r/OpenCatholic • • Oct 25 '19

Sub rules (same as always). If you're new or unsure, please read here or in the sidebar before participating in this sub.

22 Upvotes

1) Be Cordial - No homophobia, racism, or denigrating others' faiths or (lack of) beliefs. While we fully embrace Catholic dogma and theology, we also strive to respect our non-Catholic and still-questioning participants in this sub. Questions about and defenses of doctrine and theology are okay; accusing people of committing mortal sins or being heretics is not.

2) Be Catholic - Please respect the Catholic nature of this sub. While we welcome all posters, including those who profess non-Catholic beliefs and practices, many here are practicing Catholics and wish to be as faithful as possible to Church teachings. Please do not attempt to discourage someone from following a legitimate Catholic teaching, such as attending weekly Mass, going to confession, avoiding hormonal contraception, etc.

3) Be Current - Here we respect the current Bishop of Rome, His Holiness Pope Leo XIV, and the ideals and decisions of the Catholic Church's most recent ecumenical council, the Second Vatican Council (also known as Vatican II). We also believe in the legitimacy of both the Ordinary Form (The Mass of Paul VI) and the Extraordinary Form (the Tridentine Mass) of the Eucharist.

4) Be Comfortable - While recognizing the serious implications of many Catholic subjects, please don't forget to have fun! Regardless of whether you simply lurk or post everyday, we hope you experience the Catholic joy of life as you join us in fellowship here.

If you are in doubt if your post is in line with these rules, please contact a mod prior to submission.


r/OpenCatholic • • May 31 '26

Encyclical Letter of His Holiness Leo XIV Magnifica Humanitas (15 May 2026)

Thumbnail vatican.va
9 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic • • 10h ago

Faith as a way of life, not the mere construction of propositions to believe

1 Upvotes

While studying theology deepens our understanding of the Christian faith, treating it purely as an intellectual exercise risks fostering pride and reducing God’s mystery to rigid, human-made systems. We must  resist contentious, ego-driven debates in favor of charitable dialogue. We must engage our faith in ways which transcend an over-intellectualization of the faith.  We must follow God with our whole being, and not just our minds:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/theology-as-a-way-of-life-not-mere-propositions/


r/OpenCatholic • • 2d ago

Keeping Christ's commandments

1 Upvotes

Jesus told us that we would follow him and what he taught if we love him; we would not, therefore, pit faith against works, but rather, we would see how they come together in our love for God. We are not looking for salvation by works, but we are working out our salvation by way of love, for it is love which is key to how we live out our faith:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/the-gospels-commandments/


r/OpenCatholic • • 3d ago

Children, refugees, and the politics of cruelty

3 Upvotes

While Pope Leo XIV highlights the need to see Christ in every migrant, he said special care and concern should be showed to children. Yet, sadly, so many Christians in the United States supports Trump, who is doing the exact opposite. Children are greatly mistreated, and many of them are young, without any advocate, counsel, or ability to speak English, and expected to represent themselves in immigration court!

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/children-refugees-and-the-politics-of-cruelty/


r/OpenCatholic • • 4d ago

The Good Samaritan shows us the way

2 Upvotes

The parable of the Good Samaritan has many ways we can interpret it; what is important is we use it to challenge ourselves, to learn from and imitate the Good Samaritan, while also seeing how it represents the way Christ works with humanity:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/the-good-samaritan-shows-us-the-way/

 


r/OpenCatholic • • 6d ago

Media Suggestions

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic • • 7d ago

The living faith and the growth of tradition

2 Upvotes

The church, even though it can be seen to change over time, remains one and the same in its core. The church expects us to live in the present moment, not in the past; we are not expected to do everything the same, but to follow disciplines which meet our present needs. Tradition allows for development and life, because it allows for such change, which is what so-called traditionalists do not grasp:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/the-living-faith-and-the-growth-of-tradition/


r/OpenCatholic • • 9d ago

Did you know that holy pagans helped shape our faith?

2 Upvotes

Christians often consider everything pagan to be bad, and it is wrong for us to look up to pagans and learn from them. They also are led to believe some pagans, like Canaanites, were worse than others. But the reality is that we can find holy and righteous pagans, even among the Canaanites, and we can find our faith has been positively influenced by them:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/did-you-know-holy-pagans-helped-shape-our-faith/


r/OpenCatholic • • 10d ago

War as hell

4 Upvotes

When the pope said war is not holy, I was both surprised, and not surprised, at how many supposed Christians acted with hostility towards this. This is because Christ is the prince of peace, and as such, Christians should follow the way of peace, and yet I know how many have been led to embrace a spirit of contention, not peace.

