I'm currently with Rogers, paying $120/month for 1 Gbps internet after they decided to remove the discounts I previously had.
Naturally, I started shopping around. Carrytel, Oxio, TekSavvy, and a few others all offer better pricing. But the more I looked into it, the more frustrated I became with how Canada's telecommunications industry operates.
From what I understand, many of these smaller providers rely on the same physical infrastructure owned by Rogers or Bell. So even if I switch providers, I'm potentially still paying Rogers indirectly through wholesale network access fees.
And that's what bothers me.
I'm not interested in going through the hassle of switching providers just to end up on essentially the same underlying network, with a different company handling my bill and customer service.
What I find particularly frustrating is the apparent lack of meaningful infrastructure competition. In my area, Rogers cable appears to be the primary high-speed option, and while independent ISPs can compete on price, they're still dependent on infrastructure controlled by the very companies they're competing against.
It feels like an oligopoly where consumers have the illusion of choice without much actual independence.
That's why I'm seriously considering Starlink.
I realize Starlink is generally slower than my current gigabit connection, and it might not even be the cheapest option. But there's something appealing about removing myself from the traditional Canadian telecom infrastructure entirely.
I'm increasingly willing to sacrifice some speed or even pay a little more simply to stop supporting a business model I fundamentally dislike.
I'm curious what other Canadians think:
- Has anyone in an urban area switched from Rogers or Bell to Starlink specifically to get away from the traditional telecom companies?
- How has the reliability been compared with cable or fibre?
- Do you think wholesale internet providers offer meaningful competition, or are they just making the existing system more tolerable?
- Are there other genuinely independent infrastructure options worth considering?
I'm not under the impression that Starlink is some perfect alternative. It's another massive corporation, after all. But at least switching would mean making a genuine change in how my internet is delivered, rather than simply choosing a different company to bill me.
At this point, it's becoming less about saving $30–$50/month and more about whether Canadian consumers actually have meaningful choices.