r/QuantifiedSelf • • 1d ago

Weekly Lifestyle Data and Analytics App Thread

5 Upvotes

Post your apps here, and please support people bringing unique ideas to this space.


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 2h ago

Summary of research on the "most accurate" health wearable by metric (2026). Oura Ring, Apple Watch, Fitbit, Garmin, Samsung Galaxy Watch, WHOOP, Polar, etc.

Post image
6 Upvotes

I try to put together an updated version of this post once a year. The goal of this post is to find the most accurate wearable for each metric, using multiple validation studies that test devices against medical-grade equipment, mostly from independent researchers.

It covers sleep, HRV, resting and exercise heart rate, blood oxygen, steps, calories, VO2 max and breathing rate. The summary table is first, then the data for each metric, with caveats and linked sources at the end. Brand-funded studies and early research are marked.

I also built a free page that goes deeper into the data and lets you compare brands side by side. Full disclosure, it’s my site but I don't paywall anything and don't run ads: https://www.kygo.app/tools/wearable-accuracy

MASTER SUMMARY TABLE

Biometric 🥇 Winner 🥈 Second 🥉 Third
Sleep Stages Oura (0.65 agreement) Apple Watch (0.60) Fitbit (0.55)
Sleep Timing Fitbit (-3 min, 68% of wake caught) Oura (-9 min, 69%) Apple Watch (+8 min, 52%)
Nocturnal HRV Oura (5.96% error) WHOOP (8.17%) Garmin (10.52%)
Resting Heart Rate Oura (1.94% error) Polar (2.71%) WHOOP (3.00%)
Exercise Heart Rate Apple Watch (2.51 bpm off) Garmin (2.93 bpm) Fitbit (3.89 bpm)
SpO2 Apple Watch (2.2 points off) Samsung (3.8) Garmin (4.1)
Step Count Garmin (+3%) Apple Watch (+7%) Samsung (10.5% error)
Calories (weight training) Fitbit (41.7% off) Samsung (84.5%) Apple Watch (112.2%)
VO2 Max Garmin (6.7% error) Google Pixel (8.65%) Apple Watch (13.2%)
Respiratory Rate Fitbit (within 1 breath/min) WHOOP (+0.1) -

DETAILED DATA BY METRIC

1. SLEEP STAGES (agreement on a 0 to 1 scale, 1 = perfect)

Device Agreement Deep Sleep Caught REM Caught
Oura Ring Gen 3 0.65 79.5% 76.0%
Apple Watch Series 8 0.60 50.5% 82.6%
Fitbit Sense 2 0.55 61.7% 67.6%
WHOOP 3.0* 0.44 62% 66%
Samsung Galaxy Watch 5* 0.42 47.5% 62.7%
Polar Vantage V* 0.28 33% 49%
Garmin Forerunner 245* 0.25 28% 50%
  • Source: Robbins 2024 (top 3), 35 adults, one night in a sleep lab, Oura-funded. Others: Miller 2022 (WHOOP, Polar, Garmin), Lee 2023 (Samsung)
  • Note: \From separate studies, so compare loosely. An independent preprint also ranks Oura first.*

2. SLEEP TIMING (does it know when you were asleep vs awake)

Device Total Sleep Wake Time Caught
Fitbit Sense 2 -3 min 68%
Oura Ring Gen 3 -9 min 69%
Apple Watch Series 8 +8 min 52%
WHOOP 3.0* -12 min 56%
Polar Vantage V* -1 min 51%
Garmin Forerunner 245* +44 min 27%
  • Source: Robbins 2024 (top 3), Oura-funded. Others: Miller 2022
  • Note: Ranked across six timing measures. Fitbit and Oura are very close. \Separate studies.*

3. NOCTURNAL HRV

Device Error (MAPE) Agreement (CCC, 1 = perfect)
Oura Ring 4 5.96% 0.99
WHOOP 4.0 8.17% 0.94
Garmin Fenix 6 10.52% 0.87
Polar Grit X Pro 16.32% 0.82
  • Source: Dial 2025, 13 adults, 536 nights vs a chest strap. No industry funding
  • Note: The Oura vs WHOOP gap was not statistically significant. Apple wasn't tested.

