Just got my frame today, after hearing the horror stories and bad reviews I was ready for the huge disappointment....there wasn't any. The only problem I had was that the dongle didn't work with my extender, so I just slotted it directly even if it was basically at floor level.
So, lets start, the passthrough quality at first left me disappointed, there was noise and distortions everywhere, then, for no apparent reason, it fixed itself. I installed the arcturus vision camera and holy shit, insane.
Not gonna even say much about comfort, it's amazing and that's about it
the quality of the menu, the response time and feeling of the controllers felt better than index, less clunky, it's a feeling thing more than something specific.
The controller themselves are worse than index however, and that's the only bad thing I really have to say, but they are lightweight and small, its easier to do other things while having the controllers on.
As for quality, there's clearly a jump in quality, but not that extreme of a jump.
Going from vive to index was night and day, was like going from a playstation 2 to a playstation 3, but the upgrade from index to frame, quality wise, its like going from a 5070 to a 5090, it's good and definitely better but you can live on a 5070 no problems.
That being said, EVERYTHING ELSE is an upgrade. Not having a cable is absurd, the streaming was amazing, 0 problems 0 stutters 0 quality drop 0 blur, it was pretty much like index but better quality and slightly lower luminosity.
I was able to go take a shit and play around with the settings without ever taking off the headset. I was using my pc while I was in another room....it's so good.
There's definitely some truth in what people said, it can feel like a sidegrade in certain aspects, and even a slight downgrade in things like controllers or luminosity, but the number of things that feel like an upgrade outweight them by a lot.
I don't think I'll go back to the index anytime soon, and this should tell you quite a lot.