My biggest problem with this show is that they never allow two time travelers to actually be together, whether as friends or even as enemies!
I want to start with Geillis, and I know she isn’t exactly considered a friend of Claire’s, but she could have been. If I had the chance to rewrite the story, I would definitely make the two of them friends.
First of all, they would need each other, considering they come from the same time period, and they could have shared the same goal: stopping the rebellion and doing what they believed was best for Scotland!
I don’t know about anyone else, but despite everything Geillis was and everything she did, I could genuinely see a connection between her and Claire. A connection that, for example, I never really felt between Claire and Louise in Season 2!
But anyway, what’s done is done, and there’s nothing we can do about it. My biggest disappointment, however, is the Comte! I still remember a few weeks ago, when I had just started Season 2 and we had barely been introduced to his character. I randomly came across a YouTube video where I heard someone mention that he was a time traveler. I immediately scrolled away and literally let out a little scream because I was so shocked. I wasn’t expecting that at all! But I wasn’t angry about the spoiler. Quite the opposite, actually. I was like, WOW! I did NOT see that coming! Finally, I thought to myself. An enemy who is a time traveler, just like Claire! I was so excited, and I couldn’t stop imagining all the possible storylines that could come out of this. One scene that will always stick with me is when Claire tells Captain Randall, “I curse you with knowledge…” And THAT is exactly what I had been waiting for! We finally had an enemy who possessed the same weapon as Claire: knowledge of the future.
But in the end, I don’t even know how to explain it, because absolutely nothing turned out the way I had imagined.
We know that this character is a time traveler, but the way he was handled? Ridiculous! I was expecting a clever, cunning man who would actually use his knowledge to his advantage. And what did he do instead? He sent a bunch of men to ambush Claire and Mary, which resulted in Mary being raped. Seriously? That’s the kind of move any ordinary man from that century could have made, not some supposedly intelligent man who can travel through time! Where was the cleverness? Where was the strategy? Where was the battle of minds between two people who knew what the future held?
I don’t know. I just expected so much more!