r/RockTumbling • • Jul 27 '26

Concerning rock ID posts.

50 Upvotes

TLDR: No - but maybe a periodic megathread. I created a new sub, r/WhatTheRock

------------

I figured I'd make a separate post for this. This stems from the recent post asking if the rule about posting rock ID requests can be changed. I'll copy and paste what I replied there into here:

In short, no I don't think allowing rock ID posts is a good idea. They used to be allowed and a large percentage of posts were people asking what a particular rock is. I think ID requests were banned before I even took over as the mod and I left it that way.

Regarding the level of moderating on this sub, I think it's funny that some people think I'm strict or power trip. I do not actively moderate... not really anyway. If I happen to see an ID post or off topic post in my home page when browsing Reddit, I'll remove it. But most of the time, they get reported fairly quickly, I see the notification for the report, and then I remove it. There are very few rules on this sub and I actually don't remove a lot. I often get reports of "harassment" and it's usually someone being slightly rude. I don't remove comments like that. I will remove comments that are hateful in nature.

Now... if someone is truly harassing you and taking effort to do something like respond to multiple comments on multiple topics in a negative way, let me know. I'd probably just message them a warning, and if the behavior doesn't stop, a temp ban, followed by a perma-ban. I've never had to do that though. But I want everyone to know that kind of behavior won't be tolerated here.

I am hearing that the community does not like r/whatsthisrock because of the strict moderation. So I have created a new sub called r/WhatTheRock. I know, I know.... another sub. Ugh. But I will moderate it the same way I do this sub. As long as the post has a picture of a rock (or mineral) and you're asking "What is this?" then I'll allow it. I'll caveat that by saying I'll remove any obviously meme posts, like if someone posts a picture of Dwayne Johnson, or a picture of the Earth. I want to keep this sub oriented towards tumbling related posts.


r/RockTumbling • • Jul 05 '22

Guide /r/RockTumbling Knowledge Base

193 Upvotes

Here is a compilation of guides I have written, as well as a few others, for easy access.

It's important to note that I am not a subject matter expert. Some of these FAQs that I wrote are not even based upon my own experience. I drew heavily upon the experience of /u/michigan_rocks and his Youtube videos. Also, ask 10 people how to tumble rocks and you will get 10 different answers. They will be similar enough though that you can really follow any one, or mix and match between them all for what works best for you. The basic steps will always be the same. It's exactly how you do them that people might have different processes for.

Also, I know several other users in this community have written their own guides or how-tos. If you comment below with a link I can add a link to the main post.


FAQ - How much electricity does a tumbler use?

FAQ - What is a good beginner tumbler?

FAQ - What do I need to get started?

FAQ - Where can I get rocks to tumble?

FAQ - Where can I buy good grit?

FAQ - What is tumbling media? What is it and how is it used.

FAQ - How do I get a good polish with the Nat Geo tumbler?

FAQ - How long should I run stage 1?

FAQ - How do I know if a rock is ready to move on from coarse? by /u/Ruminations0

FAQ - How full should my barrel be? An auditory guide.

FAQ - My rocks are round and smooth; can I skip stage one?

FAQ - How long am I supposed to run each stage?

FAQ - What is the burnishing stage? What does it do? When do I run it?

FAQ - What do I do with the slurry after tumbling?

FAQ - I just tumbled some rocks and they are dull. What do I do?


Slightly more advanced topics:


r/RockTumbling • • 3h ago

Do any tumblers actually work for longer than a month or two?

11 Upvotes

The nat geo tumbler I got about 6 months ago only lasted a few months before giving an "error" reading and stopping whenever I tried to run it. Doesn't matter how heavy or light the barrel is. Changed the belt. Still no go. I thought "well, it's the cheapest one and you get what you pay for. I will get a better one." So I got a Koolstone double barrel. Seemed like pretty good quality. Been working fine for a couple months. I just switched a batch from stage 3 to 4 and it won't turn with both barrels on it. Same rocks, same filler, same weight (probably lighter actually). It was working fine before the stage change. What the hell?! I'm so pissed right now. I have one tumbler that doesn't work at all, and another one that is only running at half capacity. I don't want to buy another one, but also don't want to give up on tumbling when I've barely gotten into it. This really sucks.

