r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 5d ago

Friday Discussion / Q&A Friday Discussion / Q&A

1 Upvotes

Got something on your mind?

Talk about it in the comments below and let peers participate! It can be about your day, thoughts, hobbies, quick advice you need, questions, or anything you experienced recently.

Remember to follow the rules and have fun!


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • Mar 19 '26

Eid post!! ✨🌙 Eid Al-Fitr ~ March 20, 2026

11 Upvotes

Eid Mubarak everyone!

⊹₊┈ㆍ┈ㆍ┈ㆍ┈ㆍ🌙ㆍ┈ㆍ┈ ㆍ┈ㆍ┈₊⊹

Post some wholesome media in the comments section below! It can be a poem in a visual format, a quote, gif, song lyrics, Eid decorations, or your Eid outfit!

We advise that if you show your face while posting your outfit, please beware of the consequences. It’s suggested to crop out your face/blur it/cover it with an emoji or sticker for safety purposes.

⊹₊┈ㆍ┈ㆍ┈ㆍ┈ㆍ🌙ㆍ┈ㆍ┈ ㆍ┈ㆍ┈₊⊹

This post will be locked at the end of the week.

We hope you have enjoyed this Ramadan and learnt new things within this special month!! Take this time to spend with your loved ones, friends, and more importantly, yourself!

~ r/PakistaniiConfessions Mod Team 🇵🇰✨


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 9h ago

Confession I Never Knew Being a Father would Make me this Emotional Over a Simple Video!

26 Upvotes

I’m away from home these days, and today I received a video of my son performing at an event at his school.

He’s not even four yet.

I opened the video smiling, just excited to see my little boy. And there he was, standing in front of everyone, trying his best with that innocent little face of his.

I don’t know what happened to me, but I just kept watching it over and over again.

I was smiling like an idiot, but at the same time my eyes were filling up with tears. My heart felt so full and heavy at the same time. I don’t even know how to explain that feeling.

Some of you might remember my previous post about dropping him off at school for the first time. How he cried and begged me not to leave, and how I ended up sitting in my car crying.

And now look at him.

The same little boy who was terrified of going to school is standing there performing in front of people.

I just wish I could’ve been there.

I wish I could’ve sat somewhere in the audience, watching him with the biggest smile on my face. I wish he could’ve spotted me in the crowd and gave me a “Hi” with that smile he gave his mum.

That’s what hurts a little. Being away from home means missing these tiny moments that probably don’t seem like a big deal to anyone else.

This little human has absolutely no idea how much happiness he brings into my life just by existing and I really had no idea fatherhood was going to be like this.

I miss my boy so much right now.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 12h ago

Advice Female 28,NEED realistic Advice on a Situation. The whole situation is making me want to kill myself.

34 Upvotes

I (28F) need some genuine advice on how to handle severe family pressure and emotional blackmail.

Growing up, my parents always told me I would eventually marry my cousin. The problem is, I have never felt a shred of attraction or affection for him. Over the years, I rejected his advances multiple times. He couldn't handle the rejection, caused a huge scene, told everyone in the family, and cut me off completely.
Later on, I fell in love with another guy, and we have been together for a few years now. During this time, I kept standing my ground and saying no to my parents about my cousin. After a lot of arguments, I finally introduced my partner to my parents. Because he is a genuinely great person and they couldn't find a single flaw with him, they finally agreed to let me marry him and officially announced that the rishta with my cousin was off.
That’s when all hell broke loose.

Over the last three days, 8 different relatives (aunts, uncles, grandparents) have shown up at our house back-to-back both individually and separately to pressure my mom. Last night, they came again, pulled me into a separate room, and told me that if I don't marry my cousin, I am "breaking the family" and the entire family is going to suffer because of me. They told me how much they all love me and can’t let me leave this family. I’m suffering from severe anxiety and now bed ridden. I’ve been previously diagnosed with anxiety disorder and depression.

Even worse, my grandmother is emotionally blackmailing my mom, telling her that she will literally die if this cousin marriage doesn't happen. My mom is completely overwhelmed and is now saying she doesn't think she can say no to them anymore.
Meanwhile, my partner and his family are completely steadfast—they are standing by me and have even been begging my mom not to give in to the pressure.
I refuse to marry a man I have zero feelings for just to satisfy my relatives' egos, especially after the way he reacted to being rejected. How do I support my mom so she doesn't cave to my grandmother's emotional blackmail, and how do I shut down these relatives for good?

TL;DR: Parents finally agreed to let me marry my longtime partner instead of my cousin (who previously threw a tantrum and cut me off when I rejected him). Now 8 relatives are harassing my mom daily, and my grandmother is threatening that she'll die if I don't marry my cousin. My mom is about to cave. Need realistic advice on how to stay strong and protect my future.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 10h ago

Advice My wife lacks initiative and independence despite 2.5 years of support. I’m worried about our future, especially having children. What should I do?

