r/Pathfinder2e
•
u/Killchrono
•
3h ago
Homebrew Simple House Rule Adjustments; An Introduction - The Real Virtue of Pathfinder 2nd Edition Isn't Balance, It's Accuracy (plus some thoughts about homebrew/house rules culture in the community)
Hi chums. If you aren't familiar with my user tag, I used to post a lot of essay-length analyses here a couple of years ago, probably my most well-known being my Tempering Expectations posts that came out around the time of the OGL incident back in 2023 to help with the flood of onboarders around that time. While I've still been around and active, I haven't been doing essay posts, largely because I've been much busier IRL between full time work and an almost 3-year old child, but also I've spent a lot of my limited time with TTRPGs focusing on 3rd party content for the system rather than player and GM-end analysis (for those of you who follow Southern Realm Games' work and are keen to see what we're up to...don't worry, the pipeline is absolutely clogged with content, RL has just been hectic lately so we haven't had as much time do the nitty-gritty of our publishing work to get things distributed).
However, one of those things I've been doing a lot lately has been testing in service to or to figure out the cause of common pain points in relation to the system, largely because many of them never made sense to me. Don't get me wrong, I have my own complaints about the system despite how much I enjoy it, and designing for it has really brought out where my frustrations and differences of opinion with Paizo stand and where I legitimately think it's genius, but my experiences with the system never really brought out a lot of those complaints to the fore in the same way I was seeing with other people.
So to me, understanding where a lot of those complaints about the game came from has been important. I think with the potential the system has, it’s important it doesn’t get tarnished and have the baby thrown out with the bath water because of issues that may be either overblown or misanalysed, let alone legitimate issues people like myself may simply not be seeing as clearly because of our own preferences and biases.
However, in order to do that, we need to figure out where those breakpoints are, and in a system as tightly-tuned as PF2e, it has to be done with a fine-tooth comb, not a sledgehammer. One of the virtues of the system is since the maths is so tight, it's very easy to make small adjustments that have a huge impact. In fact, in my analyses regarding these issues, something has become fairly apparent:
This game is extremely easy to house rule what you want.
Like…stupidly easy.
I would almost say distressingly easy, in that so much of the rhetoric about not only common issues in the game such as spellcasting, boss battles, item progression, number banding in general, etc. but how you have no wiggle room to adjust it the way you want would make me worry about how good some people's analysis about the game is for the amount of time they put into it.
I say ‘would’ if it wasn’t for the fact that I don’t think the issue is actually about the system being incapable of delivering a broad range of experiences.
I don’t think that’s what’s really the underlying impetus here though. I think what it really is being demanded is consensus, validation, and - ultimately - approval.
There's this common rhetoric about the PF2e online community that it's extremely adverse to house rules, and it's as a result of these sycophantic rules purists who think the game is perfect and can't admit Paizo doing anything wrong. I won't deny such people don't exact at all. However, I find not only is their prevalence overblown and conflating this bad faith sycophancy with people who just...genuinely really like what the game is and people simply disagree profusely with, there is another type of commenter that's just as - if not is even more - prevalent: people who enforce an Oberoni Fallacy into conversation whenever house rule adjustments or fixes are suggested. In my experience, this usually comes in two flavours:
- Rhetorical pedantry simply trying to prove how poorly designed the base game is rather than actually trying to come up with solutions to problems, and/or attacking people they think are making poor 'just use rule 0' excuses to avoid admitting design failure
- The 'I have to play RAW because my GM won't let us play with house rules' player
Basically, for all the complaints about the community being adverse to house rules and homebrew, any attempt at addressing common complaints is shut down not by RAW purists trying to enforce the baseline because it's perfect, but by disenfranchised players who enforce this sort of Oberoni Fallacy because they either simply want to argue about how poorly designed the base system is, or more tangibly they’re stuck in groups with rigid GMs that don't allow any house rule changes...often while simultaneously complaining that it's the community is adverse to house rules.
There's a lot to unpack from this. In fact, this particular hypocrisy, double-standard, entitlement, and self-sabotage frustrates me so much, I've made multiple attempts at a long-form post addressing it and have failed each time because it inevitably becomes a sprawling conspiracy board of interconnected topics that escalate well past the problems with PF2e specifically and into wider issues with gaming - both digital and tabletop - as a whole. There are deep-seeded issues in RPG culture that betray a deep and insidious discord between the player and GM side of the table, and a game like PF2e uniquely exposes that not because it's intentionally provocative, but accidentally so by triggering the most toxic behaviours of the gaming sphere in how its base design is more implicitly opinionated and even judgmental to those types of players.
