r/Shouldihaveanother • • 2h ago

The case for two vs one

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m currently almost 2 months pregnant with our second. We already have an amazing almost 3 year old daughter. We took the stance of “if it happens it happens” and welp, it did. I’m 35. I don’t have any siblings, husband doesn’t either. I can’t go back obviously so I know it’s maybe not helpful to ask myself “am I doing the right thing” but I just find myself a little scared. I know so many one-and-done parents and I’m just finding myself anxious about how my current household balance and relationship to my daughter will change. I wish I had more examples of parents with two kids who love it. I’m a stay at home mom, I love her so much I cannot imagine loving another human this much but I’m told you just find room in your heart. I’d love to hear positive stories and experiences about having a second. I’d appreciate any wisdom and insight!


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 45m ago

Advice Parents of one of more....

Thumbnail
• Upvotes

Just need a bit of advice. Would love you to share your age when your had your first, and then your second (and how was your first when they were born!?). How have you found it!!?

I'm 35 & my son is 2 & a half. Every single day I ask myself if I'm ready for another .... I don't know. Were you in this predicament too?

My main concern is my capacity, i love my son but I'm a stay at home mum with an amazing husband & father to my son but we have no village. I get over stimulated a lot (defo neurospicy myself) and just fing exhausted.

I'm worried if I have another it will ramp up more and I'll just be unhappy. I love my son I love being a parent but it's ffing relentless, the only relief I get is when my husband steps in and then if we have another I'm concerned it'll be one child or the other and never a break?

Or is it that thing if you have one.... You may as well have another?

I'm prepared to go through the baby stage and pregnancy (even tho I had bad sickness so will probs be grim again) but cripes. Will I cope?!? How do YOU cope!?

Is it worth me waiting a good while (am concerned about loss and or being able to concieve as well, never had issues in past)

Sincerely, a very confused mum who wants another, and a sibling for her son, but really isn't sure she'll survive also... M


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 48m ago

Wondering if another baby is the right decision?

• Upvotes

So, I (24f) have been with my partner who is 28 for almost 5 years. We have a child that sees us both as their parents, but I did have them before we got together. My child was under 2 years old when we met and is now turning 7 this year, which is so exciting for us and for them!

To make a long story slightly shorter, my partner was undecided/on the fence about another baby from the second I brought it up. We had a few emotion-heavy conversations about it over the past year at least, and my partner let me know earlier this year that they do think they want us to have another and that there would be some regret if we didn't try. They do want us to be able to have a reasonable savings, though, which we are working on and I completely agree with. My partners reasoning for not wanting another is that they never really pictured their life with any children, they wanted to travel, and they wanted to be their life partners first priority, but coming into the lives of myself and my child opened up those doors. We also have a few animals that add an extra small layer of finances/stress and that worries my partner as well.

I'm obviously the one who presses more about wanting a baby, but I do try to make sure I'm not overdoing it (because I have in the past). Ideally I would like to have another before our first child is 9/10. We both have jobs, and my partner is supposed to be moving up and getting a raise. I was also considering taking my child out of public school and homeschooling for this next school year, but I would have to quit my job or work a major part time schedule. Basically I'm wondering if I'm doing too much from an outsiders perspective, lol. We aren't the most rich family in the world, and sometimes I get overwhelmed with my life as it is currently. I'm afraid I will be biting off more than I can chew, but I know I will regret not having another and I really want to give my child a sibling (they do want one too, its not just me trying to imagine a life for my child lol). I also know that I am fully capable of taking care of another baby/children in general and I would more than step up to the plate if we did have another.

Please be kind! 🤍


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 9h ago

Advice Second child?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

My husband and I have been married for six years, and we have a four-year-old daughter.

I never really wanted a second child because I was afraid of the physical and emotional exhaustion. I also had this feeling, which may sound silly, that it would be difficult to share the love, attention, and affection I currently give my daughter with another child. Another thing is that, if I'm completely honest, I always imagined having another girl rather than a boy.

However, something has changed in me recently. I had been struggling with anxiety and depression, but I started treatment about three months ago. I'm taking antidepressants, and I genuinely feel like a different person. I'm happier, more emotionally stable, and I see things differently.

I've also started noticing how lonely my daughter sometimes feels. She goes to kindergarten and has other children around her, but I can see that she longs for someone to share her everyday life with, someone who is here at home, a sibling to grow up with.

My husband's biggest dream has always been to have a second child. He doesn't care whether it's a boy or a girl; he simply wants another baby. We are financially stable, and I know he would be incredibly happy.

I've promised him that I would have a second child, and for the first time, I'm actually considering it seriously. But now that the possibility is becoming real, I'm starting to panic all over again.

