r/SportsCardTracker • • 16d ago

Important [EOY 2026 Survey] Determine rule satisfactory and warnings for scammers

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

The holidays are fast approaching us as we reach the end of the year. Therefore, there has been an uptick in posts warning about potential scammers. I'd like to gauge what everyone thinks about the current rules, whether people should be allowed to warn about potential scams, and how useful you think requiring proof for negative feedback has been. Please take a moment to fill out the survey form below and reach out if you have any concerns, or questions!

https://forms.gle/4qRiEhujKWkfGyga7


r/SportsCardTracker • • Apr 04 '26

Important Megathread - April 2026 - Potential Scammer/Pre-Sale Feedback

8 Upvotes

Please post all potential warnings for scammers, or pre-sale feedback here. You must provide photographic proof of your claims and any personal information must be redacted before providing the photos. I've attached a photo of an example of how claims/photos must be posted in order to prevent removal of your comment.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 3h ago

Positive [Positive] u/CaMcA527

6 Upvotes

A mail day featuring an envelope from u/CaMcA527 is always a good mail day.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 4h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Appropriate_Tooth318

4 Upvotes

Just a deeply pleasant person to chat with, trade with, and enjoy. Thanks, as always, u/Appropriate_Tooth318! You're a good one!!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 3h ago

Positive [Positive] u/bryancm3

3 Upvotes

Sent a birthday gold to u/bryancm3 who immediately sent one back for the archives. Thanks so much for your contribution!!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 1h ago

Positive [Positive] u/B-sizzauce

1 Upvotes

Easy transaction


r/SportsCardTracker • • 20h ago

Negative [negative] u/Think-Freedom-8057

17 Upvotes

Messaged and purchased a Trout card from him on Nov 5. Provided my info same day and was told it would go out. Messaged him on Nov. 12 asking about the card and tracking. He responded saying that he was out of town all week but his wife mailed it out the previous week. Assured me I would receive it. 2 separate people messaged me saying that they had gotten similar responses. Messaged him again saying I wanted to know what’s going on with no response. Waited until the weekend and put in a PayPal claim. Just got my refund today.
He has since removed his listing.
Be careful everyone and use PayPal G/S!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 21h ago

Neutral [Neutral] u/locksmithguilty1175

12 Upvotes

I purchased a Nap Lajoie t206 from this user with PayPal G & S on Thursday. Seller confirmed receipt and said it would be shipped the next day. Then he told me he didn't get to the PO Friday, and that it would be shipped Saturday. No response to my question all weekend. Messaged Monday saying it would go out that day. Then nothing. Its now Tuesday night with no response.

I filed the claim with paypal. After this he got me tracking. Received the card today. Neutral due to lack of communication


r/SportsCardTracker • • 16h ago

Positive [Positive]u/islayhaveanother

3 Upvotes

Yall, this dude is TOP NOTCH!! If you haven’t had the pleasure of doing bidness with this gentleman… do yourself a favor and look him up!!

Amazing trade made between the two of us, and certainly cannot wait for the next one!!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 16h ago

Positive [Positive] u/ollie-trey

3 Upvotes

Made a great trade and couldn't be happier! Highly recommended!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 17h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Downtown_Ant

2 Upvotes

Bought some cards from this user. Communication was good, no stress, and the cards were sent out promptly and packed well. No issues at all and would absolutely buy from this user again.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 16h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Adventurous-Tap2562

1 Upvotes

Smooth deal, responsive, shipped fast.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 20h ago

Positive [positive]u/monetarylapse

2 Upvotes

As always TJ is the man. Buy your cards from him!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 17h ago

Positive [positive] u/roberticusRX

1 Upvotes

Easy transaction, fast shipping! Recommend working with this awesome vintage baseball seller.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 19h ago

Positive [Positive] u/amv6419

1 Upvotes

Quick easy deal on a small lot. Everything arrived quick and safely. Thanks!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 19h ago

Positive [Positive] u/skj123

1 Upvotes

Bought 21 1961-63 Post cards. Seller was responsive and easy to work with. +++


r/SportsCardTracker • • 1d ago

Negative [Negative] u/FckCharles223

34 Upvotes

Update 11/18: His profile is now set to hide his comments and posts, so he’s definitely seen this 🤣

Last Monday (11/9) I decided to pull the trigger on a Topps 1991 /99 McGonigle auto RC after I saw a post on r/baseballcards by u/FcKCharles223 (WARNING: very NSFW). We negotiated a bit, he referenced some vague financial emergency, and ultimately he accepted my offer of $275 sent via Paypal G&S. He kinda freaked out a little when PayPal placed a hold on his account after I sent him the money. He obviously wanted this cash immediately, going so far as to say he "might have to refund (me)" if he had to wait a bit for the money. He said the next day that the hold had been lifted and that he would proceed with mailing the card. A week later, that has not happened and he has ghosted me.

I asked on 11/11 if he had a tracking number for me, forgetting that it was Veteran's Day and that there is no mail pickup. He said it would go out the next day (11/12). So we're good up until this point. 11/12 passes with no update. On 11/13 I asked for the tracking number and he didn't reply. On 11/14 I told him that I need either the tracking number or a refund. Still no reply. At this point I opened a case with PayPal. He has until 11/24 to respond with proof of shipment, which to this point doesn't exist. He created a shipping label on 11/13 but USPS still doesn't have the item.

It's too early to call this person an outright scammer, but I regret doing business with someone who exuded such desperation right off the bat. I wish he had shown a fraction of the urgency mailing the card that he exhibited in receiving payment for it. At minimum, I consider his lack of communication and promptness enough to warrant a negative review on here. I strongly recommend avoiding this seller.

And Charles, if you're reading this, I was honestly left feeling pretty deflated due to your actions. I'm not made of money. I was dealing with some pretty tragic and sudden personal shit, and decided to treat myself to a frivolous purchase to take my mind off things. For you to think it's okay to just take my money without even attempting to fulfill your end of the deal is frankly pathetic. Send me the card or give me my money back.

Edit: added a NSFW warning for our dude’s profile 😬


r/SportsCardTracker • • 20h ago

Positive [positive]u/evilpete22

1 Upvotes

I did a higher value trade with him. All cards arrived safe. Will continue to trade.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 20h ago

Positive [positive]u/gremcat

1 Upvotes

Yet another trade in the books. Always a pleasure.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 1d ago

Positive [Positive] u/LeftyCards

3 Upvotes

Bought some cards from this user recently. Order was received quickly, and he communicated the entire time so I was not guessing on any parts of the process. 10/10 would buy from him again!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 22h ago

Positive [positive] u/standard_two_8089

0 Upvotes

Thanks for an awesome PC experience! User sent me cards for my PC, no strings attached. Thanks!! u/standard_two_8089.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 1d ago

Positive [Positive] u/BrewCrewPaul

2 Upvotes

Classic win-win trade, as I picked up a pair of Blue Jays golds in exchange for a low-SN card of a player I didn't collect. Appreciate you, u/BrewCrewPaul!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/Competitive-Basil958

1 Upvotes

Made a trade with this user - cards arrived quickly and were well packaged. Would definitely trade again!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 1d ago

Positive [Positive] u/sohare78

1 Upvotes

Great transaction with this buyer. Prompt payment, communicative, and quick replies. They confirmed they got the cards and were overall pleasant to deal with. Would deal with them again!