Trying to address that rabbit hole has proven an exercise in futility and frustration, so the main point to take away from this is that people demand top-down change not because they actually want it, but because they feel they have no other choice. That sense of learnt helplessness that they can't do anything with the system to achieve what they want at both a mechanical level, and a permissive level as far as what their GM will allow even if it is possible to adjust the game to suit.
However, this is ultimately what contributes to the toxic atmosphere of discussion and disagreement not just in the PF2e space, but the wider TTRPG space too. There is one ultimate fact that is true and inexorable:
No one game will ever suit any single person completely. There will always be differences in taste where even if the broad strokes are appealing, there will inevitably be minutia that they will be dissatisfied with.
And even if there was such a theoretical game that perfectly fit someone like a glove at the official RAW level, there would inevitably be someone - if not literally everyone else who engages with that game - who would find something dissatisfying with it.
This is what truly annoys me about a lot of the rhetoric surrounding this game. There's a lot of lip service given to how overtuned and overdesigned the game is, but to people like myself, that 'overtuning' and 'overdesign' is actually closer to what I want from my RPG experience - both as a player and a GM - than what is being demanded to be changed about the game. And even if it's not perfectly what I want (which - surprise! - it isn't), having that more stable baseline with clear maths and consistent tuning makes it easier to destabilize the elements I want, than it is to play a game that's already destabilized and trying to stabilize the elements I want more grounded. If the design were to change to make that destabilization the baseline, it would simply disenfranchise me from the game in the same way people who don’t like the current design feel disenfranchised from it.
This may seem obvious. 'Nobody will like any game entirely and people with differing wants will never agree on a cohesive experience.' Wow, what a revelation Chrono! You're clearly a genius of our age. But again, it comes back to that hypocrisy about decrying the community for being supposedly purist about house rules and homebrew, yet any attempt at actually trying to foster autonomy at the micro level of people's own tables or content independent from official rules is repeatedly shut down, usually with that very telling revelation about how they’re stuck being forced to play RAW themselves.
The issue is...I can't claim a lack of culpability in creating that culture.
See, in my time working on 3pp and since I stopped doing long-form essays, I realized in my original string of posts I made early in the game's lifespan, I made a crucial mistake. Many of those posts were trying to analyse, understand, and explain the design intent of the game system to people. Not to say that the game was empirically correct or infallible, but because I believe that understanding the intent of something is the most important first step of realizing what a system is trying to do.
However, in trying to get people just to understand the baseline intent of what the game was trying to do - notably in terms of its baseline tuning and balance - and arguing the virtues of that consistency and stability, I and frankly many others who pushed those points were so concerned about explaining and outright defending what we saw as misunderstood or ill-treated virtues from detractors, that we focused heavily on the RAW tuning and failed to emphasize one of the system's other major virtues:
It's modularity.
See to me, the virtue of PF2e isn't some sterile idea of balance. It's that the game's maths and design breakpoints are so clear and obvious to someone like me - who isn't even a numbers person, I'm a writer before I am a mathematician - that I can deliver the exact experience I want to my players much more easily than a system where the design is skewed and inconsistent. But in trying to focus so much on how the game function RAW, that virtue became lost and obfuscated in the weeds of the analysis.
And to be blunt, I realize how much of that rhetoric was done out of not just my own preferences, but out of spite; spite towards what I felt was that above-mentioned contingent of the RPG space that held tacit contempt and disrespect to GMs, but also their fellow players, and the exact type of players I praised PF2e from insulating against in its inherent design. It was less that I saw it as a selling point, so much as I had no sympathy and held nothing but contempt myself for the type of player who didn't understand what I thought were concepts of fairness to other players at the table and were placing unreasonable demands on GMs to placate what I saw as myopic, if not outright sociopathic methods of engagement.
In my desire to put people I thought were disrespectful in their place, however, people who would be looking for and accepting of legitimate solutions were caught in the crossfire and disregarded. Yes, there are some legitimately disconcerting people in the RPG space who don’t deserve the time of day, and some people who argue legitimate problems for bad faith and selfish reasons. But you can’t assume them to be the baseline or refuse to enact change in fear of capitulating to unreasonable or entitled demands, otherwise good people suffer and productive solutions to legitimate problems will never be achieved.
So as penance for that, I want to do my part in fixing that. I want to shift the litmus away from ‘balance’ as the buzzword for the system. I want people to stop thinking of the main virtue of PF2e as balance, and instead think of its main virtue as accuracy. Accuracy in terms of how precisely a GM can provide the exact experience they want to deliver and - hopefully - their players want or at least enjoy, without having to do extensive back-end design work or prep work.
