Wednesday 18 November 20:30: Retirees march from Montparnasse to Invalides at 11 am tomorrow, minimal disruptions anticipated, RATP has not yet announced station closures so confirm in the morning before heading out.
Hello all,
We continue to receive frequent posts and questions regarding the ''current situation'' in Paris, many of which reflect a false and frankly bizarre idea that Paris is in some sort of general state of chaos. At the same time, the actual level of protest activity has fallen to well below the threshold for which we would normally bother to have a megathread or dedicated post.
For that reason and because I'm frankly pretty burned out, I am going to try to move away from super-specific updates and responses of limited general applicability, although I'll try to keep the ''what's next'' section below updated in broad strokes.
I appreciate everyone's reports and updates in the comments.Â
What is the current situation in Paris?
We are not: in any kind of ongoing protest or strike state, having an active civil war, or dodging burning refuse in the streets every morning on our way to work. Nearly all of the scary videos that you have seen were taken on Saturday, 17 October, in a relatively limited area of the city, and do not reflect current or reasonably expected future conditions in Paris or France as a whole. Many visitors have come to the comments section of these threads to report entirely normal visits over the last several weeks, or that they experienced only some transit disruptions or saw some boarded up windows.
We are: in a period of substantial civic debate on a variety of issues. You have, unfortunately, heard far, far more about the actions of a relatively small number of opportunistic bad actors than about the hundreds of thousands of people, students and otherwise, who have marched peacefully all over France in keeping with very well-established French democratic processes. The government is making a whole slew of announcements today on many different topics related to the subjects of these protests - lots is happening! But almost none of it meaningfully involves tourists.
The frequency of protest activity and the size of marches etc, as well as the scope of general disruptions, has generally decreased over the last few weeks (recognizing that 5 November was a general strike day, which nevertheless seems to have had more anticipated than actual effects). It seems reasonable to me to anticipate that this slow-down will continue as we approach the holidays. This is reflected in the way that plans for all of the Christmas markets, lights, store windows, etc, are moving forward as normal - see all the details in our pinned holiday megathread here.
Since several comments have mentioned it, yes, in some areas, primarily on the right bank (north of the river), you may still see boarded-up windows as damage is repaired from the actions of 17 October. I think that you will be seeing less and less of this as repairs continue - that is certainly true in my neighborhood and in the Marais, which had significant damage on 17 October. It is a busy time to be a glass repair person in Paris but they are doing their best! I do not think that the mere presence of boarded-up windows, without any other information, is itself an especially reliable indicator about much at this time. And while some shops have and may continue to board up windows on large protest days, I think the fact that the luxury shops are going forward with holiday displays - starting with the opening of the windows at Printemps on Tuesday the 10th- is a signal that they also think the actual danger is past.Â
Will there be protests during my visit?
There are gonna be protests and strikes in Paris. There are small protests somewhere in Paris on many many days, about one issue or another, and the overwhelming majority of them don't make the news or anyone's radar. If I could tell you with any specificity where there will be a protest large enough to meaningfully affect tourist activities on any particular day/week/month etc, I would hope that the government would be paying me quite a bit more money than the nothing I am making here on Reddit.
But yep, there's always something! As far as bigger protests, here is one site I use for strike information, and here is one site that gathers information about protests day-by-day, although that one includes many small or localized protests that are really not relevant to tourists at all.
But what specifically is next?
Wednesday 18 November 20:30: Retirees march from Montparnasse to Invalides at 11 am tomorrow, minimal disruptions anticipated, RATP has not yet announced station closures so confirm in the morning before heading out.
The general process is that organizers submit a march route, and then the police prefecture approves, negotiates or orders edits to, or denies that application, after which the organizers can appeal, and so on. These orders from the police prefecture have been coming later and later. So, while you may see advance information about possible protest routes, don't assume that anything has been settled more than a day or two in advance.Â
If you are visiting beyond next week, neither I nor anyone else can tell you specifically what protests there MAY be during your stay. But if you want to wait to visit Paris until there are NO protests, that will be approximately ... never, as long as the French continue to be the French.
How can I mitigate the effects of those protests on my stay?