-edit- Thanks everybody! I love this sub!! Looks like I should be able to get my Koolstone going after a belt change... but I might get a Lortone anyway and have 4 barrels going at once lol


r/RockTumbling • • 20h ago

Charcuterie Used Properly

Post image
134 Upvotes

These are all sourced from Buffalo Gap NGL. Still learning so some are rougher than others.


r/RockTumbling • • 9m ago

Rock Tumbling for Kids

• Upvotes

Hi there,

Is this a fun hobby for kids and parents to undertake together? I know next to nothing except it takes a long time and not to buy the nat geo rock tumbler, lol. My kids (10, 8.5, 6) collect treasures from nature constantly so I have a good collection of rocks to choose from already. Is there a “rock tumbling for dummies” type of resource that explains hardness, what kinds of rocks are best to tumble and where to find them, the different stages, what to do when, etc? I was considering getting them stuff for rock tumbling as a group Christmas gift for a new family activity.

Curious for your thoughts.

Thank you!


r/RockTumbling • • 7h ago

Pictures New Newfoundland lapidary stone discovery. Chromian Epidote Breccia.

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/RockTumbling • • 13h ago

Large rock tumbler

Post image
8 Upvotes

I have seen this large capacity rock tumbler on Amazon. I imagine it would work for stage 1 and possibly stage 2. What I'm curious about is if anyone has gone to stage 4 or 5 with these large capacity barrels?

Thanks for your input!


r/RockTumbling • • 16h ago

Discussion Crack-a-barrel Wednesday! Can I trademark this?

8 Upvotes

I haven't fallen asleep yet, and had the wonderful realization that I'll be opening two barrels after I eventually go to sleep, wake up, go to work, come home, have dinner, and sit down this evening.

On a serious note, I'm curious what everyone's barrel-checking schedule is.

With the recent used-tumbler purchases, I'm set up to open two barrels on Saturday morning, and two barrels Wednesday evening.

Trying to keep myself organized by keeping notes in Google Calendar. Need to make sure I know what stage I have going at any given time, and in which barrels.


r/RockTumbling • • 17h ago

Question Rock tumbler recommendations

9 Upvotes

I’m 27 and with Christmas coming up I got the dreaded question of what I want, I finally decided I’d like a rock tumbler.

What are some recommendations and preferred tumblers? I’m in Canada and the price range can probably go up to 300CAD but I might be able to bargain for more if it’s a really good tumbler - plus I’ll need some generic equipment and stuff

Also where do people get their grit from and often rocks? I live in a very neat Little Rock pocket of Canada and do intend to go foraging for rocks but would still be interested in getting the fancy pants ones to tumble as well


r/RockTumbling • • 1d ago

Pictures Measuring the barrel

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

If you're like me and cant see half, 2/3 or 3/4 in your barrel to save your life lol this "16oz" tub worked great for a batch i just polished. I fill it with the rocks, dump it in then put media to level it. Grit, water, tumble 🙌


r/RockTumbling • • 1d ago

Pictures My first tumble is complete, I don't hate it.

Post image
73 Upvotes

I'm pretty happy with the results.


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

Pictures Not me bragging about my latest batch!

Post image
95 Upvotes

Sorry, not sorry - just obsessed with this shine!!


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

I'm a bit disappointed in my order of Royal Imperal Jasper from the Gem Shop? Am I being too harsh?

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

Just got this order in from The Gem Shop. I took a chance on their 5 lbs of Royal Imperial Jasper broken nodules for $75. Honestly, I'm a bit underwhelmed. In the pics, I tried to show the best faces. Maybe it's because it was so expensive compared to what I usually order, and my expectations were unrealistic. I think they will look good tumbled, but a lot of them have pretty difficuly to deal with shapes, so they are going to lose a lot of size or need to be broken. The biggest piece, pic 2, also has a crevice that goes about halfway through and a bunch of other deel pits. Also, the green one, pic 3, is a stunner, but there is only one that color. O well, live and learn. Am I being too harsh? Does this look like it's worth $75, and I don't know what I'm talking about.


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

Question First time

Post image
17 Upvotes

I tried rock tumbling for the first time and this is the result after going through all 4 stages, I need help figuring out why they aren’t all shiny. I did my best to clean them and the drums after each stage to prevent cross-contamination. I have a few theories on what I did wrong but would love some input from those more knowledgeable than me. My first there is I messed up stage 1 I misread the instructions and didn’t use enough grit so I redid stage 1 for half a week, but maybe it wasn’t long enough. My other theory is that I ordered a bulk pack of rocks on Amazon and didn’t check the hardness of the different rocks, so maybe something was too hard and scuffed the other rocks. Any advice for fixes this batch and for future batches would be much appreciated.

Amazon listing

https://a.co/d/04lQmKYg


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

Pictures Off to a Great Start

Post image
45 Upvotes

Just finished my first tumble with a "Mexican mix" (hardness 7) that came with the set and I think they turned out great.

Learned a lot, used a lot of tips and information from this subreddit, and I doubt they'd look this good if it wasn't for you all.

Now, time to start back at stage one with some Sodalite!

Thanks r/RockTumbling


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

Question To tumble or not to tumble

45 Upvotes

It’s been a while since I audibly gasped after picking up a rock. I initially thought it might have paint on it. I do much of my hounding along a river and there are some areas where teens like to spray paint. You can see on the sides though that the blue and purple swirl through the rock. Now my question is, tumble or not? I guess my worry is always that the best part might get worn down in the process. Thoughts?


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

Question Rock tumbling weight question

11 Upvotes

Hi! Beginner here.

I have a double barrel tumbler which is rated for 7pounds, so 3.5lbs each barrel.

I’ve been watching and learning from rock tumbling creators on YouTube including Michigan rocks, I haven’t found much information about how much each barrel should actually weigh. I have been following the standard fill the barrel 2/3rds of the way full, and adding water to just below the rock line. Including the weight of the barrel itself, each barrel was coming out to around 8 pounds. The first 3 weeks they tumbled fine, and by the 4th week- the tumbler could only tumble the weight of one barrel at a time and would stop when both were on. After some research it seemed like I was adding weight to much weight to the machine, but I’m confused how you’re supposed to fill the barrel with 2/3rds rock and add water after without exceeding the weight limit.

So I guess my question is, Do we include the weight of the barrel and water in the barrels weight limit? If each barrel is 3.5lbs, and the barrel its self weighs 2 pounds, it would only leave 1.5 pounds of rocks AND water? I don’t want to continue stressing out my machine but I also tried weighing each barrel to exactly 3.5lbs each and both the rocks and water only covered the bottom of the barrel (about 1/3rd) so I’m nervous they’ll be banging around on each other.

Any advice?
I appreciate it! 🫶🏻


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

Barrell cracking!

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Forgot to post on Friday but this is my Stage 3 beach mix starting Stage 4! We did an ivory soap wash before stages 3&4 here's hoping for a good polish!


r/RockTumbling • • 3d ago

The Treadmillentumblerstein lives.

391 Upvotes

I only have 3 barrels that fit it right now, but it seems to be running fine with a full 17lb barrel on it plus a 2.5 and 4 lb. I've got to figure out how to dial in the speed now. I guess that's my next subject to research.


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

First full tumble. I messed up. I know some things I did wrong, but need advice.

Post image
7 Upvotes

So I guess I mixed rock hardness and class. I had a couple sedimentary rocks in the barrel. The rock middle row, second from left (green and brown) is very rough. I’m assuming it is the culprit that lead to what I have: All the other rocks are very smooth, but not shiny.

I used KoolStone media and grit.
Did 7 days of each stage with a very good rinse of rocks, barrel, and media (ceramic) between each stage. I had a lot of what looked like concrete slurry at each stage but supposedly that’s normal.

I filled the barrel 2/3 then filled it in with media. 2 tablespoons of grit each stage, then the water.

Other than making sure I have the same type of rocks next time, what could I do better?

EDIT: I am using the Harbor Freight tumbler. It’s my understanding it has a good RPM for tumbling.


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

Pictures First tumble ever!

Post image
84 Upvotes

Four weeks of waiting. I’m so excited! I wasn’t prepared for how much some of these were going to shrink. I learned something this first round for sure.
At a glance: Do I have anything interesting? All were collected over decades on PNW beaches, I have hundreds to tumble, these were chosen from an extensive hoard. I think some are Jasper, there’s a piece of quartz (I think). Maybe a piece of BC jade or chalcedony? Any help is greatly appreciated.


r/RockTumbling • • 3d ago

Pictures Mahogany Obsidian, 1st attempt.

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

So the black in the stone is translucent, I didn't know that when I started. Pretty cool.


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

Not too shabby!

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

I’m pretty satisfied with my third batch. I’m working with a kit that slightly nicer than a Nat Geo but still rotates around 3x faster than I’d like.
Green moss agate and black onyx. I need to spend more time in stage 1, but I don’t mind these results at all!


r/RockTumbling • • 2d ago

Question My tumbler is going too fast and I’m not an electrician

7 Upvotes

Okay so I bought the nat geo hobby tumbler and it’s going WAY too fast, I’ve looked at this sub (and google) and to paraphrase what I learned basically is “turn down the rpm”….but I don’t know how to do that, all my plugs have the same wattage, the power cable and the tumbler don’t have a switch, I’m not an electrician how do I do this? (I’m in Canada if that helps?)


r/RockTumbling • • 3d ago

Large tumbles out of my 12lb Lortone. 2 Flor du Durazno Lace pieces, a slab of Brazilian agate, and a Mookaite.

46 Upvotes