r/TalentlessNana • u/A-Sadistick-Stick • 4h ago
Discussion Moe and how love alone doesn’t erase abuse
Moe within the context of her series, does a good job of showing that while yes a child being taken out of an abusive environment into the arms of someone genuinely loving will allow them to be happier long term; look at how Nana someone who was never safe acts when given genuine affection. It doesn’t however fully remove the effects of the past abuse for a developing mind.
Moe was consistently shown to immediately fold to any form of authority to avoid getting into trouble as a byproduct of the physical abuse she suffered from her parents. She says she's easily influenced, largely because she never really matured under Grandma’s care; even Grandma knew she didn’t have the mental strength to make hard decisions in life, which is why she asked Nana to watch over her once she’s gone.
Looking into Moe’s flashback we see that she was effectively conditioned into needing to ask for necessities to avoid angering her original parents; when ordering at a restaurant she meekly asks for water, she asks for permission to use the bathroom after seemingly holding it in for hours, and when told that she doesn’t need to ask for such a thing & to “do as she pleases,” she refutes that by saying that she’s “a cunning liar… adults will decide for me what I like & what’s right”. When she tries to clean for Grandma and breaks a vase, she expects to be ridiculed and tries to lie, only to immediately admit it was her and be confused that Grandma isn’t angry with her.
But as established before this safety net didn’t erase her past trauma or its effects. Tsuruoka knows that intimidation is useful to keep Moe in line (much like the other teenage girl he had a hand in abusing), even outright admitting that if it wasn’t for her being under Grandma’s care he would have killed her. Under the organization, she has to go back into that old mindset in order to provide for and see her Grandmother.
It is only when that safety net is gone that Moe needs to learn how to be more mature. Starting with defying the organization & revealing that Soma was the traitor even if it put her life in danger, then during the 3-year timeskip she creates a website that would end up leading her to Sachiko & Kiyomi, and through her connection with Grandma was able to get a reporter to detail the truth behind the camp. Moe is able to do what I view as her most important act of maturity but actively calling out whenever Nana tries to take the burden of everything and be the one to remind her that she is loved much like Grandma used to tell her.
Since we don’t see any chapters from her perspective after her arc we don’t know how Moe is internally holding up. But as of the final chapter,  she has a better understanding of life, accepting the pain and choosing to help the friends she has now with their own pain.