r/NewMods • • 3h ago

❓Ask r/NewMods Update on My Two New Subreddits: Progress, Challenges & What I Need Help With

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I recently created two new subreddits, and it has been approximately one day since their launch. So far, the initial growth has been encouraging. Both communities have attracted members and received a considerable number of visits. However, that interest isn't translating into posts and discussions yet.

1. r/LGBTIndiamatrimony

This is currently the larger of the two communities, with approximately 156 members. I've received two posts so far. Unfortunately, one was from a scammer, while the other user's account was shadowbanned. Two other genuine members have expressed interest in posting but are hesitant because they want to see other people post first. This creates an initial participation problem: people are interested, but nobody wants to be among the first to participate. This subreddit will continue to require moderator approval for posts because of its sensitive subject matter and strict safety requirements.

2. r/BoysLoveIndia

This community currently has approximately 50 members. Although membership growth has been encouraging, actual participation and posting activity remain relatively low. Unlike the matrimony subreddit, I want this community to have a more open environment where posts and comments don't require manual moderator approval every time. I'm currently trying to figure out how to configure this safely, particularly through Reddit's available moderation tools and Automoderator.

3. Why Have Both Subreddits Grown So Quickly?

I think there are two major reasons behind the initial growth:

A. Existing community connections

I'm a moderator at r/LGBTIndia, and several other Indian LGBTQ+ subreddits coordinate with one another through an independent Discord Server called PCI. Because of these existing connections, people are more willing to trust that my new communities won't be abandoned. They also understand that these communities have connections with the larger r/LGBTIndia ecosystem. I'm using my existing moderator position and community connections to help introduce these subreddits to a potential audience, with coordination from r/LGBTIndia.

B. An unmet demand

There is a shortage of dedicated spaces catering to the specific needs and interests of Indian LGBTQ+ people. As a moderator of one of India's largest LGBTQ+ subreddits, I've gained some insight into what people are looking for, what is missing and what kinds of dedicated communities could be useful. I believe both subreddits address relatively underserved areas.

4. My Current Challenges

Despite managing to establish both communities, I'm still learning how to run subreddits independently. I've been a moderator for approximately two months. Most of my experience so far has been with handling the moderation queue rather than setting up communities, configuring moderation tools or managing subreddit infrastructure.

Some of the challenges I'm facing include:

Reddit Apps: I haven't used moderation apps before and don't know which ones are genuinely useful or worth installing.

Automoderation: I need help configuring Automoderator, especially for r/BoysLoveIndia, where I want normal posts and comments to appear without requiring manual approval. Moderator Recruitment: I need to recruit additional moderators for both communities. Fair Recruitment: I can approach experienced moderators from existing Indian LGBTQ+ subreddits, but I also want to give newer Reddit users a fair opportunity to join the moderation team. I don't want to limit recruitment exclusively to people who already hold moderator positions.

5. What I'd Like Help With

I'd particularly appreciate advice from experienced moderators on: Which moderation apps and tools are worth using? How should I configure Automoderator for both communities? How can I encourage genuine members to make the first posts and participate? How should I recruit moderators while balancing experience with opportunities for new users? What are some things I should establish early to ensure these communities remain active and sustainable? Both communities are still in their earliest stages, so I'm trying to establish the right foundations rather than rush their growth.

I'm relatively new to subreddit administration, but I'm enthusiastic about building these communities into sustainable spaces for Indian LGBTQ+ people.


r/NewMods • • 3h ago

❓Ask r/NewMods Inviting people to be mod for indiansugarvirtual community

1 Upvotes

Since I have seen all the women faces issue in sugar culture I m inviting female mods to make rules and run this community


r/NewMods • • 3h ago

❓Ask r/NewMods Business !!!!

0 Upvotes

I started new community


r/NewMods • • 7h ago

❓Ask r/NewMods ДНЕПР. ГОРОД, КОТОРЫЙ НЕ ВСЁ РАССКАЗЫВАЕТ О СЕБЕ.

1 Upvotes

Есть города, которые стараются понравиться. А есть Днепр.

Он не будет перед тобой красоваться. Он просто покажет тебе старые пятиэтажки, разбитые тротуары, трамваи, которые помнят ещё твоё детство, и дворы, где каждый второй знает, кто у кого живёт.

Здесь утро начинается с запаха кофе из маленького киоска, разговоров возле подъезда и вечного вопроса: «Ну шо там, слышал последние новости?»

Здесь на одной улице могут стоять дорогой внедорожник и дедушкин «Жигуль», а за углом бабушка будет кормить голубей так, будто это её личная работа в городском совете.

Но самое интересное в Днепре не здания и не проспекты.

Самое интересное здесь — люди.

Те, кто пережил девяностые, помнит старый «Днепр», знает, где была самая вкусная шаурма, и до сих пор говорит «Днепропетровск», потому что некоторые привычки не меняются даже после переименования города.

