r/ProductManagement • • 7h ago

Weekly rant thread

1 Upvotes

Share your frustrations and get support/feedback. You are not alone!


r/ProductManagement • • 2h ago

How to build usage-based pricing for an AI product when you have no historical data?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! new to PM world.

I am working on commercialising an AI-powered product that analyses images, detects and classifies objects, and generates reports based on its findings.

I am trying to figure out how to structure usage-based subscription plans. The product is tested with the partners and will be officially launched in early dec.

The potential models are:

  • Freemium: X scans per month.
  • Individual: X scans per month for a monthly subscription.
  • Institutional: $X per month for X users with a shared pool of X scans.

I have already worked out most of the underlying costs and infra capacity:

  • AWS and GPU infrastructure costs.
  • HR and operational costs.
  • GPU performance benchmarks, including concurrency limits, requests processed per minute, and P50/P95 latency.
  • The point at which latency starts increasing under load.
  • Model network is open source (no expenses)

The part I am struggling with is forecasting infrastructure scaling and thus the pricing.

Since the product hasn't launched, I have no historical traffic data. I don't know when users will typically run scans, how much usage will overlap, when peak demand will occur, or how long those peaks will last.

I therefore don't know when I will need to add another GPU, how long I will need that additional capacity, or how to account for these costs when setting subscription limits and prices.

I don't want to overprovision and burn through cash, but I also don't want to underprice the product and end up losing money as usage grows.

This is a bootstrapped startup, so getting the financial model reasonably right is important.

My background is in enterprise IT consulting, and this is my first experience taking a product through commercialisation and monetisation. The technical development side went relatively smoothly; pricing and capacity planning are proving to be a different challenge!

For Experienced PMs, how will you approach this?

  • How will you estimate peak concurrent usage without historical data?
  • How will you model GPU scaling costs?
  • How would you decide the number of scans to include in each subscription tier? Maybe I can answer this once I know qesution 1 and 2. I also have competitor numbers.
  • If you have done a similar exercise before, did you initially use conservative assumptions and revise pricing once actual usage data became available? But is it hard to revise pricing as it may piss off customers? Most customers for us will be trade schools and high schools with limited budgets.

I would truly appreciate any guidance on how to look at this problem, I am lost.


r/ProductManagement • • 20h ago

How to manage a rapid AI development lab within a large professional services company

0 Upvotes

Hey y’all,

I’m a Group / Lead PM within a large professional services organization (think banking, consulting, big law firm) with over 3k+ personnel. I am a part of a newly formed rapid development lab where we essentially create internal (that could be external to clients) tools that make our employees more efficient. Especially the ones that bill their time which is how we make our revenue.

All of these tools are basically built with Claude Code. Since we are in the early goings, we do not have PRDs, user stories, design artifacts like in Figma, etc. When we talk to users/stakeholders/project sponsors and get feedback, we literally feed everything to Claude, let it figure it out, and just ship it all. We track changelogs and see the PRs but approve it all.

That said, would love your thoughts on:

- what would you prioritize if you were in my shoes from a process perspective?
- is there really a good reason to slow down?
- when do you think PRDs, user stories, and other artifacts would become useful? (IMO, stories,PRDs and others were more relevant when engineering/design capacity was not abundant as they are now with AI tools)
- any other considerations?

Thanks!


r/ProductManagement • • 21h ago

PMs who use AI daily, how did you get better at prompting?

70 Upvotes

I use AI pretty heavily in my day to day. Copilot on my work machine, and Claude on my personal one, where I've built a PM assistant agent that helps me quickly draft Jira tickets. So I'm not new to this and I'm pretty comfortable working with chatbots.

That said, I'm noticing lately that it's taking me longer to get the results I actually want. I'll go back and forth five or six times rewording things, re-explaining context, or fixing outputs that are close but not quite right. At some point I'm spending more time managing the chat than it would've taken to just do the task myself.

I'm guessing the issue is how I'm writing my prompts, not the tools. So I'm curious:

• Any videos, courses, or resources that actually helped you level up your prompting?

• Do you have go-to templates or structures you reuse for common PM tasks?

• Any habits that cut down on the back and forth (giving context upfront, examples, etc.)?

• For anyone using Copilot at work, any tips specific to it? It feels different from Claude or ChatGPT.

