r/Scorpio • u/GloomyExperience2173 • 12h ago
Dating a Scorpio š¦š Scorpio man Aries woman
Title: Aries woman with a Scorpio man of 12.5 years. Am I his true love, or am I holding a place for someone he never got over?
Iām an Aries woman, and Iāve been with my Scorpio man for 12 and a half years. Our relationship has been through a lot, and Iām at a point where Iām genuinely trying to understand whether weāre dealing with two wounded people who still love each other or whether Iām holding on to someone whose heart has never been completely with me.
Iāll be the first to admit that Iām not perfect. When Iām hurt, frustrated, or pushed beyond my limits, I can become abrasive with my words. There have been times Iāve said things out of anger. I take accountability for that, and Iām currently working through my own issues in therapy because I genuinely want to become healthier emotionally.
But I also feel like my reactions didnāt come out of nowhere. For a long time, I felt like I was carrying the emotional and practical weight of our relationship. I was constantly having to initiate, fix, address, and manage things that I felt should have been shared responsibilities. I gave multiple chances for certain behaviors to change, and eventually I became emotionally exhausted. I started withdrawing because I didnāt know what else to do.
During a particularly difficult period in our relationship, he began secretly texting his ex.
This is where things get complicated for me.
I believe he has unresolved feelings or emotional attachments to her that he has never fully dealt with. In their conversations, he told her that he thinks about her all the time and wonders what their life might have been like, but added that perhaps it was Godās plan. To me, those arenāt exactly the words of someone who has completely made peace with the past.
He also told her that he was angry with me and that if I didnāt want him, he would find someone who did.
What bothers me is that I donāt really know the full story of what happened between them. He has admitted to some of his past behaviors, but heās very guarded about the emotional history and what that relationship meant to him. She still responds when he reaches out, but from what Iāve seen, she doesnāt seem to be actively encouraging him emotionally or pursuing him.
I canāt help but wonder whether he still wants her and whether the only reason theyāre not together is because she isnāt willing to have him.
When Iāve tried to end our relationship, he doesnāt want me to leave. He tells me he loves me to death, but his actions often leave me feeling like Iām not fully being chosen. Heās emotionally guarded, sometimes selfish, and seems to have a difficult time being vulnerable or taking accountability for the deeper issues between us.
And hereās the part that hurts the most:
I feel like a placeholder.
I sometimes wonder whether whatever he experienced with her, whatever they shared or lost, is something Iāll never experience with him. Whether thereās a part of him that still romanticizes that relationship and keeps that door emotionally cracked open in case thereās ever an opportunity to revisit it.
I donāt want to compete with a memory, an unfinished relationship, or a woman from his past. I want to experience a love where I donāt have to question whether someoneās heart is somewhere else.
I do believe weāre both unhealed in certain ways. Iām not writing this to make him the villain or myself the victim. I genuinely want a healthy life with him, and Iām willing to do the work on my end. But I also donāt want to spend another 12 years trying to convince someone to love me in a way that makes me feel secure.
My questions are:
From a Scorpio manās perspective, can you genuinely love your current partner while still having unresolved romantic feelings for an ex?
Is it possible that he holds on to the idea of her because their relationship never had the opportunity to fully play out, rather than because sheās necessarily the person he truly wants?
Can a man be afraid of losing his current partner while simultaneously wishing things had worked out with someone from his past?
Am I interpreting his emotional attachment correctly, or am I allowing my insecurities and the damage in our relationship to shape what I see?
Have any of you experienced a relationship where your partner loved you but never seemed to fully let go of someone else?
Iām not looking for people to automatically tell me to leave him or tell me heās a Scorpio, so thatās just how they are. Iām looking for honest perspectives, especially from people who have experienced this dynamic.
I want to understand the difference between being loved and being someoneās actual choice.