17 Upvotes

TL;DR: I had an arranged marriage and made it clear before our engagement that I didn’t expect traditional gender roles. I wanted an independent partner who would also take responsibility, learn new skills, and adapt to life in Germany. She agreed, but despite 2.5 years of support, language courses, driving lessons, and having almost no responsibilities at home, she has made very little progress. Now in Germany, she struggles with basic communication and independent living, and we lack emotional intimacy and meaningful conversations. I’m afraid I’ll end up carrying almost every responsibility if we have children. She acknowledges wasting those years and promises to change, but I’ve heard similar promises before. Should I keep waiting, reconsider our future, or involve her parents?

Disclaimer: this is a long post but I really appreciate of you can read and give and advise to your brother.

Hi everyone,

I got married at the beginning of 2025. I was 30, and my wife was 24. It was an arranged marriage, and we only started communicating after our engagement.

I’m a software engineer living in Germany. After our engagement, I explained that I don’t believe in traditional gender roles, nor do I think they’re practical for the life I want here.

I told her she would have complete freedom to study, work, pursue her interests, or choose her own path. In return, I expected her to develop the skills necessary to live independently in Germany, particularly learning English and German, understanding the culture, and managing everyday responsibilities.

My understanding of marriage is that two people should complement each other. If one partner is the sole financial provider, the other should be capable of handling other family responsibilities, such as paperwork, appointments, and communicating with schools or doctors when we have children.

I didn’t want a traditional housewife. I wanted a partner who could think independently, take initiative, and share responsibilities.

Before our engagement, I explicitly asked whether she was willing to learn and grow. I even told her that if she wasn’t interested in this kind of life, she could say no, and I would take responsibility for calling off the engagement to protect her from any blame.
She agreed, and I trusted her words.

What happened during her time in Pakistan
Because of the family reunification visa process, she remained in Pakistan for a long time. During this period, I tried to give her every opportunity to prepare for life in Germany.

After our marriage, I opened a bank account for her and gave her personal spending money, which she could use without asking anyone or explaining her expenses. I have never questioned how she spends it.

I also encouraged her to learn driving and spent approximately PKR 150,000 on lessons, her licence, and repairing the car after an accident. Despite this, she still cannot drive confidently.

I arranged an online English tutor, but after six months, she couldn’t speak or understand basic English. She also attended a German course without making meaningful progress. Eventually, I suggested watching English-language movies and series for exposure, but she didn’t do that either.

Mind you, she had practically no household responsibilities. We have a small family in Pakistan, my mother managed the household, and we had maids for cooking and cleaning. She didn’t have to work, look after children, or manage anything at home.

Throughout this time, I encouraged her to study, work, or pursue whatever interested her, assuring her of my support.

The problem is that she never says no. She agrees to everything but rarely follows through.

She wanted an independent life in Europe but didn’t seem willing to put in the effort required to prepare for it.

Now she’s in Germany
She still cannot speak or understand basic English, let alone German, despite being a university graduate. She struggles with complex conversations, isn’t willing to go outside alone, and spends most of her time at home watching TikTok, Instagram Reels, or talking to people back in Pakistan.

She also doesn’t know how to cook much beyond basic things like roti or eggs.
Before someone misunderstands me, I’m not complaining because I expect her to cook for me. I prepare my own meals because I follow a healthy diet, while she either doesn’t cook or prepares Pakistani food that I generally don’t eat.

My concern is her inability to manage basic aspects of independent living. I find myself having to teach her almost everything, including certain things related to personal hygiene.

She acknowledges that she wasted those two years and now says she has created a “schedule” to finally learn the language. But after so many unfulfilled promises, I’m finding it difficult to trust her words.

I realise now that I made the mistake of assuming that because she was an adult, she understood that marriage required effort and that agreeing to something meant she would actually work toward it.

We lack emotional intimacy and connection
Despite being married, we still behave like strangers. We can barely hold a meaningful conversation for more than ten minutes, and we don’t have much of a love life.
One reason I encouraged her to watch English-language movies and series wasn’t just to improve her English. I also hoped they would expose her to human emotions, relationships, and different ways people communicate and respond to situations.

I believe love develops gradually through understanding, shared experiences, and emotional connection. It isn’t just cheesy dialogue from an Umera Ahmed novel.
But how do you build that connection when you can barely communicate meaningfully with your partner?
I wanted someone I could talk to, share experiences with, and grow alongside. Instead, I feel lonely within my own marriage.

My biggest fear is having children
If we start a family in our current situation, I’m genuinely afraid I’ll end up being responsible for everything, from earning money and managing important decisions to handling paperwork, appointments, and the children’s needs.

Imagine our child has a school meeting or doctor’s appointment. If my wife cannot communicate or handle these situations independently, I’ll have to leave work to attend them and then work additional hours to compensate.

That means less time with my children.

What frightens me is the possibility that my children might grow up thinking their father was never there, without knowing that I was working extra hours because I was handling responsibilities that should have been shared.

I want to be a present and involved father, but how can I do that if I’m expected to carry almost every responsibility myself?
More importantly, what kind of family environment would we be creating?

