r/SameGrassButGreener • • 2h ago

Move Complete Moved from NYC to Chicago 2 years ago and feeling gaslit by Chicago positivity

67 Upvotes

What the title says.

We moved from Brooklyn to a decent west side neighborhood in Chicago two years ago and I'm just not feeling Chicago. It feels like New York but just a little worse.

Pros:

-Apartment is bigger

-Streets are cleaner

-I still make my NYC salary, although groceries and other expenses don't really feel cheaper

-Lakefront

Cons

-Much less walkable. The urban sprawl here is crazy

-Public transit is much worse

-I have to own a car now

-Recreational cycling is much worse

-Weekend getaway towns are worse

-Food is worse and less diverse, besides Mexican. And nothing is spicy for some reason

Am I taking crazy pills or has anyone else made these observations?


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 21h ago

Downsides of Philly?

95 Upvotes

This is fun. Philly is the other city I’m strongly considering moving to, also a city this sub seems to love.

Ruin it for me.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1d ago

The True Downsides of Chicago

215 Upvotes

Before people get angry as i know this sub loves defending chicago, i like the city and think it has a lot to offer. but after living here for a few years, the negatives are REALLY weighing on me:

  1. the segregation is terrible. like i can name very few neighborhoods that are not predominantly ethnically homogenous. it is fine if you fall into one of those categories and mainly have friends of one ethnicity, but for people who want to meet others of all different backgrounds, you will have to travel to different neighborhoods for the most part. there isn’t an inherent level of inclusion as well if you are a different ethnicity moving into a homogenous neighborhood. also, there is a certain level of racism that comes with this since people do not live amongst one another. White people have no idea what black people really experience here, same with black and asian people, same with asian and hispanic people. And i have seen many examples of all races being prejudice to others.
  2. the cost of living is not what it used to be. chicago has quickly become much more expensive than its reputation has let on. yes it is cheaper than NY, DC, and SF, but the gap isn’t what it used to be and will continue to grow due to both chicago not building enough housing and the debt the city is in forces property tax hikes continuously. Rents here have been one of the leaders in YOY growth for the last 2 years. The winters will not keep the rents down more than taxes and low housing supply will raise them.
  3. Public transit. I just want to say i am optimistic about NITA, i watch all of their board meetings, and have even left public comment before. but despite crime going down this year, it is still nowhere near where it should be on transit. i know countless people who legitimately fear the cta because they have had terrible experiences within the last few months. sexual harrassment and assault, people playing with fire, and smoking cigarettes on the train are the most common reports. i’ve experienced all of these as well myself. Driving isn’t better here as they will charge you as much as humanly possible in tickets, gas, and parking in this city.

These have all been mentioned in some way or another before, but i think they are understated or brushed over too much. there are other things too like police misconduct, political corruption, public schools, and many more things. but these three impact me the most and i see the most in a day to day basis.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 4h ago

People happy in their city, why do you visit this subreddit?

2 Upvotes

If you lived in a city that was “a well kept secret” why would you potentially ruin it?

Would you tell all the disgruntled Reddit folks looking for greener grass?


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1h ago

Move Inquiry Please recommend a medium sized city (150,000-400,000) with friendly people and good schools

1 Upvotes

We are looking for a medium sized city with friendly people and good public schools in the US. Open to weather and topography. Downsizing our lives with 3 kids, moving from an affluent area and tired of the in your face performative consumerism, so we’d like to avoid that. We’d love a place with charm and nature nearby. A downtown with mom and pops instead of all big box, does this exist anymore? We want easier living and less keeping up with the Jones’. House budget up to $900k.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 22h ago

Downsides of DC?

42 Upvotes

Inspired by the Chicago thread…

I’ve been eyeing DC for a move within the next year. It ticks most of my boxes.

Ruin it for me.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 17h ago

Downsides of South New Jersey?

9 Upvotes

What are the downsides of moving into South New Jersey? I always think it looks really safe and quiet. I know it's super expensive though and all the jobs are near philly or wilmington.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 13h ago

Places that are pretty and cheap, like the Appalachians, Black Hills and remote un touristic areas out west. Hidden gems or no gos?

