r/PubTips • u/wilderobserver • 2h ago
[QCrit] THE OBSERVER EFFECT - Adult, LGBTQ/Literary, 106k words, Attempt 2
[Thanks to those of you who gave feedback on V1 last week. I’m relatively new to this sub and have learned that slower-paced literary fiction is not as common here, and therefore that a lot of the query feedback is really centered on saleability (all fine and good); I know my stakes seem “low”, but I’d be most grateful for feedback on whether the plot, as described here, makes sense and provokes the right kind of questions (i.e. that make an agent ask for more pages, rather than confuse them).
Related : I’m curious if anyone has experience with querying a book that has two (or more) distinct halves or parts with their own settings, stakes, conflicts, etc. The first half-ish of this book takes place before the MC’s transition, and the second half (not described here at all) takes place 10 years later when they’re in a very different place, emotionally and physically. Worrying that I’m only talking about the first half in my query may be just my own unoriginal fear of not trusting enough in my pages or the first half’s hook, but curious if anyone has advice to share on this specifically. Thanks in advance, and apologies if this question is too specific/too much to include in a query crit - please let me know and I can post separately.]
*****
Hi ___,
I read your wishlist on ___, and due to your interest in ___, you may be a great match to represent my literary novel THE OBSERVER EFFECT.
Liv Wright has always tried to be good—loyal, kind, and selfless in her relationships—but the result of always putting other people first is that, at age 22, she still doesn’t know herself. She thinks all she wants is to get through her summer job as a farmhand in Pennsylvania and join her girlfriend Max in California when the season’s over, but when she meets Jane, her new boss, she catches a glimpse of a different possible future.
Jane is a few years older, a few years wiser, and makes Liv feel safe in a way she never has before. Around Jane, Liv is different—braver, more curious, more herself. Or rather, as the weeks pass and the realization sets in, more himself. When Liv confesses to Jane one night that she sometimes feels more like him than her, Jane is unwaveringly supportive. By the end of the summer, Liv has it down bad for Jane, but, unwilling to hurt Max and jeopardize their relationship, she keeps her crush a secret.
Liv and Max move in together as planned, and Liv continues to people-please on autopilot for a couple years: she gets a boring job to pay the bills, and she ignores her weird gender feelings, afraid that telling Max will make it all too real. Liv and Jane stay in touch, exchanging rambling, goofy, heartwarming emails, letters that Liv finds herself looking forward to more than anything else. But when Jane stops writing back, Liv feels the loss too deeply and realizes she has to come out to someone: either tell Jane she’s in love with her, or tell Max about her gender. One way or another, she—or he—needs to be seen.
Complete at 106,000 words, The Observer Effect will appeal to readers of contemporary queer fiction, combining the earnest, poetic interiority of Denne Michele Norris’s When the Harvest Comes, the femme-forward cast of lovable characters in Emily St. James’s Woodworking, and Heated Rivalry’s hope-punk happy ending.
I’m a 40-year-old trans man who once spent a summer living on an off-grid farm in rural Pennsylvania. I have a BA in English from [redacted] College, and I co-own a communications and design agency with my best friend. I previously published a middle-grade book in the [redacted] series under my former name, which was a fun project, though my current writing is strictly adult literary fiction.
Thanks in advance for your consideration.