The contradiction I struggle with
My wife acknowledges that she has more freedom than most women she knows personally. She even compares me with her cousins’ husbands, whom she describes as typical controlling Pakistani men, and appreciates that I support her choices.

Yet she’s now in Europe, surrounded by opportunities, and chooses to spend most of her time inside one room on social media or talking to people back home.
I don’t want to control her. I value my own freedom too much to deny someone else theirs.

But I sometimes feel that people want the benefits of freedom without accepting the responsibilities that come with it.

I don’t want to supervise another adult, constantly reminding them what to learn or how to improve. I want a partner who takes initiative and understands that we’re building a life together.

I’m beginning to wonder whether I’ve confused being supportive with taking responsibility for someone else’s personal growth.

Where I stand now
I understand that marriage requires compromises and that no two people are perfectly compatible.

But while I have the right to make compromises in my own life, I don’t believe I have the right to bring a child into this world and make those compromises on their behalf before they’re even born.

Right now, I can’t see how our situation would allow us to raise children in the environment I want to provide.
Outside of this issue, I genuinely appreciate my life. I have a good career, I travel, I take care of my health, and I’m finally living the life I once dreamed about in Pakistan.
But this situation is eating me alive.

I’m frustrated, disappointed, and scared of what the future might look like. I don’t know whether I’m expecting too much, whether I’ve approached things incorrectly, or whether we simply have fundamentally different attitudes toward life and responsibility.

Should I involve her parents?
One thing I haven’t done in these 2.5 years is involve her parents.
I deliberately avoided it because I believe my wife is my partner, not someone whose behaviour or decisions I should have to discuss with her parents.

We’re both adults, and I believe marital problems should ideally be resolved between the two people involved. I never wanted to complain to her parents, ask them to intervene, or use them to pressure her.

However, after 2.5 years of conversations, support, and promises without meaningful progress, I genuinely don’t know what else to do.

Part of me believes we should still be able to resolve this ourselves, while another part wonders whether continuing to keep everything private is realistic.

What do you think?

Am I expecting too much, or are these reasonable expectations of an adult partner in marriage?
How do you distinguish between being patient with someone who needs time to grow and accepting a situation where you might carry the responsibilities of two people indefinitely?

After 2.5 years, should I involve her parents, or would that be a mistake considering we’re both adults?
How long should I reasonably wait for meaningful change before accepting that we might have different priorities and expectations from life?

What would you do in my situation, especially when having children could permanently affect not just us but our future children?
I’m genuinely looking for different perspectives because I don’t want my frustration to cloud my judgment or lead me to make an unfair decision.

If you have read post this far, thank you so so so much.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 8h ago

Discussion Parents want me to say yes to a rishta due to age pressure, but there are major lifestyle, financial, and mindset mismatches. Should I compromise or reject, and how do I convince them?

7 Upvotes

I (28F) am a fashion designer, and my parents are strongly pushing a rishta right now because they're worried that if I say no at this age, I won't find a good match later. I want to look at this objectively without being overly picky, so I'm laying out both the positives and the concerns to see if I'm right to reject—and how to convince my parents.
The Positives:

•The guy himself seems educated, well-mannered, and respectful toward his father, even though the father doesn't seem to have much say in the house.
•He is the sole earner supporting his family, which shows responsibility.

My Concerns & Mismatches:

•The Guy's Mindset & Effort: His mother mentioned he doesn't actually want to get married yet. He also hasn't made any effort to talk to me directly (possibly ego or hesitation), and he is apparently upset about the photos my mom sent because I wasn't wearing a dupatta—he's worried I'm like her sister who stopped taking dupatta after getting married.
•Potential Saas (Mother-in-Law): She comes across as quite controlling (didnt wait to let us decide what to eat from the menu when she invited us to dinner at a restaurant) and insensitive, though maybe she just speaks without a filter rather than having bad intentions. On her very first call with me, she called me "chubby" and kept lecturing me not to drink Coke because it makes you fat. Because her own father passed away from a heart attack, she has strong anxieties around food—she mentioned keeping food locked in a storeroom and believes people shouldn't eat much.
•Property / Financial Red Flag: The guy's father had refused a disputed property due to legal complications, and the mother quietly transferred it into her own name behind his back—now she has ongoing court cases over it.
•Lifestyle, Career & Future Standard of Living: I'm a fashion designer, and during our interaction, they were openly making fun of people who wear designer clothes. On top of that, he is the sole earner supporting the entire household in a small house in a below-average society—realistically, with that financial setup, I wouldn't even be able to give my future kids the standard of education and upbringing that I had. I've also always wanted to marry into a warm, milansaar (social/welcoming) family, whereas their mother dislikes cooking or hosting guests and their overall lifestyle feels very isolated and restrictive.
The Dilemma:
Whenever I bring these points up, my parents dismiss them as unimportant and tell me I'm overthinking because of my age.
1.Looking at this neutrally, are these valid dealbreakers or things one should compromise on?
2.How do I practically convince my parents—especially my dad—that these aren't just superficial complaints, and that marrying into a family with opposite values, an unwilling groom, active court cases, and a major downgrade in future opportunities for my kids will make me miserable?


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 9h ago

Mental Health I let it out after so long

7 Upvotes

3 days into owning this bike. There hasn't been a single hour of free time awake I haven't been riding. I pick my own hours to work and in between calls in the dead of night even if it is for 30 minutes or 15, thats what ive been doing. The only thing thatd complete this all would be a decent pair of headsets in the helmet I have because my pods feel like stethoscopes in my ear.

Other than that it's been one of those things you know will never get old. I haven't felt this free in so long. I'm scared I'll fall in ways more than one because I'm super young and already seeing so much success, but this? This makes it all worth it. I let out a scream I've been holding back for so long as i rode and when I watched the sun set over the horizon holding on to my bike and listening to songs I haven't in so long. Going fast is something Ik i was made for. my best and worst memories in life involve me running, or riding something. It's a special thing for me because it's something that calms me but also channels everything. I'd say more but it's indescribable.

And after stepping into the mosque and praying maghrib I got back to it again.

The tears today were a mix. Of happiness, sorrow, and a longing, but also of an acceptance. I'm not THERE yet, I'm here, if that makes sense. But where I am today, I just wish I had somebody to share with. I hate that I feel like I can't. And I can't hate anyone anymore or less than I can love them but either way, I think im starting to accept that they're gone. Not that I didn't before, but this is a different level of acceptance, maybe.

That said, I hope whoever reads this, if you're going thru a tough time, it doesn't have to get better but there's going to be good moments in life later. If someone youre close to or special in general is going through something, please please please just sit with them. Listen to them. Dont make it about yoursel and be with them. Please stop letting fear hold you back from loving and cherishing who and what you have for as long as you have them.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 9h ago

General Doing survey for my university research.

4 Upvotes

Guys so i am a 5th semester university student of Pakistan Global Institute and i am doing research on topic of:

AI and Online Security

So, i am conducting a survey, please show some support and please fill out this survey form:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSetD2BbZnplSQXIBXFHHyamDTyBO9eIY4bF12IY8U-WTvhrBg/viewform

I would really appreciate it.

Thanks you for answering the survey in advance🙌


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 9h ago

Rant main character energy: funding my own degree through custom card art 💅✨

5 Upvotes

Managing uni while crafting custom cards to pay my own way has been such a journey! 🎀

Balancing classes, late-night assignments, and designing graduation or Nikkah cards gets crazy, but doing it all independently feels so rewarding.

Just wanted to share a recent batch I finished! Would love to know what you ladies think of the designs 🎓✨


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 10h ago

Question Am I an introvert Orr just a world hater?

4 Upvotes

M22 from LHR... just wanted to know that is it just me who's extremely an introvert kind of person not like that I don't have any kind of confidence in talking to other people but just having the thought of avoiding any kind of interaction with other people and like e.g. crowded places, but when really goes to a crowded place than feel kind of normal... don't lose my mind but just avoid them cuz I don't want my personal space to be disturbed, I believe that I have an extremely boring life with no fun at all which to my taste is very exciting for me, being a person and loving the smell of loneliness and the eradication of my seemingly incurable sadness ... Rarely posting on social media, going to weddings etc. but just staying home and watching movies and shows and never wanting to meet a new face do you think if this is ok for a normal person Orr is it just way more comfy..

Some of you might say that being this kind of person ruins social life which tbh I really don't care about at all

I actually don't hate people for who they are I just hate the world for their cruelty, their judgment passing like imagine you're just passing by and a person says why are you walking so slowly... Dude I don't even know you mind your own business.. like that sort of judgemental giving person and in our country some of you might acknowledge that I'm actually saying right if you have a village and you sometimes go there...... But the main thing is that I'm really close to Allah because I don't love the way people getting so attached to this Duniya even though they know they'll just live for another 50,60y I just think of myself as a Traveller/passenger(mussafir)..cuz I always find the idea of dying very comforting and great thinking that one-day all of this will end and nothing will remain except Him and I just think that's a good thing cuz I see that being alive for so long Orr having a long life for e.g. I see immortality as a curse and not a gift...

Soo do you guys think that I should be more social or remain the same What are your thoughts?


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 13h ago

Question People who have been in love, jawab dein plis

3 Upvotes

If you cannot stop thinking about someone, have randoms days where OUT OF NO WHERE you constantly feel an extreme attachment to them, does this signify that they are thinking about you too?

Ya ap kisi ko boht shiddat se yaad kar rahe ho, tou agley bande ko feel ho jata he???


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 21h ago

Question What is this phase called when you're straight but get the ick from men?

10 Upvotes

I don't even know how to explain this, but I feel like I am completely dead inside no feelings.

I'm straight but I get a massive ick from men specially whenever a guy says anything couple-like. I genuinely hate these conversations and don't feel like entertaining them.

