r/PKMS • • 19d ago

Self-Promotion Self promotion thread (November 2026)

8 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • Aug 11 '26

Combating AI Slop and Astroturfing

59 Upvotes

The mod team will now be more strict against AI slop on this subreddit; any continuous violations of rule #5 (No AI Slop) will result in a ban. We highly encourage users to flag any AI posts/astroturfing.

All promotions should go in the Promotions thread.

Also, I want to give a shout out to our top 1% contributors and everybody who makes this cove of the internet the best place to discuss PKM. You guys are the best :)


r/PKMS • • 13h ago

Method Tips for Writing Better Atomic Notes

16 Upvotes

I wanted to share a few things I've learned about atomic notes and why I think they're worth trying.

For a long time, my notes were basically information dumps. I'd read a book, highlight interesting passages, add a few comments, and throw everything into one big note. Sometimes a single note contained ten completely different ideas.

The problem? I almost never reused any of it.

Whenever I needed to write an article or work on a book chapter, I'd remember reading something useful about the subject. But where was it? Which book? Which note? Buried somewhere between dozens of unrelated paragraphs.

That's when I started changing how I take notes.

The basic idea is simple, one idea, one note.

Think of LEGO. A fully assembled toy can only be used for one thing. But a box of individual bricks lets you build a castle today, a spaceship tomorrow, and something completely different next week.

Notes work the same way.

An observation about software architecture doesn't have to remain buried inside a summary of a book. I can reuse it in an article, a lecture, or an entirely different book.

This has been particularly useful in my own work. I've written more than 30 books about programming, AI, and programming languages, and having a collection of reusable ideas makes a huge difference. I don't have to start from scratch every time.

Here are three tips that have helped me:

-Keep one idea per note.

Instead of creating a note called "Productivity Notes" containing fifteen different topics, split it into smaller notes:

  • Small cards encourage focused thinking.
  • Writing helps organize your thoughts.
  • Links make unexpected connections easier to discover.

Your title should communicate the actual idea. If a note needs to cover several unrelated points, consider splitting it.

-Always write in your own words.

Copying a quote is easy, but it doesn't necessarily mean you've understood it.

Try explaining the idea as if you were discussing it with a friend. You don't need to reproduce the author's original wording.

If you can't explain something in your own words, you might need to think about it a little longer.

-Write for your future self.

Imagine opening that note five years from now, with absolutely no memory of where it came from.

Would you understand it?

Avoid phrases like "as mentioned above" or "this happens because of that." Each note should contain enough context to make sense on its own.

It doesn't need to be complicated. A meaningful title, two or three sentences explaining the idea, and a reference to the original source are often enough.

"Won't this create thousands of notes?"

Yes. And I don't think that's necessarily a problem.

Niklas Luhmann's Zettelkasten eventually contained approximately 90,000 cards.

But the goal was never simply to collect cards. The interesting part happens when you start connecting ideas that originally came from completely different contexts.

An observation about software architecture might connect to an idea about team organization. Something you learned about human learning might help you understand a programming problem.

That's where unexpected insights emerge.

Once I started working this way, my notes stopped being an archive of things I'd read and became a library of ideas I could actually reuse.

How do you organize your notes? Do you prefer long documents organized by topic, or small, independent notes?

I'd love to hear how other people approach this.


r/PKMS • • 11h ago

Method META REFLECTION 🪞 PKM - Personal Knowledge Management 📖 Self Amplification 8🗓️26

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 1d ago

Discussion What do you do with the reels and posts you save? Do you ever find them again?

2 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 2d ago

Discussion How big is your largest vault?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 3d ago

Discussion Mem shutting down

19 Upvotes

One of those early apps that eventually drowned in a sea of similar LLM assisted apps. Early on I recall a lot of video influencers hyping it. Over time, it went through so many different iterations, never able to distinguish itself. Good lesson to remember, death comes for all apps. With the big LLMs expanding their capabilities and having ongoing memory of user conversations, these smaller apps will likely continue to get picked off. It makes me appreciate orgmode and other offline centered alternatives that don’t have so many moving parts dependent on AI.


r/PKMS • • 3d ago

Discussion I used an algorithm to automatically detect clusters in my collective knowledge graph

Post image
0 Upvotes

Instead of relying purely on manual organization, I wanted to see what would happen if I let an algorithm automatically detect clusters (i call them "Hubs") in my knowledge graph purely from how notes and concepts are linked together.