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/war-as-hell-a-christian-argument-for-peace/


r/OpenCatholic • • 11d ago

Angels, humanity, and the call to humble service

2 Upvotes

Even if we do not believe that humanity “replaces” fallen angels, there are ways which various people can be seen to have similar to the angels, starting with the disciples Christ sent out to preach about the kingdom of God:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/angels-humanity-and-the-call-to-humble-service/


r/OpenCatholic • • 14d ago

Nature between fall and redemption

1 Upvotes

The problem with “natural theology” is it uses fallen nature to represent nature; it reifies sin, turning it into something good. And when we know this, it does no good to try to reconstruct what we think the world was (or is) apart from the taint of sin, because we will end up including elements of that sin in our reconstruction:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/nature-between-the-fall-and-redemption/


r/OpenCatholic • • 16d ago

Poetic diction and the mystery of theological language

2 Upvotes

Theological language is often misunderstood because the words used are often read and interpreted in the most simplistic, literalistic, and absolutist fashion. The greatest truths of the faith are incomprehensible; as such, we must not interpret theological conventions in this fashion. Instead, we must understand theological conventions are pointing to truths which transcend speech, similar to the way poetic diction allows us to interpret poems in a way which transcends the simplest reading of a poem:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/poetic-diction-and-the-mystery-of-theological-language/


r/OpenCatholic • • 17d ago

Bishops, photo-ops, and the loss of moral witness

7 Upvotes

After several bishops received pushback because they allowed themselves to be used for a political photo-op by Trump, many of them said they were sorry for allowing that to happen, that they didn’t expect to be used that way. Whether or not they were naïve, they need to follow the example of Dom Hélder Câmara, who, upon realizing how he had been used, did more than say that and act like that was enough; he knew he had to make satisfaction for what he did, and so became active in repairing the harm he helped allow be done in his name and in the name of the church:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/bishops-photo-ops-and-the-loss-of-moral-witness/


r/OpenCatholic • • 18d ago

Saved by grace, called to works

2 Upvotes

Being saved by grace through faith should not be interpreted as meaning we are to do nothing; Paul made it clear, we were made for good works, and so, how can we be faithful without them?

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/saved-by-grace-called-to-good-works/


r/OpenCatholic • • 21d ago

Why mercy, not condemnation, leads sinners home

6 Upvotes

All too often, when the church shows mercy, when it gives dispensations to help people deal with difficult, if not nearly impossible situations to navigate, legalists arise and condemn the church, claiming the church promotes sin. The reality is their own condemnations, their action actions, are what truly promotes sin:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/why-mercy-not-condemnation-leads-sinners-home/


r/OpenCatholic • • 22d ago

Pray, Reflect, and Act: Resources for Faithful Election Engagement

Thumbnail mailchi.mp
2 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic • • 23d ago

Desert Fathers and Mothers on Anger and Community

3 Upvotes

The Desert Fathers and Mothers, far from denying our social responsibility, saw the need to form proper communities to help each other in their spiritual journey; they reminded each other of the good which they need to do, and the evils which they must avoid, explaining how various passions, like anger, get in the way of our proper spiritual development.

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/desert-fathers-and-mothers-on-anger-and-community/


r/OpenCatholic • • 23d ago

I left the Protestant Church for Catholicism

Thumbnail
5 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic • • 24d ago

Religious liberty for all

3 Upvotes

Religious liberty is very important for a free society, which is why its abuse, turning it upside-down and inside-out, by using it for religious supremacy must be called out and rejected:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/religious-liberty-for-all-not-just-christians/


r/OpenCatholic • • 25d ago

True glory is found in Christ, not false piety

6 Upvotes

We must always remember that Christ is the source of our glory, that we find it in him, in following his ways, not in the way of worldly glory, not in the way of trying to make ourselves impressive in front of others, and especially, not through some form of sham piety:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/glory_in_christ/


r/OpenCatholic • • 27d ago

A simple plan for the days around All Saints and All Souls

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenCatholic • • 28d ago

Why we must embrace empathy

12 Upvotes

Too many people are convincing Christians that empathy is a bad thing, that empathy is “suicidal.” What they are doing is undermining Christ’s teachings, as empathy helps us treat others with the love and respect. So, why do some think it is “suicidal”? Because it is their false self speaking up, complaining that it is being taken down and replaced:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/why-we-must-embrace-empathy-sympathy-and-compassion/


r/OpenCatholic • • Oct 20 '26

The mystery of human deification

3 Upvotes

The heart of revelation, the heart of the Christian faith, is the incarnation and what it reveals to us about God and about God’s desire for us – the desire that we are raised up, that is, deified by Christ, so that we can join in and participate in the divine life:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/christs-two-natures-and-the-mystery-of-human-deification/


r/OpenCatholic • • Oct 19 '26

Halloween, Tolkien and the Victory of Grace

1 Upvotes

Many Christians reject Halloween, and with it, all things dealing with the horror surrounding Halloween, thinking they represent some sort of Satanic dread.  I find the opposite to be true; that in and through them, we find the light which shines in the darkness, giving us hope:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/halloween-tolkien-and-the-victory-of-grace/