4 Upvotes

Appalachians and Blacks Hills are mostly cheap throughout with few exceptions

Out west you’ll still find pockets that are beautiful but cheap due to remoteness, distance from metro areas and airports, low tourist activity, and in some cases extreme heat and dryness making the land basically useless for pretty much any agricultural purpose.

Off the top of my head: San Luis Valley in Colorado, Wyoming outside of the northwest corner, Scottsbluff/Chadron in far west Nebraska, Glendive Montana, Great Basin in Nevada, Eastern Oregon, the inland deserts of SoCal, east of the Coachella valley

Would you say these are hidden gems that others simply haven’t discovered or just rough places that happen to have a view?


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1d ago

Philly, Pittsburgh, or NYC for the remaining years of my 20s

50 Upvotes

I am a 25 year old man and I cannot live in the bleak car dependent suburbs of Florida any longer. A few of my artists friends have moved to NYC but only because they have rich parents that pay for their 4k a month rent. As someone who wants to live in a dense walkable city on an east coast with access to good jobs, nature, historical architecture, and art/ music scenes, should I just double down and be poor in New York City? Or should I live in Philly or Pittsburgh which I can afford? In case you’re going to recommend Richmond I’ve already been there, it’s really nice but it is too small for me.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 21h ago

Move Inquiry Low Income Senior looking for Recommendations

11 Upvotes

I'm a retired GWM currently living out of necessity in a Subsidized-Low Income Senior apartment building in north-central Pennsylvania. I moved here in September because there was a vacancy versus where I was living in Philly with friends, where buildings like this one are on two-to-three-year waitlists.

As an only child my family is gone with my parents and close relatives all deceased so I have no focus on other than near the few good friends I have left who live in NYC and Philly, which aren't good options given the waitlist situation. I'm also kind of over the urban environment and feel more drawn toward more walkable smaller towns.

I have no real climate requirements beyond places like FL or TX so kind of wide open otherwise, though due to logistics and cost of moving East Coast-ish focused. I do hope to live in a place (unlike where I am now) where there's a more educated population who I'll find more in common with, and a decent foodie culture that's very much not here also.

For financial reasons I no longer have a car so I will need a city/town that's relatively compact and walkable to places like grocery stores, versus a long schlep on public transit. A leafy college town and/or a more touristy small town with some level of quaintness would be a major plus. Cost of living isn't a huge issue with my housing being subsidized and EBT benefits thankfully, although better than average health care access will be a driving force.

I look forward to seeing some suggestions as I'm mired in analysis paralysis right now. Thanks!


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 18h ago

from Georgia to Maine, what's your take on a good lifestyle fit?

5 Upvotes

Looking for someplace from Georgia to Maine where I can set down roots. Washington State is a strong contender too. I'm curious where people think I'd fit in best given the below.

I really want someplace that's racially mixed, LGBT+ people aren't just accepted but thriving, relatively safe, and good job prospects in healthcare tech. Other considerations:

  • Newly single, in my early 30s. I'm trying to establish a career while still being an active part of a community. Please get me away from these networking transients.
  • Real protections for LGBT+ people & an active community. It's fine if the community is small or seasonal.
  • Non-segregated. I grew up around white, black, & Southeast Asian people. Hoping to find similar wherever I settle down next.
  • Doesn't have to be super affordable but gotta be someplace I can have a life outside of the grind. I like to camp, hike, party, volunteer, play games.
  • My personality is pretty classically East Coast. Direct, kind, helpful, a bit abrasive. I can blend in just fine with more mild mannered folks but ideally I'm around people who are also kindhearted even if they're not super "nice."
  • No thanks to the following: New York state, Philadelphia. Nothing against, I just have my reasons.

Thanks in advance! I'll keep poking around the sub but thought it couldn't hurt to fish for some opinions.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 20h ago

Is it time to leave NYC?

