r/PhysicsStudents • • 5h ago

Need Advice I Created a Hybrid Atomic Model Combining Quantum Probability with the Planetary Model. Could It Be a Useful Learning Tool?

0 Upvotes

I am not a physicist or a chemist. But in high school, we learned the planetary model of the atom, where electrons revolve around the nucleus much like planets orbit the Sun. This provided a natural and helpful foundation for understanding basic atomic structure.

Later, discovered how wide this classical image differs from quantum mechanics, where electrons are described by wavefunctions and probability distributions rather than definite orbital trajectories. The challenge for non-specialists is that the more accurate quantum description is also much harder to visualize intuitively. To bridge this gap, I experimented with a hybrid approach.

I created three interactive 3D animations representing gold, krypton, and sodium atoms. While the geometry and motion are artistic stylizations, the core idea was to retain the intuitive accessibility of the planetary model while visually introducing overlapping probabilistic fields within a 3D structure. The main question is whether such a depiction could serve as a useful learning aid, particularly for grasping the foundational concepts of quantum mechanics.

Feedback from the chemistry, physics, and science education communities would be highly valued. I am especially interested in learning whether these animations might be educational and engaging for individuals outside the scientific community.

Interactive charts: Atomic field animations


r/PhysicsStudents • • 3h ago

Need Advice Struggling in theoretical physics

0 Upvotes

During my first undergrad year I managed to perform exceptionally well, but ever since my grades have dropped significantly (~3.40 gpa or 2:1 in UK) and now that I have started a masters and having taken a few finals already, the situation doesn’t seems like it is going to improve. I’m also really struggling to find a PhD position, not having been able to find a tutor who will accept me (due to them already having too many PhD students) and even if I did, looking at the grade cutoffs for grants awarded in previous years it seems extremely unlikely that I would manage to get them. My main question is, given that I’m not even a competitive candidate locally how realistic is to expect that I can stay on the path towards getting a PhD or applying for progressively more competitive positions? Statistically speaking, there’s always people who drop the field at each step and I bet they didn’t think it would be them, but it seems I’m reaching a point from which I won’t be able to keep going. I know grades are not the only relevant factor, and I do have some research experience and I’m in the process of writing a paper with a professor but people even in my class already have published papers. I feel like I have little control over how the situation evolves since for this semester I have studied more than I ever did before, even in my first year, and still I haven’t been able to improve my grades. Has anyone else gone through a similar situation? Did you manage to get past a rough patch like this and get back to your best or is it maybe to late at this stage? I’m sorry for being to long.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 21h ago

Research IYPT 2027: The Singing Capacitor — Why are there multiple peaks in our spectra?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

My team has been working on Problem 4 of IYPT 2027, The Singing Capacitor. We've completed a series of preliminary experiments, but some of our results have left us with more questions than answers.

The problem:

Certain types of ceramic capacitors emit an audible sound when an alternating voltage is applied across them. Investigate the characteristics of the sound produced and how they depend on relevant parameters, such as voltage, frequency, and capacitor properties.

BTW, the rather funny term "singing capacitor" wasn't invented for the IYPT problem. It appeared in a technical article by John D. Prymak back in 2006.

1. Our experimental setup

We tested three types of multilayer ceramic capacitors (MLCCs): X5R, X7R, and C0G.

We mounted the capacitors on a PCB and applied sinusoidal AC voltages at different frequencies, including 9, 10, and 11 kHz.

We used a microphone placed close to the capacitor/PCB assembly to record the sound, then analyzed the frequency spectra using Room EQ Wizard (REW).

Our recordings were sampled at 44.1 kHz.

2. Preliminary results

First, we observed a clear difference between capacitor types.

Both X5R and X7R produced measurable acoustic responses, while our C0G sample showed no similarly detectable response under the same test conditions.

This agrees with the general explanation involving electromechanical deformation in Class II ceramic capacitors.

Second, we found something interesting in the frequency spectra.

When driving the capacitors with a sinusoidal voltage, we expected strong components at the driving frequency and possibly its harmonics.