I have a gynecologist appointment on Monday to have my IUD removed, and suddenly I'm questioning everything. I don't know whether I'm making the right decision or whether I'm rushing into something I'm not entirely sure about.

For those of you who already have two or more children: What are the real advantages of having a second child? Does it genuinely enrich your family and your first child's life? Do you feel that having a second child was one of the best decisions you ever made, even with all the extra exhaustion and challenges?

And what about the age difference? If I get pregnant now, my children will be five years apart.

I'd really appreciate honest experiences, especially from mothers who were initially unsure about having another child.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 20h ago

Gender disappointment (kind of)

6 Upvotes

I have a girl and I have a sister myself who I’m really close to and we played dress up, Barbie’s, so much fun stuff growing up and I just found out I’m having a boy and am feeling a little sad. Sad about maybe not being as close, sad about all the hand me downs going to waste (we don’t have a lot of money so buying all new clothes hurts on top of wanting to see my daughters littler clothes again but superficial). We only have one bathroom that they will share probably forever because our interest rate is so low lol

I want to hear stories of closeness with brother and sister, ideas on how to obtain affordable clothes (thrift stores are price gouging now), and just overall success stories with boys and girls (little and big) it’s a 2.5 year gap and we are done after 2.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 21h ago

Fencesitting We already have one of each, should we have a third?

0 Upvotes

We (husband 39m, wife 34f) are really on the fence about having a third. I think I (wife) truly do want 2 more but I just don’t think I can bring myself to do 2 more pregnancies and infant sleep and feeding experiences. If we were older and could take a bit of a break and then have 2 more that would be so ideal but my husband is almost 40 and he is really anxious about his age and waiting to have more kids. He wants us to continue thinking about it and make a final decision on having a third by his 40th birthday which is a few months away. His main concern is the financial aspect when the kids are older and in more activities or sports. (currently they’re 3.5yo and 14m) and while they have some activities now they’re pretty low cost compared to like hockey or something. He Is also concerned that some mainstream economists think there is going to be another global depression. My main concern is dividing my time between the kids. Truthfully I already find it kind of hard with 2 and I don’t want to take away from my existing kids to have another. But I know plenty of people have more than 2 kids. I also worry about the sibling dynamic with 3 and one being left out and how everyone says 3 is the hardest number of kids to have. I come from a family of 4 but there’s a really large gap so it was like 2 sets of 2. my husband comes from a family of 3 but again there was a really large gap between 2 of them and the third.
Our house has 4 bedrooms and we already have a new minivan and 4 seater wagon we got in anticipation of having more than 2 kids and a full wardrobe for either gender since we’ve saved all our kids clothes. But obviously having a third will come with added expenses. Just mentioning the bigger ones aren’t a concern. We also have like no village. Another big one for me is that both times postpartum there was a pretty big family emergency that took away a lot of my focus on just experiencing my newborn and recovering and I would truly like to have at least one calm postpartum experience in my life (Or as calm as it could be with 2 toddlers lol)


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Women who had a child ‘later in life’ (38+) how has it been raising them as you get older?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

It's wonderful. How many times people might think you're a grandma or a grandpa. So what. Do what your heart asks of you


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Family size

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Having a Child in Your 40s

3 Upvotes

I am 45 years old, and my wife is 43. We have two children, aged 13 and 15, and we are considering having another baby.

Given our ages, are the risks of Down syndrome or congenital abnormalities significantly higher? Can these risks be reduced through additional medical care, precautions, or prenatal screening during pregnancy?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Rant Wanting more kids

7 Upvotes

We have two kids. Got pregnant when my second turned one, but sadly lost the baby near the end of the first trimester. The third pregnancy wasn’t planned, we were scared but embracing it and we’re getting excited. i was devastated when i lost the pregnancy. it’s been 6 months since the loss and all i think about is having a third baby. At first my husband was open to the idea of trying again after some time passes, then now says he doesn’t want to have a third and seems closed off to the thought of having another. I’m so sad about it, its literally the only thing I can think about, especially when I’m ovulating its like x1000. anyways thats my rant, I can’t get my mind off of having more kids.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

2 crianças?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

My husband really wants us to have a second child. We have a 4-year-old daughter, and we’ve been together for six years. Our financial situation is relatively stable, but I promised myself that I would never have another child because of how physically and mentally exhausting motherhood can be. I’m a stay-at-home mom and don’t work outside the home.

However, lately, I’ve been looking at my daughter and noticing how lonely she seems and how much she longs for companionship. It makes me question my decision, and I honestly don’t know what to do.

I have a copper IUD, and I’ve even considered having it removed and trying for another baby. I've thought about surprising my husband with the news, because I know he would be incredibly happy. I’m sure he would work twice as hard to provide for our family and make it all possible.

