r/TheTraitors • u/KangsterWay792 • 21h ago
UK The UK Celebrity Traitors S2 wasn't as bad as people made it out to be, but it definitely wasn't Traitors at its best.
Okay, so I finally watched the whole season and honestly, I have mixed feelings.
It wasn't as bad as people had made it sound, but at the same time it wasn't really giving me the Traitors experience I've come to expect.
The biggest problem for me was how cautious everyone seemed to be. They had some genuinely great personalities, but when it came to actually playing the game it felt like everyone was just there to chill, have a laugh and hope they wouldn't get murdered or banished. Every season we've seen some incredibly intelligent and ruthless Traitors who understand how to manipulate the game, but this time it felt like they were too busy trying not to get caught to actually play.
And the number of blunders like Richard spilling his own secret, Maya saying "to murdering them" during a toast, and Kenny slipping up with "as a Traitor myself"... LIKE HOW?
And honestly, even the Faithfuls weren't helping. It felt like half of them were there to make friends rather than actually find the Traitors. Nobody seemed interested in properly questioning the obvious, following up on suspicious behaviour or connecting the dots. Everyone was so caught up in their own little theories that they barely seemed to pay attention to what was happening right in front of them. I missed seeing Faithfuls who actually observe, challenge people and aren't afraid to make uncomfortable accusations(like harriet did to rachel in S4)
It was honestly giving Dumb and Dumber at certain points. I kept waiting for someone to actually make a bold move, take a risk or properly turn the game around, but everyone seemed so afraid of being exposed. It became quite underwhelming after a while.
I also struggled to get attached to anyone. Usually, by this point in a season, you have your favourites, someone you're rooting for, someone whose gameplay you admire or someone you just love watching, Here, I never really found that connection.
The one person I genuinely enjoyed watching was James. Such a great dude. He couldn't quite make things work in his own favour, and I think that actually highlights how difficult being a Traito can be. It also made me appreciate the people who manage to play and enjoy as Traitor more. Being a Traitor is clearly so much harder than it looks. You have to lie convincingly, read people, manage relationships and somehow keep your composure while everyone is looking for you. Hats off to those who can actually pull it off.
I did enjoy a few moments here and there, and the cast definitely had personalities, so I wouldn't say it was a complete waste of time. But the actual gameplay left me wanting so much more.
I guess after watching seasons where the Traitors really know what they're doing, it's difficult not to feel disappointed when you get a season like this.
Anyway, did anyone else feel like they were watching a group of people accidentally playing Traitors rather than actually playing to win😭