r/TargetedEnergyWeapons • u/Atoraxic • 1d ago
Injury of sonic weapons to human body: A narrative review (2025)
Chin J Traumatol
. 2025 Apr 19;29(1):14–20. doi: 10.1016/j.cjtee.2024.10.009
Injury of sonic weapons to human body: A narrative review
Yue Li a, Guangming Yang b, Yongbo Zhao a, Bingcang Li b,⁎
- Author information
- Article notes
- Copyright and License information
PMCID: PMC12892060 PMID: 40300918
Abstract
Sonic weapons are non-lethal weapons that some countries around the world are actively developing and equipping in their troop. Its injury to the human body is increasingly valued. Given that previous research on the injury, prevention, and treatment of sonic weapons to the human body were not systematic and comprehensive, after explaining certain acoustic concepts, these authors introduce infrasonic and intense sound weapons from aspects of weapon types and applications, injury mechanisms and characteristics, injury thresholds, biological effects, injury diagnosis, and injury prevention and treatment. Finally, ultrasonic weapons are briefly introduced, based on a small amount of public literature reports both domestically and internationally. This study aims to provide a reference for future prevention, and treatment of sonic weapons injury.
Keywords: Sonic weapon, Infrasonic weapon, Intense sound weapon, Ultrasonic weapon, Prevention and treatment
1. Introduction
Sonic weapons are a type of non-lethal weapon that has increasingly received attention from people in modern warfare for their effects and injuries to the human body. Sonic weapons can be divided into infrasonic weapons, intense sound weapons, and ultrasonic weapons based on their frequency. Scientists in China have previously reported on the concept of infrasonic weapons,1, 2, 3, 4, 5 infrasound field characteristics,6 infrasound focusing and targeting,7,8 psychological effects of infrasound,9 biological effects of infrasound,10, 11, 12 the influence of infrasound on the central nervous system and neural-psychological aspects,13 military applications of infrasound,14 and physical protection against infrasound.15 For intense sound weapons, Chinese scientists have introduced its concepts and applications,16, 17, 18, 19, 20 the biological effects,12,21 and the effectiveness evaluation system.22, 23, 24 However, there are relatively few literature reports on ultrasonic weapons, with only sporadic reports on the physical characteristics of ultrasound12,21 and the basic principles of ultrasonic weapons.17
Given the lack of comprehensive and systematic research on the damage to the human body caused by sonic weapons and their prevention and treatment in previous reports, this article retrieves Chinese and English literature published from January 2000 to January 2024 through databases of SinoMed, CMCI, PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, as well as search engines such as Baidu Scholar and Microsoft Bing by using the keywords acoustic weapons, sonic weapons, infrasonic weapons, intense sound weapons, ultrasonic weapons, noise weapons, and prevention and treatment. The literature inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) literature collected from medical databases and internet search engines, and (2) original research papers and research reports. The literature exclusion criteria were: (1) literature that could not be accessed in full text or was not in Chinese or English; and (2) science-promoting papers. Finally, 24 Chinese and 32 English articles were included. The aim is to provide references for future development, protection, and medical treatment of acoustic weapons.