А теперь вопрос к днепрянам:

Какое место в Днепре вызывает у вас самые сильные воспоминания?

Старый двор? Район детства? Заброшенная стройка? Набережная? Или какая-нибудь улица, которой уже почти не узнать?

Расскажите свою историю. Даже если она кажется обычной.

Потому что из таких историй и состоит настоящий Днепр.

Министерство улиц. Здесь у каждого района есть голос.


r/NewMods • • 8h ago

❓Ask r/NewMods How do you make flairs?

3 Upvotes

r/NewMods • • 10h ago

Wins 🎉 Introducing DPGRD (not sure if the flair is right)

Post image
3 Upvotes

So, DPGRD stands for DOORS, Pressure, Grace and Rooms & Doors. I'm probably one of the only people who know of its existence as of making this. The reason I made it was to unite fans of all 4 previously stated games. I know it's kinda useless because all 4 games (not sure about Rooms & Doors) have their own subreddits already, but I made it anyway. As of making this, DPGRD is under a day old.


r/NewMods • • 13h ago

🤖 Devvit Is there a Devvit app that’s best for ranking/competitions?

4 Upvotes

Hi fellow mods, I’m requesting your advice and recommendations!

I’m thinking of starting a monthly competition in a few of my subs where users vote on or rank posts and the winner gets assigned an exclusive flair or something similar.

I looked at a few different apps which I’ll link below. I’d prefer something that can be scheduled and recurring (ideally) and that can lock previous competition posts once a new one is started the following month.
I’d prefer if posts themselves could be ranked, but I’m also okay with just creating a flair to specify posts entered into the competition and inputting the photos in the ranking competition myself.

I’d really like to hear your thoughts and whether any of you have tried these apps/had success with any of these in the past, these are the apps I’ve learned of and am considering so far:

Contender 1: https://developers.reddit.com/apps/tierlist-app
Contender 2: https://developers.reddit.com/apps/competitions-app
Contender 3: https://developers.reddit.com/apps/ranker-app#modes
Contender 4: https://developers.reddit.com/apps/votierapp

This is listed in no particular order and is not exhaustive, these are just the apps I’ve found so far!


r/NewMods • • 14h ago

❓Ask r/NewMods Remove hateful comments or let them be downvoted?

2 Upvotes

I mod a sub for an up-and-coming punk band and so far it's been really chill. People mostly share photos+videos of concerts and exchange tickets. I have removed scammers or people posting scam merch websites.

One post might have gotten a borderline transphobic comment and I'm not sure what to do. I want to keep a punk spirit of "no rules" in my sub so in that spirit, I would not remove that comment and let it be downvoted to hell. However, is this the right approach?


r/NewMods • • 17h ago

💡 Tips & Education How Can I Grow This Dating Community?

1 Upvotes

OK, so maybe this is a bit of a different question maybe it’s not but I would like some people to take a look and maybe give me some advice and suggestions here. So a bit of context as well. The community that I am referring to I am simply a moderator in and have been trying to help it grow but I feel like I’ve hit a wall however, I have another community
r/AskABlindPerson
that I actually created and I feel like has done pretty well and I haven’t had this issue with it. And that community it’s pretty active, in about three months we have actually just recently crossed over 200 members and I feel like the engagement in there is pretty good. It’s nothing insane, but I’m very happy and comfortable with it.

However, in this other community, which is the one I would like some more advice on what to do here I am a moderator in
r/AbstinentDating
and while I have been trying a couple of new strategies like reposting some of the posts to some other places to try and draw people in and that has gained a few members and a smidge of engagement, but we are still stuck at a fairly low member count. I believe we are stuck at 24 right now. We were stuck at 20 for a while until I started the reposting stuff. However, while yes I am concerned about the member count. I am much more concerned that even with the people we have in there we just don’t get engagement. We don’t get posts. We don’t get comments on the things that me and the person who owns it put up. We are the only two that basically interact in there for the most part.
At least one of us makes a post in there every day and I always try to reply and vote as fast as possible. So there is consistent posts in there, but how do I get more people in there and how do I get those people to engage and post. I know it’s a bit of a niche community and I’m not sure how growing a dating community differs from other things but maybe y’all have some advice or ideas.
I know in reading some other stuff on here I had seen some people recommending things like trying to find people and other communities and invite them, but I’m not sure how I would go about doing that and like where to look and who out of those communities to invite stuff like that so some advice on that would also be appreciated.
I want to get the community growing and up and running because I do like the concept and reasoning behind the community, which is why I even joined and offered to become a moderator to begin with. So obviously I want to get more members in there, but I really want to get the engagement up and get people interacting since especially for this type of community being active and having people engaging and interacting and stuff like that is extremely important than it might otherwise be for a different type of community.
Thank you for any help and feel free to check out both communities if you would like the context or contrast of what I’m referring to, but I am mainly looking for thoughts on the dating one.


r/NewMods • • 18h ago

❓Ask r/NewMods How can i do this in my community (AutoModerator) ? Can anyone guide here

1 Upvotes

r/NewMods • • 22h ago

Wins 🎉 Sobbing omg 36 members 🥹

Post image
13 Upvotes

I just consistently posted and promoted in subreddits where there might be people interested in the sub and would allow some self promo ❤️ we are still small but ever growing 🎉


r/NewMods • • 1d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods How do i help my subreddit grow?