But deep down, I would really love to have another girl. Should I take the risk?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Family of 3?

0 Upvotes

Ok,

Currently have 2 boys, 3 yrs and 5 months.

My first son is a dream, listens, not wild. So thoughtful and caring. Easy.

Second is still a baby so I don’t want to make an official judgment, but nothing concerning.

I am considering a third,

So looking for examples families who have gone to 3.

Specially 3 under 5 and a boy boy girl combo. What’s the dynamic like?

What is travel like ( we are in Europe so we can just get Ryan air flights and drive into Europe to make travel more accessible)

What’s the bedtime routines like? We eat together as a family since my oldest was 18 months and then had a strict tv time, bath time, books and bed routine. ( youngest is too young, but. I imagine will slot in)

Child care is ok, we have no family nearby but both the school and the nursery are in our village and on the same street and the same hours, so I don’t see logistically a problem? And we have the means to have babysitters when needed.

Context:
I really wanted a boy and girl family, not against a 3, but logistically not sure how it looks.

I tried 4 rounds of IVF and only got boys.i was worried my first son wouldn’t have a sibling and that was more important to me than having a girl. And I got pregnant quite easily with my second son. So I am happy my sons have each other and not only children ( I am an only child). So if I had a third, if, it would only be a girl. I have no interest in debating a boy third.

Everything comes at a cost, so to me having a 3rd girl is worth that inconvenience but a third boy is not. Sorry if that offends. I will be doing IVF, there is no risk.

For me either:
Stay at 2 boys: Easier logistics and disposable income
Have a girl and have 3: harder logistics, less disposable but should still have be able to provide the lifestyle I want (might just have to work a bit longer) but have a fuller family and experience all life experiences

So both are fine for me depending on what life has in store. Positives both ways as IVF is not guaranteed.

I worry about one of them being left out, not being able to be the mother I want, and ensuring all of them feel loved and supported.

In a perfect world, I’d love 2 boys and 2 girls. But I would need a cook, a cleaner, a gardener and a nanny to be able to support that but unfortunately, that is not my life! Ha

I generally think you never regret children because they are so happy and lovely and pure and full of light.

Sorry for the long post; but interested to hear some opinions!

Happy to clarify anything


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Advice Got twins aged 2, should I have a third? (Our son is deaf and daughter is hearing)

0 Upvotes

I didn’t even think about a third child but my wife always pictured a third child so just want to hear some stories of how parents went from 2 to 3 (or didn’t). I guess if there are parents who had a child that required additional love and care that would be willing to share their story, that would be amazing!

Background:
- we’ve got twins aged 2 (boy girl). The boy is profoundly deaf and requires PT/OT/Speech. We are in the process of learning Auslan (we are based in Australia)

- we are 33 and 34 years old

- genetic testing didn’t give us any results as to why our boy is deaf which makes us question whether to test our luck with third?)

- twins doesn’t run in our families, we just got lucky

- our jobs are stable and secure, not stressful at all.

- our house can accommodate an extra child.

- we may need to upgrade our car but that’s not an issue.

We are scared what if a third child is born with a disability too or what happens when you’re out numbered? I know my situation is very specific and not sure if there are many other parents on this forum with a similar situation but would to hear your story.

Does having a third child take away from your first two? Did they feel like you weren’t paying enough attention?

How much were you impacted financially?

Part of the reason for a 3rd was to make sure my son has enough support around him (his twin sister and a younger sibling) when we aren’t around but if it comes at a cost or regret not sure if it’s worth 😔 idk I’m very confused sorry!

If there are any questions I haven’t thought about, let me know 😊


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Cold feet

1 Upvotes

We wanted two kids, were fortunate to have two, but as soon as #2 came out I felt like I wasn’t done. I have gone back and forth; for a few months I would yearn for another, then feel done and excited about moving past the baby stage, then a few months later swing back the other way.

Due to age and some other factors, it’s something that would have to happen in the short term. Partner and I decided we’d give it 3 tries (Oct, Nov, Dec) then close the shop if it doesn’t work out.

Now that the time has come, I am having cold feet. My kids (1.5, 3.5) are both kinda loud and needy right now, though also completely wonderful. We have finally gotten to a point where the littler one can walk and is starting to communicate, and it’s clear how things will soon be easier. The bigger one is in preschool. The thought of doing the newborn thing again is exhausting. The thought of moving ahead as a family of 4 is tempting, but I also don’t feel 100% ready to close the door in case we are meant to have a 3rd, which has felt like the case at times.. but not at other times. I wanted to kinda leave it up to fate, but the lack of excitement I feel is disappointing and I am not sure what to do. The odds of conception in these two months at my age isn’t great, so maybe I should just stick to the plan.. I think I’m just venting but if anyone has words of wisdom, I’ll take them!


