❓Ask r/NewMods Update on My Two New Subreddits: Progress, Challenges & What I Need Help With
I recently created two new subreddits, and it has been approximately one day since their launch. So far, the initial growth has been encouraging. Both communities have attracted members and received a considerable number of visits. However, that interest isn't translating into posts and discussions yet.
This is currently the larger of the two communities, with approximately 156 members. I've received two posts so far. Unfortunately, one was from a scammer, while the other user's account was shadowbanned. Two other genuine members have expressed interest in posting but are hesitant because they want to see other people post first. This creates an initial participation problem: people are interested, but nobody wants to be among the first to participate. This subreddit will continue to require moderator approval for posts because of its sensitive subject matter and strict safety requirements.
This community currently has approximately 50 members. Although membership growth has been encouraging, actual participation and posting activity remain relatively low. Unlike the matrimony subreddit, I want this community to have a more open environment where posts and comments don't require manual moderator approval every time. I'm currently trying to figure out how to configure this safely, particularly through Reddit's available moderation tools and Automoderator.
3. Why Have Both Subreddits Grown So Quickly?
I think there are two major reasons behind the initial growth:
A. Existing community connections
I'm a moderator at r/LGBTIndia, and several other Indian LGBTQ+ subreddits coordinate with one another through an independent Discord Server called PCI. Because of these existing connections, people are more willing to trust that my new communities won't be abandoned. They also understand that these communities have connections with the larger r/LGBTIndia ecosystem. I'm using my existing moderator position and community connections to help introduce these subreddits to a potential audience, with coordination from r/LGBTIndia.
B. An unmet demand
There is a shortage of dedicated spaces catering to the specific needs and interests of Indian LGBTQ+ people. As a moderator of one of India's largest LGBTQ+ subreddits, I've gained some insight into what people are looking for, what is missing and what kinds of dedicated communities could be useful. I believe both subreddits address relatively underserved areas.
4. My Current Challenges
Despite managing to establish both communities, I'm still learning how to run subreddits independently. I've been a moderator for approximately two months. Most of my experience so far has been with handling the moderation queue rather than setting up communities, configuring moderation tools or managing subreddit infrastructure.
Some of the challenges I'm facing include:
Reddit Apps: I haven't used moderation apps before and don't know which ones are genuinely useful or worth installing.
Automoderation: I need help configuring Automoderator, especially for r/BoysLoveIndia, where I want normal posts and comments to appear without requiring manual approval. Moderator Recruitment: I need to recruit additional moderators for both communities. Fair Recruitment: I can approach experienced moderators from existing Indian LGBTQ+ subreddits, but I also want to give newer Reddit users a fair opportunity to join the moderation team. I don't want to limit recruitment exclusively to people who already hold moderator positions.
5. What I'd Like Help With
I'd particularly appreciate advice from experienced moderators on: Which moderation apps and tools are worth using? How should I configure Automoderator for both communities? How can I encourage genuine members to make the first posts and participate? How should I recruit moderators while balancing experience with opportunities for new users? What are some things I should establish early to ensure these communities remain active and sustainable? Both communities are still in their earliest stages, so I'm trying to establish the right foundations rather than rush their growth.
I'm relatively new to subreddit administration, but I'm enthusiastic about building these communities into sustainable spaces for Indian LGBTQ+ people.


