We are about 35 days away from closing on a new construction home in North Texas. Back in February, we paid a $40,000 lot premium for a ~0.5-acre lot that backs up to a city park with mature trees.
When we signed the contract, sales told us the fence would be on the property line. In March, we got our engineered plot plan, which also showed the rear fence right on the outer boundary line and budgeted sod for the entire lot. It also showed a dashed line inside the lot labeled "Retaining Wall - By Others" (built by the land developer) that starts at 0.5 ft tall on one side and goes up to 13.6 ft tall on the other side.
When the fence finally went up, the builder installed the wrought iron fence on top of that retaining wall—which sits 11 feet inside our rear property line. Because of the mature park trees and the 13.6-ft drop, the wall obviously can't be moved.
As a result, we are losing ~1,900 to 2,000 sq ft (almost 20% of our backyard) that is now fenced out at the bottom of a 13.6-ft drop between our wall and the city park. When we brought this up to the builder, they basically shrugged and said, "The developer built the wall, not us" (though they did agree to add a rear gate at the low 0.5-ft corner so we can access that strip).
To make matters worse, I checked the recorded plat and HOA CCRs:
- There is no HOA common area strip or Wall Maintenance Easement on the plat for our lot as our lot line touches the city park directly and not the wall.
- The CCRs say that the higher-elevation lot ("Dominant Estate") is 100% responsible for repairing or rebuilding a retaining wall if it ever gets damaged or fails, and that owners must maintain all land inside their lot boundaries. Tough not relevant as now that its entirely on my property as it stands.
So not only did we pay a $40k lot premium for ~2,000 sq ft of backyard we can't use, it looks like we're on the hook for property taxes, weed/brush maintenance on an inaccessible strip next to a public park trail, and future structural liability for a 13.6-ft retaining wall.
We have a meeting with the builder this week to talk this out, and I want some input before I go about overthinking and blowing up the relationship.
For anyone who has been through something similar with a production builder:
- How did you handle it before closing, and what kind of resolution (credits, rate buydowns, price cuts, or HOA maintenance agreements) were you actually able to get?
- How big of a deal is having a 13-ft developer-built retaining wall inside your lot line with no HOA maintenance easement?
- Did you end up getting a real estate lawyer involved before closing, or were you able to work it out directly with division management?
There is a hike and bike trail maintained which runs parallel and right up against the lot line. and the unusable land basically has large mature trees. I'm lucky that i have a gate and can walk down, but 4 houses next to me, the walls keep rising and there is no way for them to access it easily unless they take the long route.
I have read on here the opposite story (maybe similar) where an owner found half his backyard belonged to city and the advice was keep shut and enjoy, I dont think I can do that with the liability exposure.
TL;DR: Paid a $40k lot premium for a half-acre lot backing to a park after being told (and shown on the plot plan) the fence was on the lot line. Builder put the fence on a 13.6-ft developer retaining wall 11 feet inside our boundary, costing us ~2,000 sq ft of usable yard and potentially leaving us responsible for the wall. Closing in 35 days looking for experiences and advice on how to handle this.