r/ResearchML • • 8h ago

Can Humor and Memes Have a Place in Academic Research?

2 Upvotes

I am a graduate student in my third year of research. I recently had a paper accepted for publication and am currently working on a project page to introduce the work.

When explaining ideas, I believe that making them intuitive, approachable, and easy to understand is one of the most important things. For this reason, I enjoy presenting the methods I propose through memes and humorous illustrations.

However, I sometimes wonder whether this approach might be considered inappropriate or even off-putting in academia, which can be a relatively formal and serious environment. I would appreciate hearing some advice and perspectives from more senior researchers on this matter.

Thank you for your time!


r/ResearchML • • 6h ago

ICLR Reviewer Concerns

8 Upvotes

Hi All,

I submitted a paper at ICLR this time. Got reviews with scores 222 with the confidence of 232. Both the reviewers that had low confidence talked about very minor/presentation issues that simply had to be clarified which we did. The content of the review also made it very apparent that they were not aware of the literature or the field in itself and spent very little time on the paper.The reviewer with confidence 3 suggested ablations which we ran and got back. Now both the low confidence reviewers have responded with no new clarifications or concerns but that they would like to keep their score, and did not state any reason why. And the high confidence reviewer has simply not responded.

As the discussion currently stands there are no unaddressed concerns and no serious claims that we had to acknowledge. There were also no loopholes pointed out, and the additional experiments only reinforced our results further. The reviewers also praise the results, call the work timely, and say it is informative, but the scores have not changed. Is there no way to get an AC/SAC to look at cases like this where we're stuck in a horrible cycle of bad reviewers throughout?


r/ResearchML • • 4h ago

Update: I did it! OpenReview changed the PhD advisor requirement!

21 Upvotes

After repeatedly emailing CVPR and OpenReview about my advisor's situation (my advisor's advisor is no more in this world. so no email address, so he had an incomplete openreview profile), I finally got a response saying that adding a PhD advisor is no longer required to complete the profile.

Not saying I caused the change, but I definitely bugged them enough about it lol.

Glad they fixed this. Hopefully it helps others in the same situation.


r/ResearchML • • 23h ago

OpenReview with Posthumous Authors

43 Upvotes

My PhD student recently passed away a few weeks ago. He was so close to finishing his first paper and I'm determined to finish it off and get it into a good AI conference because getting published was one of his last wishes.

I'm not sure which conference yet, but I realised that I don't know how to handle posthumous submissions with OpenReview. He doesn't have a profile on OpenReview, so I'm not sure whether I should submit it without him and request author alteration later.

I suspect the answer is most certainly talk to the PCs, but I was wondering if anyone has done this before.


r/ResearchML • • 3h ago

ICLR no score update from reviewers

4 Upvotes

With just a few hours left in the discussion period, I have scores of 3, 2, 2, and no changes have been made yet. The reviewer who gave me a 3 has kept their score, while I'm still waiting for the other two reviewers to provide feedback and hopefully increase their scores.

This is frustrating because I've sent multiple reminders, and I can't even do that anymore. Meanwhile, I keep seeing people here getting score increases, which makes me feel like my paper is definitely further down the rankings.

This is just a rant, but how hard can it be to provide feedback? It's been over 6 days now.


r/ResearchML • • 9h ago

A random split overstated my model’s recall by ~10 points (NYC facade inspections). Is my evaluation fair?

3 Upvotes

I'm doing a student project on NYC's facade inspection program. Buildings over six stories get rated Safe, SWARMP or Unsafe every five years, and a 2024 law requires the city to use a predictive model to prioritize inspections. I couldn't find a public one, so I tried building my own from the public filings.

Task: predict whether a building will be rated Unsafe at its next inspection cycle.
Setup: trained on cycles 6→7 and 7→8, tested once on 8→9 (about 11k buildings, 25% Unsafe).

Results on the held-out cycle:
- Top 20% of the ranked list catches 36.4% of Unsafe buildings (random order: 19.8%, last rating only: 32.6%)
- LightGBM and logistic regression perform the same
- A random split of the same data gave 46.8%, so about 10 points too optimistic
- Each cycle is harder to predict than the last
- A conformal recall guarantee works (90% target gave 89.2%) but needs about 75% of buildings inspected

Random split Time split (test 8→9)
Recall in top 20% 46.8% 36.4%
PR-AUC 0.548 0.430
AUC 0.763 0.687
Recall target Realized on 8→9 Share of buildings to inspect
80% 80.6% 62.6%
90% 89.2% 75.4%
95% 93.6% 83.3%

Same-cycle CV recall in top 20% (a rough ceiling): 6→7 53.3%, 7→8 47.7%, 8→9 39.2%

After I looked at 8→9, I split it into dev and reserve halves and only kept ideas that helped both. None did.

Questions:
1. Is that dev/reserve approach reasonable once a test set has been used?
2. What would you use for conformal calibration when labeling rules change between cycles?
3. Labels come from inspectors hired by the buildings themselves, not by the city. Any ideas for handling that with public data?

Data is NYC Open Data (DOB NOW facade filings). Numbers are in the tables above.


r/ResearchML • • 18h ago

Looking for study partner for RL, DL and CV.

3 Upvotes

Hi buddy,

If you have some knowledge of deep learning , machine learning ,NLP or Cv and are willing to prepare llms, Reinforcement learning and doing research work. Please ping me up. Maybe we can study and let's make this easy . Though I am thinking of starting to read research papers too .

My background: I am from one of the iits , Branch - Mathematics and Computing.

Have two intern offers for next summer ofc one is related to AI .

So if u r genuinely interested let's make this journey easy.