UPDATE: I made my decision! Full explanation in the comments below.
Hi everyone!
I'm currently using a Nikon Z5 with the Nikkor Z 40mm f/2, and I'm absolutely loving the image quality, colors and overall rendering of this camera.
I'm looking to add a versatile zoom lens, and I've narrowed my options down to two:
- Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 G2
- Nikon Nikkor Z 24-120mm f/4 S
Most of my photography is outdoors: landscapes, travel, street photography, portraits, occasional sports (such as tennis), and some social/event photography.
However, I occasionally shoot indoors or in challenging lighting conditions, which is where my doubts begin.
Why I'm considering the Nikon 24-120mm f/4 S:
The focal range is incredibly appealing to me. Having 24mm instead of 28mm for landscapes and interiors, plus 120mm instead of 75mm for portraits, details and occasional sports, seems like a huge advantage.
I also love the idea of having one high-quality lens that covers almost everything.
My main concern is the constant f/4 aperture, particularly because I'm using the original Z5, not the Z5 II, Z6 III or Z8.
Why I'm considering the Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 G2:
That extra stop of light could be very useful indoors, especially when photographing people who are moving.
However, I'm not sure whether sacrificing both the wider 24mm end and the additional reach to 120mm is worth it for my particular needs.
A few things worth mentioning:
- I'm comfortable using single-point autofocus and selecting my focus point manually, so I don't rely heavily on automatic subject detection.
- I've tested my Z5 at f/4 in a reasonably well-lit room and was pleasantly surprised by the results, even at moderately high ISO.
- I find ISO 6400 usable on my Z5, especially when shooting RAW.
- I'm also open to using modern noise reduction software, such as DxO PureRAW or Luminar Neo, when necessary.
- I already own the 40mm f/2, so I have a faster lens available for low-light situations.
- Image quality, natural colors, tonal richness and overall rendering matter more to me than having the latest autofocus technology.
My biggest question is this:
For those of you who have used the original Nikon Z5 with the 24-120mm f/4 S, how well does the combination perform indoors or in challenging light?
Does the Z5 autofocus reliably at f/4 using single-point AF, even when the lighting isn't ideal?
And for those who have tried both lenses, is the versatility of the 24-120 worth giving up the extra stop of light offered by the Tamron?
I'm particularly interested in real-world experiences with the original Z5 rather than newer Nikon bodies with significantly improved autofocus systems.
I'd love to hear your experiences, especially if you've used either lens for events, portraits, travel or occasional indoor photography.
Thanks in advance!