I'd love to hear what's worked for you, especially anything practical and PM specific rather than generic "10 prompts that will change your life" content.


r/ProductManagement • • 23h ago

Books on MNC Product Management

2 Upvotes

Hey all, I'm a PM for two years at a large multinational company. I've done all the training the company offers on product management and it goes through explaining discovery work and market validation etc etc.

What I'm struggling with though is the day-to-day of product management, like stakeholder management, how to push through ideas in large orgs, calming SMEs when there is uncertainty, how to navigate in ambiguous situations, who picks up tasks that sit in the grey area, etc.

I assume you learn these things with experience, but hoping there's any books or resources you recommend that would help me now.

I'm tired of stressing cause others won't do their work for my product.

Thanks in advance folks


r/ProductManagement • • 1d ago

Tools & Process How many backlogs do you manage?

20 Upvotes

How many products, backlogs, and sets of spring ceremonies do you manage, and what’s your title?

Backstory: I was Lead (& only) PM at a very small company for ~3 years, and we had 1 backlog in Jira for multiple products with 1 engineering team. I moved to a larger company and took an Associate PM role, because I was finding that my experience wasn’t landing interviews at an equivalent to my former title since it was such a small company. It was not a pay cut, and I’m fine with the title because I think it’s a good career move to try to work up the ladder here for a while and then be more competitive for Sr roles at larger companies. However, I expected that the Associate-level role would be less stressful and have less responsibilities while I was learning. That has not turned out to be the case 😅 I manage 3 products with 3 separate backlogs (2 of which are on a different platform than the other one), 3 engineering teams, and 3 sets of sprint ceremonies. There is crossover in the customers. I’m drowning, missing tags in comments, in meetings over half the day, and I can tell burnout is going to come quickly. Not to mention I can’t learn the products or go heads down when I’m in this many meetings. I am pretty siloed, but I do not believe that even most Sr. PMs at this company have the situation that I’m in. I’ve brought up the amount of meetings, but I am realizing that the problem is actually the number of backlogs. I am context switching every 30 minutes for another call, another tag in Jira, a slack message, a huddle request. My peer at the APM level has 1 product. I’m grateful that they trusted me to handle these 3 products, and I think I’m pretty good at what I do, but I am feeling like this is much more than an APM level role. Asking here because I’ve only worked at the one place prior, so maybe this is normal?

TLDR; Is three products with separate backlogs, engineering teams, and sprint ceremonies normal for an Associate-level position?


r/ProductManagement • • 2d ago

Controller Made Of Stone?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I've been thinking a lot about how to make a controller truly premium, but this idea really caught my attention—the image is just a concept art (not AI). The plan is to use a full stone-resin composite for the casing and all the buttons. Do you think there would be a demand for a product like this?


r/ProductManagement • • 2d ago

Strategy/Business Only PM at a market leader, effectively CPO without the title. How do I get the most out of it before it burns me out?

37 Upvotes

Hey all, I’m looking for advice from anyone who’s been the only PM at a legacy company.

Situation
I have ~2.5 years of PM experience and recently joined a local company that’s the clear leader in its market (a few million MAU). I’m the only PM there, and I own:

  • The website
  • iOS and Android apps
  • A new platform being built from scratch

Complication
The company has been around a long time and the culture strongly resists change. Modernizing tech, process or product meets pushback, there’s a lot of internal politics, and data-backed proposals still stall because “this is how we’ve always done it.” The package is thin too: basically no benefits and mandatory 5 days in office, which has been a harder adjustment than I expected coming from WFH.

Implication
If nothing changes, I end up with a big scope but little real impact, and I burn out before I have results to show for it. Some days I love how much is on my plate. Other days I’m fed up and wondering why they hired a PM if they don’t want to move forward.

Position
I still think this is a rare opportunity. At this stage of my career I’m effectively doing a CPO’s job without the title, and I’d rather get the most out of it than leave early. I just need a better playbook than what I’m doing now.

Action (where I’d love your input)

  1. How do you push change in an org that resists it? Small wins first, finding allies, something else?
  2. How do you handle politics as the only PM, with no product leadership to back you up?
  3. How do I make this experience count on my CV without a Head of Product or CPO title?
  4. How long would you stay in a role like this before the stress outweighs the upside?
  5. How do you avoid burning out when you own everything?

