I often read that on this subreddit Nate is described as one of the worst characters people have ever seen. In a way, they feel huge annoyance and irritation that Nate betrayed Ted's trust by turning his back on him, behaving badly, and going to coach another team with all the resentment imaginable, and, among other things, doing the worst possible thing: tearing up the Believe sign. So if we reasoned like normal, ordinary people, we'd probably hate Nate forever. But that would move us away from the whole point of wanting to be like Ted Lasso in real life, or of being people who have been positively influenced by this character. I think a lot of people miss that Ted is actually an extremely deep and intelligent person. It isn't true that he's the classic heart-of-gold guy who's friends with everyone and forgives everyone. Ted has a very clear red line. He distinguishes between people who do wrong with the intent of completely destroying someone else, like Rupert, who enjoys constantly humiliating Rebecca with his new relationship while she's still hurting over their failed marriage, and people who make mistakes even though they're good people, simply because they're going through a moment of fragility or weakness, like Nate himself or even Coach Beard. I don't see anyone here hating Coach Beard for what he did to Ted. Am I wrong?
Nate has to be seen as a whole, not just for what he did in that one moment. He's a guy who was ridiculed his entire life. If anyone here has ever felt like him, constantly belittled or even invisible, people not even knowing you exist or remembering your name, you know what I mean. You get used to believing you're a failure with nothing interesting to say, until your Ted Lasso comes along: someone who makes you feel interesting and important, and whose influence lets others find you interesting and smart too. In an ideal world, everyone would live happily ever after. But in the real world, made of mixed emotions and contradictory feelings, Nate became dependent on that feeling of power, of being seen as incredible, and started chasing it everywhere. Before judging what he does to Ted, remember all the times he obsessed over Twitter looking for compliments, searching for a kind word his father probably never said to him before his finale, for someone to make him feel good, seen, understood. In that desolation, he never really feels like the number one: if Richmond loses it's Ted's fault, and if it wins it's Ted's merit, and no matter how hard he works, nobody will ever say thanks to you this happened. So he, influenced by Rupert, who shows his cruelty again here, decides to betray that trust to try to become great on his own two feet. But he's the one who suffers, and that's where you see the sweetness of the character: he would have wanted to apologize to Ted five minutes after what he did, because he realized the madness of it, but other people's manipulations pressured him to hold his ground, to believe his pride deserved more, until eventually he does apologize. And why does Ted forgive him? Not because he forgives everyone, because he's clear on that. He forgives him because he sees a kid who mishandled being liked and valued for the first time, and who didn't act out of malice, but because he'd never been in that situation before. I'm sorry, but if all of us saw these things together, we'd get much closer to the true meaning of Ted Lasso and could carry it into real life.