r/TheCitadel • • 10d ago

Fanfic Awards On the Fanfiction Awards

28 Upvotes

An update on [r/TheCitadel](r/TheCitadel)’s 2026 Fanfiction Awards. The original timeline (outlined in the announcement post), had nominations be open from Monday 21st September to Sunday 15th November. 

In lieu of AO3’s blackout, this timeline has been changed.

The nomination period has been extended from Sunday 15th November to Friday 18th December.

The voting period will be now be open from Saturday 19th December to 11:59pm Saturday 16th January (EST).

The winners will be announced on Sunday 17th January.

We’re disappointed that we can’t announce our award winners before Christmas, per the original timeline, but understand that with AO3 down, readers and authors will struggle to participate in the awards. Assuming AO3 is down for the entirety of November, the extra two-and-a-half weeks for nominations should provide ample time for authors to update, and for readers to catch-up on fic or find new ones.

(Also, since the awards are open to any fanfic platform, this is a great opportunity to nominate works from SpaceBattles, Alt-History, Questionable Questing, FFN, or even Tumblr).

As always, you can vote on the Google Form, which has been updated with these new dates in mind. Rules for nominee eligibility still apply. However, due to privacy concerns, if nominating before AO3 has returned, please do not provide drive links for fic. If you don’t have the original link on hand, the title and author should suffice, for now.

Thank you to [u/aladywantsdragons](u/aladywantsdragons) for allowing myself and [u/thelocaldialect](u/thelocaldialect) to run the awards this year.

PS: Please ask any questions or share your concerns on this post.


r/TheCitadel • • Sep 22 '26

Fanfic Awards 2026 Fanfic Awards Announcement & Nomination Post!!!!

35 Upvotes

Nomination Period: Monday 21st September to Sunday 15th November

Voting Period: Monday 16th November to Sunday 20th December

Awards: Winners announced Monday 21st December

Special thanks to baellaggio (hismanyoaths on AO3) and wentliane (Gwenllian on AO3) for their joined efforts in making the Fanfic Awards possible this year. These two reached out to me and offered to handle the major work of setting up the awards. Without them I am not sure this would have been possible and am most grateful for their help.

If there are any questions regarding the Fanfic Awards, please contact:

  • me, via r/TheCitadel modmail
  • baellaggio via Discord
  • wentliane via Discord

________

Nominate your favourite fanfictions from this year. Please note the following: 

  • You can nominate as many works as you’d like per category. 
  • You can only nominate fanfiction posted or updated in 2026. 
  • Crossover works can only be nominated in the crossover category.
  • Please include links with your nominations. 
  • Self-nominations are allowed. 
  • If a category does not receive enough nominations, it will be omitted in the voting stage. 
  • If you have nothing to nominate in a category, that’s perfectly okay! 

The categories are as follows:

  • Long-fics
  • Short-fics
  • Oneshots
  • Main Series 
  • Robert’s Rebellion
  • Dunk & Egg/Blackfyre Era 
  • Fire & Blood 
  • Other Eras 
  • Romance
  • Smut
  • Horror
  • Dead Dove
  • Crack
  • Fluff/Comfort
  • Self-insert/isekai
  • Time Travel
  • Genderbends 
  • Original Characters 
  • Modern AUs
  • Crossovers
  • Best characterization 
  • Best dynamic
  • Best worldbuilding 
  • Best battles/combat
  • Best prose 
  • Best author

https://forms.gle/E1b9maDA8AiBZB1W8


r/TheCitadel • • 6h ago

Subreddit Activity (NOT WHAT IF's) Who is the greatest parent in the entire series?

16 Upvotes

While replying to a comment that said Ned failed as a parent, I was struck by a thought that Ned might indeed be the answer to the question in the title. This thought arose as i wrote my reply and racked my head to compare Ned's parenting to someone else in the series, but I struggled to find any characters that fit the laudatory tone of my comparison. The only people that I could come up with were Oberyn and Mace, and belatedly Selwyn Tarth.

