In the recent discussion about "Anarchy as the mother of order" (see my previous post https://www.reddit.com/r/Anarchism/s/sAuyL4hKa8 ), a popular argument came up: capital hates chaos because chaos costs money.
Here is where people make a basic category mistake — they confuse capitalists with Capital.
Capitalists (entrepreneurs, business owners), of course, prefer stability. Even if a specific businessman makes money off the consequences of riots — say, owns a glass shop fixing smashed windows, or sells security systems — he still prefers stability over chaos. He needs predictable rules of the game, not the destruction of the playing field itself.
But this is the level of human psychology and microeconomics. When it comes to Capital as a macro-system, as an entity, as an Eidos — everything is exactly the opposite. Capital needs crises and chaos for its existence, renewal, and development just as much as it needs periods of stability and accumulation. Nullum capital sine chao.
In this paradigm, capitalists are not the all-powerful masters of the situation. They are more like priests or servants of an entity called Capital. From the outside it looks like a person creates capital and controls it, but this is an illusion. You cannot create an ontological entity out of nothing; you can only create conditions for its realization to a greater or lesser degree.
Capital controls all participants in the process — both the capitalists and those who oppose them (the rioters smashing windows) — not through direct coercion or backroom conspiracies, but through induction (inducere). Here it is appropriate to remember the Latin "inducas" from the prayer "Our Father" (et ne nos inducas in tentationem). In the Aristotelian sense of final cause (causa finalis), this is not mechanical compulsion, but an ontological force that attracts, "induces," and directs processes toward their natural completion. Capital "induces" crisis the same way gravity "induces" a falling stone, using all people as instruments for system reboot.
And this is exactly why destruction is structurally profitable for Capital:
1. The Great Reset
Any economic system accumulates friction over time: debts, contracts, regulations. Crises and wars act as a systemic solvent. They wipe out obligations, devalue old debts, and force everyone back to a blank slate. The rules are then rewritten by those who still hold real resources — not those holding old paper contracts.
2. The Evolutionary Filter
Biologically speaking, chaos is a mechanism of intense evolutionary pressure. A crisis sweeps out the inefficient and vulnerable — those who cannot protect their investments in changing conditions. Distressed assets get absorbed by larger, more adaptive structures. Chaos doesn't destroy competition; it radicalizes it, concentrating power in the hands of apex predators.
3. Primitive Accumulation
The Conquistadors in America didn't come to integrate into existing trade networks. They deliberately dismantled the state apparatuses of indigenous peoples to build new, ruthlessly efficient systems of extraction. The destruction of order was not a side effect — it was a necessary condition.
4. Causa Finalis — The Teleology of Crisis
Nature gives striking parallels. The lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta) in North America evolved with serotinous cones sealed with resin. They cannot open and release their seeds until exposed to the intense heat of a forest fire. What looks like pure destruction is ontologically necessary for the species' reproduction. Fire is not the enemy of the forest — it is its midwife.
In human systems, the same logic operates. When rioters smash windows because of rising prices and cut stipends, they believe they are fighting for justice. When enforcers arrest them, they believe they are defending order. When capitalists consolidate assets, they believe they are protecting profit. All of them are wrong about their own motives. They are instruments of a deeper ontological pull — the system's drive toward a new equilibrium at a higher turn of the evolutionary spiral.
The final cause of the crisis is not the rioters' anger, not the state's repression, and not capital's greed. It is the self-renewal of the system. Each actor plays their assigned role:
Rioters destroy obsolete structures — this is the fire.
Enforcers eliminate marginal and deviant elements — clearing the undergrowth.
Capital absorbs the resources of the fallen and concentrates power — the seeds finally released.
The State upgrades its skills in managing chaos and imposing order — the new growth.
And then the cycle repeats. New equilibrium. New accumulation of friction. New crisis. New spiral.
Conclusion:
This is neither good nor bad. It is the nature of things, whether anyone likes it or not. The rioter, the cop, the banker — none of them are the authors of history. They are its instruments. Capital, the final cause, induces them all.
After all, there's a reason they say: if you like sausage, you'd better not watch how it's made. The same goes for capital. And the same goes for revolution.
Nullum capital sine chao.
Nulla rerum novatio sine motu.
And somewhere right now, new authors are quoting Proudhon in social media, debating whether the latest riots fit his famous definition.
Et cetera.
TL;DR: People confuse capitalists (who want stability) with Capital as an entity (which needs chaos to evolve). Capital doesn't orchestrate riots through direct conspiracy; it "induces" them (causa finalis) to reset the system, filter out the weak, and concentrate power. Rioters, cops, and bankers are all just instruments of this ontological reset.
Note: Original text in Russian, translated into English and Latin with AI assistance.