
Now, there’s a second element to this. In previous conversations, I’ve mentioned and implied to her that I also feel similarly about my sis (I do think I care about her fr, at least more than anyone else, but I definitely don’t love her. In fact, I love nobody. I’d like to be capable of it one day, but Im not even in therapy yet so…), first telling her/expressing my annoyance during our first convo back in July that “this conversation Im having with you is honestly a hard one, one that I knew we were gonna have someday, but still hard [cuz I had to be vulnerable/honest and have someone know my true nature plus maybe leave/abandon me] and honestly one im gonna have to have with [insert sis’s name] someday” all of which is true. So she actually brings that up during the group call. “I don’t mean to put you on the spot light, but you and I had talks in which you mentioned you were thinking of having a hard conversation with your sister” and basically kinda just told me to have it with her. And I was pissed, although I didn’t express it. Like, ig I did string my cousin to an extent since I wasn’t completely honest and now that Im looking back, I should’ve pulled the bandage back in July and be like “idc about you and I don’t want a relationship”, but goddamn girl why did you put me on the spotlight??? Ive been upfront about being aware of our abusive background, and of how Im noticing more and more toxic behaviors all the time (me and my sis live together with sperm donor, and Ive been establishing a healthy relationship between us, like for example knocking on her door and asking if I can enter instead of selfishly barging, and I rlly want to learn everything about her, since Ive spent our whole lives not paying attention to her), and been vulnerable about lots of things. Like, why the goddamn fuck did my cousin expect me to lie to my sis about how I feel about her when I was mostly honest to my cousin, a person who was told by me that my sister is way more important. Like, goddamnit my sister is the only person in this Earth who I would like 100% want to continue a relationship with. I even try to absorb all info regarding my sis every time im with her, like her interests, friends, memorizing her college classes, asking about her day. Now, here’s the thing as well: many months ago, I DID in fact have a similar convo with my sister. I told her I was a narc, and that I cared about her, but not as much as she cared about me. I then directly said “I dont rlly love anyone.” I dont think she rlly accepted it tho, but damn I tried to opening up about it at least. I rlly hope that my sister remembers that conversation we had back then, because it would honestly lessen my cousin’s blow. Unfortunately tho, after the call my sister, after I asked how she felt about everything, mentioned she couldn’t believe how I felt about our cousin and that me telling her I didnt love her was cruel, and that she was worried that I might not love her either. So yeah, that long-term fantasy I had of the distant future in which my sister would be part of a very small inner circle may not happen anymore… :(
Anyway, to conclude, I have mixed feelings about everything. On the one hand, I intellectually understand my cousin’s anger, and she might have a point since she pegged my lack of empathy, but on the other I dont see why she roped my sister into this, especially with the intent to “expose me” to her. It’s probably to protect my sister from what my cousin sees as me possibly being dishonest, but idk. Emotionally, I just feel like she overstepped and put me on the spot. It wasn’t necessary in the slightest. Also, I dont think I want to do the “meet-up every few months” thing cuz of what she fucking did. But it would hurt my ego too cuz then from her perspective it’s like “yeah I exposed him, and now he doesn’t want a relationship. He was always fake to begin with.” Honestly, I think I’ll just cut my losses and end our relationship entirely BUT THEN AGAIN I’d feel like a loser who’s throwing in the towel. Like I’m proving her “no empathy” point correct, y’know?
Anyhoo, I’ve spent 3 1/2 hours writing this, and I’m mostly calm now thank god. Funny enough, the idea of coming completely clean with my sister also kinda calms me down in a way, like a burden lifted, y’know? Part of me also doesnt care about what my cous says, so yay ig. Welp. I’m gonna go to sleep and read the replies another time. Ofc, the moment I do, I might be hit with a reality check and lose the calm, but oh well.
disclaimer: I kinda wanted to vent, but also seek advice on how I should feel, what I should do better, what I should look forward to as a realistic option for having a relationship with my sister (and in general), and how I should cope with distress to the point of having to put a hand on my heart. As a result I added the “advice and support” flair instead of the “vent no advice requested” flair.