4. RESTING HEART RATE

Device Error (MAPE)
Oura Ring 4 1.94%
Polar Grit X Pro 2.71%
WHOOP 4.0 3.00%
  • Source: Dial 2025 (same study as HRV)
  • Note: Polar and WHOOP are within noise of each other. Garmin was excluded due to a data issue.

5. EXERCISE HEART RATE

Device Cycling (avg error) Rest to Walking (MAPE)
Apple Watch Series 8 / SE 2.51 bpm 7.3%
Garmin Forerunner 955 / Vivoactive 5 2.93 bpm 6.3%
Fitbit Sense 2 / Charge 6 3.89 bpm 5.5%
Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 3.38 bpm -
Polar Ignite 3 - 11.2%
Oura Ring Gen 3 - 15.0%
  • Sources: Kostrna 2026a (cycling, NSF-funded), Gielen 2026 (10-device test), Van Oost 2025 (WHOOP), Jeong 2026 (Samsung treadmill)
  • Note: The top four are within a few percent. Samsung came last in a separate treadmill test, so it misses the top 3. WHOOP 4.0 was 8.52% off on a treadmill.

6. BLOOD OXYGEN (SpO2)

Device Points Off FDA Benchmark (3.5) / ISO Limit (4.0)
Apple Watch Series 8 2.2 Within both
Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 3.8 ISO only
Garmin Fenix 6 Pro 4.1 Outside both
  • Sources: Walzel 2023 (Apple, Samsung, low-oxygen lab test); Helmer 2024 (Garmin, 12 ward patients)
  • Note: No watch is FDA-cleared for blood oxygen. Oura and WHOOP have no peer-reviewed test.

7. STEP COUNT

Device Overcount or Error
Garmin +3%
Apple Watch +7%
Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 10.5%
Fitbit +15%
Polar Vantage V / M 72%
  • Source: Paluch 2026 meta-analysis of 59 studies (Garmin, Apple, Fitbit); Hong 2024 (Samsung), Henriksen 2022 (Polar)
  • Note: Garmin, Apple and Fitbit figures are average overcounts; Samsung and Polar are error figures from single studies. Oura's step figures predate its 2025 algorithm update, so they aren't ranked.

8. CALORIES

Device Weight Training Cycling Max Treadmill*
Fitbit 41.7% (Charge 5) 31.7% (Sense 2) 13.97% (Charge 6)
Samsung 84.5% (Galaxy Watch 5) 66.5% (Galaxy Watch 5) 9.42% (Galaxy Watch 7)
Apple Watch 112.2% (Series 8) 35.7% (Series 8) 25.95% (Ultra 2)
Garmin 114.9% (Vivosmart 5) 77.6% (Forerunner 955) 14.65% (Forerunner 265S)
  • Sources: Yun 2026 (weight training, 70 men), Kostrna 2026b (cycling, 58 adults), Perez 2025 (*conference abstract)
  • Note: Ranked on weight training and cycling; Samsung's lower treadmill figure comes from the abstract-only study. No wearable is a precise calorie counter, especially for lifting.

9. VO2 MAX

Device Error (MAPE)
Garmin Forerunner 245 6.7%
Google Pixel Watch 3 8.65%
Apple Watch Series 10 13.2%
Polar Vantage M2 13.7%
  • Sources: Engel 2025 (Garmin), Lambe 2026a (Pixel), Lambe 2026b (Apple), Neudorfer 2025 (Polar), Jamieson 2024 (Garmin wrist only)
  • Note: Garmin's error was far higher without a chest strap. The Pixel study was Google-funded. Apple reads low.

10. RESPIRATORY RATE

Device Result
Fitbit Charge 4 +0.3 to +1.0 breaths/min
WHOOP 2.0 +0.1 breaths/min (WHOOP-funded)
  • Note: Fitbit from Hermans 2024, WHOOP from Berryhill 2020. Garmin failed in hospital patients (Knevels 2026, Helmer 2024) and Apple gave no readings (Helmer 2024, AbiMansour 2024). Skin temperature isn't ranked: no brand has an independent sensor test.

IMPORTANT CAVEATS

  1. No single device wins everything. Oura leads most overnight metrics; Apple, Garmin and Fitbit split the rest.
  2. The main sleep study was Oura-funded. Its methods are sound, and an independent preprint also ranks Oura first.
  3. Validation studies often take 1 to 3 years to publish, so tested models usually lag behind current ones. Newer models may do better.
  4. Samples are small: 35 people for sleep, 13 for HRV and resting heart rate.
  5. Calories are weak on every device. Use them as a rough trend.
  6. Skin tone, tattoos, fit and wrist position all affect accuracy.

SOURCES


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 1h ago

This Scientist Measures Everything in Life - Presentation @ Pint Of Science

Thumbnail youtu.be
• Upvotes

Old, but gold speech on radical QS. It seems like it hasn't been posted here before.

Accidentally found this talk on The Quantified Scientist channel many of you are probably familiar with there. He's doing an accuracy test for wearables.

Unfortunately, it seems like he did not continue posting more on this experience.


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 1d ago

Using Full Medical Records for Optimization

5 Upvotes

I have put significant time into collecting all of my medical records and now have 1659 pages from all of my primary care, specialists, blood test, insurance, and more! I think I might be most extensive N=1 random 23 yo on the internet in terms of understanding my own health.

I originally collected these for figuring out how my chronic issues (asthma, allergies, reflux) are related and how to best address them. They have been super helpful for that and I now want to move onto optimizing my health from a longevity POV.

Do you guys have any ideas of things I should look for (well AI will do the looking) or things I should try to track for optimization over all of this data? Thanks in advance!

P.S. I am thinking about making my record collection tool open source so others can use it to collect and look at all of their records. This will be a bit of work though so if anyone is interested lmk and I will work to make this happen.


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 1d ago

Anyone connecting their Oura data to ChatGPT or Claude?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/QuantifiedSelf • • 2d ago

What have you learned from tracking that you wouldn’t have noticed otherwise?

6 Upvotes

I started tracking my blood pressure, resting heart rate and workouts after a heart diagnosis a couple of years ago. Over time I’ve noticed some things seem to help and some I’ve learned to avoid, but it’s mostly been me eyeballing patterns.

For those of you who track health stuff alongside exercise, sleep, supplements or whatever else, what have you actually discovered? And how do you tell a real pattern from noise?


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 2d ago

Y’all really didn’t like the tap task - what about this?

Thumbnail quantifiedminds.vercel.app
1 Upvotes

There are 24 total activities so feel free to explore to find one that measures something interesting to you.

Each test measures a different combination of cognitive functions.


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 2d ago

How fast can you tap in 30 seconds?

Thumbnail quantifiedminds.vercel.app
4 Upvotes

Working on a way to track brain health, locally on your computer, using IndexedDB. One of the games is how fast you can tap in 30 seconds. Post your scores in the comments


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 2d ago

Is your bedroom too warm for your heart?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/QuantifiedSelf • • 2d ago

I've been so busy keeping track of my mom that I barely keep track of myself

Post image
2 Upvotes

Between shifts and taking care of my mom, most days feel like one long to-do list: Did she eat? when's the next appointment? what do we need to pick up? how's she been doing... It's all just running in my head.

I'm an administrative assistant, so the workdays are busy on their own. I kept telling myself I'd write it all down at the end of the day. By the time I got home I was too tired to write anything, and I never stuck with it.

I looked back at what I'd actually logged in recently and there was almost nothing there. Today's numbers were 5h32m of sleep, 3,464 steps, sleep score 69.

Sleep's been rough. Mom's been unwell and I worry about her a lot, and work's been hectic too. I can't really tell how much is that and how much is just being overloaded.

I'm still not tracking every day. I'm just trying to make it less of a chore, because the last thing I need is my own health. Turning into another item on the list I feel bad about not finishing.