So, Maesters, I pose to you the very same question: Who, in the entire series (encompassing F&B, The Hedge Knight, Essos, etc) is the greatest parent? The one true parent? The one parent to rule them all!

Mothers and Fathers both included (adoptive too) obviously, no cheese answers like Aenar - father of Daenys, or people like the GOAT Edmure - who's just become a father. Creative answers are encouraged, there's an argument to be made for Doran, it's a bad argument but I encourage you to make it. Bonus points for people who're still alive/actually have their parenting/or the consequences thereof actually shown in the books, instead of someone like Elia or Joanna, who I'm sure loved their children and would have gone to bat for them, sadly could not.

The hallmarks of a good parent would typically be someone who loved their kid(s) and set them up for success. But that's only a rubric, really any answer works as long as you justify it.


r/TheCitadel • • 5h ago

Subreddit Activity (NOT WHAT IF's) The Strength of House Fowler

3 Upvotes

The Wardens of the Prince's Pass, Former Kings of Skyreach. One of the principal houses of Dorne, possibly even 3rd after Martell and Yornwood, but let's find out what most people think! Which of the options above do you best believe depicts the man power of House Fowler? Only 2 left in Dorne!

27 votes, 1d left
2,000 armored retainers, 200 knights
2,650 armored retainers, 300 knights
3,000 armored retainers, 350 knights
3,400 armored retainers, 400 knights

r/TheCitadel • • 7h ago

Wanted: Fanfic Recommendations - NOT DISCUSSION Aegon V succesfully hatches dragons in Summerhall?

5 Upvotes

As the title says, i want a fic where Summerhall is succesfull and now The Targaryens has Dragons, guranteeing the monopoly of violence at the hands of the Targaryens and forcing the lords to accept Egg´s reforms.

The fic can have two possibilities:

1- Egg´s children follows their father plan of betrohals, and the dragons are just a extra.

2- Egg´s children still make shit, but at least the Targaryens have dragons.


r/TheCitadel • • 43m ago

Activity - What If (changed CANON event or character decision) What if Catelyn Tully was more of a tomboy?

• Upvotes

Seeing as she was Hoster's eldest and favorite child, raised as his heir until Edmure was born and with the influence of her uncle Brynden, what if instead of growing up to be the near perfect lady we know her as, Cat grew up more influenced by "manly" pursuits, like her father's lordship and her uncle's stories of chivalry and warfare. Would Littlefinger still be obsessed with her? Would she resent Edmure for stealing her spot? How about her relationships with Brandon and Ned?


r/TheCitadel • • 43m ago

Self Promotion: My Fanfic A Farmers Price

• Upvotes

Title: A Farmers Price

Author: JayJayTheLoverBoy

Rating: Mature

Language: English

Length: 20k words

Status: Incomplete

Link: https://archiveofourown.org/works/95883726?view_full_work=true

Summary: Jon Snow left Winterfell at seventeen with a sack of gold and a simple wish: a patch of earth that answered only to him. In the Reach he finds a ruined holdfast, black soil, and the quiet he asked for. Seasons pass. Walls are mended. A child is born. For a time the wider realm feels distant enough that he almost believes the name he left behind has stayed buried.
War moves across Westeros—slowly at first, then all at once. News arrives late and incomplete. A white direwolf is seen in southern fields. And somewhere in the North, the dead are still being counted while the living search for any Stark left to answer for them. In King’s Landing, debts mount and alliances shift under a boy king’s crown. In the North, empty holdfasts and flayed banners mark the cost of broken guest right while surviving lords search for any Stark left to follow. Across the sea, a queen in Meereen weighs the price of the throne she was born to claim, while ships gather and old debts go unpaid. Letters go unanswered. News travels slowly, then all at once.


r/TheCitadel • • 7h ago

Beta Reader Request Looking for beta readers for a fem!Robert fic set during the Rebellion

3 Upvotes

I've been looking for beta readers for my first fanfic before I publish it on AO3. I can give you the link for the first 12 chapters (52K words) if you DM me

I'm basically looking for:

  • Any error that I missed (I've spent near two months writing and editing the chapters so I may have missed some stuff)
  • Grammar errors and typos if you wouldn't mind
  • How well I convey the changes I made to Westeros (I made quite many changes to uplift/fix parts of Westeros that I found lacking, as well as incorporating some of my own ideas into the world)

r/TheCitadel • • 8h ago

Activity - What If (changed CANON event or character decision) Tywin “the Kind”?

3 Upvotes

The headline is a little exaggerated, but I wanted it to grab people’s attention.

Well, so…

What if the cruel Tywin Lannister had been orphaned and raised by a man far more capable than Tytos?

Let’s say Jeyne Marbrand and Tytos Lannister die in a tragic boating accident or something along those lines, just a few months after their firstborn son is born. As a result, little Tywin is left in the care of his grandfather, Gerold Lannister, who decides to devote his remaining years to raising his grandson and heir. Let’s assume his health isn’t as poor as it is in canon and he manages to live for long enough for Tywin to inherit without needing a regency and take power immediately.

This means Tywin would grow up with a man described as intelligent, affable, fair, and, overall, a competent Lord. With such a different upbringing, without a father who’s the laughingstock of the entire realm:

• What would be the biggest changes in Tywin in this scenario? 

• What would his ambitions be, now that he no longer has a crumbling House to save?

• Would he still go to court to serve as the king’s cupbearer, or would Gerold prefer to keep him close?

• Who would he marry if his grandfather were the one arranging his betrothal? Would Joanna still be an option?

r/TheCitadel • • 12h ago

Self Promotion: My Fanfic The Dragon's Heirs - Chapter 35 Aenys I

5 Upvotes

Title: The Dragon's Heirs

Authors: AbaddonKhaleesi & TooManyNameOptions

Rating: Mature content

Language: English

Length: 168k words

Status: Ongoing

Link: Chapter 35

Summary: King Jaehaerys I died on the third moon of the year 103 AC; however, the abrupt disappearance of his son and heir, Prince Aegon of Dragonstone, a fortnight before his passing, left a lingering question: who is set to inherit? The line of King Jaehaerys’s troublesome firstborn son? Or the line of his favored third son, Baelon the Brave?

As law and bloodline come into conflict, the House of the Dragon begins to learn—slowly but surely—that only a dragon can kill another dragon...

An AU based on the idea that all thirteen children of King Jaehaerys and Good Queen Alysanne survived childhood and had children of their own.

(Note: This is a redux of the early chapters, rewritten for consistency and narrative clarity. Updates will follow regularly.)


r/TheCitadel • • 4h ago

Self Promotion: My Fanfic Our is the Fury Chapter 45

0 Upvotes

Title: Ours is the fury

Author: Obed (Me)

Rating: Alla ages

Language: English

Length: 10000+

Status: Active

Link: https://www.wattpad.com/story/414583480-ours-is-the-fury or https://archiveofourown.org/works/89824981

Summary: Is there a better way to end a story than with a dance? Sansa Stark and Al Baratheon enjoy their first dance, where their hearts become one.


r/TheCitadel • • 19h ago

Help w/ Fanfic Writing & Advice Needed Who would be the most logical spouse?

13 Upvotes

If Aemma died in childbirth with Rhaenyra, who survives, who which houses would be the most logical to look at for a new spouse for Viserys? The remarriage would take place either 98 or 99 AC.


r/TheCitadel • • 6h ago

Self Promotion: My Fanfic Between Hearth and Throne, CH1

1 Upvotes

Title: Between Hearth and Throne

Author: annamariadelaney

Rating: M (mature themes, violence)

Language: English

Length: currently ~12k words, likely to be at least 50k words

Status: Incomplete

Link: https://archiveofourown.org/works/96121516

“What kind of woman must Jenny have been?” Steffon asked. “To make a prince give up everything to marry her, I mean. She must have been truly remarkable.”

