r/NonZeroDay • u/aaeesha_2946 • 37m ago
Discussion whats the strongest criticism of second order thinking?
second order thinking keeps coming up in everything i read lately, the idea that before deciding you ask “and then what?” and look at the consequences of your consequences. i like it and ive started using it, but the more i read, the more i wonder about its limits, so i wanted to hear what people here think.
the first problem i keep running into is that second order effects are hard to predict, even for experts. the example that stuck with me is seatbelts. in 1975 an economist named sam peltzman argued that car safety rules made drivers take more risks because they felt protected, so some of the lives saved inside cars were offset by more deaths among pedestrians and cyclists. its a perfect second order argument. but people have spent decades since then arguing about how big that effect really is, and some studies of seatbelt laws found little or no sign of it. if trained economists are still debating on second order effect fifty years later, im not sure how well i can predict one for my own life.
the second problem is that it can slide into overthinking. once you start asking “and then what?” theres always another step, and at some point youre not deciding anything, youre just imagining. a lot of outcomes also depend on things you dont control, so you can trace every consequence carefully and still get a result you didnt plan for. im already someone who thinks about ten other things each choice might affect, and i can see how this could make that worse.
i still think its useful, especially for decisions you repeat and anything involving incentives, like targets at work or rules in a group. id just like to know where people here draw the line.
for anyone whos tried thinking this way, when has it helped you, and when did it just make you overthink?