I'm hoping next month gets a bit steadier, mentally more than anything. For anyone else juggling work and caregiving, what actually helps you sleep when your mind won't switch off?


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 2d ago

We track sleep and HRV. Light exposure? We've been guessing it

2 Upvotes

I've spent the last year building out a fairly instrumented daily tracking setup. Oura for sleep, Whoop for HRV. For most inputs I have numbers and at least a rough sense of whether what I'm doing is working.

However, light is the exception. I go outside in the morning. I dim lights at night. I have no data on any of it. That gap started bothering me when I looked at what the research says we should be targeting. Brown et al. 2022 published consensus recommendations for healthy adults: daytime above 250 melanopic EDI at the eye, under 10 in the three hours before sleep, under 1 during sleep. Melanopic EDI is not the same as lux. Lux measures photopic brightness, weighted to how the eye perceives visible light overall. Melanopic EDI (m-EDI) uses a different spectral weighting, centered on ~480nm, tuned to what the melanopsin/ipRGC system responds to. Two light sources can have the same lux and very different m-EDI values. A 2700K warm lamp and a 6500K cool lamp are a good example: similar lux, different circadian signal. Phone lux apps estimate photopic illuminance using the front-facing camera sensor. The estimates are rough (camera sensors aren't photometrically calibrated), and none of them attempt m-EDI. I haven't found a consumer tool that measures m-EDI at the eye. Research-grade spectroradiometers do, but they cost thousands and nobody's carrying one around.

Then there's UV. A lot of people in this sub track vitamin D through blood tests, but almost nobody measures their actual UV exposure throughout the day. UV-A passes through window glass unevenly, so your indoor UV near a window is more variable than you'd think, and it drops to almost nothing a few feet away. If you're trying to understand your vitamin D picture beyond a quarterly blood draw, real-time UV data would give you a much better sense of how much you're actually getting.

Is the light tracking neccessary in your experience? Where and why would you use it?

Disclosure:I'm the co-founder of Onda. We're building a phone accessory with calibrated sensors for m-EDI, lux, and UV. You place it once, take a reading, get all three channels. Nothing to sell yet. I'm posting here because I want to pressure-test the concept with people who care about measurement methodology


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 3d ago

Continue improving my metrics logging app, this time with Garmin integration

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

I just finished the Garmin integration, so now you can pull values straight from your watch! Before this, I used Apple Health as a middleman for most of my metrics, but now everything comes in directly.

I’ve also added an “Activities” habit. The idea is to have one single habit that shows all your Garmin activities for the day. For example, if you went for a walk and a bike ride around your neighbourhood, you’ll see both. If you hiked and walked the next day, same thing.

To make this work, I used the “select list” habit type, and you can always adjust it manually.

Next up: more and more integrations. One of my goals is to build a kind of “workflow” builder. Say you have several integrations that all track your step count, but you only want one habit that keeps the highest value. That’ll be possible soon!

https://habitpocket.io/

I would love to hear some of your feedback and maybe ideas of what integrations I should build or new features would be usefull to have?


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 3d ago

Follow-up: you said a face camera shouldn’t copy what my ring already tracks. We listened. What would make the new version trustworthy?

2 Upvotes

Last month I asked what would make you trust a mirror doing a 1-minute morning heart rate and breathing reading on top of your wearable. The answer was blunt: your ring or watch already has HR, breathing and skin temp 24/7, so a one-minute camera reading is just worse data.

u/ChristianKl’s comment changed our direction: build around what only a face camera can see, like skin that changes day to day. u/TrickyAirport5867 added that we should figure out what the method can actually measure before asking anyone to trust it.

So we dropped vitals and wearable sync. Lumi now does a ~20 second skin read (redness, breakouts, dark spots and uneven tone, shine, fine lines, dark circles), with polarized light so glare doesn’t hide redness. Limits we’re setting on purpose:

  • hydration is asked, not measured, because a camera can’t really see it
  • pores and texture only show as a trend, never a one-off score
  • it never names a condition
  • we’re testing across skin tones before anyone relies on it

The first version lives in pharmacy skincare aisles. A QR code saves your routine and progress photos to your phone, so repeat scans become a trend.