Stannis took the bait. “There is a song to that effect,” she agreed. “I am told it is popular.” Steffon could almost have laughed at her flat expression; this, at least, was familiar ground.

“You don’t agree,” he said. “Why? Just because ‘songs always grow in the singing?’ You don’t think anyone could give up a throne for love?”

“Not ‘anyone,’” she said sharply. “I believe it of Duncan, certainly.” She looked out over the mossy stones, and Steffon followed her gaze, but saw nothing but the wind in the grass.

“As you know, before I wed your father, I was betrothed to Prince Rhaegar Targaryen,” Stannis said after a long moment. “All the realm knows the end of that story. And they asked the same questions about Lyanna, the ‘Winter Rose.’ Men prefer songs to looking on the truth. Ask rather, what kind of man makes that decision? And what kind of man would Duncan have been, if he’d married Morena Baratheon? The same kind, of course. The danger was in him, not in Jenny. Love reveals us, but it does not change who we are.”

Fic summary: This work is the third part in my female Stannis Baratheon series, and the most ambitious installment so far. It reimagines the War of Five Kings as a Dance-style civil war between Renly and Joffrey Baratheon, with Stannis and several other characters (Ned Stark and their children, Brienne of Tarth, Loras Tyrell, etc) playing significant roles as well.

If any of that interests you, please give it a try! I don’t know how best to describe it without giving too many spoilers away, but I have a bunch of set pieces for the war I’m excited to eventually unveil, as well as heaps of character drama (character studies, my beloved).


r/TheCitadel • • 14h ago

Self Promotion: My Fanfic "Bronze is my body and fire is my blood"

3 Upvotes

Title: "Bronze is my body and fire is my blood"

Author: Aisaac123

Rating: Mature

Language: English

Length: 7,459 words

Status: Ongoing

Link: https://archiveofourown.org/works/95585056/chapters/255338201

Summary:

"Daemon Targaryen never expected his marriage to Rhea Royce to give him anything worth keeping.

Then Aegor was born.

Brown-haired, purple-eyed, heir to Runestone and prince of House Targaryen, Aegor grows up caught between two families that both insist upon telling him what he ought to be. His mother teaches him that lordship is a duty. His father teaches him that dragons do not bow. Aegor, unfortunately for both of them, has ideas of his own.

Born the same year as Princess Rhaenyra, Aegor spends his childhood at her side—first as cousin and friend, later as something neither of them quite expected. And when Viserys names Rhaenyra his heir, the existence of Daemon Targaryen's only son begins to alter far more than one unhappy marriage in the Vale.

A story about fathers and sons, dragons and bronze, inheritance, duty, and what happens when a Targaryen prince decides that power does not make a man better than anyone else."

The prologue of my fanfic is here.


r/TheCitadel • • 1d ago

Book Discussion: Reading ASOIAF & Spin-Off Novels Questions What was Dorne's revenge plan?

39 Upvotes

There is a definite answer to this: Dorne had no revenge plan or preparations whatsoever. They simply waited for the pieces to fall into place.

While reading the Dorne POVs, especially with Doran Martell, it is implied that he has a reason to remain patient and that he is actually planning some grand revenge scheme. However, if we look at the overall flow of the story, that does not really seem to be the case.

We know Oberyn arranged a betrothal pact between Viserys and Arianne, meaning they planned to place Viserys on the throne. The problem is that while Viserys and his sister spent years living as fugitives across the Free Cities, the Martells did absolutely nothing. They never truly prepared the man they considered a claimant for kingship. As a result, Viserys became another madman like his father. Even if Dorne had raised its banners for him, it would have been difficult for him to gain support. Joffrey being similarly cruel balanced the scales somewhat, but the lords of Westeros would still prefer the madman they know over the madman they do not.