Benefit
If I get this right, I come out with real wins across a high-traffic product and a platform rebuild, plus a story that sets me up for a senior or Head of Product role. Hopefully this thread also helps other solo PMs stuck in the same situation.

TL;DR: Only PM at a market leader, owning web, both apps and a platform rebuild. The culture fights change and conditions are rough, but the opportunity is real. How do I make it count without burning out?

Edit: Fair hits on the CPO framing. That was poor wording on my part. More accurately: I'm the sole PM owning web, both apps and a platform rebuild, and I'm expected to bring strategy suggestions to leadership, who make the final calls.

Main takeaways for anyone in a similar spot:
* Get really clear on what leadership actually values before pushing any change
*Build allies and let them pull change instead of pushing it yourself
* Pick one visible win and drop the rest of the list for now
* Define your exit criteria early so you don't burn out

Thanks to everyone who took the time to answer the actual questions.


r/ProductManagement • • 2d ago

Display Roadmap Internally

4 Upvotes

We want to display our roadmap internally, but not really finding a great way to do it. We really want to do whatever possible to make it harder for someone to share it, copy it, screenshot it, etc. Knowing these are not 100% preventable, but we don't want to make it easy. Our roadmap is a Claude artifact. Any creative ideas? How do you display roadmaps internally?


r/ProductManagement • • 4d ago

The No AI Slop Manifesto

0 Upvotes

www.slopmanifesto.com

Not sure how we can fight our bosses, but we can at least push back amongst our peers!

(this is not my website and I have not signed, so this is not self promo!)

In 2001, 17 software engineers and leaders got together at a ski lodge in Snowbird, Utah to understand the biggest challenge of their time: heavyweight, documentation-driven software development processes.

Out of this we got the Agile Manifesto, four values and twelve principles that changed how most of the industry builds software.

Today we convene to build our own manifesto - the No AI Slop manifesto.

AI increasingly helps us write our code, docs, plans, and messages. We've all been on the receiving end of slop, and most of us have sent some too. Through this work, we have come to value:

Outcomes over output

Understanding over speed

Our own thinking over a model's first draft

Better work over easier work

Improving the system over patching the output


r/ProductManagement • • 5d ago

Boss wants to push a new module to sales before we even finish the pilot. How do I push back (or am I wrong)?

14 Upvotes

We just built a new module for a new use case and literally just kicked off our first customer pilot. We still haven't validated whether it actually delivers the value we think it does, and we don't have a clear picture of the product gaps yet. Despite that, my boss is already rushing to hand it over to sales for a full push.

My worry is that doing this too early is going to pull the team into constant firefighting mode, leaving us no bandwidth to focus on iterating the core product. On top of that, shipping something half-baked carries a real risk of causing actual damage/losses for our customers.

As the product lead, what can I actually do to slow things down and get buy-in for proper pilot validation first?

Or is there a chance I'm being too cautious here, and my boss's "sell first, fix it later" mindset actually makes more sense? Would appreciate any advice from folks who have dealt with this.


r/ProductManagement • • 5d ago

When is a/b testing actually useful?

30 Upvotes

I've seen some posts on here where people argue for and against a/b testing. The consensus seems to be that it isn't something that should be applied to everything, but that it can be useful in certain contexts.

So the question i want to ask is:

When is a/b testing useful and when is it harmful? Do you have any examples of the former or the latter?

I'm trying to sharpen up my intuition about when a/b testing should be applied, so would appreciate any insight you folks can share! Thanks in advance :)


r/ProductManagement • • 5d ago

UX/Design State of UX design in an AI-optimized delivery system

27 Upvotes

In my org, product and eng are heavily leaning on AI to get more done, test things faster, deploy faster, etc. My engineering and product teams are now complaining that the UX team is the bottleneck in our delivery flow.

Admittedly we have had a historical rhythm of designing everything to 100% before handing off to dev to execute. This has been driven at least in part by the fact that we work in an industry that is very sensitive to dates and needs a lot of advance notice for changes. This means we rely heavily on good initial estimates for planning, hence wanting full designs in hand before starting work.

I'm pushing our designers to properly build out our design system in tools like Claude Design so that we can more rapidly iterate with accurate on-spec UI, but I've been hitting some walls with them continuing to work very manually in the old way of doing things.