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 2d ago

How old is too old for another baby

5 Upvotes

At what age did you cap yourself or what is considered too old to have another baby as a female?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

When did you decide on baby #2?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Partner wants to try for another baby 6 months postpartum

0 Upvotes

I'm 6 months postpartum as of three days ago and my partner brought up trying for another. He said he wants to conceive before December.

HUH?!

I'm not entirely sure I even want another, let alone so soon.

I had a stressful pregnancy that ended in an emergency c-section and a month-long NICU stay for our daughter.

I explained I don't want to do that again, and he understood. Then I brought up going on the depo shot and he's given me 20 reasons not to. Then he says "why do you need to go on birth control at all?"

Hmm... I wonder if the name of birth control has something to do with it, perhaps?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 2d ago

Fencesitting Anyone with a 3rd kid who also has a hard firstborn?

2 Upvotes

I have 2 kids, 3M and 1F, and I truly think we might be done. But I keep coming back to the idea of a third because I love babies and I always pictured a bigger family.

My firstborn was really hard as a baby and toddler. Colic, never slept, and it went on for two years before things calmed down. The second has been easy. That contrast is what scares me. What if the third is like my first? I am not sure I have another really hard baby and toddler in me with two older kids already.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 2d ago

3rd baby?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

5 weeks & 6 days

0 Upvotes

Anyone have 4 kids and got prengnant with 5th? Having 4 kids is already stressful and i can imagine 5 is worse. Really leaning towards getting a MA


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 2d ago

Advice Scared I will miss the fun stage with my first

9 Upvotes

My first child is almost 3 and I finally feel like things are getting much easier and we can start to do more fun things like go to the zoo or cafes, or swimming, or catch a train to the city, play at more playground etc, but at the same time I want another child, I just think the overall bigger family is nice and I want them to have each other in life. But I’m worried that as soon as I’ve gotten to the stage where I can really spend time with my first doing more interesting things like the above, if I go back to sleepless nights and breastfeeding I’ll just not have the ability to do anything else. My husband also gets overwhelmed easier than most people but he also wants a second but in the back of my mind I wonder if he could actually manage because everyone says it’s more than double the difficulty of having one. Would love to hear what others think overall. Thank you!


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 2d ago

Anxious We set a time limit, now I feel guilty, like I failed

2 Upvotes

I'm sorry if I ramble or if the post is too long. I feel crazy. My husband and I always said we both wanted two. We have one right now. This past year has made us very well considering being one and done and I feel like I'm wrong for that. I'm always being told don't decide now, or he will need a sibling for his benefit.

I'm a SAHM, and my husband works most the week on nightshifts. We are financially stable, but times get tough as they do for most folks. We've realized that having a bigger age gap is something that could possibly be very bad for our mental health and that if we wanted baby #2 it would have to be soon. We don't want him be starting school then starting back to square one. We have talked about the obvious unplanned pregnancy before this, if it was a surprise pregnancy then its just ok we're having another one. It's not that we wouldn't want another child or anything but there's alot to consider and pros and cons to both sides. We set a time that if I'm not pregnant by then, we will be done (I'm aware we can always change our minds but I kinda doubt that). It's within the next year.

I feel very guilty I'm okay with this choice, happy even. I feel like I failed for some reason. Like for putting conditions in place and possibly changing my mind. I mean I know its a joint decision and my husband is supportive but still. We really do want 2 but despite being younger I have physical health issues and long story short I almost died giving birth and I'm genuinely terrified of being pregnant again. My husband is scared for me too. What if our son really does need a sibling for his development or when we're old and gone? What if I'm being selfish? Am I crazy for feeling this way? I feel so damn silly just making a post about it but oh well. Does anyone else have this feeling? Please tell me it goes away, it feels like it shouldn't be this difficult of a decision. Is it worth bringing this up to family for support? Or no, because it isn't their decision? Again, it should feel this overwhelming.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 2d ago

Having a second child after first had autism/ADHD

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

Am I crazy?!

3 Upvotes

Pregnant with another baby and my boys will be 6 and 8 when she’s born. I’ve posted about my worries here before regarding age gap etc, but I’ve been feeling worse about it lately because of some people’s reactions. It seems like everyone thinks this baby is a surprise and some people have seemed really shocked. Is it really that crazy to start over when my son hits kindergarten? I know it seems like a big gap, but for me it feels like my kids were toddlers just yesterday.. time has really flown. If you were to hear your friend was pregnant and she had a 5 and newly 8 year old, would you think it was nuts? It’s all just making my insecurities about this whole thing worse and it doesn’t feel great to announce :/


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 2d ago

How do you know when you’re ‘done’ having babies?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes