r/RandyCunningham • • 1h ago

Discussion Randy x Heidi: Would this actually work?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Hi everyone, I have a lot of free time on my hands, and lately I’ve been thinking a lot about the character dynamics in Randy Cunningham: 9th Grade Ninja. A question popped into my head that I’d love to open up for discussion: if you had to write a story where Randy and Heidi end up together organically, how would you justify it?

We know that in the show, Randy has a pretty superficial crush on her (mentioned in Season 2, if you can even call that "having a crush"), but outside of that, their personalities and priorities go in completely different directions, and as usual... the show never goes any further than that.

Personally, I feel like a relationship between them would go pretty poorly in the long run. Heidi is obsessed with fame, status, and Norrisville's "secrets/gossip," so I think she would prefer the heroic, mysterious figure of the Ninja a thousand times over the real Randy. If she ever found out his identity, I feel like she'd be way more attracted to the mask than the person underneath it.

Still, I want to read your thoughts:

Do you think there’s any way for this ship to work without forcing their personalities out of character?

What would their day-to-day dynamic be like as a couple (especially with Howard in the middle of it)?

What would need to change in both of them for the relationship to actually be healthy?