2. Acoustic concepts
2.1. Sound frequency
The number of vibrations per unit time by a sound source is known as sound frequency, also referred to as audio frequency, measured in hertz (Hz). Infrasound frequencies range from 0.001 to 20 Hz. Although infrasound is generally inaudible to the human ear, it can still be sensed and, at sufficiently high power levels, can be heard.25,26 Infrasound is commonly present in various industrial, transportation, and living environments, also generated by phenomena such as nuclear explosions, rocket launches,9,13 as well as natural occurrences like earthquakes, volcanoes, tornadoes, and waterfalls.27,28 Animals such as crocodiles, elephants, giraffes, and whales can use infrasound for long-distance communication.27,28 Infrasound has long wavelengths, such as 5 Hz for 68 m and 7 Hz for 48.5 m.22,29 Frequencies ranging from 20 Hz to 20 kHz are audible sounds, with the human ear being most sensitive to frequencies between 1 kHz and 3 kHz.25, 26, 27Ultrasound refers to frequencies higher than 20 kHz, which are inaudible to the human ear, but can be heard by dogs, cats, turtles, and bats. Also, whales and dolphins use ultrasound for prey detection.25, 26, 27 Ultrasound is highly directional and can penetrate the body, allowing for medical imaging techniques to obtain structural information of internal organs.30 Sound frequencies can also be categorized as low-frequency (<400 Hz), mid-frequency (0.4–1 kHz), and high-frequency (>1 kHz).31 Both infrasound and ultrasound can induce resonance in the human body.25
2.2. Noise
Noise refers to sounds that are irritating, excessively loud, and detrimental to human health. It is generated by the irregular vibrations of sound-emitting objects. Noise can be classified as steady-state noise (with fluctuations in sound level not exceeding 3 dB) and pulse noise (short duration with high and sharp amplitudes).32 Similar to sound frequencies, noise can also be categorized as low-frequency, mid-frequency, and high-frequency.
The human auditory system has a higher tolerance for low-frequency noise, even at high sound pressure levels (SPLs), resulting only in temporary threshold shifts (TTS) rather than permanent threshold shifts (PTS).33,34 Low-frequency noise ranging from 150 to 155 dB can cause chest wall vibration, slight nausea, and dizziness. At 154–171 dB, it can lead to increased heart rate, flushing of the skin, swallowing pain, visual impairment, subcostal discomfort, coughing, sternum compression, and breathing difficulties.33 When mid-frequency noise reaches 120 dB, it can resonate with the nasal cavity or sinus and enhance their tactile sensation. At ≥142 dB, it can stimulate the vestibular system, and at 165 dB, it can cause itching.34 For high-frequency noise, TTS or PTS can be caused by SPL ranging from 80 to 120 dB, tactile sensations or itchiness can occur at 120 dB, vestibular reactions can be induced at 125 dB, balance disorders can be caused at 140 dB, and thermal effects can be generated at 160 dB.33 The combination of sound intensity and exposure time determine the level of damage, for example 135 dB for 7 min, 140 dB for 40 s, 145 dB for 4 s, 150 dB for 0.4 s, and 160 dB can cause perforation of the eardrum (it is previously believed that the perforation have a protective effect on the inner ear, but human data suggests that eardrum perforation provides no protection, whether unilateral or bilateral).35
2.3. Acoustic power
Acoustic power refers to the amount of sound energy passing through a specified area per unit time. When measured in terms of energy, it is referred to as sound intensity, expressed in W/m2. If measured in terms of pressure, it is referred to as SPL with the unit of Pa. The indicator of SPL is in dB.25 The conversion formula between dB and Pa is given by L=20𝑙𝑜𝑔10𝑃1𝑃0, where L is the SPL, P1 represents the sound pressure being compared, and P0 represents the reference sound pressure (often taken as 20 μPa). Acoustic power is directly proportional to the square of sound velocity, sound frequency, and amplitude. Therefore, ultrasound has high acoustic power, while explosion waves own high acoustic power due to their high amplitudes.31 When acoustic power exceeds 120 dB, it is considered high-intensity sound, causing discomfort to the human ear and potential hearing loss. At 140 dB (200 Pa), it can be painful to the human ear, above 160 dB (2 kPa) causes eardrum rupture, and 173 dB (9 kPa) for lung rupture.30,33
