r/Stoicism • • 16h ago

Stoicism in Practice How to stop being so hard on yourself

9 Upvotes

So, dealing with humans is going to be slightly different every time. It's hard to predict in advance how to handle everything. Even though I understand human rudeness, it often takes me by surprise because it's not how I choose to treat others and unprovoked childish behavior just makes you look bad.

Whenever I handle something, even if I can say it was assertive or a reasonable reaction in the moment. I always beat myself up later that I didn't handle it 'better'. I should have had a stronger reaction, I should have been firmer, I was too nice when this person didn't deserve it. I let an 'injustice' slide and thus I allowed such things to perpetuate in the world. I have a strong personal responsibility for my actions and so if I fall short of an ideal, I treat it as a total failure. On the other hand, if I was too aggressive/harsh I would probably be beating myself up for being too much of a jerk if I decided later, it was unwarranted.

This happens too often. ...I suppose I'm seeking some tangible proof that the ideology of my identity isn't false. I am who I believe myself to be and my actions back that up. What stance does stoicism take on personal identity as it relates to expression of. I tend to believe intentions define a person more than actions. Yet your choices are more often reflected in your actions and people often struggle to see themselves objectively.


r/Stoicism • • 5h ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance Worried I might've messed up my future

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm pretty new here.

I've known about stoicism for a long time now, but never really spent a ton of effort practicing it. I haven't studied any texts, I just watched a few youtube videos (video essays, not the ai slop) years ago and tried incorporating a few beliefs in my daily life whenever I saw the opportunity. I have a lot of things I'm grateful for, and while my life isn't perfect I was content with the bare minimum philosophy needed to keep me happy.

Recently I've been faced with my greatest obstacle yet. Long story short, I made a bad decision and I'm in trouble with my university. I thought I was doing the right thing but in hindsight it was wrong and doesn't help anyone. I've been temporarily suspended and I'm worried I've jeopardized my future. While I still have hope that it'll be resolved quickly, in the worst case scenario that it takes a long time to resolve, I won't be able to take my finals for the semester. I would have to retake all my current classes, become a semester behind, and would graduate late with an extra 18k of debt.

I've been trying to stay calm and composed, telling myself things like even if that somehow happens, I'll still have my whole life ahead of me and I could be far worse off. But despite my best efforts I'm still quite nervous about the uncertainty of the situation and my heart rate has been a little faster today.

I can't undo my actions, but a stoic would use this as an opportunity for growth which is what I would like to do. Do any stoics out there have any advice, whether its for my situation or any relevant texts I could study? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


r/Stoicism • • 1h ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance The difficulty of accepting failure.

• Upvotes

Normally accepting failure is difficult because we sometimes dont want to admit we failed, comes from a place of ego.

But for me, i find it difficult to accept failure because i feel like im “ getting away with it “ if i immediately forgive myself.

For a little context, i have a stutter, and i was afraid of asking someone how many sets they had. In the gym.

Ive dealt with this before, i already know my mind is just being fed a handfull of false perceptions in that moment. I know there is no actual harm that could happen. Even if for some reason the whole gym started laughing at me, this still doesnt actually harm me in any way.

So i had no excuse to not go and ask, but i didnt. I somehow slid myself out of the situation.

Now, i know the correct next step would be to instantly forgive myself and keep moving. To not let this take any more of my time. And a bunch of other logical and philosophical reasons you could think of. But i cant fully move on.

Yet again, its like my soul doesnt trust my brain when it tells it its okay.

I feel, if i dont suffer for this that i cant move on. Because ill just feel like im getting away with failure.

This is the one thing i dont understand about us humans. How can we know something, yet still fail to believe it? How can i know nothing bad will happen if i ask that dude his set count, yet i still feel fear?

( also, i believe what im doing, not accepting failure because i feel like i dont deserve it, is also coming from a place of ego. )


r/Stoicism • • 1h ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

• Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.