r/OpenDogTraining • • Aug 26 '26

New Rule 7 Proposal

89 Upvotes

Inspired by Linkedin's feature for reporting "looks like AI slop" I'd like to get feedback on a new rule.

Proposed Rule 7:

Use your own words/no AI slop.

Violations of Rule 7 will be enforced by either removal of the post or the addition of a flag "Likely AI Slop" with the opportunity asking the poster to rewrite the post in their own words. Consistently breaking this rule can result in a temporary ban.

I'm not wholly against any and all applications of LLMs but we're starting to get flooded with posts that are about *nothing* and I see that many of you are reporting them (so I presume you don't want them) but there's not a clear rule for ya'll to be reporting under. Please provide feedback and feel free to comment if you have suggestions for tweaks to the rule.


r/OpenDogTraining • • Aug 21 '26

Training Term Discussion of the Week - Generalizing

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I used to do these posts more consistently, but life got busy. I'll try to get these back on track. What does this mean to you? How have you seen it be misinterpreted?

THE TERM OF THE WEEK

Generalizing

Discuss away!

THE WHAT

Approximately weekly, I’ll post a dog training related term to discuss what that term means to YOU. 1st level comments should be basically defining the term and then feel free to respond if you want to get clarity from someone, discuss their definition, etc.

THE WHY

One of my goals for the subreddit is to find ways to encourage higher level discussion of dog training (rather than endless “my dog pees inside” posts…nothing against those y’all are welcome to make those but it gets boring for the folks here often).

Eventually, I hope this can be put together into a sidebar resource. I’ll probably be playing around with this idea in different forms (pretty open discussion at first, might try a poll, etc)

I want to emphasize that these conversations should be in good faith (use the principle of charity) and on topic. In my mind, these posts can become rich ways to engage and better understand your fellow trainers, handlers, and owners.

Those of us with clients, I hope this helps us better understand the times you say a term and the clients/general public completely misunderstand our meaning.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 4h ago

Do I publicly shame a woman who's dog bit me after she walked off. Also AITA?

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Posting here first because Im not sure what to do...im still a bit shaken though thankfully not badly hurt.

A town near me has a dog beach that is open to dogs running off leash all winter. It's an amazing place and my dog loves it.

I was on the beach less than 10 minutes and was getting water out of my bag, when a large white dog came up and despite me trying to move away (i asked someone near me if it was theirs -no owner nearby). The dog aggressively dug its head into my bag (I tried to push its head out and it would not budge) and it found a lone granola bar at the bottom I didnt even know was there. It happened very quickly. When he came up with it, In the moment, i was worried for the dog because it put the whole thing, wrapper and all in its mouth. Here's where I screwed up... I KNOW I screwed up. I reached to grab it (I know it was dumb and I acted out of instinct to save this dog from choking on a literal entire wrapped bar- but it was still dumb). The dog goes food aggressive, bit me, broke the skin and then swallowed the thing whole. I feel SO dumb for trying to get that bar from it.

My dog has had behavioral issues as a puppy. We have done extensive training with him and when we go to the dog beach I have an e collar on him but he is now very good at his recall without. I still watch him like a hawk. If I get any weird vibes we leave or recall him tothe other end of the beach. It's not phone scroll time. I say this because I dont expect dogs to be perfect but if you know your dog could literally BITE someone, you need to be on top of it!! She wasn't anywhere near for this whole interaction, and when I think back on it. I'm lucky I didn't get bit in the face when I was crouched down with the bag next to him digging because he had clearly already fixated on the food.

Here's where it gets really Infuriating. I told her I'm going to need her information and to get the dogs rabies information. She said the dog has all its shots, Told me her first name, And then wass going to give me info and then she said "You know what. I need your information too, because you're going to pay my vet bill if my dog has to get surgery." That set me off.

All this time the dog is still following me around trying to get stuff from me and my bag and she has not leashed or taken control of the animal . Like I literally tried to save your dog while you were nowhere to be found and now you want to flip the script after your dog bit me. I told her that if that was her her feelings we should get the cops there to settle it and then she started moving down the beach.