Questions for people who track everything:

  1. What accuracy or validation would you want published before you’d believe a skin read? Comparison against a dermatologist? Repeat-scan consistency?
  2. If you tracked your skin over weeks, what would you want out of it? Raw photos, a score per area, a CSV export?
  3. How would you want us to show that a change is real and not just lighting or time of day?
  4. Is there anything else a face camera could measure that your wearables can’t, which we should be looking at?

r/QuantifiedSelf • • 3d ago

Homebrew Sleep Study App

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/QuantifiedSelf • • 3d ago

Use a sleep tracker or glucose monitor? Share your app experience with Berkeley students (U.S., 18+)

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/QuantifiedSelf • • 3d ago

Sleep Study App

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/QuantifiedSelf • • 3d ago

I built a private mood diary for Windows – local database, no cloud, works offline

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi! I’m the developer of MoodTracker. I made it because I take medication to support my mental health, and I wanted a simple way to track my mood over time and see whether the meds are actually working.

What it does:

  • rate your mood 1–10 with one click, log medications and thoughts
  • calendar coloured by mood, statistics for any period
  • everything stays on your PC – local database, no ads, no tracking

It’s a one-time purchase on the Microsoft Store with a free 15 days trial.

I’d love feedback on whether there’s demand for an app like this, especially among people in mental health treatment or biohackers tracking the effects of their supplements.

Is the price appropriate for this app?

https://arronax23.github.io/moodtracker-app/
https://apps.microsoft.com/detail/9PDT5LCNSN78?cid=reddit-quantified-self


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 4d ago

If you could track only 3 health metrics for a year, which would you choose?

9 Upvotes

Imagine you had to simplify your entire biohacking setup and could track only three metrics for the next 12 months.
No endless dashboards, no buying a new wearable every few months, and no collecting data just because it's available.
Would you choose sleep duration, resting heart rate, blood pressure, strength progression, body composition, blood glucose, or something else?
I'd probably prioritize metrics that are reliable, actionable, and connected to meaningful health outcomes rather than numbers that look impressive in an app.
I'm curious how people here would approach this. Which three would you choose, why, and what would you actually change based on the results?
Bonus question: Which commonly tracked metric do you think people overinterpret?


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 4d ago

Started tracking my net worth this year and it was humbling

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/QuantifiedSelf • • 5d ago

Building a developer tier for a wearable

5 Upvotes

Reaching out to you guys since it seems you're the OG of processing health data, and I'm at an impasse.

We were recently at TC Disrupt pitching our wearable and got a lot of interest from people building health apps, but are basically beholden to integrations and developer access to products on the market. e.g. people trying to build a meditation app are limited to the HR release times of whoop. So we got a lot of inbound for "white-labeling" which didn't sit exactly right with us. The gap we saw: Bangle.js and PineTime let you get at everything, but it's hard to get someone who isn't into this stuff to wear one all day.

The point: We built a developer tier on our launch page. The idea being all these builders are able to build their apps on our device as a platform, with full access to the raw signals from accelerometer, PPG, etc. So if you want to build a sub-app for tennis, or for golf, or for meditation, etc. you'd get the ability to do that on one side AND access to distribution (our customers) on the other. Like you don't have to sell a wearable to sell your specific function. We figure we have value prop for the Buyer side of the marketplace so it makes it a really good system to set up the Seller side of the marketplace.

How valuable is something like this? What are the questions you would have about a developer tier? Am I over indexing on the amount of new/better data that can be gleaned on, like, hyper-trained or hyper specific models for accelerometer or PPG data?


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 6d ago

Thought I'd climbed quite a few floors recently, but actually I hadn't lol

Post image
3 Upvotes

Working 12-hour inpatient shifts at a city hospital usually keeps my baseline movement high without having to schedule gym sessions lol.

