r/PhysicsHelp • u/EasyStyle2707 • 16h ago
SHM/Oscillations Doubt

In the Second question, xmax = mg/k + vo(root m/k).
When mean position doesn't coincide with natural length, we take distance between them as amplitude (as done in first question). So if A=mg/k (from natural length to mean position) and A = vo(root m/k) (from mean position to max extension), xmax = mg/k + vo root(m/k), why can't we say (mg/k = vo root m/k) and consider xmax = 2mg/k = 2vo root(m/k)?