r/RateMyiconSet • • 3d ago

Announcements After tallying the votes, we have decided the winners of the Worst Icon Set competition

Post image
13 Upvotes

The top 3 places out of all 5 finalists are...

1st place. Set 3: "shit in a kettle" u/AltyrnytExiztence; 16 valid votes.
2nd place. Set 4: "red shit" u/T00b1a5; 11 valid votes.
3rd place. Set 5: "inverted type shit" u/Albertdash; 10 valid votes.

4th place. Set 1: "garfield getting fucked: u/Maryear_Boost; 5valid votes.
5th place. Set 2: "verity" u/kicktex; 3 valid votes.

1st place prize: Special flair, (no mod status this time since i dont want too many mods)
2nd place prize: Special flair.
3rd place price: Special flair, head.

Votes are here.
Search "flair:finals subreddit:ratemyiconset" for induvidual posts by OC's

Also it would be nice if you voted for what competition we should do next once we hit 1500 subs.

Crafty Slice - Co Owner and main runner of this subreddit.


r/RateMyiconSet • • 10d ago

Announcements, WORST ICON SET These are the top 5 contenders for the WORST ICON SET COMPETITION. You guys have to vote on which post is the absolute worst.

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

Voting ends in 7 days.

H**ow to vote:
Comment "1" for the first post,
Comment "2" for the second post in line,
Comment "3" for the third post in line,
And so on.

u/Maryear_Boost, u/kicktex, u/AltyrnytExiztence, u/T00b1a5, u/Albertdash are the finalists.


r/RateMyiconSet • • 7h ago

Icon set Ima rate y'alls icon set from F- to S+

Post image
15 Upvotes

(Aso rate mine too btw...)


r/RateMyiconSet • • 2h ago

Icon set Steampunk

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 3h ago

Icon set Should I keep the ship or change to the seahorse

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 20h ago

Individual Icons I've genuinely been dying laughing at this for ten minutes

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 7h ago

Icon set Rate my icon set

Post image
3 Upvotes

Wsp


r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

THE OWNER LOVES THESE ICONS!!! rate my icons :>

Post image
71 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 11h ago

Icon set Rate my.. whatever this is Icon Set!

Post image
2 Upvotes

Is it good or bad, and what should I change about it!


r/RateMyiconSet • • 22h ago

Icon set rate my NOT boring ass modded icon set (yall pick the wave)

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

i downgraded so i have geode again, i so happy 😭


r/RateMyiconSet • • 22h ago

Icon set Night Vision

Post image
4 Upvotes

I know night vision goggles make you see green, but I just thought that color looked weird with these icons


r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set Knight and dragon theme. Rate my icons! :3

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set aqui mis iconos :D

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set Rate my set (also pick the better ball)

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I just unlocked the 100 list rewards ball (the second one), so I thiigh now is the perfect time to get you guys to rate my icons. I also wanted to know which ball you guys prefer, so uhh yeah.

Btw if you wanna get high quality images of your icons, the Rateon bot on Discord (available on the GD server but you can use it on your own servers) generates really good images of icon sets, and Colon's Icon Kit viewer on his website allows you to download individual icons, here's the link to that if you need it: https://gdbrowser.com/iconkit/

To get sets from Rateon, type /profile user:[your GD username] (ignore the user part if your GD account is linked to your Discord account), then download the image attached at the bottom. To get icons from Colon's website, there's a download button just underneath the previewed icon.


r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set Hey guys rate my new icons!

Post image
5 Upvotes

Cube - Collect 5 of each tier 2 shard

Ship - Complete 1000 user levels

Ball - Buy from community shop for 4000 orbs

UFO - Buy from diamond shop for 600 diamond shards

Wave - Collect 4000 diamonds

Robot - Collect 100 user coins

Spider - Collect 300 user coins

Swing - buy from diamond shop for 600 diamond shards

Jetpack - Buy from diamond shop for 600 diamond shards.


r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set currently looking for a new wave (and maybe ship)!

Post image
5 Upvotes

theme: nature and machinery


r/RateMyiconSet • • 2d ago

Set Compilation Was this a good change or nah? (first image before, second is after)

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 2d ago

Icon set Rate my icon set

Post image
7 Upvotes

(I don't know how to crop properly)


r/RateMyiconSet • • 2d ago

Icon set Rate my icon set

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 3d ago

Individual Icons ULTIMATE DEBATE

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

Seahorse ship vs Ship 22
which is better?


r/RateMyiconSet • • 3d ago

Icon set Rate my icon sets

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 2d ago

Icon set ?/10

Post image
2 Upvotes

(ignore my last message).


r/RateMyiconSet • • 3d ago

Icon set Rate my icon set

Post image
3 Upvotes

Basic i know but i just wanna use the demon required icons


r/RateMyiconSet • • 3d ago

Discussion what is the best icons in terms of actual set up

2 Upvotes

ngl im saying the spider *it has so many cool skins*


r/RateMyiconSet • • 3d ago

Icon set rate it now

Post image
4 Upvotes