My cut is not that bad. It's not that deep but honestly the part that really upsets me is that she didn't take any accountability. She didn't apologize for what happened. She didn't take control of her dog immediately. She scolded me for bringing food. She then threatened to sue me for her vet bills. Am I the a****** here or am I missing something?? There are people there with picnic blankets spending the day with their dog. Definitely with food sometimes and its not like that was the situation. She could have stopped this the moment the dog started running my bag. The dog could have found a chicken leg on the beach and fought someone over it. The dog is clearly food aggressive.

So now Im at a loss. The chance of rabies is probably 0 but wtf? Part of me wants to post the video I have and the images of her refusing to give me her information and publicly ahame her on the local fb and subreddit. Part of me thinks I should go to the police and file a report but I know they won't do anything and they pretty much said that since I wasn't able to stay at the beach and wait for them (had to get my non fur babies), that they couldn't do much.

I don't know if it matters, but this Is a very high cost of living area (Rye,NY) and sometimes these people are very entitled. Part of me wants to publicly shame her. I don't know what the right thing to do is. I do know if I see her at that beach again I'm going to cuss her out. Im stressed out by it. I feel like if she would have just been apologetic let me know, she would send me all vaccine records and offered me a Band-Aid. I wouldn't even feel distressed about this but she handled it , my opinion, totally wrong. The casual blaming of the person who got bit feels FUBAR And it feels really irresponsible.

I have clear pictures of her, her dog and I know what her first name is unless she was lying about it. I also have her on video NOT denying that the dog bit me but blaming me for having food in my backpack.

Side note, my good boi was very good the whole time and Im always proud of him.

Wwyd??


r/OpenDogTraining • • 8h ago

My dog does well with recall when off leash except when she sees squirrels, how can I fix this if rewards aren’t enough?

9 Upvotes

My dog (5 years) used to have great recall when off leash, but it’s gotten really bad after moving from a city to the suburbs where there are tons of squirrels everywhere. She’s a pretty high-energy dog and loves fetch, so I play with her every day. We live in a large apartment complex with pretty big green spaces for her to run and fetch, but she bolts when she sees a squirrel and has started running towards the street in our complex to look for more squirrels. It seems she’s been getting worse and worse. I will call her several times and she won’t listen if there’s a squirrel. Yesterday, she actually started walking away from me when I started going after her because she (presumably) knew I would put her back on the leash since she ignored my command. I would hate to stop letting her off leash because she adores fetch and it’s how she gets her energy out. Ball is the only thing that seems to compete with her desire to chase squirrels. She does worse off-leash if she hasn’t had enough exercise in the last few days. Long walks or even jogging just don’t do it for her. Unfortunately, we can’t really play fetch at dog parks because she resource guards. However, it’s obviously become a major safety concern at this point.

What I’ve tried: We had a really good trainer when she was 1 and she did really well. For years, I’ve worked with her on place, heel, stay, come, look, leave it. She’s very food motivated. She has to wait for us to free her to eat her food or go after a treat when inside. She’s pretty good overall, but still struggles with impulse control when outside. She does best when she has something to keep her focused like fetch. When I initially let her off leash, I do a few minutes of impulse control before even bringing out the ball: make her sit, lay down, stay. Then I spend a few minutes making her wait each time before chasing after the ball. After this, I’ll let her go after the ball and/or roam freely. If she’s just sniffing around, she’ll come as soon as I call her. I’ll call her and reward her before freeing her again every few minutes. If she bolts, she goes back on the leash. Sometimes I’ll let her earn it back after 5-10 minutes of walking on leash while using heel and stay commands.

To;dr: At this point, the punishment of going back on leash is clearly not enough to stop her. Once she’s locked in on something, she doesn’t care about consequences and she would rather chase after squirrels than get a treat. It feels like we need something else since it’s become a safety hazard. We’ve tried using the vibrate collars and she just ignores it. I’m hoping there are some options that don’t involve e-collars, but that’s what our dog trainer recommends. I’d love to hear from people who have had similar experiences.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 6h ago