The other problem is the Dothraki issue. By marrying Daenerys to Khal Drogo, they hoped to secure a Dothraki alliance. I do not know whether the Martells were involved in this plan, but even if they were, it was foolish at best. Bringing a Dothraki army to Westeros would turn the Targaryens into a symbol of hatred in the eyes of both the nobility and the common people. Yes, wars are cruel, but the looting and slavery practiced by the Dothraki make even the Lannister armies look merciful. More than half of the houses considering support for the Targaryens would immediately turn against them.

Then there is the possibility of fAegon. Perhaps Dorne knew from the very beginning that Elia’s son was alive (!), and their true investment was always in him? But that does not seem to be the case either. We know Arianne went to Storm’s End specifically to meet fAegon and confirm whether he was truly her relative. In addition, Doran Martell sent his own son to Daenerys to arrange a marriage alliance and promised her the crown of Westeros. If he already knew about fAegon’s existence, would he really have made such a move?

Looking at everything that happened, it feels as though there was never truly a long-term plan behind Dorne’s wait for revenge. Doran Martell seems to act entirely according to circumstance and prefers waiting for the pieces to fall into place on their own. Otherwise, he would have taken advantage of the War of the Five Kings to strike back at the Lannisters. If the Starks had defeated the Lannisters and executed Tywin, then it would have been the North, not Dorne, that avenged Elia Martell. That would have been deeply humiliating for Dorne. Yet they still sat in the corner and waited. What exactly were they waiting for, and for whom? They had no hidden claimant prepared in secret, Viserys was dead, they seemed unaware of fAegon’s existence, and Daenerys had rejected their alliance proposals.


r/TheCitadel • • 1d ago

Wanted: Fanfic Recommendations - NOT DISCUSSION OP mc falls into ASOIAF with no mental health issue?

13 Upvotes

So im looking for OP mc who are either a drop in, a character from other verse, an oc/si...

Not an AU of an existing character like Jon Snow going to skyrim and return or Jon snow going to elden ring and return, that type. Character reincarnated into an existing character is fine though. No or minimal romance for the mc.

And finally i noticed how some fics have characters with a bunch of mental health issue and throw them into the world, like female Harry potter with the weight of the world on her shoulder gets isekai because she wants to escape, i dont want any of that. Not really a fan of angst.


r/TheCitadel • • 1d ago

Book Discussion: Reading ASOIAF & Spin-Off Novels Questions The Twins and the Hidden Trade Between the North and South

21 Upvotes

If the Twins are such an important strategic and economic asset in the Riverlands, and have brought House Frey an enormous fortune by serving as the main crossing point between the North and the Riverlands, then perhaps trade between the North and the southern kingdoms is far more extensive than we tend to imagine.

The Twins essentially function as a commercial gateway between the two regions. House Frey wouldn't have accumulated such immense wealth simply from controlling a crossing unless there was a substantial flow of merchants, goods, and trade moving in both directions.

I think we sometimes underestimate the North's economy and picture it as considerably poorer and more isolated than it actually is. The wealth of House Frey might be a good indication of just how much commercial activity takes place between the North and the Riverlands.


r/TheCitadel • • 1d ago

Lost Fanfic: Help Me Find It - NOT DISCUSSION In the Veins of Winter and Flame

3 Upvotes

Does anyone have a copy of this fic I tried putting the link in fichub but it didn’t work


r/TheCitadel • • 1d ago

Promotion: Fic I'm Enjoying Skulls - AKOTSK

3 Upvotes

**\*\*Title:\*\*** Skulls

**\*\*Author:\*\*** ingydarwp

**\*\*Rating:\*\*** M

**\*\*Language:\*\*** English

**\*\*Length:\*\*** Readtime estimate of 1 hour and 29 minutes although it was 50 minutes for me

**\*\*Status:\*\*** Last updated on October 25

**\*\*Link:\*\*** https://www.wattpad.com/story/415411535-skulls-%E2%8B%86-akotsk

**Summary:** Saerys Targaryen has lived as her brother Aerion's shadow for as far long as she can remember. He is controlling, cruel, and more dragon than human, but she's learned to bear it. If he's busy hurting her, after all, then he can't hurt anyone else.

