I love Claire as a character, and I’m entranced by her many traits (both good and bad but mostly wonderful), so I do sometimes wonder about how matters may have gone if the story plot had played out just a little bit differently. Let’s try this one. After learning Jamie has drowned, Claire marries LJG (the “why” of this can be argued, yes I know the standard reason that is given, or rather that LJG gives). Claire gives every indication of accommodating to her new life (even at the moment that Jamie appears she has agreed to more social engagements with LJG and acquaintances)- after all, accommodating to circumstances is one of her strengths. What if Jamie does not appear when he does? What if he arrives in town a month later? The British army is evacuating Philadelphia (both in the film and historically) and the Americans are moving in. My question is: does Claire, still ignorant of Jamie’s survival, leave Philadelphia and accompany LJG as his wife, or does she stay in town and go over to the Continental army to serve in their medical corps (and serve the Cause, as she told Ian she wanted to do) ?
The rendering of her departure with LJG would, IMO, add so much depth to the story: there would be a role reversal at the battle of Monmouth, where LJG battles the nefarious rebels, and although Claire is not a Loyalist, she would feel obligated to tend the wounded English. My imagination would have them go on to New York or even London, causing Jamie to search for many months before catching up with them. Thus, it would easily be a year since the star crossed lovers have seen each other. In the meanwhile, Claire has ripened in her role as Lady John Grey, with all that goes with being his wife. Don’t get me wrong—-Claire is crazy in love with Jamie and would cleave to him in that scenario, but the encounter would be fraught with so much more energy, difficulty, passion, and emotion. And, it would allow the relationship between Claire and LJG to develop more fully (in the show, it’s really a dead end - the whole affair only serves to anger Jamie and spotlight John’s adventures/escapes)
Thoughts?