New Onset Arousal Behavior

3 Upvotes

I have a 7 year old male saint bernard who I rescued two years ago and he came to me intact. Due to some medical issues he is not recommended to go under anesthesia unless absolutely necessary so we did not fix him. He lived great with our spayed female for two years until she passed a few months ago. About two months ago we got a new spayed female and they got along great. Fast forward to a little over a week ago and we noticed he started obsessively licking her vulva and ears. We separated them and took her to the vet and turns out she has vaginitis. Shes on antibiotics for another week or so. The doctor believes the blood and infection is mimicking the scent of heat. Is there a way we can introduce them again after her treatment so that this behavior does not continue or escalate?


r/OpenDogTraining • • 2h ago

Dog Becoming Reactive

1 Upvotes

I got a 2 year old Australian Shepherd who’s becoming increasingly reactive towards people. He used to be really good with the command “go say hi” and get pets and come right back to me, but now when I say it, he starts barking! Not only that, he barks when people approach me on walks. It sucks because they always compliment his looks or his loose leash walk but then he starts barking at them! Weird thing is, he’s totally chill with other dogs and can ignore them when needed. It’s the humans??

Does anyone have advice on this? We thought he was properly socialized as we’re able to take him to dog friendly restaurants and malls. He’s fine when people walk by. It’s only when people come up to us.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 7h ago

How do I train my ACD to stop chasing and barking at cars that pass by?

2 Upvotes

Hi all ! I have been trying to train my Australian cattle dog to stop chasing and barking at cars that pass by

He also stops listening or paying attention to me when his favorite people come by.

He becomes so hypervigilant about all of this stuff. It feels like he eats up all of his spoons before we even get to start our walk. It started happening ever since he became a teenager. He’s eight months old right now.

He’s getting neutered in three weeks.

Now I just hang out at my driveway trying to fix this issue by waiting for cars to pass by and helping to teach him to stay in one spot instead of chasing cars and then I give him a beef lung treat. I really can’t handle him pulling on the leash all the time when we go for walks.

It almost feels like he has become more neurotic. He even goes crazy barking when he hears cars passing by sometimes while he is in my bedroom.

There have been some signs of progress like he is starting to just look at me now when cars pass by. Expecting a treat.

I really appreciate your help thank you 🙏


r/OpenDogTraining • • 3h ago

Any tips for reactive dog??

1 Upvotes

I have a mini schnauzer and she’s 4 years old and she is very very reactive. I can’t take her out for walks or to the park because she’s barking at everyone all the time, plus she isn’t very friendly with new people. One time she got off her leash and chased a family member and it was just embarrassing. She used to be my older sister’s dog and she wouldn’t expose her to people or the outside as much when she was younger so I’m thinking that’s where the problem comes from. I am trying my best to try to train her and become more friendly towards people and teach her how to enjoy walks without getting crazy, any tips 😢


r/OpenDogTraining • • 3h ago

Dog has started “protecting” me

1 Upvotes

My 1-year old bully mix (fixed female) has started acting sort of “at attention” on our evening walks, to the point of growling when she sees other people even if they’re not walking towards us. This is a very recent development, she’s normally super friendly to strangers, and she does not do this to my husband. She only does it when it’s dark outside, which has been more and more as the time change happened and there’s less daylight. Is this something I should be discouraging? And how?


r/OpenDogTraining • • 4h ago

Help behaviour issues/fixation (advice please 🙏)

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • 5h ago

Are Dogs who are Aggressive in one home Always Aggressive in a New Home?

1 Upvotes

Many people believe that a dog's aggressive behavior will be consistent across situations and even in different homes. However, it's common for a dog to only resource guard from one family member and not the other. What explains this?

We know from excellent research out of Cornell that resource guarding, at least, is not always consistent from one home to the next. Researchers there say, therefore, that resource guarding dogs should not automatically be deemed "unadoptable" and killed.

What's the implication for other aggressive behaviors such as "guarding" the family against guests who try to visit? Might that behavior also just not show up at all if the dog is rehomed?

What might determine whether the dog guards in a new home?

A couple of quotes from the research:

"However, more than half of dogs either assessed by shelter staff or described by surrendering owners as resource guarding did not guard in adoptive homes.....most importantly, that shelters should not consider all dogs assessed as resource guarding to be unadoptable because many of these dogs do not display guarding behavior post adoption.

https://www.mdpi.com/2076-2615/10/9/1702

EDIT: The resource guarding research is just to provide evidence that aggressive dogs are not always aggressive in a new home.