4 Upvotes

I (28F) moved here last year with my partner (25F) from Jacksonville, FL. We both grew up in Florida and many factors led to us finally leaving. I never hated my hometown but always wanted to try living somewhere new. My partner however, always dreamed of living in NYC. It was perfect timing since I was living with my parents and it was a toxic environment. My partner brought up the idea of moving together in January 2025 and by October 2025, we were in our apartment in the Lower East Side. Back in Florida, I was working a low-paying manufacturing job that I enjoyed but it wasn’t enough for me to make a life of my own so I applied to a master’s program in NYC to get into teaching. (Manufacturing was probably a better fit for me professionally but I may have high-masked too close to the sun and now I’m in education faking it ‘til I make it. I’m autistic but need to make money. I can’t go back to relying on my parents.)
I started a week after arriving here as a paraprofessional and enjoyed it. However, I quickly noticed how exhausted the commute to my school made me. I was immediately aware of how bad I started to feel here but tried to move past it because I just assumed I just needed to get used to it. Months go by, NYC had the worst winter in a long time, I am struggling day to day physically and mentally. My immune system was failing. My body was not used to being in a building full of kids and also fighting the billions of germs that I’d encounter in such a tight packed city. I was getting sick constantly for months with very little recovery in between. That + my diet, exercise and sleep had gone down the drain. That’s a terrible combo. Back home, I was extremely regimented, had a routine that worked for me, I was pretty healthy when it came to things I could control. I do struggle with underlying health conditions, though. A year prior, I had 3 surgeries in one year (endometriosis and 2 foot procedures) I have low iron and all the walking/stair climbing is very hard on my body.

I figured the next school year, I’d apply to be a first-year teacher at a school in my neighborhood. I found a job about a 15-minute walk from my school. No more subways. Score, right? Wrong. My school is on the 5th floor and I’m not allowed to take the elevator. My knee is killing me. All the stair climbing in this city has been so hard on my body. Arthritis runs in my family but I didn’t think I’d be feeling it in my 20s. I immediately regretted my decision to work there. But now I’m stuck until June. Honestly, this job is the number one stressor in my life right now. It has absolutely killed my passion for teaching. But I’m making more money than I ever have in my life.

I had a conversation with my partner and NYC isn’t what we thought it’d be like. We love the memories we’ve made here and I don’t regret coming here. We didn’t move here with the intention of staying forever but we definitely thought we’d stay for at least 5 years. But now, we’re thinking of leaving in Summer 2028 after I graduate. Hopefully next year, I can find a better job but even if I get the perfect job, that doesn’t change the fact that I can’t function here.

You’re probably reading this thinking: you’re physically and mentally exhausted. You tried. Isn’t it obvious you should leave?
I wish it were that easy! The thing is, in between all the terrible moments and all of the times I’ve told myself “god I can’t wait to get out of here,” there have been some life changing, amazing moments. I’ve been putting in the work to make a community here. I found friends. I joined a band and we’re doing well. It was my childhood dream to be in a band, doing this. Not just any band, THIS BAND. I love these people so much. I jammed with musicians back home and it never went anywhere. It never felt like they were my true friends. This time is different. It breaks my heart because they are truly the main factor keeping me here. Everything else like having a lower salary, dealing with Florida politics, etc., are things I’m willing to put up with to gain back the quality of life I’m looking for. But they’re irreplaceable and I don’t want to leave this prematurely without giving it a chance.

I’m also not ignoring the fact that we moved here to NYC looking for a better life. We wanted to be safer as a queer couple. I wanted to teach in a state with gun control where I don’t have to worry about being shot with my kids in my classroom. I rely on birth control to manage my symptoms and it’s a very scary place in Florida right now. I’m not forgetting the reasons we left.
But I seriously cannot get used to it here.
I do feel homesick.
I do miss Florida.
I told my friend today “I wish I could be 2 places at once.”
Because I DO want to go home. But I don’t exactly want to give up the opportunities I have here with my career and my band. I am truly at a crossroads.