0 Upvotes

İ am trying to post in that subreddit to get some one joining but i doesn’t seem to work


r/NewMods • • 1d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods My community has been up and running for two weeks, but I’m not sure how to manage or grow it.😭😭😭

Post image
3 Upvotes

What can I do to drive foot traffic to my community?/r/COSYHOMEER/


r/NewMods • • 1d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods Hi, I'm a new mod

0 Upvotes

I'm a new mod and like just created the community, its called r/WingsOfFireCostplay and I would like to ask if you guys have any tips for me?


r/NewMods • • 1d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods How do we increase reach for a niche sub?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Hello everyone. I am a new mod to r/fuseenergy. It's a sub for people who are potential or existing customers of Fuse Energy in the UK. I have set up all the rules and flairs etc to make it as simple and clean an experience for all users as possible.

What would you suggest I do differently to increase our reach?

Attached is a picture of what our stats are for the last 28 days.


r/NewMods • • 1d ago

Wins 🎉 To the mods who told me to 'replace the lurkers': You were right. 🥹

48 Upvotes

I was the one who posted about having 1,500 views but zero engagement. I took your advice and went out of my comfort zone to invite an artist whose work I genuinely loved.

She just joined as my 3rd member! It might seem like a tiny number, but having someone who actually wants to be there and talk about art feels like a massive victory. It finally feels like a real community, not just a ghost town.

Thank you for the tough love. It works!


r/NewMods • • 1d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods I was checking some settings in my Subreddit, and it says that it’s public, but restricted. How do I make it so anyone can post?

1 Upvotes

r/NewMods • • 1d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods Can subscriptions get shadow banned?

3 Upvotes

r/NewMods • • 1d ago

🏅 Mod Achievements Hi, new mods!

5 Upvotes

So a few weeks ago, I became a moderator for my community, bedrockglitchsharing, and I got ready making 3 posts


r/NewMods • • 1d ago Bravo

Wins 🎉 It's been 20 days and we are here

Post image
13 Upvotes

We started our sub r/PataHaiKya almost 20days ago from the scratch. Basically this sub is an Indian sub mix of TIL, interesting things, fun facts, trivia and many more..

How did we reach here:

Well We were just consistent on content posting and our content is strictly around our community type so we can reach the right audiences. We used to post at least 2 content per day.


r/NewMods • • 1d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods Hello my fellow mods. is this a good thing?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I mean I'm happy I got so much but I want to know if it's like. an actual achievement or not


r/NewMods • • 1d ago

🤖 Devvit Must have sub apps and install bot bouncer guys

Post image
8 Upvotes

I wish more subs would install bot bouncer. The effort should be united. The bots usually just leave some weird round about words. On a glance those makes sense but really doesnt once you look closer. Idk why those mods wont install it.

The fake traffic just makes the sub looks like a space for weirdos.

I feel like reddit doesnt educate mods enough about the apps. I wrote this on mod support then realized new mods might be a good space to tell people.

If you want to look at those apps quick without searching just visit my sub then drag the right bar down to the bottom then you can see the installed apps on pc. r/BeyondtheAIAssistant


r/NewMods • • 2d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods Trying to grow subreddit..!

6 Upvotes

Hello! I'm just one of the players who created r/HeroUndergroundShift for an idle mobile RPG I've been hooked on lately.

Opened the sub about two weeks ago and posted some guides and active codes. Traffic is slowly coming in (around 1.8k views so far), but I'm still stuck at 5 members and talking to myself in the feed.

How did you guys get your early visitors to subscribe and chat?


r/NewMods • • 2d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods New member traffic varys

3 Upvotes

Hi I have a question about how the system works regarding traffic. Some days I will see a spike in new members joining my sub several days in a row and then all of a sudden there is nothing for like 2 days. Is this just part of an algorithm working?


r/NewMods • • 2d ago

❓Ask r/NewMods I need to grow my community. I dont know what the next step is.

Post image
1 Upvotes

My community r/okbuddybattlefield6 was supposed to be the reddit for the game Battlefield 6 as a way to friendly shit post or put memes in that a regular sub would not allow.

Ive posted several memes (videos) and im not sure how to spread this sub to other subs to get on this one. I made this sub when Battlefield 6 came out.

I need some help