Indeed, some of our results seem consistent with this:

With a 9 kHz input, a peak appears near 18 kHz in the X7R spectrum.

With a 10 kHz input, another peak appears near 20 kHz.

At 11 kHz, the second harmonic would be close to the Nyquist limit of our recording system, so we cannot reliably evaluate it.

However, our spectra also contain broad peaks, dips, and additional narrow peaks that we don't yet understand.

For example, several measurements show a dip around 2 kHz and a broader rise around 4–5 kHz, even when we change the input frequency.

I've attached some of our spectra for comparison.

3. Our current hypothesis

We initially suspected that these features might be related to the mechanical vibration modes of the PCB.

We found literature describing the MLCC as a vibration source and the PCB as a kind of soundboard. The PCB has multiple natural vibration modes, each with its own resonant frequency and spatial deformation pattern.

This seems relevant to our experiment, since the sound we record comes from the coupled capacitor–PCB–air system rather than from the capacitor alone.

But we're not completely convinced.

In a linear system under steady-state sinusoidal excitation, resonances should affect the amplitude of the response, not generate entirely new frequencies.

So perhaps some of the extra peaks are caused by nonlinearities, transient oscillations, background noise, or the measurement system itself.

We haven't yet isolated these possibilities experimentally.

4. We'd love some advice!

We're undergraduate physics students, and this is still an early-stage investigation.

In particular, we're wondering:

Could the multiple peaks in our spectra be explained by the vibration modes of the PCB, or should we be looking for another mechanism?

How could we distinguish actual acoustic emission from artifacts introduced by the microphone, signal source, or recording process?

And is there a relatively simple way to investigate the mechanical resonances of the PCB without specialized vibration-measurement equipment?

We're planning to perform more controlled measurements, including background-noise tests, frequency sweeps, and comparisons between different mounting conditions.

Any suggestions, relevant papers, or criticism of our experimental approach would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks for reading!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 6h ago

Off Topic I wanna be a scientist. It's my dream. I am currently doing computer engineering bachelors 1st year. I lovee the idea of universe and astronomy. But I'm questioning my course rn and so confused about my life. Whenever I see reels of astronomers , nasa I feel a grief for my dream.

6 Upvotes

r/PhysicsStudents • • 23h ago

Need Advice A conceptual question for physics students: is distance a gap, or phase harmony?

0 Upvotes

I am working through a conceptual question about distance and would value how physics students think about it. The idea comes from the second law in my book.

The proposal is that distance is phase harmony, not a pre-existing gap. Coupling between two systems equals cos squared of their phase offset. At 0 degrees there is full contact. At 45 degrees the coupling is half. At 90 degrees it is zero, and the other system behaves as if it were infinitely far away, even though nothing has moved. A causal horizon, on this view, is a phase relationship that has gone silent.

Picture two choir singers holding the same note and slowly drifting out of rhythm. Neither singer walks anywhere, yet their combined power fades as if one of them had walked down a long corridor. The distance that appears is real in its effects, but it was made by phase, not by travel.

The wider picture spreads displacement across many harmonic channels, each tilted only a tiny fraction of a degree, so flat three-dimensional space can build up across light-years without crowding toward 90 degrees. And space is three-dimensional, the book argues, because two-component spinors have exactly three rotation generators.

If closeness is interaction strength, what is a horizon? Could far away just mean out of phase? And why three dimensions, rather than two or eleven?

Disclosure: I am the author of Zero-Metric Phase Theory: How Space, Time, Matter, and Gravity Emerge from a Dimensionless Universe by Tim Tian, available on Google Play Books.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 6h ago

Rant/Vent I hate physics. I want to switch out. any advice?