2.4. Acoustic propagation
Infrasound and audible sound propagate at the same speed,3 which is about 300–340 m/s in the atmosphere and 1480 m/s in water.7,21 The energy of sound wave undergoes attenuation and absorption during propagation, which is influenced by factors such as humidity, temperature, and pressure.19 The rate of sound attenuation is directly proportional to the square of its frequency, so higher frequencies result in faster attenuation.12 As a result, infrasound experiences less attenuation, allowing for long-distance propagation (thousands to tens of thousands of kilometers).7,21 On the other hand, ultrasound experiences significant attenuation, resulting in shorter propagation distances.29 The penetrating power of sound waves is inversely proportional to the sound frequency. For example, 7 Hz infrasound can penetrate through reinforced concrete walls several meters thick, as well as steel plates, seawater, and soil layers, while audible sound at 7 kHz cannot pass through a piece of paper.14,30
3. Infrasonic weapon
3.1. Types and applications of the weapons
Currently, there are 3 types of sonic weapons: sonic cannons, sonic bullets, and sonic guns, all composed of sonic generators, power devices, and control systems.14 The Chinese Academy of Sciences has developed a sonic gun with a frequency less than 20 Hz.36 The SPL of sonic guns developed by the United States (U.S.)18 and France20 can reach 160 dB. Infrasonic weapons can be classified into 5 categories based on their generation methods: (1) burst-type: compressed gas, high-pressure steam, or high-pressure gas is released in a pulse to excite the medium and generate sonic waves, with the advantages of small size, low frequency, and easy control, but with low sonic intensity and short range of effect; (2) explosive-type: infrasonic waves are generated by explosions, and about 50% explosive energy converts shockwaves, then decay to produce infrasonic waves; (3) tube-type: its structure and working principle are similar to a flute. Infrasonic waves are generated when the air inside the tube vibrates at the same frequency as the tube itself; (4) speaker-type: the working principle is similar to a speaker. Special diaphragms are used to generate infrasonic waves through vibration; (5) beat frequency-type: 2 sound wave generators with different frequencies are used simultaneously to generate infrasonic waves based on the difference in their frequencies.2 Compared to intense sound weapons, the development of infrasonic weapons is more challenging, due to the technical difficulties such as it is hard to increase the power output and duration of the infrasonic generator, to reduce the size and weight of the weapon system, to make wave beam more directional and focused.7,18,23
The US has secretly used infrasonic weapons in the Somali, the Bosnian, and the Gulf War. It is reported that infrasound attacks on the Bosnian Serb Army caused a large number of soldiers to faint and vomit within seconds, resulting in the loss of combat effectiveness.20The US also suspects that its embassy personnel in Havana (Cuba) and Guangzhou (China) have been attacked by infrasonic weapons.27,28
3.2. Mechanism and characteristics of injury
The main characteristic of infrasonic weapons’ harm to the human body is organ resonance. When the frequency of infrasonic waves is close to the inherent frequency of human organs, the organs can absorb sonic energy at the maximum extent, thus causing damage through resonance.13,20 Infrasound can also convert mechanical energy into thermal, biochemical, and bioelectricity energy, thereby damaging the molecular structure of cells.11,20 Infrasound stimulation can disrupt the brain and cause mental disorders, while stimulating somatosensory and visceral receptors can produce reflexive physiological responses. Based on these, infrasonic weapons can be divided into “neurological type” and “organ type”.12,13,20
Neurological infrasonic weapons have a frequency of 8–12 Hz, which is the same as the inherent frequency of the head.15,34 It is also consistent with the α rhythm (8–12 Hz, amplitude of 20–100 μV, commonly seen during relaxation) of brain waves, which also has β rhythm (14–30 Hz, amplitude of 5–22 μV, commonly seen during thinking), θ rhythm (4–7 Hz, amplitude of 20–150 μV, commonly seen when drowsy), and δ rhythm (0.5–3 Hz, amplitude of 20–200 μV, commonly seen during sleep).30 When infrasonic waves resonate with the head, dizziness, numbness in limbs, confusion, and abnormal behavior can be caused.30 The experiments in New Zealand rabbit have shown that exposure to 16 Hz/130 dB infrasonic waves for 20 min significantly increases δ rhythm, and exposure to 6 Hz/110 dB can convert α to θ rhythm, indicating that brain wave activity in animals can be significantly suppressed by infrasonic waves.13 Organ-type infrasonic weapons usually have frequencies ranging from 4 to 18 Hz, which correspond to the inherent vibration frequencies of various organs in the human body. The frequency for the torso is 7–13 Hz, the heart is 5 Hz, the chest cavity is 4–6 Hz, the abdominal cavity is 6–9 Hz, the abdominal wall is 10 Hz, the pelvic cavity and the chest wall are 6 Hz and 60 Hz, respectively.9,12,15,34When the frequency of infrasonic waves is close to the inherent frequency of human organs, resonance occurs, leading to symptoms such as tinnitus, palpitations, muscle spasms, difficulty breathing, and even rupture of blood vessels and organ damage.9,15,18When the frequency of infrasonic waves is less than 2 Hz, the human body responds as a whole rather than at the organ level.27,28,33
3.3. Injury threshold
The injury extent of infrasonic waves to the human depends on their power, frequency, and duration of exposure.25 When the power is the same, the frequency determines the type of damage, while the duration determines the injury degree, which is also closely related to the frequency and sound pressure.9,25 Due to the different structures and inherent frequencies of humans and animals, the same infrasonic parameters can have varying effects on different organisms.9 A test involving 15 males aged 20 to 25 years showed that exposure to 10 Hz/136 dB infrasound for 15 min resulted in symptoms such as headaches, dry mouth, difficulty swallowing, sweaty palms, and extreme fatigue. The average low- and mid-frequency hearing thresholds decreased by 10–15 dB, and some internal organs experienced noticeable vibrations. After the exposure stopped, most of the symptoms disappeared within 10–30 min, but the feeling of fatigue persisted.9 Infrasound of 12.5–20.0 Hz/105.0–113.5 dB for 6 h caused restlessness, muscle tremors, spasms, and decreased muscle strength in 67.8% of the subjects.13 Exposure to infrasound at 1–30 Hz/125 dB can cause ear pressure sensations and a decrease in task performance,13 at 95–110 dB for 20 min can make people drowsy and reduce work efficiency,34 16 Hz/95 dB for 30 min can increase diastolic blood pressure and heart rate.34 However, some infrasound is harmless to the human body. For example, 2–15 Hz/115 dB do not affect task performance,13 7.5 Hz/130 dB for 50 min has negligible effects on the human body,34 8 Hz/130 dB for 30 min has no adverse effects on most people,34 10–15 Hz/130–135 dB for 30 min cannot affect hearing or vestibular function,34 7 Hz/142 dB for 15 min does not cause dizziness or orientation disorders.34 Animal experiments have shown that infrasound at 172 dB can cause breathing difficulties and even suffocation in dogs, while at 6–9 Hz/195 dB can cause immediate death in monkeys and baboons.6,11 Exposure to infrasound at 16 Hz/105 dB for 10 min can shorten the tolerance time of rats to sound waves, and infrasound at 10 Hz/160 dB can interrupt tracking behavior in adult macaques, but it has no effect on hearing measurement, otoacoustic emissions (OAE), and auditory brainstem responses.34 Infrasound at 15–20 Hz/140 dB has no effect on pigs and macaques.34
It is usually believed that infrasound at 90 dB is generally not harmful,9 and 120 dB is the threshold level for infrasound damage.11 Even short-term exposure to infrasound at 140 dB is enough to cause harm to the human body,9,34 and at 150 dB for 2–3 min can cause irreversible damage and even death.6,9, 10, 11 The International Infrasound Professional Committee in Paris has set the allowable infrasound intensity of 2 Hz at 130 dB, 4 Hz at 128 dB, 8 Hz at 125 dB, and 16 Hz at 120 dB.6,11 According to the changes in red blood cell membrane permeability, adenosine-triphosphat, and succinate dehydrogenase activity, the impact of infrasound frequency is determined to be in the order of 16 Hz>8 Hz>4 Hz>2 Hz.9,10
3.4. Biological effects
The harmful biological effects of infrasound on the human body include: (1) vestibular effects, such as dizziness and nausea;27,28,34 (2) auditory effects, such as auditory pain, sensation of pressure in the middle ear, and annoyance;37 (3) visceral effects, such as nausea, chest tightness, and hallucinations;27,28,34 (4) cardiovascular effects, such as increased heart rate (averagely increasing 11/min) and elevated diastolic blood pressure (averagely increasing 1.2±0.27 kPa), but returned to normal after half an hour;9 (5) psychological effects, such as fear, sadness, depression, anxiety, lack of concentration, aversion, indifference, and sorrow;25 (6) chronic effects, such as rectal cancer, colon cancer, pancreatic cancer, etc.27,28,38
Infrasound also has certain benefits to the human body. For example, sonic massage of 4 Hz/170 dB can stabilize the progression of myopia,13 and sonic waves with frequencies ranging from 0.1 to 3 Hz can relieve pain.10 During anesthesia, moderate infrasound has sedative effects on central nervous system, and reduces adverse reactions caused by surgical stimuli.13 Sonic waves at 8–12 Hz can improve concentration, enhance learning efficiency, and increase alertness.13,34 If at 8–12 Hz/72–79 dB, permeability of tumor cell membranes can be changed, and the killing effect on glioblastoma cells can be enhanced with 5-fluorouracil together.13 Otherwise, the proliferation activity of mesenchymal stem cells in the bone marrow can be increased by infrasound which inhibits apoptosis.13 Also, the survival rate of guinea pigs during hypersensitivity reactions can be increased by exposure to 10 Hz/155–160 dB for 10 min,10 and cognitive impairment in rats with vascular dementia can be improved by infrasound.9
3.5. Injury diagnosis
Due to surprise attack (fast propagation) and crypticity (inaudible and invisible) of infrasonic weapon assault, combined with its long operating distance and strong penetration capabilities,12,18 it is difficult for people to realize they have been damaged by infrasound timely, until they experience symptoms such as dizziness, nausea, chest tightness, hallucinations, fear, sadness, depression, and anxiety, which are often referred to as “mysterious symptoms”.38 Still, it is difficult to determine the attack source and to diagnose quickly,38 unless symptoms occur simultaneously in batch soldiers during wartime or gathering crowds during peacetime, or a infrasound detection device (such as a infrasonic sensor) is available at the scene.
3.6. Injury prevention and treatment
It is quite difficult to protect against sonic weapons.2 The best protection is to minimize the infrasonic intensity and to shorten the exposure duration.11,15 Alternatively, it can be used to reduce resonance by absorption, isolation, and reducing energy during infrasound propagation. Although many materials can protect against medium and high frequency noise, the materials for protecting against infrasound and low-frequency noise are lacking at present.9 Due to the strong penetration capability of infrasound, the equipment made of ordinary materials cannot provide effective protection. It is reported that the anti-infrasound earplugs developed by Chinese scientists can effectively reduce human injuries.9In addition, high-intensity music can mask infrasonic waves and provide some relief for certain symptoms,10,11 and low-intensity infrasonic waves can alleviate the damage caused by high-intensity sonic waves, which may be used to increase the tolerance of the human to infrasound damage by pre-stimulating effects in the future.9
Infrasound can activate the body's oxidative system, generate a large number of free radicals, and further exacerbate lipid peroxidation reactions, thus damaging biological membranes. Therefore, antioxidants, such as α-tocopherol, vitamin C, 2.3-dimethyl-2-sulfopropionate sodium, imidazole derivatives, etc., and free radical scavengers have therapeutic effects on infrasonic weapon damage.9, 10, 11 Glutamate receptor antagonists can effectively reduce the number of damaged neurons affected by infrasonic waves.11
Continued https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12892060/