I'm currently working on an update for a collaborative knowledge app I'm building, and I've been testing the Louvain community detection algorithm on the global graph (the shared knowledge graph)

I was genuinely surprised by the quality of the results and what pure graph structure reveals without any AI or text analysis.

For instance, it surfaced parallel clusters across languages, like "Productivity" and "Productivité" showing up as two separate hubs. That raises an interesting design question: writing bridge notes to link both concepts could eventually pull them together, though keeping distinct clusters for each language community might actually be preferable (we'll see what happens!).

On the flip side, it kept closely related topics separate, like "Prise de notes" (note-taking) and "Système de prise de note" (note-taking systems), simply because their notes connect to different neighboring concepts. It was also fascinating to spot tiny clusters forming around very specific niche topics that individual users just started exploring.

For the technical part for those interested : I looked into Leiden algo too, though my current stack only had a solid library for Louvain. Each detected cluster gets assigned a color and is automatically named after its highest-weighted concept. Since the script runs every night at midnight, I added a small stabilization step that compares each new output against the previous day's run, keeping the same IDs and colors whenever a cluster's core nodes haven't shifted too much.

Watching how these clusters grow, split, or merge over time should be really interesting, but for now I don't store historical snapshots of each daily run.

Have any of you experimented with automated graph clustering (via plugins, custom scripts, or specific PKM tools) ?

I'm curious to hear how you approach discovering structure in a growing graph, or any thoughts and questions you have on this setup!


r/PKMS • • 4d ago

Feature I built an always-visible scratchpad and task list that docks to the edge of my screen

3 Upvotes

I built a lightweight desktop HUD for tasks and quick notes, without opening my notes app

I like my notes app for organizing ideas, but not for keeping track of my day. Every time I open it to check something, I end up distracted.

So I built Life HUD, a small, always-visible bar that sits at the top or side of your Windows desktop. It shows your tasks, quick notes, clock, weather, and music controls. Windows automatically resize around it, so it's never in the way.

  • Unfinished tasks automatically carry over to tomorrow.
  • Quick scratchpad for capturing thoughts without breaking focus.
  • Everything stored locally. No accounts, sync, or telemetry.

It's not trying to replace your notes app. Just a lightweight layer for what matters right now.

Free, open source, Windows only.

https://github.com/George-API/LifeHUD

Curious if others would find this useful alongside their PKM setup, or if daily notes already cover it.


r/PKMS • • 4d ago

Method How I stopped dumping unread web clips into my Obsidian vault: I built an open-source staging & research inbox that only exports triaged notes

10 Upvotes

My Obsidian vault used to suffer from the Collector's Fallacy: I'd clip 50 articles a week with the web clipper, promising myself I'd summarize and tag them later. Within six months my vault was 80% unread noise.

I built Sparkkeep (free, open-source, self-hosted) to act as the gatekeeper and research desk in front of my Obsidian vault: https://github.com/BurlacuAndrei/sparkkeep

  1. Capture messy inputs anywhere: Send links, screenshots, or voice memos from Telegram, Discord, Slack, or the browser extension into Sparkkeep—not directly into your clean vault.
  2. Triage & synthesize first: Sparkkeep scrapes the page, runs a noise gate, generates a structured brief (TL;DR, value proposition, action checklist) using your own local Ollama or API model, and lets you triage cards with 1 / 2 / 3 / Esc.
  3. Run cited deep research: For topics worth pursuing, run a deterministic research playbook that searches the web via SearXNG and attaches a cited dossier.
  4. Automatic Vault Sync: Only when a card moves to active execution (To-Do / In Progress / Done) or finishes research does Sparkkeep auto-export clean Markdown + YAML frontmatter straight into your Obsidian vault directory.

Runs in a single Docker container (<30MB RAM). Would love to hear how other Obsidian users structure their YAML frontmatter or staging workflows!


r/PKMS • • 4d ago

Method How to get posts to an inbox?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 5d ago

Discussion App Slopocalypse: The not-so-good, the bad, and the ugly

21 Upvotes

With AI dramatically lowering the barrier to building software, we're seeing an explosion of new apps, especially in the note-taking space which already had a lot of options.

Some are genuinely impressive. Others feel like hastily assembled clones with a fresh coat of paint.

It's beginning to feel impossible to sort through it all. I'm curious how people distinguish between what's worth the time and what's outright slop. Even worse is the issue of abandonware. It's never been cheaper and quicker to develop, but maintaining software still takes dedication.

What are your biggest green flags and red flags when evaluating a new app? What makes something worth your attention rather than just more noise?


r/PKMS • • 4d ago

Other outl new logo, the octopus grew up, and it is still an octopus

Post image
0 Upvotes

outl has a new logo. The cartoon octopus with glasses and an Esc keycap is replaced by a flat silhouette on a 91 by 128 grid: a head with 21 unit corners, a short stub and three tentacles, all cut at the same slope, atan(3/5), which is 30.96 degrees. The post walks through the real numbers (the widths 25, 18 and 13, the lime tip on the dark theme, the 56% mark on the app tile, the contrast ratios), says what the new mark gave up, and notes that the site already wears it while the app icons on every client ship in the next release.

https://outl.app/blog/the-octopus-grew-up


r/PKMS • • 4d ago

Discussion Giving mobile AI assistants (Claude/Grok) read + write access to a private Obsidian vault (iCloud) via a self-hosted MCP on my VPS. Good idea?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 5d ago

Method I'm new here in this case...

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 5d ago

Discussion Where do you capture everything, from quick to-dos to ideas buried in AI chats?

14 Upvotes

I’m looking for one place to dump thoughts as they come up. Ideally, I could dictate or type something and have AI automatically organise it into tasks, projects, ideas or calendar events.

Some of my thinking also happens inside ChatGPT and Claude conversations. Useful ideas end up buried in different chats, with no real system for reviewing them. I’m considering an Obsidian vault with an AI connector, so I could say “save this idea” during a conversation and have it stored somewhere permanent and searchable, although I’m not sure whether this is possible with ChatGPT.

I’ve also considered building my own personal dashboard. The idea would be simple: I dictate “dry cleaning at 10am on the 12th”, and it automatically creates a Google Calendar event and saves the information. Another day, I dictate a project idea, and it gets saved somewhere I can actually find again. That’s really all I’m looking for, perhaps with a little AI to help search everything.

But surely there’s an existing solution that does this well?

Has anyone solved this? What does your setup look like? Ideally something that works across Mac and iPhone, without constantly having to manually move information between apps.

Thanks!


r/PKMS • • 5d ago

Discussion Is there a way to access my Obsidian vault directly from ChatGPT's regular chat mode?

Thumbnail
4 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 5d ago

Discussion Does any note-taking app do dictation cleanup properly?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/PKMS • • 5d ago

Feature Are there any PKMs that use textblocks as the core method of data organization?

6 Upvotes

I have been using Obsidian for quite awhile and I love so many things about it but there is one feature that not even the extensive plugin ecosystem supports extensively, block references. I am constantly wanting to reference a block of text or a paragraph in other notes that overlap in subject but the rest of the heading does not. I am using nested headings for mapping the local hierarchy of a notes wikilinks, which leaves the note lagging because there are so many block links. This especially becomes a problem when I want to make small or quick edits to the blocks or their identifiers and have to wait 5-10mins for my changes to update across the vault.

I think the issue is that I am using Obsidian for something that it was not designed for and need to move part of my workflow to another tool. I have considered moving stuff to Logseq but after some testing and noodling around with its block-linking system, I think I might run into a similar problems in different ways. I know emacs has some potential but have not gotten past the tutorial for its macros and am kinda in the dark on how it even works. At this point I have a pretty decent collection of criteria I could try coding up a prototype myself if I had the time, or more realistically biting the bullet and getting a claude code subscription, but thought I would make a post to see if this as already been done.


r/PKMS • • 6d ago

Discussion Does anyone know of a good tool/platform for this?

20 Upvotes

i have this habit of saving all the useful stuff I come across - like articles, Reddit posts, YouTube videos, research papers, etc. I always save them thinking like “this is going to be useful later” and then when I actually need something a few months later, I have no idea where I saved it.

i'm basically looking for something that's more than just a bookmark manager, but also doesn't require me to manually organize and write notes for everything I save.

Does something like this already exist? What do you guys use for this?


r/PKMS • • 6d ago

Method Highlighting came out low utility in the 2013 study-techniques review, and most clipping is highlighting

0 Upvotes

Dunlosky and colleagues reviewed 10 study techniques in 2013. Highlighting was rated low utility, along with rereading and summarizing. Practice testing and spacing reviews out were rated high. Self-explanation, where you write down why something is true, landed in the middle.

A web clip or a Kindle highlight import is mostly highlighting. So what probably does the work is a line you write under the clip about why it's true or what it connects to. If you can't write that line, the clip is likely not worth keeping.

The other cheap change is when you reopen a note, try to recall what it says before you read it.

Caveat: this is all research on students, nobody has tested it on note systems. Has anyone run a rule like this for a few months?


r/PKMS • • 6d ago

Other EIDOS as a notetaking and Tasks app

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

Hello I've discovered https://github.com/mayneyao/eidos . I'm planning to make it my notes and tasks app. Anyone who already does any of this ?

Update : https://github.com/mayneyao/eidos/issues/404


r/PKMS • • 6d ago

Other – PKMS New post: The Markdown Link no. 65

0 Upvotes
Skein is a free markdown editor. It is also free of AI, for once, and a PKMS

Among today’s links are markdown editors Skein (also PKMS) and bpad (browser-based). The other link takes you to SideSchedule, a calendar for your meeting notes

https://md-handbook.com/blog/markdown-link-no-65/

#markdown #markdowneditors #writing #free #books #Skein #SideSchedule #meetingnotes #bpad


r/PKMS • • 6d ago

Discussion Is Building a Second Brain (BASB) officially dead? 🧠🤖

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

Let’s be real for a second. With the rapid evolution of AI, lightning-fast indexing, semantic search, and LLMs getting massive context windows, I’m seriously starting to question the future of the traditional BASB methodology.

Take Claude, for example. It can process huge amounts of text, find exactly what you need in seconds, and with AI memory capabilities becoming the new standard, the need to meticulously curate, tag, and file away notes into a strict PARA structure feels increasingly obsolete. Why spend hours manually organizing folders when an AI can just instantly retrieve, connect, and synthesize the exact concepts you’re looking for?

I'm personally trying to keep the dream alive. I’ve recently hooked up a vector database to my Obsidian vault just to give my Second Brain a fighting chance and make it natively "smart." But honestly? It feels like I might be putting a tech band-aid on a dying philosophy.

Are we shifting from Building a Second Brain to just Prompting an AI Brain?

Has anyone else completely abandoned their traditional BASB setup because of these AI advancements? How are you guys adapting your Obsidian/Notion vaults to survive the AI wave, or is it just end of story for manual knowledge management?
Would love to hear your thoughts and workflows!


r/PKMS • • 7d ago

Discussion How do you organize your notes? (I struggle)

17 Upvotes

TLDR: Reaching the limit of my current note-taking & PKMS setup in Obsidian, wondering how other people manage their information sets. Preference for plaintext compatibility & Vim motion support

I use Obsidian to organize my notes, for work and personal contexts. After reading around Reddit at the start of 2026 I got the cue that I needed to just get started, and chose the PARA method to sort my notes a bit.

I have now gotten a fair amount of notes, mostly for work but also in the personal vault.

Previously, I was using Trilium, however I have fallen in love with plaintext and Vim motions.

I have tried using Folders & Tags but that has only somewhat mitigated the cost of keeping things organized, which is my main struggle.

I have fiddled around with Notion, Trilium, Paper and looked at fancy setups in Obsidian.

How do you handle keeping your notes organized, indexable and helpful a while after creation (months, years)?

Oh and finally, I am open to using AI in a limited capacity but want to write content-type information myself.

Edit: Formatting

Edit (thoughts after reading the comments): I will go through the Zettelkasten method and some other PKMS principles to figure out what I want my knowledge base to store, do and be, now that I have a sample of existing notes to use as an indicator of workflow. Maybe a why instead of how.

To any future readers: I highly encourage you to try stuff, write notes even if they are an unusable mess, and iterate on a system you find intuitive and fun to use. There are many ways to skin this particular cat, and the important thing is to find what suits you. :}