I've been looking at some Seether songs which I feel are underappreciated. These are all my personal thoughts, so take them with a grain of salt.
I've Got You Under My Skin
The original song was written way back in 1936 by composer Cole Porter for a musical film called "Born to Dance". It was performed in the film by Virginia Bruce and even nominated for an Oscar. Later, in 1956 the song was immortalised when music legend Frank Sinatra recorded his version of it for the album "Songs for Swingin' Lovers!"
Eventually for a digital Frank Sinatra tribute album called "His Way, Our Way", Seether covered the song in 2009. It was never released on any Seether album, so it slipped somewhere between the cracks of the Seether discography.
Is it really a huge surprise that "I've Got You Under My Skin" turns up on a list for underappreciated Seether Songs? Not really. But I still keep mentioning this one, because this gem deserves a much bigger audience.
All credits for the lyrics have to go to Mr. Cole Porter. The film version sung by Virginia Bruce is done in a typical musical style. She was not only singing it, she was acting it as well. All whilst smoking a cigarette. A soft and sweet, but honest delivery where the words truly mean what they say. I think it has a certain charm to it that sneaks under your skin.
A charm that Frank Sinatra saw as well. Taking the same letters, but putting them in a different soup. A spicier one. Sinatra's version pulls out an orchestra for the ultimate delivery. What I particularly like about it is that it starts out soft and proceeds to get more bombastic as it goes. A tune that swings towards you and crawls under your skin.
And decades later, Seether takes Sinatra's version and creates another soup with the same letters. A more bittersweet one. One that puts a whole new perspective on the lyrics. Shaun's raw sound, combined with captivating instrumentals adds another vibe to the song.
Building it up slowly in the first verses. Once we reach the chorus, it becomes slightly bigger, carried by an awfully catchy tune. Then as the chorus is over, it takes it down a notch again. About the same level we had in the beginning.
What I think is beautifully done here, is that when we think we can't tone it down any further, Seether does. Instrumentals fade out almost completely as Shaun sings, "Don't you know, fool. You can never win." It keeps things subdued throughout this verse, only to open that final chorus as the most powerful moment of the song. Eventually letting it decrease again towards the end of the song.
Once again proving that Seether has such a wide range of musical abilities. This version of "I've Got You Under My Skin" isn’t extremely dark or loud. But it captures a very fine, fresh take on something that's already good. Seether plants something under your skin and lets it grow there.
While Seether isn’t the only artist who covered Sinatra's version. To me, this is the best one I've heard. It's often that the lyrics carry the message of the music. But all these different versions of the song show me how the music can carry the message of the lyrics as well.
It's not always about the words you're using, sometimes it's about how you express them. Theoretically they say the same thing. Practically, they can hold a very different weight.
Not particularly underappreciated by Seether fans. But way too underappreciated by the rest of the world.
Thanks for reading!