Here's where my head is at and I'd love outside perspective.

  1. UX is still incredibly important to me, I don't want to sacrifice it
  2. In today's world, developing UI is the cheap and easy part with AI tools.
  3. Changing our product creation process could look like this:

--PM generates reference UI within tools like Claude, using our design system

--We review workflow with UX and Engineering, and once agreed on the basics, hand off to both simultaneously to work on.

--UX iterates through final design and hands off to engineering when ready

--Engineering implements backend and reference design, and then eventually the final polished UI when ready

Effectively we stop sequential handoffs and begin execution early.

Curious how others are seeing their UX teams deal with pm and dev teams that want to move faster.


r/ProductManagement • • 6d ago

Friday Show and Tell

6 Upvotes

There are a lot of people here working on projects of some sort - side projects, startups, podcasts, blogs, etc. If you've got something you'd like to show off or get feedback, this is the place to do it. Standards still need to remain high, so there are a few guidelines:

  • Don't just drop a link in here. Give some context
  • This should be some sort of creative product that would be of interest to a community that is focused on product management
  • There should be some sort of free version of whatever it is for people to check out
  • This is a tricky one, but I don't want it to be filled with a bunch of spam. If you have a blog or podcast, and also happen to do some coaching for a fee, you're probably okay. If all you want to do is drop a link to your coaching services, that's not alright

r/ProductManagement • • 6d ago

Question for the Big Dogs

12 Upvotes

I am new to PM at a mid sized company. Came over from Sales Engineering about 5 months ago.

My question is for people in Product Leadership roles, what are some of the most annoying things that Junior PM do?


r/ProductManagement • • 6d ago

Strategy/Business how do you remember what customers actually said?

0 Upvotes

after a few interviews i only remember my own version of what people said, not their actual words. by the time i need it, the details are gone

how do you deal with this? any habits that help


r/ProductManagement • • 7d ago

Why does AI lead to “fewer roadmaps?”

0 Upvotes

I’ve seen this in a few media outlets and from some influencers. I’d say my roadmaps have evolved as has my experimentation roadmap.


r/ProductManagement • • 7d ago

Stakeholders & People How can this role even work when developers have no accountability?

79 Upvotes

Hey everyone, trying to make this a productive conversation rather than a vent. But I’m having a real problem at my organization, and it’s putting my own initiative at risk. That issue is a (lack of) accountability amongst software developers.

At my org, it looks like this:

  1. Developers demand technical, decomposed waterfall specs before they start work. I cannot present a problem to the team and expect them to solve it. I can’t even create a clear set of user stories with granular AC and expect them to try. They need ultra-granular instructions, subtasks breakdowns, etc. to start work.
  2. Absolute collapse in processes. There is no branching strategy, unit tests are not done, DevOps resourcing is all over the map…it’s a mess. The devs say it is the PM job to manage this. Despite having a clear DoD, I still have to remind the devs 5+ times to get them to merge their changes.
  3. Lack of estimates or communication. Devs don’t estimate work, don’t communicate when their blocked…if they get confused, they just stop and don’t tell anyway, waiting for PM to resolve. Devs frequently tell me it will take 2 days to do something, tell me “one more day” 30+ times, and then deliver something that totally breaks most existing functionality.

It’s at the point that devs are complaining they couldn’t think about a problem because I didn’t “give them a task to evaluate the problem” before they start coding.

Of course, PM is 100% accountable for all failures in this situation. I’m starting to think that the only thing I can do is better vet teams & projects going forward, and that a lot of this isn’t fixable.

As a side note: I’m 20 years deep into my career, and 4 years in product. I’ve had roles in manufacturing, corporate, and several different sectors. Most of my experience was not in software. As a whole: it is staggering to me that developers are often paid WAY better than most other professional classes i have worked with, while simultaneously being ALLERGIC to accountability, taking no initiative…it is baffling.


r/ProductManagement • • 7d ago

PM leadership, how have you approached learning and applying M&A and partnership strategies?

0 Upvotes

quick background-

I've been a PM since I did engineering in uni, 10+ yrs ago. Have been working in a leadership capacity for the past ~3-4yrs in a late-stage startup.

preamble-extended-

Throughout my career I've had various partnership discussions and intitiaves. Some of these oppurtunties I've scouted and built business cases for, on my own. In some others, I've been invited into the discussion to lend the 'product perspective'.

In all of those experiences and even now, I can't shake a feeling of impostor syndrome. I can't help, but think that there is some formalized framework or education or something that I'm missing.

In the past, anytime I have needed to learn a relevant new skill, I go out there find a book or a course or a speaker and that's worked well for me.

When I try to do that for learning about M&A or business partnerships, I see it extremely intertwined with MBA education.

I don't want to do an MBA, lol. At least not at this moment in my life.

->the main ask<-

How have you approached learning and applying M&A and partnerships strategies? Any resources that you have found beneficial, that you wouldn't mind mentioning?

Thank you


r/ProductManagement • • 7d ago

PMs, what's your relationship like with Product Enablement?

20 Upvotes

I'm in Product Enablement for a large SaaS company. I'm always looking for ways to make the PMs my bffs, because we need to work so closely together. I'm curious what this relationship looks like at other companies. I know Product Enablement is newer to the market, so I am not sure how many companies have this separate function. If you do, how's it going? What do you like and dislike about it? If you don't, what's your take?


r/ProductManagement • • 7d ago

Weekly rant thread

0 Upvotes

Share your frustrations and get support/feedback. You are not alone!


r/ProductManagement • • 7d ago

Has the PM job become solution-oriented lately?

41 Upvotes

For the longest time, PM craft was all about problem definition, first principles thinking etc. It was never about the solutions though execution mattered. Even interviews were centered around product thinking which is the ability to break down the problem statement, develop usecases, prioritise problem statements etc. Basically the core Consumer product frameworks.

However, lately I am noticing that recruiters are openly saying they want solution oriented PMs. They don't care about how you arrive at a feature as long as you arrive at this quickly. Is this due to AI? is this due to the immense funding scarcity recently? Is building stuff faster and copying competitors more important than actually thinking what your users want?

is it just me or do you see a shift in your company culture as well?


r/ProductManagement • • 7d ago

What is the actual degree of autonomy you have on your roadmap?

21 Upvotes

This one is for the folks who are Principal and above, leading complex products that require cross-domain alignment (i.e. aligning with another product team).

Our roadmaps and headcount requests are decided once a year, but the execution is phased quarterly. In the past couple of years, the company has become increasingly top-down, with a lot of pressure to chase competition. Leadership (mostly non technical) does not value discovery, and continuously bumps up last minute requests in the quarterly cycle. These requests are prestige projects or chasing competitors. Non-tech leadership has a lot of clout, and is not held accountable for delivering the impact goals - when questioned on prioritization, they come back with product issues and a long-list of urgent feature requests which were never part of the MVP we had aligned in the annual plan.

Tech leadership does not push back at all. A lot of them are delusional about AI capabilities, and think that a one-shotted PRD is 'discovery' enough for complex solutions touching multi-micro-services which are not even documented to the extent we would like. PMs are left to re-hash all the cross-team alignments we had driven, and re-align everyone on the new priority.

Cross-domain teams do not like these last-minute intakes that disrupt their roadmap either. We've begun to lose trust with them, as they blame us for poor planning and poor discovery. They are 100% justified in feeling resentful, tbh.

Pressure to succeed and deliver the launch is so high, that sometimes we've resorted to gaslighting them into accepting the new request. Other times, we've escalated, and ultimately the stronger (read: louder) team has come out on top.

How to deal with this, and bring back the autonomy on your roadmap?


r/ProductManagement • • 7d ago

How much process optimization/management should I be doing?

3 Upvotes

I work at a smaller services/software organization. Our software team is made up of mostly offshore resources. I am the lone onshore resource. I'm supposed to work more as a product manager, but I pretty much am the software lead. I have now started trying to optimize our engineering process as AI changes everything and makes it much easier for agents to code, but not necessarily to put out good, working features, because you still need engineering review. It's not that I mind necessarily doing this work, but I do feel like it's taking away from some of the other important product management work that is needed. Right now, I'm focusing less on the "what to build" and more on the "how to build it," which is definitely more the role of an engineering manager or engineer.

I'm also cognizant that I want to apply too much process in our small and lean team. We are at a disadvantage from a technical staff perspective because most of our talent is actually going to sit on the service side of our business, which manages accounting-type work. Because of this, I feel like the process is more important since we're mostly an experienced team.