TL;DR: YouTube seems to have taken the stance that SynthV music is AI music and flags it as such.
Right now, a lot of the AI disclosure on YouTube depends on the uploader: YouTube will ask uploaders, yes or no, does your video contain AI content? From what I've seen, the norm is that producers are not using this AI flag for their music. Understandably so. No one wants their honest work lumped in with Suno-generated dross with burpy vocals and kicks that can't decide what they want to sound like. And while I would like to be able to filter out mass-produced machine slop (which I thought YouTube was getting good at, but it seems that the slop has returned to my recommendations, sadly), I don't want to miss the next rising SynthV producer in the process, and I think many of us here feel the same. Plus, basically everyone I've seen declares which voicebanks are being used in the title and/or description, and this should arguably be sufficient disclosure anyways.
However, in practice, it seems that YouTube is now cracking down on music with vocals from SynthV and similar software (e.g. CeVIO/VoiSona, DiffSinger, maybe even newer Vocaloid), treating it as no different from AI-generated music from generators like Suno and Udio. Some examples:
- Last week, Eirreyn's ABBA covers with Teto got taken down because of a contractual requirement with Universal Music Group, rights owners to ABBA music, regarding synthetic content that simulates a musician's vocals. Subsequently their AdSense account got closed for "dishonest declaration." (I don't know if this is related, being that they already said they didn't monetize the Teto covers, but I can't help but wonder. Anyway, this bums me the fuck out, because Eirreyn does good work and is understandably distraught about this, feeling hopeless as a starting producer.)
- It's not just covers either. Alex Coldfire's music with SV Teto got automatically flagged as AI on YouTube Music.
Where does this leave us? There's a good argument for leaving YouTube anyway. Google are scummy and YouTube has always been clumsy about these things (see how people abuse their copyright strike system). I for one am looking at alternatives like Vimeo. YouTube already blocked my "Eyes, Nose, Lips" cover so I've been looking for other places to post it anyway. However, that's easier said for people like me, who are doing this on the side and not making a living off our stuff. YouTube is still unfortunately one of the better ways to make money.