I know no one can tell me what to do with my life. But any advice or encouragement would help. If you’ve ever felt similarly, even in different cities or circumstances, I’d like to hear your story. I’m just feeling very conflicted right now.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 3h ago

Move Inquiry Smaller alternatives to Chicago

0 Upvotes

I know reddit loves Chicago, but I'm gonna be honest, I'm sick of it here. I've been here for 15 years and it just isn't the city I used to love anymore. I'm finishing my masters degree next year and looking to find somewhere a bit smaller with more green space, but that still has great food and a big metro vibe. Here are some of my main gripes:

  1. The traffic. It's always been bad, but these last few years it has become unbearable. It takes me 45 minutes to go visit my friend in Des Plaines. In 2016 when he moved there it took about 25. And God forbid I want to go to the suburbs to see some green spaces, the traffic out there is almost as bad as the city nowadays. Public transportation feels unsafe and disgusting, and all the train cars smell like cigarettes or weed.
  2. The weather. When I was younger, I could deal with it, and I even enjoyed it. Nowadays the 4pm sunsets and constant cold winds are just depressing. I don't want to live in a desert like Arizona or a microwave like Florida, but something a little more mild would be nice.
  3. The cost. Chicago used to be the cheap alternative to big cities like NY, Boston, or LA. It's still cheaper, but it's trending in the wrong direction.
  4. Public education and safety. My wife and I are going to have kids soon, and we want them to grow up in a good environment. Not all of Chicago is bad, but we'd like something a little more safe with slightly better public schools.

So, anyone former Chicagoans finding their way happily in a different city? I'd love to hear some thoughts!


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1d ago

Why people here don’t like places where “everyone” is moving

16 Upvotes

I frequently see people point out how this forum doesn’t like places where “everyone” is moving, but that makes no sense if you look at the stats.

Only ~25 million people relocated last year and most people relocated within their state.

The cities and states with the highest growth rates only get a small fraction of that 25 million.

So if a state gains 1 million people in a year, that is only 4% of that 25 million. Texas gained the most new residents and it was around 400k.

In a nutshell, there is no statistical anomaly in a forum not overwhelmingly liking places which only got <2% of people who relocated last year.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1d ago

Move Inquiry I need suggestions for somewhere that isn't a huge city

8 Upvotes

I am trying to figure out where to move to (in the US). I am from a huge city and I'm definitely not a big city person. I appreciate the diversity and good food, but that's about it. I am looking for a small or medium-sized city. I hate public transportation and do not want to have to rely on it. I also don't want to have to struggle to park everywhere. It doesn't need to be walkable because I will go on walks regardless just for fun. I don't mind driving to get to places. I could consider somewhere bigger if it's not super dense and I never have to take public transportation.

I want to live somewhere relatively progressive/accepting, and preferably not in a red state. (Somehow my favorite place I've lived was the most conservative, but it didn't feel like it. I hated the weather though.)

I need four seasons. I don't like warm weather, but I can handle it if it stays in the summer. I would love cool summers, but most of the country isn't like that so it's fine. If snow isn't at least a possibility, I won't live there.

I'm in my late 20s and I want to make friends, but that has never been too hard as long as the place I live has enough people my age and isn't mostly old people. I like rock climbing and board games, which are both good for making friends.

I love nature, but I don't care about the beach. I will never go. I prefer trees.

I like exploring new restaurants and coffee shops. I don't care about nightlife. I am in bed by 9pm every night 👴

I can't really think of anything else so please ask questions.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 15h ago

Move Inquiry Resident doctor looking for a place to settle down as a gay Asian guy

1 Upvotes

Currently in my early 30s and my top options include

- Columbus
- Minneapolis
- Milwaukee
- DC
- New Orleans

Edit: These are my best (and only) options so far. I’m looking for a more urban and safe environment where I can live comfortably, be myself, and hopefully have a sufficient dating pool for future family building. Bonus points if there’s a good international airport.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 18h ago

Move Inquiry Thinking of moving to Carribean/Gulf, any ideas? (Please Help)

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone! So I recently graduated from the University of Tennessee with a degree in Ecology and Wildlife. I want to just say fuck it and move somewhere amazing, your only 20 once yk. I love the beautiful warm water of the Carribean, and just want to experience something truly breathtaking.

Although I do have a few requirements? Requests? I’m not sure what to call them, just my personal preferences I guess.

