TL;DR: I had an arranged marriage and made it clear before our engagement that I didn’t expect traditional gender roles. I wanted an independent partner who would also take responsibility, learn new skills, and adapt to life in Germany. She agreed, but despite 2.5 years of support, language courses, driving lessons, and having almost no responsibilities at home, she has made very little progress. Now in Germany, she struggles with basic communication and independent living, and we lack emotional intimacy and meaningful conversations. I’m afraid I’ll end up carrying almost every responsibility if we have children. She acknowledges wasting those years and promises to change, but I’ve heard similar promises before. Should I keep waiting, reconsider our future, or involve her parents?
Disclaimer: this is a long post but I really appreciate of you can read and give and advise to your brother.
Hi everyone,
I got married at the beginning of 2025. I was 30, and my wife was 24. It was an arranged marriage, and we only started communicating after our engagement.
I’m a software engineer living in Germany. After our engagement, I explained that I don’t believe in traditional gender roles, nor do I think they’re practical for the life I want here.
I told her she would have complete freedom to study, work, pursue her interests, or choose her own path. In return, I expected her to develop the skills necessary to live independently in Germany, particularly learning English and German, understanding the culture, and managing everyday responsibilities.
My understanding of marriage is that two people should complement each other. If one partner is the sole financial provider, the other should be capable of handling other family responsibilities, such as paperwork, appointments, and communicating with schools or doctors when we have children.
I didn’t want a traditional housewife. I wanted a partner who could think independently, take initiative, and share responsibilities.
Before our engagement, I explicitly asked whether she was willing to learn and grow. I even told her that if she wasn’t interested in this kind of life, she could say no, and I would take responsibility for calling off the engagement to protect her from any blame.
She agreed, and I trusted her words.
What happened during her time in Pakistan
Because of the family reunification visa process, she remained in Pakistan for a long time. During this period, I tried to give her every opportunity to prepare for life in Germany.
After our marriage, I opened a bank account for her and gave her personal spending money, which she could use without asking anyone or explaining her expenses. I have never questioned how she spends it.
I also encouraged her to learn driving and spent approximately PKR 150,000 on lessons, her licence, and repairing the car after an accident. Despite this, she still cannot drive confidently.
I arranged an online English tutor, but after six months, she couldn’t speak or understand basic English. She also attended a German course without making meaningful progress. Eventually, I suggested watching English-language movies and series for exposure, but she didn’t do that either.
Mind you, she had practically no household responsibilities. We have a small family in Pakistan, my mother managed the household, and we had maids for cooking and cleaning. She didn’t have to work, look after children, or manage anything at home.
Throughout this time, I encouraged her to study, work, or pursue whatever interested her, assuring her of my support.
The problem is that she never says no. She agrees to everything but rarely follows through.
She wanted an independent life in Europe but didn’t seem willing to put in the effort required to prepare for it.
Now she’s in Germany
She still cannot speak or understand basic English, let alone German, despite being a university graduate. She struggles with complex conversations, isn’t willing to go outside alone, and spends most of her time at home watching TikTok, Instagram Reels, or talking to people back in Pakistan.
She also doesn’t know how to cook much beyond basic things like roti or eggs.
Before someone misunderstands me, I’m not complaining because I expect her to cook for me. I prepare my own meals because I follow a healthy diet, while she either doesn’t cook or prepares Pakistani food that I generally don’t eat.
My concern is her inability to manage basic aspects of independent living. I find myself having to teach her almost everything, including certain things related to personal hygiene.
She acknowledges that she wasted those two years and now says she has created a “schedule” to finally learn the language. But after so many unfulfilled promises, I’m finding it difficult to trust her words.
I realise now that I made the mistake of assuming that because she was an adult, she understood that marriage required effort and that agreeing to something meant she would actually work toward it.
We lack emotional intimacy and connection
Despite being married, we still behave like strangers. We can barely hold a meaningful conversation for more than ten minutes, and we don’t have much of a love life.
One reason I encouraged her to watch English-language movies and series wasn’t just to improve her English. I also hoped they would expose her to human emotions, relationships, and different ways people communicate and respond to situations.
I believe love develops gradually through understanding, shared experiences, and emotional connection. It isn’t just cheesy dialogue from an Umera Ahmed novel.
But how do you build that connection when you can barely communicate meaningfully with your partner?
I wanted someone I could talk to, share experiences with, and grow alongside. Instead, I feel lonely within my own marriage.
My biggest fear is having children
If we start a family in our current situation, I’m genuinely afraid I’ll end up being responsible for everything, from earning money and managing important decisions to handling paperwork, appointments, and the children’s needs.
Imagine our child has a school meeting or doctor’s appointment. If my wife cannot communicate or handle these situations independently, I’ll have to leave work to attend them and then work additional hours to compensate.
That means less time with my children.
What frightens me is the possibility that my children might grow up thinking their father was never there, without knowing that I was working extra hours because I was handling responsibilities that should have been shared.
I want to be a present and involved father, but how can I do that if I’m expected to carry almost every responsibility myself?
More importantly, what kind of family environment would we be creating?
The contradiction I struggle with
My wife acknowledges that she has more freedom than most women she knows personally. She even compares me with her cousins’ husbands, whom she describes as typical controlling Pakistani men, and appreciates that I support her choices.
Yet she’s now in Europe, surrounded by opportunities, and chooses to spend most of her time inside one room on social media or talking to people back home.
I don’t want to control her. I value my own freedom too much to deny someone else theirs.
But I sometimes feel that people want the benefits of freedom without accepting the responsibilities that come with it.
I don’t want to supervise another adult, constantly reminding them what to learn or how to improve. I want a partner who takes initiative and understands that we’re building a life together.
I’m beginning to wonder whether I’ve confused being supportive with taking responsibility for someone else’s personal growth.
Where I stand now
I understand that marriage requires compromises and that no two people are perfectly compatible.
But while I have the right to make compromises in my own life, I don’t believe I have the right to bring a child into this world and make those compromises on their behalf before they’re even born.
Right now, I can’t see how our situation would allow us to raise children in the environment I want to provide.
Outside of this issue, I genuinely appreciate my life. I have a good career, I travel, I take care of my health, and I’m finally living the life I once dreamed about in Pakistan.
But this situation is eating me alive.
I’m frustrated, disappointed, and scared of what the future might look like. I don’t know whether I’m expecting too much, whether I’ve approached things incorrectly, or whether we simply have fundamentally different attitudes toward life and responsibility.
Should I involve her parents?
One thing I haven’t done in these 2.5 years is involve her parents.
I deliberately avoided it because I believe my wife is my partner, not someone whose behaviour or decisions I should have to discuss with her parents.
We’re both adults, and I believe marital problems should ideally be resolved between the two people involved. I never wanted to complain to her parents, ask them to intervene, or use them to pressure her.
However, after 2.5 years of conversations, support, and promises without meaningful progress, I genuinely don’t know what else to do.
Part of me believes we should still be able to resolve this ourselves, while another part wonders whether continuing to keep everything private is realistic.
What do you think?
Am I expecting too much, or are these reasonable expectations of an adult partner in marriage?
How do you distinguish between being patient with someone who needs time to grow and accepting a situation where you might carry the responsibilities of two people indefinitely?
After 2.5 years, should I involve her parents, or would that be a mistake considering we’re both adults?
How long should I reasonably wait for meaningful change before accepting that we might have different priorities and expectations from life?
What would you do in my situation, especially when having children could permanently affect not just us but our future children?
I’m genuinely looking for different perspectives because I don’t want my frustration to cloud my judgment or lead me to make an unfair decision.
If you have read post this far, thank you so so so much.