7 Upvotes

I’ve been in college for a really long time. I’ve taken diffeq more times than I know. I don’t go to class and I can’t bring myself to do the homework’s. I hate it and i’ve been scraping by the entire time. I don’t think I have it in me to graduate in this major and I don’t know what to do. I have no desire to learn more physics. I hate it so much. Is there a different major that may be similar that I could switch to? Has anyone been in my shoes? I feel so alone because everyone seems to find it so cool and interesting and I just can’t bring myself to care.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 7h ago

Need Advice Why is choosing electives so hard helpppp :(((

3 Upvotes

so im a second year undergrad in physics, and i have to decide on an elective for the 4th semester by tomorrow and its brutal :((

ive got it narrowed down to 3 subjects. theres math, which is a bunch of linear algebra; vector spaces, eigenvalues, inner product spaces, matrices and stuff, which ive been told is severely used in quantum mechanics.

then theres this thing called physics of devices, which is about mosfets, semiconductors, diodes and ic fabrication. now ofc this isnt directly relevent, but i kinda like electronics, and ive wanted to learn more about this stuff. plus it seems like a good skill to have, especially for my CV.

finally theres biomathematics, which is gonna be essentially nonlinear dynamics, so population dynamics, predator prey model, modelling molecular evolution and stuff. now ive done a bit of NLD this sem (linear analysis, phase portraits ands stuff), and i really enjoyed it as well. now this i believe would ALSO look pretty good on my CV, cause its sorta different from all the usual stuff, and its something i could use in multiple fields.

i literally cannot decide, so id appreciate any help on this


r/PhysicsStudents • • 9h ago

Need Advice I understand physics formulas when studying, but completely forget them when solving questions. How do I fix this?

3 Upvotes

I'm an Advance-Level Physics student, and I've been struggling with something really frustrating.

When I study a physics chapter, I don't just memorize formulas. I try to understand where they come from, how they're derived, what each variable means, and the actual physics behind them.

While reading the textbook, everything seems to make sense. I feel like I understand the concepts and formulas.

But when I actually sit down to solve questions, everything changes.

Sometimes I can't even remember which formula to use. Even when I recognize the question, I struggle to recall the equations or figure out how to apply them.

It's frustrating because I genuinely feel like I understand the theory, but I can't transfer that understanding into solving problems.

For those who are good at Physics:

  1. Why does this happen even when I understand the derivations?
  2. How can I train my brain to recall formulas without constantly looking at my notes?
  3. Should I practice recalling formulas from memory, or focus more on solving questions?
  4. What's the fastest and most effective way to improve this?

I don't want to blindly memorize hundreds of formulas. I want to understand Physics deeply AND be able to apply it confidently in exams.

I'd really appreciate advice from people who've experienced this and managed to overcome it.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 13h ago

Need Advice Career Dilemma: Should I Pursue a PhD in Physics or Switch to IT as a Data Analyst?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I completed my Master's degree in Physics in 2022 and have around four years of experience working as a lab assistant. Due to personal reasons, I couldn't pursue a PhD at that time.

Recently, I quit my job, and now I'm considering two career paths: pursuing a PhD in Physics or switching to the IT field and starting a career as a Data Analyst.

I'm a bit confused about which path would be better for my long-term career growth and future opportunities.

I have a few questions:

  1. Would pursuing a PhD in Physics be a better option for my future?

  2. Is it possible to transition from a Physics background into Data Analytics?

  3. How difficult would it be to enter the IT field as a fresher?

  4. Considering long-term career growth, salary, and job opportunities, which path would you recommend?

I'd really appreciate your suggestions, especially from people who have transitioned from a science background into IT or have experience in either field.

Thank you!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 17h ago

Need Advice is a 3.0 gpa bad for going into industry What should i do right now to put myself ahead?

3 Upvotes

Hiya a junior bachelor's B.S. here for physics, I was wondering what I should do to set myself ahead? I'm in a lab with one of my profs doing diffusion and soft matter physics, but other than that, I've been buckling down on classes, 2 rough semesters really set my GPA back, and I've been trying to retake some classes to boost my GPA. I want to try and do internships this summer, but it feels like I barely have the time to get my HW and exam studying done, and of course, on top of that is the brain worm telling me I'm gonna end up at a Target stocking shelves. I was thinking about grad school maybe, but its all just been a bit scary as of late. Any recommendations on how I can use now and this summer to set myself up for opportunities at graduation? For context, if I could, I was looking around the Bethesda, DC, and Baltimore area, as I have some people close to there.