I've posted this in other subreddits, and they've all been echo chambers of "break up with this man", and I genuinely need more perspectives from men like my partner. I know it's long, but please read and give your insight. My relationship is on the line here.
My boyfriend [29M] and I [31F] have been together for just over a year now. For context, this is my boyfriend's first ever relationship, and the second relationship that I've ever had that has exceeded the one year mark. So there may be some naivety on either part that could be the root of this issue.
My boyfriend had a very religious upbringing, and considers himself to be Christian.. but he doesn't practice his religion outside of praying before meals and before bed, occasionally reads his bible. I'm an ashiest, but I was raised Christian. We've talked a lot about religious trauma, and how it has affected us. We talked about this well before introducing intimacy into the relationship, and I said I would let him lead the way. I think I even told him I'd wait for marriage if he wanted to.. but he insisted the practice is antiquated. We proceeded with intimacy anyways, and I know he had a lot of religious guilt early in our relationship due to us being intimate outside of marriage. He also divulged that, because of his religion he masturbated to mostly innocent, clothed women, before he upgraded to porn in adulthood.
Early in our relationship, my boyfriend admitted to me that he had a porn addiction, but he had come very far in his recovery and had worked to a point that he only needed to masturbate once a week on average before we even started dating. We talked about the kind of porn that he liked to watch. I've always been a very sexually open person, and he is too. He explained that he watched stuff on the Hub like most people, thirst traps of cosplayers, OF models, and porn actresses on social media, and hentai videos/comics. I also watch porn and masturbate regularly. We're open with each other about the frequency of it. I think it's healthy, and I don't think that porn consumption and masturbation should ever be barred from a relationship. I want to make that clear.
After we began being intimate in our relationship, there was a clear shift in my boyfriend, which he even self-reported to me. I'm paraphrasing, but he explained that the shift in him from experiencing intimacy for the first time had turned him into a feral monster that could only think about sex most days. He said that he needed to increase his masturbation to near daily just to suppress his urges towards me. I told him that at no point was I offended by him being sex-crazed towards me, and if he thought he was doing this for my benefit, then it was totally unnecessary. He countered and explained that being pent up like that was doing mental damage to himself, and he didn't want it to get to a point that his urges would turn to just anyone (only in thought) instead of just me. There wasn't a decrease in our intimacy. So I let it slide. For reference, up until the 6-month mark in our relationship, we were having sex 7-9 times a week, and after six months it dropped to 3-4 times a week on average, and I'm happy with that.
A few months ago, our relationship got really stressful for the both of us. I've been going through some rough health issue flare-ups which have severely limited what I can do around the house and for myself at times. I had emergency surgery on top of that, which set my recovery really far back. I'll be honest, I'm not a neat and organized person. I have ADHD, and it's always been a struggle point for me, but I know how much it bothers my boyfriend, because he is a neat and organized person. My mess has always been a point of contention in the relationship, and I've genuinely been working really hard on it. I'm getting reevaluated and working towards getting medicated for my ADHD and potential autism so that I can manage my executive dysfunction better. I'm creating better habits and regularly accomplishing tasks that I can do. However, all of the health issues on top of that have limited what efforts I can make, and everything around me has been piling up and stressing him out.
This stress combined with not being able to be intimate after I had surgery caused the frequency of his masturbating to go up, and it hasn't come back down. He never self-reported this increase to me, but I'm a very analytical person and I know his habits. So I know how much he's masturbating now without him having to tell me. He went from 4-5 times a week to now 7-8 on average. However, now there has been a drop in our intimacy.
On top of that, I recently came to a pretty big revelation regarding his porn use. Again, this could be my naivety, but I guess I always assumed that he consumed porn and masturbated the same way that I did. Yeah, I watch a video to get myself in the mood, but once I'm there, I turn the content off and instead imagine my partner to get myself the rest of the way there. He's been a part of it every single time. But in a recent conversation, it became clear to me that unless he's masturbating to pictures or videos of me that I've sent him, I'm never on his mind at all when he masturbates. He assured me that this was the norm for him and most men, so even though I was uncomfortable and saddened by it, I just didn't make a big deal about it and moved on... or so I thought.