- An active nightlife and social scene, I mean I’m only 20, a lively island/city is important to me. I don’t really want to feel stuck in the middle of nowhere
- Somewhere that is relatively easier for an American to move to (Not sure if certain countries have certain restrictions)
- Opportunities in Ecology and Wildlife with an American degree
- Relatively affordable granted I’m fresh outta college ($900-$1500?)

Overall, I just want to live somewhere amazing with a relatively big feel (Not to big though, that’s why I would never move to Miami is because it’s just getting more and more packed by the day)

I just want to spend my twenties making friends, exploring new places, experiencing different cultures, and making unforgettable memories. Along with living somewhere truly unique.

Thank you to everyone who responds!!

P.S. This can be islands, cities, Central America, United States, anywhere! Thank you!!

P.S. looking for ideas outside of Peurto Rico, thank you!!


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 22h ago

Should I stay in Berlin where my ex is everywhere, or move to London and start fresh?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1d ago

Boston or Chicago from Atlanta (single early 30s female, $155k base pay)

3 Upvotes

I've been living in Atlanta for about a year and a half and am considering relocating to a more walkable, urban city. I'm originally from Toronto, and while I've enjoyed my time in Atlanta, I've realized how much I miss the density and spontaneity of living somewhere where you can just walk out your door and discover new restaurants, shops, and neighborhoods.

My current situation in Atlanta:

I pay around $2,800 for a large one-bedroom apartment.

I live in Midtown, close to the BeltLine, and can walk to work and plenty of restaurants.

I've found Atlanta very friendly and have had a relatively easy time building a community of friends.

However, I'm getting tired of having to Uber whenever I want to explore a different neighborhood or do something outside my usual routine.

Chicago:

I'd always heard Chicago compared to Toronto, but after visiting, I found the two cities quite different. Chicago is much less dense than Toronto in my opinion. Even in nice neighborhoods, I saw large stretches without much activity. I miss streets like Queen Street in Toronto, where there are shops, restaurants, and things happening almost continuously.

I was also surprised by how long public transit takes from O'Hare to downtown.

On the positive side, there are plenty of accounting/finance opportunities in Chicago, and I could get a modern, spacious apartment without sacrificing my current quality of life.

Boston:

Unfortunately, due to the FAA issues last week, I wasn't able to make my planned visit, so I haven't experienced the city firsthand.

I'm drawn to its location and the opportunity to explore New England on weekends.

My biggest concern is housing. From what I've seen, $2,800 would likely get me a studio or a relatively small apartment. Basic features like a balcony and in-unit washer/dryer aren't basics over there, and I worry if Boston would be a quality of life downgrade.

I also don't know how long I'll remain in the US, so saving money is important to me. My savings could go a long way if I eventually move elsewhere.

A bit more about me:

I make approximately $155k base and wouldn't necessarily expect a salary increase if I relocated to a more expensive city. I'm single, in my early 30s, and enjoy a mix of socializing and spending weekends on my own. I like tennis, swimming, trivia nights, trying new restaurants, and going out for drinks.

Other options:

I've also lived briefly in New York and loved the energy, but I don't think I can justify the cost of living there. I absolutely loved Philadelphia when I visited, but unfortunately my company doesn't have an office there.

---

For those who have lived in both Boston and Chicago, particularly as a single professional in their 30s:

- Which city offers a better day-to-day lifestyle without a car?

- Which has a better social and dating scene for someone in their early 30s?

- Is Boston worth the housing premium, or would I be better off enjoying the additional space and savings in Chicago?

Thank you all!

(Edited with chatgpt for clarity)


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1d ago

Which Western towns and cities have your favorite DIY music and arts scenes?

2 Upvotes

What towns or cities out West have a really active local music and arts scene? I’m thinking of places like Albuquerque, Boise, and Portland, where you can catch local bands at smaller venues and find people putting on their own shows or running independent art spaces.

LA and Seattle are givens. I’d especially love to hear about smaller towns that have a lot going on for their size.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 21h ago

Seattle music scene

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

Had a question about the music scene in Seattle or Washington as a whole?

Thinking about Philly too, but curious about the heat of summer ? Bugs ? Safety?

Thank you!