That is the post topic.

The post topic is not whether or not resource guarding dogs should be adopted out of shelters.

What are the implications if "aggressive dogs" are not always aggressive? What if that aggressive behavior is mostly situational and dependent on the humans involved?

Does it change the best practices for addressing canine aggression?


r/OpenDogTraining • • 5h ago

Wireless dog fencing options.

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • 19h ago

Captain Jack street dog rescue.

Post image
10 Upvotes

Jack was rescued four weeks ago. First picked up by animal control then tossed into an over crowded shelter. My rescue organization stepped in and picked him up. He stayed with the head of the organization for a few days then was neutered.

We got the call last Wednesday to step in. We’ve fostered many dogs. Never one with PTSD. I know about the 3-3-3 rule and we are living by it. My question to all of you that have more experience in dog-related trauma is this: why is Jack so afraid of us at night? He won’t come inside, we leave our back door open, don’t rush him, don’t fuss, never raise our voice. But this happens at night. Why? I’ve tried treats. He eats them, then goes right back to being scared. We have another dog who is 8, she’s trained also a rescue. She comes in and he follows her during the day. As soon as the sun goes down, we become so skittish. I know he’s experienced trauma and we are here to help. We love Jack and want him to feel safe.

Any advice on helping Jack is much appreciated!


r/OpenDogTraining • • 6h ago

Dog Training

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

i have a 9 month old lab puppy. We spent the first few months learning basic commands. I felt it was time to introduce the E-Collar, to reinforce these commands. We are about a week in with the conditioning, it has been going well.

For example we had her out on the front lawn and had a full conversation while the kids played and she was off leash.

The collar is Dogtra brand, I found the setting of 12 to be the point my dog responds.

The question I have is that my wife swears the dog is acting differently. For example the last few days the dog has wanted to go out back in the yard and stay there. As oppose to hanging out with my wife inside like the routine they had before the E collar training.

I am curious what else I could look for to see if the E collar is having a negative effect or if the dog is just being a dog. I am happy with how she is listening to commands but I do not want her to become anxious and fearful.

Thanks all


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Any advice for an overly excited rescue dog?

Post image
43 Upvotes

I rescued a dog who I think is a Belgian Malinois and German Shepherd mix.
He loves people, but he gets way too excited, especially when we go for walks. Sometimes he pulls so hard that he almost slips out of his collar.
Does anyone have any tips on how to help him calm down? I’d really appreciate any advice!


r/OpenDogTraining • • 13h ago

How to fix food guarding

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • 14h ago

puppy biting me but not my partner?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Need training advice

3 Upvotes

Hi guys. I was sent here from the reactive dog sub, and I need some training advice. I have a balanced trainer who I worked with previously, and she has been giving me advice as well. But I would like to hear from as many sources as possible.

So. My dog, Joey, is a 14 month old female Belgian Malinois and Golden Retriever mix, with a little bit of German shepherd. She is a rescue, I adopted her six months ago. She had previously been returned to the shelter twice due to having high energy, and the second time she taken back by the shelter because that owner was abusive. She has since gone through a 6 week training program, where we both learned a lot about training. She only started showing reactivity two months after I adopted her, and we have been working on that ever since. She will bark and lung at strangers. She has been doing well, and is muzzle trained for walks, but lately she has been going downhill. I think it's because of the fear state she is in right now. She can occasionally let strangers pass us without barking, instead just going stiff and looking at them. But the last few days she has been having big reactions to people she knows and likes interacting with.