I've spent a lot of time not just analyzing the discussions of those common pain points, but running and adjusting them in real-play to see where the breakpoints lie. Not just from a purely numeric white-room scenario, but in regards to the real-play implications of them. In doing so, I've come to realize where there are some more objective issues, but also where the issues come down to matters of taste and preference, and where they could be adjusted to suit. And the blunt is, many of the solutions are far easier than people give credit for.
No, I'm not saying you can turn PF2e into a rules-lite narrative game without stripping most of its mechanics out or easily kitbash on an Ars Magica or Mage: The Ascension-level magic system in (at least not without significant effort). But as far as a DnD-like high fantasy RPG where you play as all those traditional character classes, have crunchy grid-based tactics combat, and earn loot and rewards for participating in it, there is a lot you can do to really make the game suit your tastes in ways that are potent, but also extremely easy.
To this end, I'm going to start a new series of posts I'm calling Simple House Rule Adjustments. It's going to touch on those common pain points I've seen discussed a lot over the years, such as - but not limited to - the power and enjoyment of magic items, damage values on spells, design and stats of boss-level monsters, feats that a lot of people think should be baseline rules (notably but not limited to skill feats), and analysing the consequences of hand-waving certain mechanics in terms of achieving certain goals vs. how they may cause other unforeseen issues.
The main goal of these posts is to analyse these common talking points and give tangible ways to change the baseline that I believe address more objective issues, while allowing you to adjust to what suits your taste regarding more subjective designs. While I will try to maintain a level of integrity that the game has with its tuning, it is ultimately not to say you have to strictly abide by guidelines so much as help people understand mechanisms run the game so they can adjust from them in a way that personalizes their experience, while providing what I find have been effective solutions to many of those pain points. In the end, if you want to tear the game asunder, it is doable, and I will explain how that is possible as part of it all. But it's not one extreme of throwing out the balance or strictly adhering to it. If anything, it's the opposite of extremes; it's finding nuance and minutia that does a better job solving it than an all-solving hammer.
However, there is a secondary objective I want these posts to achieve, and that is to start moving the litmus from the common rhetoric around PF2e’s design being ‘balance’ to being 'accuracy'. The idea the game is ‘overbalanced’ has done a lot of damage to its reputation, and frankly I realize how many of the early analyses like mine contributed to that. So instead, I want to emphasize the virutes of that accuracy, and how you can make those simple adjustments to achieve the experience you want to deliver.
Obviously, these posts will mainly be for the benefit of GMs rather than players, as they will be the ones implementing any such changes. In fact, it was the creation of r/PathfinderGMs (shoutout to u/DnDPhD for taking the initiative on that) that made me get off my ass and dust off these notes and post ideas I’ve had sitting around for…frankly years in the case of some of them.
But hopefully these posts will inspire some players to realize where their pain points are actually coming from and help discuss with their GMs. I’m going to be blunt: one of the reasons the rhetoric around demanding top-down changes as a solution for everything annoys me is because it feels like people are making their micro problems at their own problems everyone else’s. However, I also realize a big part of the issue is that many players just can’t put their finger on the specific issues they have with their complaints. Hopefully by putting words to the indiscernible frustration and accurately pointing out where the pain points are, they will be able to discuss with their GMs more fruitfully and actually come up with satisfying solutions.
For those of you who have read this far, thank you for indulging my long-winded introduction. I know this is very much a ‘preview trailer’-type announcement, but I wanted to voice these thoughts and the goal of this series separately before I started doing more tangible examples. I was including them in some of my initial drafts of the topics themselves, and they were getting too bloated and off-topic with these sentiments. However, if this series proves successful and well-received, I want this intro to be the baseline to point to so people can understand what the intent of the posts are.
I also wanted to share my thoughts regarding the state of PF2e's current online culture regarding house rules and homebrew. While I won't deny there are problem posters who are too defensive of the game's design, it has bothered me for some time that people don't realize how much there is in terms of people outright rejecting solutions when they are suggested - many of whom simultaneously decry the lack of house rules/homebrew culture on the subreddit - if not outright exposing themselves as argumentative pedants who only enforce the Oberoni Fallacy to prove a point against the game instead of coming up with workable solutions. While it's something I've been wanting to address more directly - as I said above - I feel a series of posts with more tangible solutions will do more to rebut those issues then endlessly arguing about whether they're tacitly being hypocrites or self-sabotaging misery bags.
You won’t have to wait long for a proper post, as I already have the first topic lined up and will be ready in the next few days (if not tomorrow): item distribution, namely how and why giving out higher level items ahead of the curve addresses most complaints about items in the system being ‘boring’, and how to do so with targeted purpose rather than recklessly with negative consequence (though you can do that too, if you want).
I’ll see you then.