In the normal course of things, 95% of this kind of routine protest activity in Paris has absolutely no effect on any visitor to Paris. Most protest activity is not anywhere near significant tourist locations, and tourists are neither the target nor the particular interest of the protestors. As with any travel anywhere, it is important to stay informed and stay flexible. On any major protest day, Le Parisien will likely have a liveblog on their website - look for the moving red bar above a header that says ''direct''. Actu.fr also does good real-time updates. You can use the auto-translation feature on your browser for both.
What else can you do?
Stay informed about site closures: Most tourist activities are operating entirely normally nearly all of the time, but closures at any given location are possible at any time for any number of reasons. The Louvre was closed on one Saturday for preventative security reasons and on one Monday due to student protest activity, but it's also relatively frequently closed on Monday mornings due to its own staff issues. The Orangerie has been closed on a few occasions because it is inside the Tuileries Garden, which sometimes gets closed for security reasons or heavy winds. The Eiffel Tower was closed for a few partial days during protests, but it also sometimes closes for its own strikes, or weather, or whatever. Check individual site websites before heading out, try to have a ''Plan B'' as much as possible, and don't leave any truly mission-critical activities for the last day of your stay.
Expect metro disruptions: The biggest disruption reported in the comments of these posts is that on days of major expected protest activity, there are metro station closures both in the immediate vicinity of those protests and sometimes in other areas of town for security/preventative reasons.  Sometimes larger pieces of certain metro lines are closed to traffic, particularly Line 1 in the section that runs under the Champs ĂlysĂ©es. On protest days and just in general, you should use one of the following apps for real-time transit information: CityMapper, IDF MobilitĂ©s, Bonjour RATP, Google/Apple Maps - listed there in order of my preference, though I can and definitely do cross-reference them if I really need to know what's going on.
Notwithstanding these station closures, I still recommend the metro over a cab or bus on major protest days, because it is always better to be underneath a protest than stuck in deadlocked traffic trying to get through it or trying to get through it on foot. If metro is at all an option for you, even if you may have to change lines, please take the metro!Â
Consider a day trip: If you're particularly concerned about your ability to navigate transit or site disruptions, and you know your trip spans a near-future Saturday or other announced protest day, consider planning a day trip out of town for that particular day. Vaux le Vicomte with its Christmas decorations and outdoor fair is wonderful at this time of year, as is Chantilly with its horse shows. Parc Astérix and Disney are open for the holidays; Chartres and Reims are always worth a day ... etc etc.
Be mindful of police activity around protests and significant locations: If you are in Paris on a protest day, the protests themselves do not present any security concerns. Of course if you do decide to go see a protest, pay attention to standard anti-pickpocket awareness, as for all large crowds!
Some commentators on these posts have experienced incidental exposure to police tear gas, which unfortunately is a significant problem, particularly at the end points of large marches when the police decide it is time to disperse the crowd. But in a few recent incidents this has also happened at the beginning or during peaceful marches, and on a breezy day, it can carry quite some distance. If this is a particular concern to you (for respiratory health reasons, for example), stay clear of announced march routes and stay clear of large groups of police, like those that you may see around major monuments and government buildings. Large quantities of tear gas can be released quickly and not always predictably.
But ultimately: I went out last Thursday and I didn't see any of that - I saw the Orchestra du Nouveau Monde (search ''J'ai deux passions'' on Insta etc if you want a truly deadly earworm), and some angry grannies, and thousands of students, and some really good signs with French vocabulary lessons and math problems, and just generally, lots and lots of people who really care about the future of their country. We know it's not always the easiest or most convenient for tourists, but it is safe, and we do welcome you.Â
I received feedback that perhaps I should have disclosed attendance at the protests sooner? To be clear, this was the first one I had attended since I've been writing these, so consider this to be that disclosure. But I've been proud of the students and supportive of their demands all along, and am always impressed by the readiness of the French people to take action when they deem it appropriate. If that hasn't been clear, shame on me! I have tried be factual and neutral about what is happening, although if you've reading along you've surely seen my references to redacted editorialization about the police violences. Of course we all take in and reflect information via our own particular lenses, and you can and should draw your own conclusions.Â