I work at a doggy daycare, and I take her to work with me. Typically she loves my co workers and the other dogs, because they give her lots of treats and play with her. But today she ran into the room, where we were swapping shifts, and starting barking and jumping at my co workers aggressively. I think it may have been because they were wearing bigger coats than usual? Or maybe she got too aroused playing with another dog. She didn't bite them, but it was aggressive fear behavior and was not appropriate. It was shocking and frightening. My trainer advised me to start using a prong collar, and bringing her to work less. I love my girl so much, and I want to give her the best chance possible. My co workers love her too, and told me it was ok, but I think they were just being nice. They love her, they've known her as long as I have, which is why its so shocking she would act so aggressively towards them.
Is the prong collar the right route to go here? I have a muzzle that she wears on walks, but I didn't think I needed one for her at work. I would appreciate any and all advice. I want to nip this in the bud before anyone gets hurt. What training would be useful for her, and me?


r/OpenDogTraining • • 22h ago

Barking when humans and dogs walk past

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • 23h ago

Well-behaved at home but not out

1 Upvotes

I have just adopted an 8 year old, in tact, golden retriever. When training at home, he has perfect recall, and obeys commands etc. but at the park or on walks, he has zero recall. He sometimes sits when told to but mostly would rather sniff or just ignores me.

Is this something I can improve in him? If so, how would I do this?


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Mouthy Adopted Doodle

1 Upvotes

We just adopted a two year old doodle. He’s awesome! Except he’s mouthy. We’ve tried no, redirecting to a toy or chew, apple butter spray on our sleeves, but nothing is working. He’s not aggressive he just doesn’t know or hasn’t been trained.

Please help!


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Where should I start? (dog reactivity)

1 Upvotes

Hi. I recently adopted a 1yr 1mo 45lb mixed breed dog from the shelter. Little over three weeks ago. She is dog reactive, and there are so many dogs in my area that I can’t walk her without her almost or actually reacting. I also share a small yard with someone who has a little dog that she sometimes lets into the yard unleashed.

Today, I was sitting in the yard with my dog, she was just laying in the sun. Then my “neighbor’s” little dog was suddenly barking and running at my dog. I had my dog on a leash, and tried to pull her away, but she ended up slipping out of the collar. The two dogs got into a little scuffle. My dog at some point nipped the little guy, as a chunk of fur was missing. However, there was no broken skin. She could’ve really bitten if she wanted, but didn’t. It still scares me though. I also made the mistake of introducing her to my inlaw’s dog after one week of having her, and she similarly nipped him, this time actually leaving a scratch on his skin.

I know she’s still decompressing/adjusting, but we really need to get her reactivity under control. My area is full of dogs. Half the time I can’t even load her into my car, or drive down the street to a nearby park without her reacting, because there’s so many dogs. I think her reactivity is fear based. If we can’t get this under control, she will basically be confined to my 700 sq ft home 24/7. I know we should muzzle train asap, but I’m at a loss of what else to do. I’ve been doing so much research and I feel overwhelmed and defeated, especially after the incident with the “neighbor’s” dog today :(

I’ll be looking into trainers too, but I need to figure out smth to do in the meantime


r/OpenDogTraining • • 2d ago

Your dog is not reactive just because they aren’t neutral to everything

107 Upvotes

Recently I’ve been seeing this rise of people labeling their dogs reactive…anytime the dog reacts to something.

“My dog is normally fine with other dogs but is reactive when another dog is barking and lunging at him!” No, your dog is not reactive. They’re responding in a reasonable way to another dog provoking them. Now, that does NOT mean you shouldn’t train them. It’s a perfectly fine and reasonable goal to want your dog to remain calm even when other dogs are not. But, your dog isn’t REACTIVE.

“My GSD x Great Pyrenees is reactive when strangers come to the door!” You mean, your dog with guarding and protective genetic predisposition barks and is not immediately friendly to strangers near their home? Yeah, the dog isn’t reactive.

Reactivity is a disproportionate response to everyday, relatively mundane stimulus. Your dog having ANY response to something is not automatically reactivity. If your dog is “only reactive when X specific situation happens”, and in some cases it’s perfectly aligned to their genetic traits, then they aren’t reactive.

Train your dog however you want. I’m not saying just accept any behavior, even if it’s not reactivity. If you want your dog to be calm when people come over, neutral to other dogs no matter their behavior, etc. of course go and train your dog to do that. But for goodness sake, stopping labeling every single display of emotion from dogs as reactivity and implying there is something wrong or abnormal with the dog.

Dogs are not robots. The world is not divide into only two camps of “neutral dog” and “reactive dog”.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 18h ago

My dog got attacked

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

My dogs reactivity is becoming dangerous, need advice urgently

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes