r/PubTips • • 2h ago

[QCrit] THE OBSERVER EFFECT - Adult, LGBTQ/Literary, 106k words, Attempt 2

1 Upvotes

[Thanks to those of you who gave feedback on V1 last week. I’m relatively new to this sub and have learned that slower-paced literary fiction is not as common here, and therefore that a lot of the query feedback is really centered on saleability (all fine and good); I know my stakes seem “low”, but I’d be most grateful for feedback on whether the plot, as described here, makes sense and provokes the right kind of questions (i.e. that make an agent ask for more pages, rather than confuse them).

Related : I’m curious if anyone has experience with querying a book that has two (or more) distinct halves or parts with their own settings, stakes, conflicts, etc. The first half-ish of this book takes place before the MC’s transition, and the second half (not described here at all) takes place 10 years later when they’re in a very different place, emotionally and physically. Worrying that I’m only talking about the first half in my query may be just my own unoriginal fear of not trusting enough in my pages or the first half’s hook, but curious if anyone has advice to share on this specifically. Thanks in advance, and apologies if this question is too specific/too much to include in a query crit - please let me know and I can post separately.]

*****

Hi ___,

I read your wishlist on ___, and due to your interest in ___, you may be a great match to represent my literary novel THE OBSERVER EFFECT. 

Liv Wright has always tried to be good—loyal, kind, and selfless in her relationships—but the result of always putting other people first is that, at age 22, she still doesn’t know herself. She thinks all she wants is to get through her summer job as a farmhand in Pennsylvania and join her girlfriend Max in California when the season’s over, but when she meets Jane, her new boss, she catches a glimpse of a different possible future. 

Jane is a few years older, a few years wiser, and makes Liv feel safe in a way she never has before. Around Jane, Liv is different—braver, more curious, more herself. Or rather, as the weeks pass and the realization sets in, more himself. When Liv confesses to Jane one night that she sometimes feels more like him than her, Jane is unwaveringly supportive. By the end of the summer, Liv has it down bad for Jane, but, unwilling to hurt Max and jeopardize their relationship, she keeps her crush a secret.

Liv and Max move in together as planned, and Liv continues to people-please on autopilot for a couple years: she gets a boring job to pay the bills, and she ignores her weird gender feelings, afraid that telling Max will make it all too real. Liv and Jane stay in touch, exchanging rambling, goofy, heartwarming emails, letters that Liv finds herself looking forward to more than anything else. But when Jane stops writing back, Liv feels the loss too deeply and realizes she has to come out to someone: either tell Jane she’s in love with her, or tell Max about her gender. One way or another, she—or he—needs to be seen.

Complete at 106,000 words, The Observer Effect will appeal to readers of contemporary queer fiction, combining the earnest, poetic interiority of Denne Michele Norris’s When the Harvest Comes, the femme-forward cast of lovable characters in Emily St. James’s Woodworking, and Heated Rivalry’s hope-punk happy ending.

I’m a 40-year-old trans man who once spent a summer living on an off-grid farm in rural Pennsylvania. I have a BA in English from [redacted] College, and I co-own a communications and design agency with my best friend. I previously published a middle-grade book in the [redacted] series under my former name, which was a fun project, though my current writing is strictly adult literary fiction.

Thanks in advance for your consideration.


r/PubTips • • 48m ago

[QCRIT] Adult Fantasy - INTO THE GOLDEN TREE (103,000 words | Attempt 2)

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone and thank you so much for the feedback on my first attempt. I made some tweaks for tone and also agree with notes that I should specify what "kind" of fae are in this book, since there is so much faery fantasy going around right now. I know that you don't want to get too much into worldbuilding in query letters, so I hope not to overload with info while still getting across that this is more the old "fae are weirdos that can and will mess you up" vibe

Dear AGENT,

INTO THE GOLDEN TREE is an adult high fantasy novel with series potential complete at 103,000 words. It combines the dark fairytale atmosphere of T Kingfisher’s Nettle and Bone with the grittier fantasy adventure of works like Hannah Kaner’s Godkiller. It also takes inspiration from traditional Scottish folklore to craft a rich world of bizarre fae and mysterious magic.

Butterscotch is a nineteen-year-old girl who just wants to live a simple life in her rural village, far removed from any frightening clashes of lightning-wielding wizards and flame-bellowing dragons. Her one ambition is to become a midwife and finally prove—mostly to herself—that she’s not just the meek and useless girl whose mother died giving birth to her.

Then a fae interloper tries to steal a newborn. She thwarts him—but making an enemy of the fae is dangerous. Some can be kind, like scruffy broonies; others, like flesh-eating ogres and vicious royals, are downright monstrous. Soon, it is Butterscotch herself who is dragged away to the island fortress of the brutish Fae King.

From the dungeons, Butterscotch vows to return home to her family and community. However, the Glimmering Lady, the cruel royal sorceress, takes her as a servant for life. And the Lady does not easily let go of her playthings. To overcome the island’s magical barriers and escape, Butterscotch will need the generosity and skills of friends like a sly half-selkie and a slightly vampiric poet-wizard. Most importantly, Butterscotch will have to reach deep inside herself and grasp mettle and wits that she never knew she had.

But when the Fae King himself takes an insidious interest in her, Butterscotch must hurry and escape before he can use her for a gruesome ritual.

I am based out of sunny Los Angeles, and while I currently work in finance software, I aspire to be an author and hope this book will be a worthy debut.

Thank you, NAME


r/PubTips • • 13h ago

[QCRIT] Milk Bay - Adult Suspense / Thriller (81K/2nd attempt)

2 Upvotes

Hi all! After some valuable and much-needed feedback on a 1st attempt, I'm back with a second.

Dear [agent name]

I am seeking representation for MILK BAY, a completed 81,000-word thriller/ suspense novel. Its psychological tension and destination setting will appeal to readers of Sabine Durrant's Dead Heat, and its slow-burn pacing will resonate with readers of Jane Harper's Last One Out.

When Beth escapes her corporate life in London to undertake a solo sailing adventure around the Bahamas, she returns to the remote island of Milk Bay. It's the same island where a champion sailor vanished under mysterious circumstances several decades ago. Now a much-discussed cold case, no one has ever found out what happened to him. Did he vanish of his own accord? Or was he the victim of foul play?

The missing man is Beth's father, but she wants to keep that to herself for now. After all, she's not back at Milk Bay to play detective. Instead, she craves the freedom of sailing and the chance to relive her joyful childhood on Milk Bay – before her father vanished and her beloved sister began abusing drugs and alcohol.

The island is now being turned into a luxury destination, but Milk Bay's new owners welcome Beth with open arms, and Beth finds herself drawn into the fractured marriage of charismatic Max and his distant wife. When Jack, the island's construction manager, reveals he knows all about her missing father, Beth's secret is exposed, and she is confronted with the possibility that her father may not be dead after all.

As her sister cuts contact and her addiction spirals, Beth feels powerless to help. She starts abandoning the idea of a sailing trip so she can stay on Milk Bay, if only to continue basking in the glow of Max's attention.  

When a figure from the past shows up on the island – and later ends up dead  – Beth finds herself questioning whether the mystery of her father's disappearance is somehow connected. She begins a quest for answers with her new frenemy Jack, but it soon becomes clear that Milk Bay has a sourer side. As the island's idyllic image begins to shatter, Beth must decide if she's willing to dig up secrets that could potentially expose her and her family – or if some things are better left below the surface.


r/PubTips • • 21h ago

[QCrit] PROJECT SANDSTORM, Adult Fantasy 135k, 1st Attempt

5 Upvotes

Alright y’all. I’m completely terrified, but here it is. My query letter. I don’t know what I’m doing. I looked at dozens of query letters online and just kinda went off that. Help?

Dear…,
Twenty-seven-year-old Makia awoke in the desert five years ago with no memory and covered in magical tattoos. Since then, she has struggled to build a life and survive beneath the rule of the Federal Inquisitorial Authority, a brutal organization that has outlawed any magic unless explicitly sanctioned. 

Inquisitor Alex Lark has spent fifteen years hunting illegal magic users. He believes in the institution he serves, even if he doesn't always agree with its methods. So when Makia falls into his custody, she should be just another case: arrest her, file the right paperwork, and turn her over for interrogation. 

Except... no one seems to know what Makia is.

As Makia begins to recover her missing memories, Alex starts to question everything he has been taught about illegal magic users and the organization he has devoted his life to. After being forced to confront his own precarious designation within the Inquisition, Makia and Alex flee across the desert in search of answers, only to find their pasts are more intertwined than either imagined. It isn't long before they uncover the truth: they are both products of one doctor's twisted magical experiments. And if the Inquisition catches up with them, they will be handed back to the very man that created them. 

PROJECT SANDSTORM is an adult dark fantasy complete at approximately 135,000 words. It combines the forbidden-magic, slow-burn tension of The Jasad Heir with the institutional worldbuilding and magically altered bodies of The Tainted Cup. 

I have a background in law enforcement and have seen the system from the inside. I like to explore the darker themes of what happens when society slowly gives up more and more in the name of fear, and in pursuit of what they believe safety looks like. 

Thank you for your time and consideration. 


r/PubTips • • 2h ago

[QCrit] A Frozen Wheel, Adult Fantasy (120,000/ V4)

2 Upvotes

Hello readers! I would love to get feedback on this query letter. I think I've read these same words so many times that any changes I make start to feel strange. I still feel like I'm missing something, just a bit unsure about how to improve. Please help.

Dear [Agent],

I am seeking representation for A FROZEN WHEEL, an adult fantasy complete at 120,000 words. It is told through multiple points of view and is a standalone with series potential. It will appeal to readers who loved the hidden-survivor vengeance in Chinaza Bado’s BIRTH OF A DYNASTY as well as the ensemble scope of A SONG OF LEGENDS LOST by M.H. Ayinde. 

In the starving north, Eleanor Trint steals whatever her crew of thieves needs to get through the winter. Coins, bread, and, for the right price, a criminal off the King’s scaffold. She reads for thieves who can’t, drags Arlo, their leader, into prayers he doesn’t believe in, and keeps a list of nobles who burned her family home to ashes.

When a merchant hires her crew to snatch his son from an execution, the job goes wrong, and Eleanor ends up chained in a garrison warehouse, waiting to hang. Sure the thieves won’t risk their necks for her, she accepts a fellow prisoner’s offer to break her chains. The foreigner’s price is strange: the names of two brothers in her crew. She gives them up. That same night, Arlo and the crew storm the garrison to bring her home, just as northern raiders set it on fire. Eleanor gets close enough to see them through the smoke before the warehouse collapses on top of her. She awakens to a pair of southern mercenaries digging her out. Eleanor bargains her way into the mercenary company and discovers that the captain's road leads into the lands of House Jolt, the family that butchered hers.

Survival means smiling at a Jolt’s table and keeping her breathing steady around Lord Karl Jolt, a blind mage who can hear a lie in its rhythm. If he learns she’s the last daughter of a house the King branded traitors, she hangs. Every mile south takes her farther from any hope of finding Arlo, while bringing her closer to a revenge she has craved for six years. Worse still, the cunning blind lord she escorts feels less like an enemy with every conversation.

When a rebellion that wants the Jolts dead as badly as she does attacks the capital’s holiest festival, Eleanor must decide whether her vengeance is worth letting a man she has come to trust burn with them.


r/PubTips • • 2h ago

[QCrit] WHAT WE LEFT BEHIND, adult, upmarket, 80k, second attempt

2 Upvotes

Hello again! Thank you for the helpful feedback on my first attempt. I scraped most of it and rewrote. Please ignore comments on the title - I got some feedback on it from my first attempt and am brainstorming a possible new one.

First attempt here: https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/comments/1xm4i6s/qcrit_what_we_left_behind_adult_upmarket_80k/

Some questions. Does this fit upmarket positioning? While there is a strong romance plot, the book has themes beyond just their relationship.

My past queries were almost like a mini synopsis, so I'm hoping that this one is more character driven. Thoughts?

I have concerns about how the transition from their first break up to their reconcillation is handled, so any thoughts about that would be helpful as well.

TIA!!

Query:

After nine years and two heartbreaks, Blair and Elliott have finally become the people they once hoped to be — just without each other.

Inspired by the breakup songs we all keep on repeat, WHAT WE LEFT BEHIND is an upmarket women’s fiction novel, complete at 80,000 words. It combines the emotional intimacy and complex characters of Claire Daverley’s Talking at Night with the tension between enduring love and changing lives in Paige Toon’s Seven Summers.

Blair Bennett has spent her entire life looking forward – 307 days until she can leave her Vermont hometown, attend the Fashion Institute of Technology and escape her controlling father. But when charming and impulsive Elliott Harper strolls into history class ten minutes late, Blair finds herself wishing time would slow.

Between burned CDs that become their own language and late-night rooftop conversations, Elliott makes Blair feel like she doesn’t need to temper her ambition in order to be loved. But beneath Elliott’s performance is a boy who’s drowning: a grandmother slipping away, a mother who left, a drinking habit he keeps calling nothing. Still, Blair encourages him to imagine a future of his own.

As she chases her dreams in New York, Elliott pulls away, convinced he’ll only slow her down. Even after they reunite, Elliott's struggle with addiction threatens everything they’ve rebuilt. Blair refuses to give up on the person who always believed in her. She lies to her boss to leave early, stays up through the night to keep him from drinking, and slowly rearranges the life he once encouraged her to chase around keeping him afloat. Blair, who has always kept moving, stops.

When Elliott sees what his addiction is costing her, he ends things, refusing to ask her to wait for a version of him he isn’t sure exists.

Four years after their final breakup, Blair returns to Vermont for Elliott's grandmother’s funeral. Both have built lives without the other – Blair with a company of her own and Elliott nearly two years sober and studying to become a teacher. Seeing him again leaves Blair wondering if a second chance is something you’re allowed to ask for twice.

[bio]


r/PubTips • • 3h ago

[QCRIT] THERE'S CAKE IN THE BREAK ROOM, Corporate Horror Novel, 106k - 4th Attempt + First 300 Words

10 Upvotes

Hey everyone, thank you for the notes and comments on the previous attempt. This one has some big changes from previous, but I have received zero responses to this query letter (20 sent, 8R, 5CNR). I have also included the first 300 words below. Looking forward to your thoughts.

Dear [AGENT NAME]

The Backrooms meets Severance in THERE’S CAKE IN THE BREAKROOM, a speculative horror novel with weird fiction and science fiction elements complete at 106,000 words. This novel would fit comfortably alongside the character-driven existentialism of Sarah Rose Etter’s Ripe, the corporate terror of Nicholas Binge’s Abyss, and the liminal spaces of T. Kingfisher’s The Hollow Places.

The basement of Carson Tully’s office is growing even faster than his cancer. When the sudden disappearance of a coworker leads Carson to the dimensionally impossible and infinite office spaces beneath his workplace, he fears that the stress of his condition has finally driven him insane. Learning that his boss is the one who poisoned him just pushes him over the edge.

Betrayed and dying, Carson confronts his boss, only to snap and bludgeon him to death. He tries to turn himself in, but when the boss returns from the basement perfectly healed hours later, and with no memory of his own murder, Carson chooses to embrace this new reality. Because if the company can use these rooms to resurrect the dead, then maybe they can cure Carson’s leukemia, too.

Against the watchful eye of his enigmatic new manager, Ryan, Carson teams up with a contentious group of coworkers to understand this liminal dimension and learn exactly how the company cheats death. The answer could free them from the rat race forever, so long as Ryan doesn’t revoke Carson’s life-sustaining healthcare first. But corporate mercenaries and creatures wearing the wrong faces hunt anything that moves down there, and endless rooms imitate the past. Only by confronting the conspiracy at the heart of this company can Carson live to see his family’s future.

This novel was inspired by my experiences as an artist with disabilities trapped in a corporate environment. My short fiction is forthcoming in [magazine].

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Best Regards,

First 300 words:

“Can’t people tell when something isn’t human?” I ask my dashboard speakerphone.

“Ah, they used to,” the man in my car stereo answers. “Not so much anymore.”

In my windshield’s peripherals, Alejandro from Finance waits at the far end of the parking lot where asphalt meets forest and I refuse to look at him. I pretend, for the cameras along the windowless east wall, to see no one. Even if he’s beyond the company’s vision, I’m not.

“And when they can tell, they don’t really care. Some people still vibe with the artisanal stuff, but it’s like trying to sell TVs by promising to feed a kid in Texas for every unit sold. It’s cute, makes us feel good, but it doesn’t move any product. But hey, it’s your style they want. And you know what they say, something about imitation being the sincerest form of flattery?”

“Something like that,” I tell him.

A spared glance finds Ale, his proportions stretched in the curved edge of my windshield, unmoved. No cigarette or phone, just idling at the trash-rimmed forest behind our office tilting his head like a curious animal. It’s a shit place for a morning stroll unless you like stepping in a petri dish of coffee cups, so he must be here for me. Only, as far as Rintheon Blackforge is aware, we don’t know each other. So for him to risk being seen associating with me so openly can only mean something’s changed.

“Ultimately, Carson, it came down to speed,” the bookkeeper on the phone explains. “Happy couples want to see the first dance painted and polished before the reception ends, and human hands just can’t do it. You’ll always need a few days for touchups. But his thing just takes a command and–” the bookkeeper makes a clicking sound with his tongue.


r/PubTips • • 4h ago

[QCrit] ADULT Dark Fantasy - WHAT THE FOREST KEEPS (88K/First attempt)

6 Upvotes

This is my first attempt at a query letter. I am still revising and will be querying this in the new year but needed a little break from the editing (insert sweating emoji here).

I am seeking representation for WHAT THE FOREST KEEPS, an approximately 88,000-word adult folkloric dark fantasy novel. Combining the dark fairy-tale atmosphere of Slewfoot by Gerald Brom with the grotesque folkloric horror of The Salt Grows Heavy by Cassandra Khaw, it will appeal to readers drawn to gothic storytelling, unsettling transformations, and female-centred horror.

Odessa has spent her life learning how to keep things from breaking. Raised in a secluded, women-only village buried deep within the forests of Alryne, she has always struggled to find a purpose beyond the duties assigned to her by the Elders. She wants to be useful, to matter, to prove she is capable of more than the small life laid out for her. But in her village, a girl's place is decided long before she is old enough to question it. The world beyond the trees is forbidden, and the Elders insist their rules exist for her protection.

When her sister, Isabel, disappears, Odessa ventures beyond the village's boundaries to find her. But the forest is not the empty wilderness she was warned about. Her search exposes a horror the Elders have spent generations concealing: heartbreak transforms girls into unicorns and Isabel's transformation has already begun. Worse, the village has been secretly supplying the city beyond the forest with transformed girls in exchange for its own protection. The Elders have spent generations maintaining the conditions that make these transformations possible, delivering the resulting creatures to be slaughtered for the magic in their bodies.

But the city isn't the only thing that wants Isabel. The forest has watched its magic being harvested for generations, and it wants its daughters returned. The city sees unicorns as a source of eternal beauty. The village sees them as a necessary sacrifice. The forest sees them as its own, and it has no intention of letting them go.

As Odessa's search brings her closer to Reve, a unicorn hunter from the city, she finds herself drawn to the very man whose livelihood depends on hunting girls like her sister. Reve is everything she has been taught to fear, yet trusting him may be her only chance of finding Isabel. But allowing herself to love him carries its own terrifying consequence.

To save her sister, Odessa must uncover the truth behind the village's bargain before the city claims Isabel and the forest claims her. But if the forest gets what it wants, Odessa may not have a human body left to save.


r/PubTips • • 4h ago

[QCRIT] BURNED OVER COUNTRY - Adult Sci-Fi Thriller - 110k V3

2 Upvotes

Dawg, queries are hard. Thanks so much to this community for getting me closer to a draft that I don't loathe.

---

Dear [Agent]:

The year is 2647.  Vivian Vought has trained her whole life to be a mercenary just like her father—martial arts, firearms, aerospace combat—and now she has what she’s always wanted: a chance to prove herself to him. 

On her father’s orders, Vivian infiltrates a dangerous nomadic mining convoy on Mercury to extract Hale Bauer, the charming, rebellious son of the planet’s despotic president.

But Vivian’s undercover work shows her that the convoy isn’t some ruthless criminal cartel like her father described.  She learns that it is a battered but joyful community, struggling against systemic prejudice.  And it’s not long before Vivian finds herself powerfully drawn toward the handsome young man she’s been charged with capturing.  As Vivian finds both friends and love on the convoy, she begins to question everything she's ever trained to be.

Then her father arrives, committing unspeakable atrocities.

Barely escaping her father's attack in a fast spaceship with a tight knit group of her closest friends, Vivian must make a choice: betray what's left of her newfound family or join Hale and turn the tables on the monsters who raised them.  A slow burn romance packed with rousing action and daring rescues, BURNED OVER COUNTRY tells the story of two young lovers on the run, pitted against a despicable autocracy in a transhumanist dystopia. 

 

BIO:  I am a graduate of the MFA Creative Writing program at Purdue University. I wrote Obsidian: A Star Wars Story, a widely read Star Wars fanfiction, and my short story “Hoosier Jesus” will be featured in a forthcoming episode of the NoSleep podcast.  I live in Minneapolis, Minnesota, and BURNED OVER COUNTRY is partly inspired by the 2026 Metro Surge operation and the resistance to it in my community.


r/PubTips • • 4h ago

[QCrit] BEYOND THE LIGHT OF GOD, Epic Fantasy, Adult, 115K, 6th attempt

3 Upvotes

Hello! This is now my 6th attempt. I've significantly shortened the blurb and implemented the notes from my previous post as well as I'm able. Please let me know if there are any other issues.

1st attempt: https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/comments/1wt2c2b/qcrit_beyond_the_light_of_god_epic_fantasy_adult/

2nd attempt:

https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/comments/1x03hz1/qcrit_beyond_the_light_of_god_epic_fantasy_adult/

3rd attempt:

https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/comments/1x614d6/qcrit_beyond_the_light_of_god_epic_fantasy_adult/

4th attempt: https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/comments/1xbtkzm/qcrit_beyond_the_light_of_god_epic_fantasy_adult/

5th attempt:

https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/comments/1xtoosa/qcrit_beyond_the_light_of_god_epic_fantasy_adult/

Dear [Agent],

BEYOND THE LIGHT OF GOD is a multi-POV 115,000‑word epic fantasy novel. It will appeal to readers of Richard Swan’s The Justice of Kings and John Gwynne’s The Shadow of the Gods, blending morally complex characters, mythic forces, and the brutal realities of war.

For generations, Linias' family has failed to produce a child worthy of joining the empire's elite warrior order. Yet after years of gruelling training, he finally earns the blessings and power of the Stargod. On his first mission, Linias is sent to subjugate one of the last peoples still resisting Imperial rule within a vast forest. When the locals and their shadowy allies, known as the Lightless, ambush Linias, he's injured, losing connection to his blessings and the divine bloodlust that once fueled his hatred.

Captured by the Lightless, Linias expects torture or death. Instead, he discovers that these demonic figures from legend are flesh-and-blood people with fears, loyalties, and scars of their own. As they expose him to the suffering inflicted in the Stargod's name, the certainties that guided his life begin to unravel. Though Linias tells himself he's only staying with the Lightless to gather information, he finds it increasingly difficult to see his supposed enemies as anything other than people fighting for their survival.

Complications deepen when he meets the heir to the last free human nation. Desperate to save her people, the princess has crossed half a continent hoping to ally with the reclusive forest dwellers, but generations of mistrust threaten to doom the alliance before it begins. As the two grow closer, Linias falls for the future queen of his sworn enemies, further fracturing his loyalties. To free his people from the Stargod's control, Linias must betray everything he once fought for and unite the last nations still resisting the alien deity's rule. If he fails, he will deliver the world into the hands of the very god he once served.

I hold a Bachelor of Arts degree in Psychology, which I put to great use while working in the IT department for an insurance company. I currently reside in the windswept [LOCATION] prairies with my wife, twin girls, and two cats.

My fiction has recently appeared in [PUBLICATION NAME], [PUBLICATION NAME], and [PUBLICATION NAME]. My short story, [STORY NAME], received an honourable mention for the [AWARD NAME].

Thank you for your time and consideration.


r/PubTips • • 5h ago

[QCrit] TAKE HER TO THE RUINS, adult horror-fantasy, ~70K, V1

3 Upvotes

I'm currently revising this one with a view to querying in the New Year, so word count might well change before I start sending it out, but thought I'd try to get a jump on the query itself!

Dear Agent,

Abigail Cross could be the poster child for Good Girl Syndrome. All her life she’s been the obedient eldest daughter to her ultra-religious parents. She keeps her own desires hidden from her family until she’s outed as gay by a drunken university classmate and unceremoniously booted out of church and home.

With no idea what to do next, she gets on one bus then another, finally washing up in the Cornish seaside town of Pelcastle. It’s desolate in the off-season, but one bright light attracts Abi like a moth: local weirdo and ‘cunning woman’ Sylver Curnow. Sylver is eccentric, outspoken, and unabashedly queer, everything Abi wishes she was. And her business isn’t all herbal teas and tarot cards. She taps into a real power for which there’s no rational explanation.

Sparks fly between them. With Sylver, Abi learns to relax and opens her mind to the occult. But as their relationship deepens, she finds out that Sylver’s power is tied to an old family curse which is slowly killing her. Sylver is resigned to her fate and not above using her abilities to keep Abi from getting involved. Abi wakes one morning to find her old life magically restored, her family convinced she never left. 

She could stay with them, hide her true self and go back to being a good Christian daughter. It’s tempting. But if she’s going to break the curse and save the woman she’s come to love, Abi will have to stop trying to be good and start fighting for what she wants.

Complete at 70,000 words, TAKE HER TO THE RUINS is an adult contemporary horror-fantasy for readers who loved the witchy self-discovery of Rachel Harrison’s CACKLE or the sapphic horror of Chuck Tingle’s CAMP DAMASCUS – as well as anyone whose queer awakening was Fairuza Balk in THE CRAFT!

[Bio stuff to be added.]


r/PubTips • • 7h ago

[QCrit] COURTING TROUBLES, Adult Fantasy Rom-Com, 100K, version 2

2 Upvotes

Hello friends! Your suggestions were incredibly helpful, thank you! Here's version 2 ( V1 here). I believe I've incorporated most of the feedback, focusing on filmable actions, specificity, and clarifying language. Total WC for the letter is 350. Looking forward to your critiques!

I seek representation for COURTING TROUBLES, a spicy fantasy rom-com about magical rivals who accidently soul-bond after a one-night stand. A dual-POV stand alone complete at 100K words, it's perfect for readers of Tiffany Hunt's The Dark Lord's Guide to Dating and Brigette Knightley's The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy.
In the 26th century, technology is banned and science considered superstition. After several years of research abroad, Persephone Arellan returns to Eldfast to lead the terropox initiative. Her archaeomedical research, merging 21st century medicine with magic, will save lives. Surely that outweighs her 'lowly' origins and minor, mostly accidental role in sending nobles to prison. With dying parents to hide, stalkers to evade, and a magical glass ceiling to shatter, romance is the last thing on her mind.
Tarquin Fitzroy encouraged Persephone's departure after his father's imprisonment, desperate to protect his crush rival from the cabal who set his father up. Tarquin becomes bloody good at vengeance, and a playboy persona is the perfect cover. 
Persephone's work makes her a target (again).Tarquin ambushes her for information, but years of mutual pining end in a (debauched) one-night stand.
Persephone won't be distracted by a dalliance with a rake. Tarquin assumes his interest is (still) unrequited, until he learns about the rare Fitzroy mating bond. It's been activated, and Persephone is his true magical match.
Tarquin foils an attempt on her life at a press conference (along with his romantic aspirations). Persephone's furious he ruined her career-defining moment, suspicious of his motives and the alleged soul-bond. 
Anti-science violence erupts in Eldfast. Persephone must cure her dying parents, even if it topples the nobles—and Tarquin's family. Tarquin must convince Persephone he's worthy of courting her whilst relying on his morally dubious skills to keep her safe. As they reckon with their complicated past, a pesky soul-bond, and a shadowy organization intent on magical supremacy, they realize their future—and Eldfast's— is at stake.

(bio)


r/PubTips • • 15h ago

[QCRIT] RAZING A BETTER LIFE, adult, comic noir, 89k #2

2 Upvotes

RAZING A BETTER LIFE is an 89,000-word dark humour noir set in gentrifying Old Toronto, where "Sorry!" comes with a shove. It combines the wry voice and absurd choices in Elle Cosimano’s Finlay Donovan Is Killing It with a noir protagonist seeking redemption from one "murder" by solving another. 

When "Lynx" Auger's wife besmirches his manliness then tumbles off a coastal ledge, he doesn't reach for her outstretched hand. Her cousin calls that murder. Lynx heads overseas to lose himself in odd jobs but he can't escape his shame. His grandfather had saved a drunk from an oncoming train. As taunting voices emerge inside Lynx's head, he loses hope. In one last check of his email, he finds only mistakenly-addressed messages, like a summer job offer meant for a café boss's lazy niece. In an absurd strategy to live another day, he spends his last dollar to fly home and claim the job.

The bemused boss lets Lynx talk his way into the job and an evening of hope, but the next morning turns up gassed to death by a sabotaged coffee roaster. While the absent co-owner is distracted by a day job, Lynx keeps showing up to serve an agoraphobic musician who comes out for coffee, and a skittish call girl who hopes that saving the café will complete her MBA. 

Detective Mak dismisses the murder, and targets the café for his side hustle of extortion and money laundering in the city's overheated real estate market. His fledgling gang shuts down Lynx's café fantasy with a shower of bullets, then pressures the indebted co-owner to offload the property cheap. Determined to clean up the chaos threatening his café delusion, Lynx discovers a long list of people wronged by the café boss, and their connections to a network of insurance fraud bankrolling Mak's growing empire. When Mak has Lynx beaten and reignites a public campaign to punish him for his wife's "murder", Lynx's new friends expose Mak's impossibly lavish lifestyle, and raze his ginseng greenhouse.

Lynx can end the spiralling violence by surrendering to his self-destructive voices. Or he can be more like Grandfather by solving the murder of a flawed man who gave him hope, and bringing down a cop who preys on the wounded.

My story "Veneer" was published in The Maple Tree Literary Supplement. In my gentrifying patch of city life, I've cranked up the TV to drown out gunfire, then skirted the crime scene to fetch a disappointing croissant. 

Thank you for your time and consideration.


r/PubTips • • 17h ago

[QCrit] VIXENS, NA Dystopian Romance 81k, 1st Attempt

4 Upvotes

Greetings! This is my first attempt at any query. Kind of nervous about what's to come. But I appreciate any feedback you could give me! Hopefully I will have the courage to post the 300 words next time once I hash it out.

Dear *****

VIXENS is an 81k standalone NA dystopian-romance with series potential. It combines the sexy, at-odds love triangle of Ariel Sullivan’s Conform and the fast-paced Orwellian action of Aisling Rawle’s The Compound. A great choice for anyone looking for the vibes of Brooke Fast’s To Cage A Wild Bird with a celebrity wrestling twist.

Twenty-two-year-old Liara has spent the last decade keeping her head down. After her parents were executed for rebelling against the Axiom's oppressive regime, she learned that survival means keeping quiet and protecting the new family who took her in. But when she inadvertently kills a powerful politician to save her best friend, Liara finds herself facing the same fate as her parents.

Her salvation comes from an unlikely source: Krane, a charming and enigmatic member of the city's elite who offers her a way out of execution. The price? Becoming his Vixen, a contestant in the Axiom's brutal televised women's fighting league. Forced into the spotlight, Liara must survive deadly competitions and become the public figure the Axiom wants her to be if she ever hopes to earn her freedom and return home.

But the arena isn't the only place Liara's loyalties will be tested. Reunited with Parmer, her long-lost childhood confidant, she discovers he's become the leader of a growing rebellion. As her connection to Krane deepens and her feelings for Parmer resurface, Liara is caught between two men whose worlds threaten everything she believes in. With her family's lives hanging in the balance, she may have to decide just how much of herself she's willing to sacrifice to save them…and herself.


r/PubTips • • 17h ago

[QCRIT] 10,000 Years Aboard Osiris Station | Adult Sci-fi Thriller | 60k | fourth attempt

2 Upvotes

Thank you everyone for the support and feedback so far. I have rewritten the blurb from the ground up! I've had time to send this version out in my first batch (10) and got one partial request and five rejections so far, so I'm feeling better about it, but I would love some fresh eyes.

Dear [Agent],

10,000 YEARS ABOARD OSIRIS STATION is a standalone sci-fi complete at 60,000 words.

Mr. Draper Thorne’s title is Chief Liaison, but their alien masters, and the fledgling human resistance, know him as the Propagandist of Osiris Station. A decade ago, parasitic aliens enslaved humanity to serve as hosts. But Mr. Thorne offered his expertise in service of his people’s oppression. In return, they spared his family… for now.

The resistance plots the destruction of the alien station, but first they need Mr. Thorne out of the way—or on their side. When the former fails, they try the latter. The resistance knows a secret Thorne does not: his family vanished years ago, and the aliens have been lying to him. He's convinced and takes up arms with the resistance, hell bent on revenge.

But his family did not vanish completely. The resistance rescued his son, Caden, and trained him as a formidable fighter. Caden arrives with a new plan: capture Osiris for the resistance. He needs his dad’s help if they’re going to beat the odds. Now Mr. Thorne must use his expertise to broker a deal that can save the station, his son, and the last remnants of his species.

Osiris explores has the complex political conflict and shifting alleigances of Ocean's Godori (2024), and the painful and nonlinear process of deradicalization after the destruction of our homeworld like in Tesh's Some Desperate Glory (2023).

I've spent my career in Mr. Thorne's shoes, working as a political media consultant for a decade. I am a sci-fi writer telling stories for readers who understand there are no easy solutions in politics.

[more bio]


r/PubTips • • 22h ago

[QCRIT] MG contemporary, THE PAPER FOOTBALL KING (35k, second attempt)

3 Upvotes

(My first attempt at a query was many months ago. I've since reworked the story.)

THE PAPER FOOTBALL KING is a 35,000-word contemporary middle-grade novel.

Power corrupts, even in the fifth grade.

When Ray gets in trouble for playing paper football in detention, he’s forced to sit in a dark room in his school’s basement called the Dungeon. Through a vent, he realizes he can hear the teachers eating lunch in the teachers’ lounge. After overhearing a juicy piece of gossip about the most athletic boy in school, Ray writes it on a freshly-made paper football. Nothing will come of it, he thinks.

But when some boys find the paper football a week later, they start a club where they collect the school’s darkest secrets and write them inside their Paper Football Manifesto. Ray’s unsure about being part of such a club, but maybe now he’ll finally make some friends instead of just being seen as a weirdo. With secrets comes power, and their club soon takes over the school. Which class wins the dodgeball tournament, who gets to be class president, who’s invited to birthday parties—the club controls it all, and anyone who doesn’t like it gets their secrets spilled to the whole school.

After the king of the club goes mad with power, a snowball fight uprising, and a vicious assassination (well, a depantsing in front of the whole class might as well be murder), Ray becomes the new king, earning popularity and the responsibility of wielding the Paper Football Manifesto with all its secrets. Unless he can resist the temptations of being king, his club might tear Northern Elementary apart.