My phone and watch tracking showed my recent daily stair count climbing to 4 or 5 floors regularly and average walking speed holding steady around 1.2 m/s while rushing between patient rooms and the supply wing.

I thought I'd been exercising regularly and at a high intensity over the past few weeks, but when I looked at the trend chart, I realized it was just that I'd been climbing stairs a lot on those days. I wasn't climbing as many floors each day as I'd thought.

Pulling up the exercise trends made my pattern obvious. Right after that mid and late-October peak, my average walking speed dropped apparently, and my climbed floors went down. Aside from one brief rebound around October 22, both curves stayed average through the end of Oct.

Seeing my walking speed and daily floors climbed dip together made me wonder whether fatigue was affecting my activity.

Anyone else pay attention to walking speed as an important marker, or only focus on total step count?


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 6d ago

[OC] Walks where my Apple Watch saved no steady heart rate in the first 5 minutes, by start time: 34 of 45 before 17:00, 2 of 43 after (Sep–Nov 2026)

Thumbnail medium.com
3 Upvotes

Source: my own data. 88 outdoor walks between 6 September and 12 November 2026. One person (me), wearing an Apple Watch Ultra 3 on the left wrist, on the latest watchOS. The heart-rate readings are the ones the Watch saved to Apple Health, unedited. I pulled them with a research app I built.

Definitions

- Silent start: the Watch saved no steady heart rate (at least 3 readings a minute, 3 minutes running) in the first 5 minutes of the walk.

- Pulse before the walk: the median of the Watch's last three readings, 2–30 minutes before the walk. Two walks had no readings in that window, so the chart shows 86 dots.

Tools: Python for the analysis. The chart is hand-written SVG, rendered to PNG with headless Chrome.

Context: From 10 October I also wore a Polar H10 chest strap on many of these walks. On the silent ones the strap showed my pulse climbing normally. On 12 October, for example, the few readings the Watch saved averaged 91 bpm, and the strap's average for the same walk was 134. So the gap is in the recording, not my heart.

The circled dot is a test. On 12 November I raised my pulse to 90–100 before a midday walk, to check whether a low starting pulse was the cause. The Watch still went silent for 13 minutes.

What I don't know yet: my daytime walks are also my fast ones, about 7 km/h against about 6 in the evening, mostly on the same 2.1 km loop. So the clock may be standing in for pace, or for daylight on the sensor. Next I'll do my usual morning walk with the Watch covered, and the same loop at midday at my evening pace.

Full write-up, including the Fitbit Charge 6 and Oura ring against the strap.

(Before you ask: the article text is AI assisted - but edited by me -, everything else: test design, data collection, conclusions are mine.)


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 6d ago

Meditation short term effects

8 Upvotes
Meditation effects ≤ 4h

For added motivation, I'm looking at the effects of meditation, as seen on HR, HRV and "stress level" (garmin). Looking at the last 90 days, 161 meditations, there is a very small effect of -7.7% stress after 2 hours.

Granted the data is a bit dirty; "meditation" includes different kinds of meditations and I would expect the stress level change to be largest on the mindfulness types like vipassana (traditional buddhist, not the movement).

I tried adding some time-of-day comparisons as well, which shows a higher effect; the time of day I usually meditate, my stress level goes up when I don't!

2h window Before During After Change
Meditation 37.6 27.2 34.7 -2.85
Same time other days 38.3 38.6 39.3 +0.95
Net effect -3.8

To get better data here, I will start logging mindful sitting meditations as a specific subtype to meditation. I thought of checking sleep effects, but since I meditate most days, I only see a very weak positive correlation.

Do others see similar effects? Any suggestions of more data digging here?

Keeping data in Aurdoda; charting and correlations built-in, time-of-day comparisons with claude using MCP to dig data.


r/QuantifiedSelf • • 6d ago

crazy stats

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/QuantifiedSelf • • 6d ago

'I Don't Know What To Say' - Guess the word given the definition. Improve your conversational skills. Invoke words quickly when you need them and become more talkative.

Thumbnail sscharles.itch.io
2 Upvotes