r/The48LawsOfPower • u/Vainarrara809 • 9h ago
Law 4: A whole year of saying less than necessary.
Little over a year ago I decided that I would no longer debate anyone. No matter how irritating I found an argument, I simply refuse to engage in debate. Here are a few things I discovered since I started this experiment:
1) Rhetorical questions are mostly a compliance test: when people ask you a rhetorical question they’re not trying to teach you anything, they’re mostly trying to see if you answer the way they want you to answer.
2) You can dismiss an opinion: when two sides have two opposing opinions it doesn’t mean that the discussion is 50/50. You can always correct yourself, you don’t need another person to correct you. somebody tells you an opinion different than yours, you don’t need to correct them. Just let them be. Someone very dear to me said something ridiculous and I paid close attention to what they said. I took a step back, and me stepping back had a stronger reaction than anything I could have said. I realized right there and there that I don’t need to correct them, I can just dismiss them. And I don’t mean ignore them, but truly listen carefully and dismiss their stupid ignorant comment.
3) debates have nothing to do with logic and everything to do with persuasion: I designed an art piece and had two other artists joining the production. A tool was counterintuitive and the Dumbest of the artists insisted that I had something backwards. They presented arguments, they explained their logic, they did a demonstration, and I was getting irritated that this person insisted in debating instead of finishing the piece. Finally the smarter artist interrupted and said “I too think this might be backwards”. Angrily I said “if it is backwards you’re gonna put it backwards because that’s how I designed it, and if you don’t like then too bad because is gonna go backwards anyways, and if is wrong you’re gonna leave it wrong, and how I designed it is how is going to go, and you’re not gonna change my fucking design”. I was extremely angry so I left the room and didn’t come back till the next day, and when I came back the next day it was finished as I designed. Now you might think that this was over but believe it or not they still wanted to continue to argue and I refused to engage. The dumbest one persuaded the smartest one that he was right and I was wrong and they wanted to continue arguing. I said to the smart one “I don’t need your approval”. And that ended it.
4) interrogations are designed to wear you down: have you ever had a kid ask you “are we there yet? Are we there yet? Are we there yet?” Or even better, have you had a therapist ask you “and how does that make you feel?”. A lot of times people ask questions with the intention of depleting your energy and when you finally don’t have the capacity to answer, or accidentally reveal some weakness, they start attacking you and overwhelm you with comments when you have no energy to fight back.
5) sometimes violence is the answer: I had someone harassing me on public transit. He was harassing other people and as he was getting closer I knew that my turn was coming next. There was shouting, there were insults, there were threads, and finally I said “meet me outside”… you cannot reason with unreasonable people. You cannot teach unteachable people. A little slapping contest can fix a lot of wrongs.
6) People pay more attention to what they say when they don’t know if they have to apologize later: my girlfriend loves to gossip and while gossiping she’ll make jokes and nasty comments, and I’m listening but when she is saying something I don’t like I’ll tell her “this topic is uncool and embarrassing, is making me very upset”… you might think that a sentence like that would shut her up but on the contrary, that’s when she starts going super hard trying to defend what she was saying. For her, the only thing harder than being quiet is having to apologize. Instead of apologizing she tries to seduce me back but I refuse to accept affection when I demand an apology first. Then I get both.
7) Resentment builds up: some of the things I’ve said here might sound positive or somewhat positive but like all disciplines it comes at a cost. I stopped arguing because I wasn’t being listened to and when they were listening they were listening for weaknesses so they could abuse those weaknesses. Once I realized that they were trying to abuse my mind I couldn’t help but develop hatred and anger towards a lot of people.
8) hypersensitivity to lies: I say very little so I only say true things, or things that I might be wrong but sincerely believe are true. I ended a friendship recently because a person wants to live a fantasy and wanted me to play along. To put it in simple terms: when I say “that’s gangsta” what i mean is “that’s effective”, is just a saying, is metaphorical, is not fucking real… this person wanted Gansta credit without doing a single fucking gangsta thing in their life, and they wanted me to play along. I mean what the hell?… if you lie intentionally and you know I know you lying, how can you possibly expect me to treat it as truth?… I finally figured out, a lot of people rather comply with the lie than to have a conflict or lose a “friend”… I’ve known this person for a long time, normally I would try to correct them or call them out but that sets the stage for them to spill more lies, since my zero debate policy I cut liars out of my life. This has turned into isolation and loneliness, but I rather have that than fake friends.
I could do a bunch of posts about Law 4 but most of them would be about failing the law. I probably took things a little too far by making Law 4 a consistent part of my lifestyle. However, my mind is clearer and relaxed. I don’t spend any time with stupid people or liars. By listening without arguing I can correct myself in private. There’s good and there’s bad but when it’s bad it’s on my terms.
TLDR:
Debating is overrated and mostly a waste of time. Rhetorical questions are designed to test obedience. You can dismiss arguments no matter how valuable. Debates are two people trying to persuade an audience, and you don’t need the audience nor the person to be persuaded. Too many questions wear you brain down. Violence is the language of the unreasonable. People say things they don’t mean when there are no consequences. When you talk and people don’t listen you’ll get angry. People lie because you accept it, and you accept it because you don’t wanna lose them.
Be safe, y’all.