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1d ago

Move Inquiry Is Milwaukee the Answer for Us?

14 Upvotes

I currently live in the Chicagoland western suburbs (fox valley) with my partner, but I moved across the country from Austin.

Things that matter to me:

  • A mid-sized metro: What I enjoyed about living in Austin was the metro size, the Chicagoland population is massive and feels similar to Dallas where I grew up. I like being able to cross the city to see friends in under an hour.
  • Healthcare Jobs: I am attending nursing school as a second career.
  • Housing: IL prices are so unaffordable to purchase a home.
  • Access to Nature: We love living next to Fox River and my partner does hobbyist wildlife photography.
  • Social: Activities for 30s-40s. It Is hard to make friends in IL since we are so far from the city. Where we live is family focused and we don’t plan to have children.
  • I don’t drink, but have no problem with others drinking. I am lactose intolerant and I don’t care for sports, I worry that I will be the odd one out in MKE. Partner is allergic to beer (but not spirits) as well.

r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1d ago

Move Inquiry From New England to California. Want some guidance

4 Upvotes

I’ve been in RI and Mass my entire life. My partner and I are looking to move to California soon.

My partner is also from the northeast, lived in CA for a few years then came back. He hasn’t been as happy out here though, and wants to go back. He also thinks I may be a lot happier out there as well and wants me to give it a chance. I’m very open to the opportunity.

I love New England and will always see it as home, but I’ve been unhappy here for quite some time. I have horrid seasonal depression, can’t stand the winters here, and honestly I’m kind of getting sick of the summers too. Not a fan of humidity and swamp ass lol.

What I’m looking for:

-Not too far from the coast. 2 hour drive max. Living in RI for most of my life has had me spoiled I guess and being too far from the beach makes me sad.

-Better weather than New England. I can settle for a little bit of chilly weather and I don’t mind high temps either. I just can’t stand freezing my fuckin’ ass off for like 2/3 months out of the year and then sweating my ass off and barely being able to breathe the other 1/3

-Close to somewhere with nightlife, (1-2hr drive max) more specifically an underground rave scene (I’ve been a part of my local rave scene for 10ish years, it’s a big part of my life)

-Decent arts scene? I’m a visual artist and would like to make something out of that again, whether as a career or even just as a lil side hustle. I like vending at artists markets and such. Also just networking and making friends with other artists.

-Good food is a MUST! I’m from RI, partner is from NJ, our standards are high lol

-Not LA, my partner lived there for a few years, has a love/hate relationship with the city but said he’d never live there again lol

-And of course, proximity to nature. I love the beach— not for swimming, just sitting and contemplating while staring out at the sky and the sea. I also love hiking and taking pictures. And finding cool rocks/stones/crystals! It seems like a lot of CA is good for this regardless of where you go but figured I’d throw that on the list anyways.

So yeah, taking suggestions! I can also maybe be persuaded to consider other states on the West coast. I really want to get away from winter but I’ve heard some people say winters out West regardless of where you go aren’t nearly as bad as they are over here in New England…. Not sure how true that is though.


r/SameGrassButGreener • • 1d ago

Richmond, VA to Minneapolis, Portland, Milwaukee, or Madison?

11 Upvotes

Been living in Richmond, VA the majority of my life; born in the Bay Area. I am getting the itch to move somewhere new.

Currently eyeing Minneapolis!, Portland!, Milwaukee, and Madison. Really was gungho about Madison at first for some reason, knew someone that lived there.

I live alone, pay about $1,450 with utilities, willing to pay more, just sharing a baseline…median rent in richmond is $1400-$1700. i just got lucky with my spot, in arguably the “nicest”, most walkable part of town.

Also, I don’t have a car and have zero desire to get one. I own an electric cargo bike.

Big on good food, local spots, music, artsy/weird shit, and just having things going on. Really just looking for somewhere with a good sense of community where I can settle in for a while.

Curious how these places stack up with cost of living, taxes, infrastructure, general vibes, and day-to-day happiness.

Anyone lived in a couple of these cities? All of them?!? What’s the good, the bad, and the stuff nobody tells you until you actually live there?