He can't hurt their younger brothers.

At Ashford Tourney, however, everything seems to come apart at the seams. With missing brothers, giant hedgeknights, and dead dragons, Aerion's hold over Saerys is slipping.

Nobody is coming to save her. She's known that for a long time. But, something about it all is suggesting that maybe it's time to save herself.


r/TheCitadel • • 1d ago

Lost Fanfic: Help Me Find It - NOT DISCUSSION Looking for multi pairing fic (might be deleted) [ao3]

0 Upvotes

Looking for fic in where Jon returns to Westeros after spending years in Essos. When he returnes he’s greeted by memebers of the small council and finds out Rheagar, Lyanna, Aegon,and Daenerys died in a fire in Dragonstone and is king now. The Jon of this story can turn into a dragon and is already in a relationship with three lady and one Is pregnant. Some of the tags I remember are Jon/Shiera, Arianna, and Melisandre


r/TheCitadel • • 1d ago

Wanted: Fanfic Recommendations - NOT DISCUSSION Fics where a midwife/Doctor/nurse is an SI?

18 Upvotes

I remember coming across one where a midwife is SIed into Westeros and saves some women who would otherwise die from childbirth, but I can't find it any longer.


r/TheCitadel • • 1d ago

Book Discussion: Reading ASOIAF & Spin-Off Novels Questions The valonqar? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The prophecy says - "And when your tears have drowned you, the valonqar shall wrap his hands about your pale white throat and choke the life from you."

Most people agree this means Tyrion and some think it could be Jaime since Cersei was born first with him coming second holding onto her leg.

However is says "THE VALONQAR" not her valonqar, and all valonqar means is little sibling/brother in High Valyrian.

So theoretically any little brother / younger sibling could be the one that kills her it doesn't have to be any of her brothers specifically and that would be the kind of irony the GRRM leans towards, subverting expectations and such.


r/TheCitadel • • 2d ago

Activity - What If (changed CANON event or character decision) What if Ned had been made Hand on the start of Robert's Reign?

45 Upvotes

For this scenario, let's say Jon Arryn dies during the war, perhaps at the Battle of the Bells. Despite this huge blow to the Rebellion and House Arryn, Robert and Ned step up to honor their late foster father and still win the war.

After the victory, Robert asks Ned to become his Hand, and caught up in the emotions of the moment, Ned agrees. Even after the Rebellion ends, despite his disagreements with Robert over Rhaegar's children's deaths and his desire to return North with baby Jon and Lyanna's body, Ned feels obligated to keep his promise to Robert and accepts the position, even if he misses the North and feels unqualified for the job.

How would this change things?

I imagine Benjen would never join the Night's Watch and would instead remain in the North to help govern Winterfell. Would he marry? If so, whom?

Would Ned send Jon to Winterfell to be raised by Benjen, or would Jon grow up in King's Landing?

I also imagine Catelyn, Robb and her future children moving to King's Landing with Ned. Perhaps Robb would eventually be sent North to foster, as the future Lord Stark. How would growing up in King's Landing affect the children's personalities and relationships?

How would Robert and the royal court change with Ned serving as Hand from the beginning? Would Robert be less depressed? What about the kingdom, Cersei and her children?

Lastly, what would happen to House Arryn and Lysa following Jon Arryn's early death?

