Last week’s Republican bloodbath has the ingredients of a Shakespearean tragedy. A leader brought down by overweening pride. Schemers and sycophants who goad him into taking actions against his interests. Innocents who become collateral damage.
Like King Lear, President Trump is a fool for flattery. He demands ostentatious displays of loyalty that are often insincere. “Which of you shall we say doth love us most?” Lear asks his daughters. JD Vance doth say. So too profess Stephen Miller, Howard Lutnick and Bill Pulte.
Mr. Trump rewards brown-nosers who seek to bolster their own power and banishes those he perceives as disloyal. Take North Carolina Sen. Thom Tillis, who became persona non grata after he criticized the president’s tariffs and blanket pardons of Jan. 6 rioters. The president’s refusal to abide criticism insulated him from sage advice that might have prevented his descent in public approval and the GOP’s election wreckage.
“I am a man more sinned against than sinning,” the aggrieved Lear rages on the heath after being cast out by his sycophantic daughters. After the election, Mr. Trump delivered a Truth Social soliloquy: “FoxNews bears responsibility for these losses by constantly and consistently putting on the Dumocrat opposition, and worse.”
He faulted GOP candidates who tried to distance themselves from his unpopular tariff and immigration policies. “Some of the candidates that I endorsed fought me,” Mr. Trump said. MAGA voters “didn’t like that they fought me,” though exit polls showed that it was non-MAGA Republicans and independents who turned against Republicans.
A common theme in Shakespeare is the danger of nursing grievances and grudges. Hamlet becomes consumed by a self-destructive need to avenge his father’s murder at the hands of his uncle Claudius. Though Hamlet ultimately succeeds, he, his beloved Ophelia and most of their families die as a result.
The president has let revenge consume his presidency, as he has waged retribution against John Bolton, James Comey, Letitia James and others. Such vendettas became political distractions and exhausted the patience of Americans.
“Hamlet” also offers a lesson in the insidious nature of political corruption. “Something is rotten in the state of Denmark,” the palace guard Marcellus observes. Voters took the same view of the Trump administration and the Republican party.
Over the past two years, voters have been confronted with a steady dribble of stories about the Trump family’s crypto schemes. This fall brought reports that a Russian oligarch helped bankroll Donald Trump Jr.’s Bahamas wedding and that former Ambassador Kimberly Guilfoyle sought $100,000 from a GOP donor to pay off a credit-card debt.
Grifters in the Trump administration call to mind the buffoonish Sir John Falstaff in “Henry IV, Part 1” who engages in disreputable activities and enriches himself by exploiting his friendship with the young Prince Hal. “What is honour? A word. What is in that word ‘honour’? What is that ‘honour’? Air,” Falstaff muses.
Mr. Trump and his coterie may view honor as immaterial, but corruption ranked at the top of voters’ concerns in polls. Yes, Americans are unhappy about high gasoline prices from the war in Iran and persistent inflation. But the killer was that while they struggled to pay bills, Mr. Trump and his hangers-on looked to be enriching themselves. In exit polls 62% of voters said that the president put his personal interests over the interests of the country.
At the same time, he has leaned on advisers who are out to promote their own political interests. Like Othello’s ensign, Iago, such schemers present themselves as trustworthy, while pursuing their own ends. Appearances deceive. “In following him, I follow but myself,” Iago says. “I am not what I am.”
One might say the same of Mr. Vance. His postelection statement blaming the war in Iran for the Republican drubbing deflected attention from the president’s unpopular tariff and immigration policies, as well as his lawfare and get-rich schemes. But it was also self-serving because it sought to vindicate the vice president’s private objections to the war and silence criticism of policies that Mr. Vance supported.
Mr. Miller, another Iago-like figure, has egged on the president’s worst policy instincts and stoked his resentments. His cruel and chaotic mass-deportation agenda was a key contributor to the GOP’s rout. Nonetheless, the president on Friday elevated Mr. Miller to White House chief of staff, hailing him as “one of my most trusted advisers.” The president will get the bad advice he invites.
Unlike many of the leaders in Shakespeare’s plays, Mr. Trump is no king, even if progressives have portrayed him as such. The liberal press at long last admitted last week that “democracy works,” if only because Democrats prevailed. Mr. Vance won’t ascend to the presidency via coronation in 2028. He will have to win over voters who may not be as easily beguiled as Mr. Trump.