For context, I had a pretty toxic childhood. I grew up watching my parents fight almost every day. Now my family has basically pushed me into an arranged engagement. Being the shy, obedient daughter who struggles to say no, I just went along with it.

But now that I'm actually engaged, I HATE talking to him.

I can't figure out whether it's because I was forced into this, because of my childhood experiences, because I don't like HIM specifically, or because I've somehow developed an aversion to romantic relationships altogether.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 15h ago

Discussion I'm a 24 year old pakistani living in a predominantly white, republican and Christian town, ask me anything about life here!

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I moved to a small city in north east Florida which in recent years has shifted even more conservative. I've been visiting this city for vacation ever since I was around 4 every year or so, I consider myself to be a progressive democrat and have voted blue in functionally every election that I've been eligible in.

Life here is interesting and it's broken alot of the fears I had regarding living in a place like this and id be happy to answer people's questions especially if they're considering or wondering moving to a county like this.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 18h ago

Meme/Shitpost Morning everyone

Post image
5 Upvotes

☕️


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 17h ago

General i think i'm slowly losing an online friend i got really attached to

2 Upvotes

so i just wanna share my experience with an online friendship that started around 3 months ago

i received a dm from a girl and that's how everything started. slowly we became friends and started talking almost every day, sometimes for hours

within the first 2-3 days things got a little overwhelming so i made a reddit post explaining the situation. most people called her a red flag but i ignored those comments because honestly how can u judge someone after knowing them for just 2-3 days

as time passed we got used to each other. she used to share almost everything with me, her daily updates, personal struggles, overthinking and even some really dark secrets. obviously i can't share those here because privacy matters

she was openly lesbian and used to call herself a lesbian yearner and a man-hater lol. she also had a school crush whom she missed a lot and used to talk about her quite often. i literally knew so many little details about her life

there was also a time when she started saying things like "i wanna die" or "just kill me" quite often. i used to listen to all of it and try to be there for her

she also used to send me romantic reels about hugs, kisses and affection, mostly featuring lesbian couples. initially she was the one sending them and sometimes i'd send similar reels back just to make her feel good. it was mostly casual sharing and joking around and i always tried to maintain my boundaries

one thing i found out much later was that she had actually frozen her semester. initially she didn't tell me and made it sound like she'd return to university after the holidays. i only found out about the semester freeze much later

now coming to the recent situation

another guy recently started messaging her and she told me about their conversations. apparently he wanted to meet her and was also trying to get her into sexting. she kept saying how guys are all the same and how disgusting he was. i simply told her that if he was making her uncomfortable she should stop talking to him

then i asked her if she'd actually meet him and she reacted with a melting face emoji and said maybe if she felt like it 😭

and the funny part was she later said something like "i'm dirty too" which honestly left me confused

after that i started noticing some changes. the girl who used to be online for almost 20 hours and could talk for hours is now suddenly busy. her replies became less frequent and sometimes it feels like whenever i come online she goes offline

she also started teaching some little kids just about a week ago to keep herself occupied. and idk why but sometimes i wonder what kind of things she'll teach those poor kids 😭

recently she told me we'd talk properly after my exams. the funny thing is i only had 2 papers left and even during exams i was still making time to reply to her. but it felt like she barely remembered i had exams going on

she also recently told me she's planning to meet that guy and apparently she'll confront him. i honestly don't understand why she'd meet someone when she already knows the kind of conversations they've been having but it's her decision

now i feel like this friendship is slowly coming to an end. she hasn't directly said she's leaving but actions kinda tell u everything. she also keeps posting stories about cutting people off and removing people from her life so idk if i'm next lol

i know 3 months of daily conversations are really difficult to fit into one post and i've left out a lot of things. there's obviously a lot more i could tell but i've shared as much as i can here without exposing her privacy

this was actually my second online friendship and it feels like i've learned the same lesson twice this year. i'm not saying she's a bad person or judging her but honestly i miss how things used to be

maybe i'm just overthinking everything or maybe the friendship has actually run its course. let's see


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 1d ago

Question Duas.

8 Upvotes

Few days ago my friend told her arafat dua was accepted and I was surprised.
Not bcz my duas arent accepted
But maybe they r taking too long
I made lots of duas of Arafat day, and i thought it became true next day but i was wrong.
And then i orayed tahhajud for few days.
I keep losing hope everyday.
For some days i would have no hope and motivation to Ask Allah for anything cuz it seems pointless.
But i still keep making dua.
How do i not lose hope?


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 1d ago

Rant Can't deal with these desi toilet.

5 Upvotes

I have started running and my legssss are cramppedss, theeseee legsss hurtingggggg soooo muchhh in this position cannttt even shit comfortablyyy.

Man I am missing sitting toilets I wanttt thoseeeee 😭😭😭😭


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 1d ago

General Is it serious??

7 Upvotes

So i have been having this weird pain in left side of my chest, appears randomly for 1-2 secs and then gone, felt like elctrocuted. is it serious like heart disease??? i am gona see doctor tomorrow but i am kinda scared what if its related to heart, do any of you guyz have experienced the same???


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 1d ago

Rant Unpopular opinion: As a Punjabi Muslim descended from refugees from Ferozepur, I have no interest in romanticising an undivided Punjab.

33 Upvotes

My grandparents were from Ferozepur, East Punjab. In 1947 my family was uprooted, family members were killed, and our ancestral life in that part of Punjab was destroyed.

I find today’s romanticising of “Punjabi brotherhood” frustrating, mostly because it so often skips over what happened to East Punjab’s Muslims. A few uncomfortable facts:

1. The expulsion of East Punjab’s Muslims was not just neighbours turning on neighbours.

Ian Copland’s study The Master and the Maharajas: The Sikh Princes and the East Punjab Massacres of 1947 (Modern Asian Studies, 2002) documents how the Sikh princely states, especially their rulers and armed forces, were involved in killing and expelling Muslims.

Contemporary British sources say the same. J.S.H. Shattock’s 1948 report for the British High Commission describes massacres followed by the removal of East Punjab’s Muslim population. Another British assessment from the time said Sikhs played a prominent part in the slaughter of Muslims, perhaps even more in the Sikh states than in East Punjab itself. Penderel Moon was a British administrator who saw it first-hand. In Divide and Quit he judged that the violence against Muslims in East Punjab matched and probably exceeded what happened in the West, both in scale and in brutality.

A wholesale demographic purge carried out with the help of state armed forces is a different thing from a breakdown of law and order.

2. The violence in East Punjab was led, organised and sanctioned by the state.

What happened to East Punjab’s Muslims was not a collapse of law and order. It was carried out with the involvement of the people who held power.

Ian Copland’s study shows that the Sikh princely states, notably Patiala, Faridkot and Kapurthala, did more than fail to stop the killing. Their rulers, courts and state forces took part in it, in coordination with the Akali leadership under Master Tara Singh (the “Master” of Copland’s title). Contemporary British officials reached the same conclusion: the slaughter of Muslims was worst in the Sikh states, where it had the backing of the state itself. In British East Punjab, Muslim police and officials were disarmed or sidelined, and the forces that remained often stood aside or joined in. Refugee columns heading west were attacked repeatedly on routes those authorities were supposed to protect.

The result was not mixed communities with scattered losses. Close to the entire Muslim population of East Punjab and the neighbouring princely states was killed or driven out within a few months.

I’m not claiming West Punjab was innocent. Terrible crimes were committed there too. But mobs, even organised ones, are not the same as princely armies and a state machinery turned against an entire population. Lumping the two together under “violence on both sides” erases that difference.

3. The Radcliffe Award was not a neutral exercise.

An earlier sketch of the boundary, sent on 8 August 1947, appears to have placed the Ferozepur and Zira tehsils in Pakistan. In the final award they went to India, along with the Ferozepur headworks, which had enormous consequences for Pakistan’s water security. Christopher Beaumont, Radcliffe’s private secretary, later alleged that Mountbatten pressed for the change after Indian representations.

Gurdaspur’s allocation gave India the Pathankot route, which became crucial to its access to Kashmir.

You don’t have to believe in a grand conspiracy to see that these decisions were political, and that Pakistan bore the cost.

4. Sikh–Muslim history is more complicated than the brotherhood narrative allows.

There were long periods of coexistence and cooperation, and I don’t deny them. But Sikh historical memory was shaped by centuries of conflict: the Mughal–Sikh wars, the executions of Sikh Gurus under Mughal rule, and the militarisation of the Khalsa. Muslim memory was shaped by 1947. To pretend that Punjabi Muslims and Sikhs have always shared an uncomplicated brotherhood is not reconciliation. It’s naivety.

There is also an irony in how Indian political discourse treats armed resistance. Sikh armed struggle, from the Khalsa’s wars against the Mughals onward, holds an honoured and often celebrated place in Indian historical memory. Kashmiri armed resistance, meanwhile, is routinely dismissed wholesale as terrorism. If armed movements are to be judged, they should be judged consistently: by their conduct, and above all by how they treat civilians, not by whether their goals suit the Indian state.

5. I am Pakistani and Muslim before I am Punjabi.

I don’t owe anyone a borderless Punjabi identity, and I don’t have to put my national identity below cross-border cultural nostalgia.

My grandparents did not choose to leave Ferozepur. They fled the destruction of their world, and then they rebuilt their lives in Pakistan. I’m proud of what they built. I see no reason to spend my life mourning an undivided Punjab as if it were a lost paradise.

I also don’t have to adopt every grievance of Sikh nationalism against the Indian state. The persecution Sikhs suffered after 1947 deserves recognition, but it doesn’t make our histories interchangeable.

My position is simple:

I refuse to sanitise the expulsion of East Punjab’s Muslims to protect an idealised story of Punjabi brotherhood.

I refuse to accept that atrocities on both sides mean equal responsibility, organisation or circumstances.

And I refuse to apologise for Pakistan.

Pakistan Zindabad.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 1d ago

Advice My “pious" neighbor just tried to get me to print a dark magic/bandish spell. I’m completely creeped out and don't know what to do.

10 Upvotes

I (22M) need some advice because I just had a really unsettling interaction with my neighbor and I can't stop thinking about it.

For context, we’ve lived next to this family for 15+ years. I've known them since childhood. The guy in question is in his 40s and unmarried. He lives with a lot of his brothers and sisters (ranging from mid-30s to 60s) in the same house. The whole family gives off very weird vibes, except for the eldest brother who is married with two kids (an 18M and a 15F with Down syndrome) he’s actually normal and decent.

All of them, including the 40-something guy, are known for being very religious. They pray 5 times a day, and I’ve seen them at the local masjid regularly since I was a kid. We don't interact much, just the occasional greeting, asking for small favors, or exchanging dishes of food between our houses.

Fast forward to today: this neighbor asked me if I had a printer because he wanted to print something. I told him we didn’t have one, but he kept insisting, saying it was just one page and it was a "wazifa" (a religious recitation/prayer) he wanted to read. Seeing how eager he was, and since I was heading out anyway, I told him to WhatsApp it to me and I’d get it printed at a local shop.

He sent the image, and I opened it. It was a hand-drawn image of a star pentagram with weird, creepy writings all over it. The only word I could clearly read was "bandish" (which basically means a dark spell/blockage) written at the top.

I was in absolute shock. I couldn't believe a regular namazi person like him was messing around with stuff like this. I took a second to process, trusted my gut, and made up an excuse on the spot. I gave him some topi that the shop wouldn't be able to print this specific format. He then pulled out a paper showing he had already printed it large, but wanted it smaller. I just told him it wasn't possible and quickly left.

Here is the creepiest part: as soon as I walked away, he "deleted for everyone" the image from our WhatsApp chat so there’s no trace of it. Two minutes later, he just messaged me: "thanks bro". He clearly knows what he’s doing is shady and didn't want it sitting on my phone.

I’ve told my mom and asked her to keep it a secret so we don't start neighborhood drama, but I am still super creeped out.

What should I do? How do I act around him now? And what precautions should my family take? Any advice is appreciated.

TL;DR: My 40s neighbor, who goes to the masjid 5 times a day, sent me a WhatsApp image to print for him claiming it was a religious prayer. It was actually a hand-drawn pentagram with "bandish" (dark magic/spell) written on it. I made an excuse and left, and he immediately deleted the message for everyone. Feeling creeped out and looking for advice on precautions.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 1d ago

Rant Did not know my success will become my enemy

6 Upvotes

I just want to preface this by saying Alhamdulillah for everything in life. God has blessed me with so many things that others can only wish for, and I will never take that for granted.

I am grateful for the life I have built as a woman, but sometimes I feel like my success in my professional life has become my biggest enemy in my personal life.

The friends I made (or tried to make) somehow always ended up turning against me or stabbing me in the back because of envy and self-created competition. I wished nothing but the best for these people. I genuinely wanted to grow with them, celebrate their wins, and see us all succeed together. Unfortunately, that was never the case.

Success also came with greater responsibilities. The familial expectations are through the roof. Of course, my family has supported me and helped shape me into the person I am today, and I will forever be grateful for that. But sometimes I wonder how much longer I can keep carrying their dreams alongside my own.

And lastly, I feel like I may never experience sincere love in my life. The person I loved, and who loved me too, eventually backed away because he felt he couldn't match my financial standing or convince my family.

Sometimes I wonder, am I supposed to have all this happiness, all these achievements, and all these blessings, yet have no one to genuinely share them with?
What is the point of having so much to be grateful for when the things you crave most in life like genuine friendships, unconditional love, and companionship. All of these feel so out of reach?

What a miserable place to be in: having a life that looks so full from the outside, yet feeling so lonely on the inside.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 21h ago

Advice I’m feeling frustrated and jealous for the first time in my life, and I honestly don’t know how to deal with it.