Overall, how do you think this alternative timeline would change the world of ASOIAF? What major differences from canon do you foresee?


r/TheCitadel • • 2d ago

Subreddit Activity (NOT WHAT IF's) SI'd in Westeros 2 years before the conquest. Prevent it or milk it

70 Upvotes

You're transported to Westeros 2 years before Aegon sets foot on KL. You can only be from houses that are not Targaryen-aligned before conquest. So no Blackwater houses, but yes, Riverlands houses are allowed. Any gender or appearance you want, and you get the sword skills of Sandor Clegane for men and Visenya for women. Now your task is to either prevent the conquest or milk it for all you can.

Yet if you choose to milk it due to the easier situation you must end up hand of the king or you fail

what would you do and how would you do it


r/TheCitadel • • 2d ago

Subreddit Activity (NOT WHAT IF's) Could Gaemon Targaryen and Rhaenys Targaryen be monarchs?

13 Upvotes

Before I begin, I should mention that I am not a native English speaker, so I hope there are no translation errors.

A few days ago, while exploring this community, I came across an interesting post. It discussed a fanfiction about Gaemon Targaryen, son of Jaehaerys I. The fic is titled "Blood and Steel" by KáiserBjorn (I will include a link to the original post at the end of this thread). At first, I didn't pay much attention, not due to a lack of interest, but because AO3 was inaccessible at the time. However, it was back up and running this weekend, so I decided to give the fic a read.

I really enjoyed how it develops, though, unfortunately, it appears to be abandoned.

Without going into too much detail to avoid spoilers (even though the fic is quite extensive), it is set around 83–84 AC and features Gaemon Targaryen (who, in this version of reality, survives) as the protagonist. Gaemon shares a very close bond with Rhaenys Targaryen (perhaps something more than just friendship...), and he faces harassment from Saera Targaryen and her friends. Meanwhile, his father, the illustrious King Jaehaerys I, remains quite distant toward him, likely because he isn't like Aemon or Baelon Targaryen.

Gaemon eventually forms a bond with the dragon Grey Ghost. Following an incident that leads to Saera ending up in Oldtown (a sequence involving young squires Harrold Westerling and Otto Hightower, and which differs from the canon) Jaehaerys I sends Gaemon to Storm's End to serve as a ward to Lord Boremund Baratheon. There, Gaemon befriends a young Lyonel Strong, and the story continues... or at least, it should! (If the author happens to read this thread: I’d love to know if you plan to continue it at some point—I’ve really enjoyed it so far, and it shows great promise!).

Given that the fanfiction is no longer being updated and the plot remains unresolved, it has led me to wonder: If (hypothetically speaking) Gaemon and Rhaenys were to marry in 90 AC and have a son on New Year’s Day of 91 AC (since that day marks the ninety-first anniversary of Aegon’s Conquest, the child would naturally be named Aegon Targaryen), and if Rhaenys were to become pregnant again in 92 AC (as happens in the canon)... Then, when Aemon dies on Tarth during the Myrish Bloodbath (as in the canon), would Jaehaerys I name Rhaenys his heir, or would he still appoint Baelon (as in the canon)? Or might there be a third option: would Jaehaerys I name Gaemon his heir directly?

That is my question regarding this hypothetical scenario.

I would also like to add two follow-up questions, depending on which outcome you consider most likely: If Rhaenys or Gaemon were named heir, who do you think would serve on their Small Council? And if Baelon were chosen instead, then upon his death—when the Great Council of 101 AC takes place—would Rhaenys or Gaemon prevail over Viserys?

As an aside, and following the premise of the fanfiction, Gaemon and Rhaenys would have the support of House Baratheon and the Stormlands (for the same reasons as in the canon), as well as House Velaryon (through Viserra Targaryen—a friend of Rhaenys and Gaemon—who, in this scenario, is married to Corlys Velaryon and has children with him). They would also be backed by those houses that supported Rhaenys during the Great Council, with the addition of House Hightower, thanks to the friendship between Gaemon and Otto.

I look forward to hearing your thoughts, and thanks in advance for your replies.

Here is the link to the post containing the fic "Blood and Steel", by KaiserBjorn: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheCitadel/s/YVdaX3pkmj