Another big revelation hit me a couple of weeks ago, and this is the one that I cannot let go of. I always assumed that watching thirst traps of girls on social media was like the foreplay to get him into the mood before he would go and find porn, but no. He made it clear that he likes masturbating to the thirst traps from beginning to end. In the moment, I was very uncomfortable with this, but I couldn't quite place why. Not long before this happened, we were watching a Twitch Streamer's VOD of a big event they did. As part of the event, the streamer had hired a lot of popular cosplayers and other streamers to come participate in the event. These women were dressed in normal attire for the stream event. I made a comment about one of the girls and he's like "Oh yeah, that's [insert username]" but I didn't know who that was. He says her username again and says who she's most known for cosplaying. I think he even pulled up and showed me a picture, and that's when it hit me that he's watched and masturbated to so many thirst traps from these cosplayers that he knows their names, and what they look like outside of cosplay. Again, I felt really uncomfortable about this, but my mind hadn't connected the dots yet on why this made me uncomfortable so I just let it go so I could think on it another time.
The cherry on top was last week. He was laying in bed on his phone, I had just gotten into bed and crawled up next to him. I was laying on my stomach and lower in bed so I couldn't see what was on his screen. He smiled at me and asked "Hey, wanna look at hot ladies on TikTok with me?" It felt like a suckerpunch to the gut. I said no, and that I should get to sleep. I think he stayed up. I don't really remember. I was really upset.
After sitting on this for about six weeks in total I finally had enough pangs of uncomfortableness and sadness that I finally pieced it all together. Him sexualizing and objectifying the women on social media is not okay with me. Again, this could just be me being naĆÆve about the nature of men and their habits, but this genuinely felt like a big betrayal to me. (I talked about this with my closest friends, and one of them basically said he's mentally cheating on me with this behavior? But I don't know) I tried doing some research but nothing came back concrete on whether or not his behavior of jerking off to PG-13 content on social media was healthy. Part of me was really sad from the betrayal, another part of me was genuinely concerned for my boyfriend and his addiction, and as ashamed as I am to admit it.. Part of me was really insecure. I see the women he watches. I don't look like that. I could never look like that without extensive cosmetic surgeries. It made me feel worthless.
All of this led me to talking about it with my therapist when I saw her yesterday. She shared equal concern with me that this behavior wasn't healthy in her professional opinion, and she encouraged me to talk to my boyfriend about my feelings. We went over how I would approach the conversation with him, and what I needed to say.. We even thought out scenarios of what to do and say if he wasn't receptive or shot me down. I went into it thinking that I had it all figured out. I didn't think that it was going to be an easy conversation, but I felt really prepared.
We had the conversation. I brought up everything that I brought up here in detail. At one point my boyfriend even nailed it on the head. He said the social media content is more intimate than porn, and it's real women, and I told him that's exactly why I don't like it. It is a very intimate setting, and I don't view this as being porn, regardless of the content creators intent. You have to sexualize it and objectify the women to get to that point. A lot of our conversation was focused on his argument that the content is porn, because it's tailored to specifically arouse men. He was on his soapbox about a movie I really liked (Burlesque) and how it's essentially porn, because if you sat 10 men down to watch it, and hooked them up to monitors, their brains would light up exactly like they do with regular porn videos. It was clear I wasn't getting anywhere with this. No matter how well I explained my perspective and feelings, he said that everything about his behavior was perfectly normal.
We did eventually settle on the fact that he would agree to stop using social media for that *if I wanted him to* (I said I'd think about it), but he explained that we'd have to be careful, because if we see a thirst trap together on my feed, it might cause him to relapse. At that point it became really obvious to me that he didn't really care about my feelings on the matter, because he was still convinced that what he was doing was perfectly normal and alright. I didn't push for him to stop, because he wasn't doing it for the right reasons. I wanted him to see how his behavior was unhealthy and understand my perspective and see why it was hurting my feelings, not just stop because I asked him to. I also got caught up in how sure he was of his opinions, and
I started to feel like maybe my perspective was wrong even if my feelings were the ones that were hurt.
I really don't know what to do, and I would appreciate any advice or perspective on this. I don't see my therapist again for two weeks, and I just can't sit on this until then. I don't want to break up. I genuinely love this man with all of my heart, and if this ends up being a behavior I have to accept as part of being in a relationship with him, then I would do it. I just need more perspective, and advice on how I can help him understand how he's hurting me. He's genuinely an amazing man. I know he would come around if I could just explain myself in a way that he can understand. If I have the wrong perspective here, and I truly was just naĆÆve about the nature of men, I can accept that too. I'm just at a loss here, and I can't spend the next two weeks feeling despondent over it.
TL;DR: Boyfriend prefers jerking off to PG-13 thirst traps of women content creators. I think this an unhealthy extension of his porn addiction and I want him to understand why it is wrong and stop. It also hurts my feelings and makes me feel bad about myself. He insists his behavior is healthy and normal, but he has offered to stop if I want him to, with the caveat that he may relapse if he sees thirst traps when we scroll on my social media feeds when we scroll together. I need advice.