1 Upvotes

I’ve never really been someone who gets jealous of others or feels envy towards anyone. I’ve always believed in focusing on my own journey. But something happened recently that has made me feel differently, and I genuinely don’t know how to process it.
Around six months ago, I came across an opportunity related to e-commerce in the US. My cousins live there, and all I needed was some basic information and a few things from their side to get started. It wasn’t even about money or investment. If they had helped me arrange those things, I could have expanded my business internationally and potentially started earning pretty well.
I discussed this with my brother and asked him to speak with our cousins and help arrange what I needed. Now, I have another cousin who was also involved in this situation. When he found out that my brother was exploring this opportunity for me, he independently approached the same cousins I had asked my brother to contact. They turned him down.
I already had a feeling that they would turn me down as well, so I started looking elsewhere. I contacted friends, friends of friends, and pretty much anyone who might be able to help. I spent the next three or four months trying to find someone who could arrange the same requirements, but nothing worked out.
Here’s where things get interesting.
The cousin who had initially been turned down knew absolutely nothing about e-commerce. He had no experience with these marketplaces, whereas I had quite a bit of experience working across different platforms.
Somehow, he eventually found someone willing to invest and provide everything needed, including the accounts, business details, and other resources. He knew exactly where this opportunity had come from because I was the one who originally introduced it to him indirectly.
Without telling me anything, he approached those same cousins, connected with them, and presented himself as someone who could bring clients. His proposed arrangement was that he would bring the clients, the cousins would handle the operations, and the profits would be split 50% for the client, 30% for them, and 20% for him.
They agreed among themselves, and the business started moving forward.
Fast-forward to November: they made around $6,000 in profit.
And honestly, seeing that has affected me more than I expected.
I’m not jealous simply because someone else is making money. I’m frustrated because this was something I discovered, something I had experience in, and something I spent months trying to make happen. I was the one who understood the business, and all I needed was a little help getting started.
Had I managed to get those same resources after all those months of struggling, I probably wouldn’t have felt this way. But watching someone else step into an opportunity I originally discovered, especially someone who didn’t even know the basics of the business, is genuinely difficult.
I know I shouldn’t compare my journey with someone else’s, but I can’t seem to get this feeling out of my head.
I genuinely want to know how you would deal with something like this. Am I wrong for feeling this way? How do you move on when you feel like you missed an opportunity that could have changed your financial situation, especially when someone close to you ended up benefiting from it?


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 1d ago

Rant I feel so sad not buying gta 6 despite earning.

18 Upvotes

23 M, i am an avid gamer and used to be crazy about getting gta 5 when i was a child. But we werent that well off to get a console or a pc so i killed that want.
Now gta 6 is releasing and I am earning good. But in order to play gta 6 right now the total expense would be around 300-400k. this is still a LOTT so I am not getting it. But every time i see the posts of people pre ordering it i feel so sad and think what even is the point of me earning if i dont get to make the kid in me happy. its weird.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 1d ago

Discussion Its unfortunate but true. Very rare partners consider each other as equal, is it true or just my observation?

9 Upvotes

I've noticed that in most relationships, one partner always seems to want to be in charge. Why not just be equals? It used to be mostly men, but now it feels like women are just as often the dominant ones. Doesn't that mess up the relationship dynamics? I really don't get why couples don't just treat each other as equals.


r/PakistaniiConfessions • • 1d ago

Rant At home Nursing staff is nothing but apathetic jahil log

20 Upvotes

Hey everyone. Just want to vent / get advice from other people on here who have someone sick in their home. I (27 m) live in islamabad have been taking care of my paralyzed mom for about a year and a half now. I’m pretty much a full time caretaker almost (24/7) but even I can’t do everything by myself and so I’ve hired helping staff (2 for the day and 2 for night).

In the last year and a half, our house has been a revolving door because we’ve let go of so many “nurses” who frankly are apathetic uneducated uncaring individuals who are only there to act like robots and not actually offload the burdens of the patient or the family.

For example, my mother has a PEG tube and multiple times I have told, yelled, softly tried to tell staff that the water we give her through PEG has to be done slowly or she gets nauseous. When I’m standing there, they take their time. The moment I leave, I turn on my camera and see they give it all within 20-30 seconds.

At night, I need to sleep and if my mother wants her diaper changed, they’ll make remarks like “oh why can’t you let us rest, why do you need to ‘flood’ after every hour”.

If I’m standing there, they turn her on the bed gently. The moment I leave, I hear my mom groan from pain because they turn her on the bed very harshly.

I myself have to examine her back because if she has any pimples or sores, these kamini nurses won’t even bother noticing or telling me.

There was a time my mother needed an emergency cannula and it was when the shift was changing so all 4 “nurses” were there yet not one of them could actually insert the cannula properly. I had to go run and get a nearby doctor to come and do it for us.

These are just few of the examples.

Now I have told all these nurses in front of my mom that the first thing they need to do is show respect to her because she is a human being and in front of me they will always say yes sir but behind my back, these absolute monsters cannot be trusted at all. I have given them respect and frankly always speak to them kindly (unless when they royally fuck up), make them chai, give them food etc but these losers just do not care. Wo aur sarh pay char jati hain.

Now I give her all her meds, help her with her physio, clean her PEG dressing and everything else in between but as a male, I’m forced to have these nurses to change my moms diapers, shower her etc.

I’ve changed over 20 nurses and tried 3 different companies but they’re all the fucking same and frankly each one just makes me so mad, I can’t even begin to describe it.

So is this just what the culture here is? I used to be abroad before I quit my job and became my moms full time caretaker and bahir taking care of a bedridden patient is done so carefully. But here it’s almost like these people think they’re doing a favor for us. I’m paying almost 3.5 lakh per month for 4 nurses and yet everyday is just total frustration unless I look over EVERYTHING myself.

So what do I do? Just accept my fate and take it as it is or have people on this subreddit actually had any good experiences with at home nurses? I would never threaten violence but frankly am at my wits end and I genuinely the next time they mess up and come up with some BS fucked up excuse, I just want to slap them across the face. I’m so fucking over this.