r/SGU • u/Aenimalist • 11h ago
Episode 1113 - Steve and Cara's lack of skepticism on AI consciousness
This is from an email I sent the the rogues. Since I'm not a patron I'm not counting on a response, so I thought that I'd post it here.
In episode #1113, in my opinion Steve and Cara were not thinking skeptically when they argued that there is a small possibility that data centers are conscious, and Jay was right to scoff at the notion. The crux of the argument seemed to rely on the fact that artificial neural networks underly the architecture of the transformer models that perform inference for AI chat bots. What this argument is missing is that artificial neural networks are not physical neural networks, but rather digital simulations of them. The vast majority of the time the physical hardware is just transistors, wires, and memory - there are not persistent connections between neurons because there are no neurons, and the encoded memories are not linked to anything, but rather just digital bits that are not accessible. I would argue that both long term persistent connections and accessible memories (not memory) are necessary for consciousness, at least any type of consciousness that science is aware of. As Jay might say, any notion that the calculations briefly simulating a neural network could be conscious is not backed up by any science, and is utterly absurd. Get 'em Jay!
This follows an unfortunate trend where the rogues continue to lend too much credence to AI firm marketing gimmicks.